Mate, what was wrong with that person’s questions? I’ve at least been using leftypol since it was still on 8chan, that thread OP looked fine to me, the problem is that everyone memed instead of using a serious rebuttal. For instance, why is it not a fair and good faith criticism to call Marxism neo-Ricardian and promote marginalism? You may not agree with these criticism, but they are still criticisms of theory itself and thus offered in good faith. That’s why I say only Eugene responded seriously, because he rebutted the notion that marginalism is anything other than nonsense. This is my problem, the things OP said were not nonsensical nor impossible to respond to, they were actually debate worthy questions.