[ overboard / cytube] [ leftypol / b / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime ] [ meta ] [ GET / ref]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internets about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)


File: 1613757829328.jpg (5.93 MB, 3711x3281, Russian_Imperial_Family_19….jpg)

 No.86716[View All]

Was it moral to kill the Czar's children?
77 posts and 20 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.87945

>>86895
yeah in theory we don't even "need" to kill porky just expropiate their shit
>>

 No.87969

>>87934
thats not relative or subjective morality thats historically determined morality and it's not the same since we can actually understand history in a rational way and figure out in which direction it is heading objective morality must follow the path of history which means the only objective morality is the morality of the revolutionary class
>>

 No.87974

>>87969
Okay so now explain why Shining Path executed peasants with machetes
>>

 No.87982

it was a heated gaming moment
>>

 No.87987

>>86964
>Imagine tagging Marx's grave with this epitaph, kek
I will do this one day. Screenshot this.
>>

 No.87993

>>87974
because they thought it was necessary the real problem with them is that they followed some retarded dogmatic cultist ideology that could justify doing something like that
>>

 No.87994

>>

 No.88013

>>87993
also mautists and other pseudo marxists have a glorified conception of violence they are the kind of people who forget all context that justifies revolutionary violence and think violence for violences sake is enough justification like they would see shit like the romanov's killing and think the only way to be good commies is by killing the families of your enemies
>>

 No.88724

File: 1613882744907.jpg (146.95 KB, 719x456, IMG_20210208_070642.jpg)

Die
>>

 No.88732

File: 1613882988963.png (153.33 KB, 500x457, unknown (2).png)

>>

 No.88735

>>86943
this was composed by a Stirnerbro who influenced Nietzsche
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGU1P6lBW6Q
>>

 No.88762

>>86781
>why are you guys even socialists?
Because Marx discovered the laws of motion of politics and communism is inevitable (barring enormous disasters). Moralistic appeals can be useful cynically and sure we would like people to live in a society that actually works, but the ground truth of it all is that we understand the mechanics of the system and can see where it logically goes. It's also in my interests to struggle for improvement since historically that's what you have to do even for modest reforms.
>>

 No.88768

>>86781
Morality according to who? The only good place for monarchs is gulag just like Puyi, if they still can be persuade. But the 1917 is necessary to show the monarchs that the power of the people matters above all.
>>

 No.88769

>>86781
Yes? Its in my self interest to have power over the owners, and co own and direct the production and distribution of things along with me friends family and equal social class. Its in the self interest of all workers to be socialist, therefore it is in my interest to be a socialist and share ownership of the means with my fellow labourers and toilers
>>

 No.88786

File: 1613888186797.jpg (293.58 KB, 720x1431, Screenshot_2021-02-21-13-1….jpg)

>>

 No.89308

File: 1613936672074-0.png (2.29 MB, 1644x1480, Grace & liberty-tan No God….png)

File: 1613936672074-1.png (2.47 MB, 2000x2000, Monarchy vs Anarchy.png)

File: 1613936672074-2.mp4 (6.24 MB, 640x360, EVERY MAN A KING (NEW VERS….mp4)

>>86946
Honestly, coming back to this post,
You say that because you're both anarkiddies, don't you? Basically, demofags.
I personally want to vomit when I see an "anarcho-monarchist" myself, but every man a king?
>>

 No.89319

>>

 No.89324

File: 1613937313028.jpg (1.22 MB, 2833x2125, 09781240891289041089424890….jpg)

>>

 No.89383

>>86716
Moral? Very spooky.
But i would kill them again.
>>

 No.89388

Morality has nothing to do with it.
>>

 No.89644

>>86863
have sex
>>

 No.89719

>>86716
yes and it was based
>>

 No.89720

File: 1613971734200.jpg (126.76 KB, 800x491, 163e2b3ce84f74ab4a7627695d….jpg)

>>

 No.89726

>>88724
based
>>

 No.91009

>>86863
Grace is a slut after all. There are many hentai about it. The monarchs fall & the peasants take what's theirs.

