/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

Yes

>>954521
>Paul cockshott claims that the incas were communist
Sounds anachronistic.

>>954521
>Citation needed
The Post (aka a Shitpost of an OP)

>>954521
can you explain what a palace economy is?

>>954525
This is obnoxious. Marx isn't an oracle

Ay caramba shut it down, the gringo knows!

>>954521
Way to out communism as an ideological equivalent of how actual monarch families treat each other
The only difference being the religious like attention put on manners, which is impossible on a society wide scale

>>954921
you're obnoxious feeding this shit thread

>>954963
Bump :)

>>954964
keep posting unfunny memes for me

>>954521
Planned economy =/= communism

A planned economy does not equal communism or socialism.

>>954973
Bump again :)

>>955185
There is clearly nothing valuable being communicated here.
Why are you continually bumping this shit thread?

>>954521
>Paul cockshott claims that the incas were communist
where does he say that?

>>955220
who cares

Communism is when you have a plan of what to do obviously

OP you should just ask yourself the following question:
Was the Minoan civilization a class society?

the existence of palaces would indicate an economic elite and ruling class of kings, so no
a better case could be made for the Indus Valley Civilisation.
>no monuments or large buildings devoted to a wealthy elite, political leaders, or gods
>society of modest burials, no rich grave goods or elaborate tombs have been found
>there is little evidence of violence
>no evidence of wars

>>954593
Cockshott ould never claim that. Planned economy on the other hand, thats not far fetched.
Dictatorship of the proletariat? Sure, in feathered crowns and blood lineage

>>956319
maybe OP is confusing temple economies like the Ubaid culture with palace economies like Ur?
>mass production of erotic female figurines
booba truly transcends time

>>956319
>BOOBA
Based Indusians.

>>954521

Not all palace economies have communist societies but all communist societies have palace economies.

Necessary but not sufficient condition.

>>956319
pajeetsirs, i kneel. og no gods no masters way before bakunin

"Our father is Marshal Kim Jong Un, Our Home is the Party's embrace"
"With the Respected Marshal who loves people most and regards his trouble for the people as his joy as our father in the harmonious great family we are assisting each other in the warm cherished house, our socialist homeland"

"The Household / Family well ordered is the true image of the Commonwealth." -Jean Bodin

"My old home the Monarchy, alone, was a great mansion with many doors and many chambers, for every condition of men." -Joseph Roth

"Socialism is the phantastic younger brother of Despotism, which it wants to inherit. Socialism wants to have the fullness of state force which before only existed in Despotism." -Friedrich Nietzche

"A family being nothing else but a small Kingdom, wherein the paterfamilias had Regal power… and a Kingdom being nothing else but a great family." -Gryffith Williams

"For as household management is the kingly rule of a house, so kingly rule is the household management of a city, or of a nation, or of many nations." -Aristotle

"The rule of a household is a monarchy, for every house is under one head." -Aristotle

"Visitor: Well then, surely there won't be any difference, so far as ruling is concerned, between the character of a great household, on the one hand, and the bulk of a small city on the other? – Young Socrates: None. – It's clear that there is one sort of expert knowledge concerned with all these things; whether someone gives this the name of kingship, or statesmanship, or household management, let's not pick any quarrel with him." -Plato

"So that Aristotle following Xenophon, seems to me without any probable cause, to have divided the Economical government from the Political, and a City from a Family; which can no otherwise be done, than if we should pull the members from the body; or go about to build a City without houses… Wherefore as a family well and wisely ordered, is the true image of a City, and the domestical government, in sort, like unto the sovereignty in a Commonwealth: so also is the manner of the government of a house or family, the true model for the government of a Commonwealth… And whilest every particular member of the body does his duty, we live in good and perfect health; so also where every family is kept in order, the whole city shall be well and peaceably governed." -Jean Bodin

>>970418
So there you have it, /leftypol/.
The true means for the socialist takeover of the State… is to have a palace economy and a proletarian Red Dynasty that will champion the People's cause.

>>970421
Monarchy via reincarnation of a lama but the qualifications of being lama requires being cute

>>970418
the original cancel culture was the culture of debt cancellation

>>970563
Make jubilees great again?

>>954521
No. Central planning is not communist by itself.

Cockshott never said this. Show a single source. At most he says they are planned economies which is true. Planned economy =/= communism. The damn USA had a planned economy at the height of WW2.

>>971032
>The damn USA had a planned economy at the height of WW2
Did not, the overwhelming majority of the economy was still privately run, just with price controls, higher taxation and it was far less state directed than Britain or Germany were.

>>971190
> majority of the economy was still privately run
so was the ussrs

>>971198
Good joke.