https://hanime.tv/videos/hentai/oujo-onna-kishi-w-dogehin-roshutsu-chijoku-no-misemono-dorei-1

https://hanime.tv/videos/hentai/kyonyuu-princess-saimin-1
>>

 No.91012

>>91009
Coomers are going to horny gulag anyway. Bastards like you shall be lynch.
>>

 No.91088

>>86716
Imagine an alternate timeline where the kept the kids alive and brought them into Marxist-Leninism. Perhaps when Gorby was succumbing to Pizza fever, the new monarch of the Soviets might of been able to hold down the fort, I mean they would have the support of the monarchists.
>>

 No.91102

>>91012
Eat my ass, monarchist.
>>

 No.91114

I don't know, was it moral for the Tsars to live like gods in comparison to their fellow countrymen? Was it moral for the millions of toiling peasants to toil, suffer, live like animals, and die an early death while the royal family did objectively nothing to improve their living conditions? Was it moral for them to let life go on like this without even lifting a finger to try and provide their people a respectable standard of living while living lavishly? Why is it that the lives of the tsars children matter so much more to you than the lives of the children amongst the workers and peasantry?
>>

 No.91263

>>91114
whataboutism
>>

 No.91265

>>91263
>whataboutism
liberal invention to ignore westoid faggotry and jim crow
>>

 No.91956

File: 1614127075718-0.jpg (48.43 KB, 453x503, 57b14e0f773e13ec55d47eec9c….jpg)

File: 1614127075718-1.mp4 (299.54 KB, 640x640, mpUDEgrAAkAq4_6P.mp4)

>>91114
>I don't know, was it moral for the Tsars to live like gods in comparison to their fellow countrymen?
Yes, there should be royal splendor.

From Bossuet's Politics Drawn from Holy Scripture:
>God forbade the ostentation which vanity inspires, and the mad swelling of a heart intoxicated by its riches; but he willed nonetheless that the courts of kings be striking and magnificent, to impress a certain respect upon on peoples… And even today, at the rites of kings, as we have already seen, the Church offers this prayer: "May the glorious dignity and majesty of the palace make shine in all eyes the great splendor of the royal power, such that light, like that of the flash of lightning, may illuminate it from all sides." All these are words chosen to express the magnificence of a royal court, which is asked of God as a necessary support of royalty.

>Men are the true riches of a king… One is delighted when he sees, under good kings, the incredible multitude of people and the astonishing largeness of the armies. By contrast one is ashamed of Achab and of the kingdom of Israel exhausted of people, when one sees his army encamp "like two little flocks of goats"–while the Syrian army which faced it covered the face of the earth… In the enumeration of the immense riches of Solomon, there is nothing finer than these words: "Judah and Israel were innumerable, as the sand of the sea in the multitude." …But here is the pinnacle of felicity and of richness. It is that this whole innumerable people "ate and drank of the fruit of its hands, every one under his vine and under his fig-tree, and rejoicing." For joy makes bodies healthy and vigorous, and makes profitable the innocent repast that one consumes with his family."


>>91009
>>91012
The peril of coomunism…
I am not looking at that hentai

>>91102
Sorry, but coomers go to the Bastille.
>>

 No.91988

File: 1614129233782.jpg (71.69 KB, 500x650, the-guillotine-large.jpg)

>>91956
>coomers go to the Bastille.
How compelling. Follow your liege, simp.
>>

 No.91995

>>91956
the cope is fucking real in this post.
>>

 No.92038

>>91956
??? I thought you were about monarchy as a concept (with tyranny and roman dictators) more than about defending specific monarchs.
I mean,who are supposed to be "legitimate kings" in France for exemple,does Napoleon descendants even count,or is he "less" legitimate than the Habsurg dude.
And does genes even really matter at that point when they are so "diluted" ?
You wouln't happen to be baiting on purpose the dude who gets mad at socdem flags wouldn't you ?
>>

 No.92042

>>86716
No, but it was a necessary evil. In China it didn't need to happen, and Mao recognized that.
>>

 No.92057

>>92042
>evil

>The tzar’s diary is the best of all testimony. From day to day and from year to year drags along upon its pages the depressing record of spiritual emptiness. “Walked long and killed two crows. Drank tea by daylight.” Promenades on foot, rides in a boat. And then again crows, and again tea. All on the borderline of physiology. Recollections of church ceremonies are jotted down in the same tone as a drinking party.


>In the days preceding the opening of the State Duma, when the whole country was shaking with convulsions, Nicholas wrote: “April 14. Took a walk in a thin shirt and took up paddling again. Had tea in a balcony. Stana dined and took a ride with us. Read.” Not a word as to the subject of his reading. Some sentimental English romance? Or a report from the Police Department? “April 15: Accepted Witte’s resignation. Marie and Dmitri to dinner. Drove them home to the palace.”


>On the day of the decision to dissolve the Duma, when the court as well as the liberal circles were going through a paroxysm of fright, the tzar wrote in his diary: “July 7. Friday. Very busy morning. Half hour late to breakfast with the officers … A storm came up and it was very muggy. We walked together. Received Goremykin. Signed a decree dissolving the Duma! Dined with Olga and Petia. Read all evening.” An exclamation point after the coming dissolution of the Duma is the highest expression of his emotions. The deputies of the dispersed Duma summoned the people to refuse to pay taxes. A series of military uprisings followed: in Sveaborg, Kronstadt, on ships, in army units. The revolutionary terror against high officials was renewed on an unheard-of scale. The tzar writes: “July 9. Sunday. It has happened! The Duma was closed today. At breakfast after Mass long faces were noticeable among many … The weather was fine. On our walk we met Uncle Misha who came over yesterday from Gatchina. Was quietly busy until dinner and all evening. Went padding in a canoe.” It was in a canoe he went paddling – that is told. But with what he was busy all evening is not indicated. So it was always.
>>

 No.92062

File: 1614134050952.png (2.66 MB, 3408x2800, Gr01m.png)

>>92038
>I thought you were about monarchy as a concept
Especially.
w/ an absolutist touch (meaning, 1500s-1600s)
>(with tyranny and roman dictators)
My main reason for this is I get tired of the tyrannophobia hysteria
>does Napoleon descendants even count,or is he "less" legitimate than the Habsurg dude
I'm not so picky about bloodline/dynasties which seem like an excuse for larpers to have political parties. Let there be new blood.
But Great Man Theorylets often take an anti-royalist spin… I dislike anti-royalist Great Man theory takes.
>And does genes even really matter at that point when they are so "diluted" ?
It's not so much about purity.
Hereditary rule is appealing like a preservation technique.

>>92057
What do you expect from a diary, anon?

>>91988
So scary, a guillotine.
So happy I will destroy those.
>>

 No.92071

File: 1614134792520.png (219.09 KB, 342x372, 1592712623499.png)

>>92062
You better not be jerking off to getting bullied.
>>

 No.92113

>>92042
>evil
Every monarch should be shot. We tried the Chinese approach and the fucker not only bailed on us when we fought the French, but then later turned traitor because he couldn’t handle living like a normal citizen.
I suppose it’s karma that most of his children died young and he himself died penniless in exile. Fuck Bảo Đại.
>>

 No.92130

File: 1614137245725.png (130.41 KB, 421x446, 40e64ab29ec3e11c7dc427581f….png)

>>92071
Me? A coomer? Very funny, anon.
Plus two anons said I was baiting people.
Who exactly is being bullied?
>>

 No.92139

>>92130
based and cute
>>

 No.92146

>>86716
It wasn't ideal but it was necessary for the situation they found themselves in. Anyone stating anything else is just an edgy roleplayer
>>

 No.92247

yes it was, they would've fled to the west, claim the russian throne and spread lies about the ussr, they deserved it.
>>

 No.92256

>>91956
>I'm not looking into that hentai
>Cope again
Lol how weak
>>

 No.92258

Grace is secretly a fan of Juche.
>>

 No.92264

>>92062
>>91988
Guillotine is so old-fashioned. Why don't use this machine & be done with it?

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/fukouna-shoujo-03
>>

 No.92343

Was it moral? No
Was it based? Yes
>>

 No.93158

>>91012
Based
>>

 No.99113


Unique IPs: 37

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ overboard / cytube] [ leftypol / b / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime ] [ meta ] [ GET / ref]