Search

>>2876996
Explain why else union participation is below 10% and why “socialism” is only popular among the downwardly mobile petit bourgeois and PMC

>>2875708
>PMC
It doesn't get better. Go back to DSA posting on twitter

>>2875706
They’re PMC, meaning not proletarian, ML “”””states””” are nothing more than dictatorships of managers

>>2875126
>pure envy
I wish I had enough food as a kid like these petite bourgeois liberals like Zohran's mom who throw parties to hang out with the Epstein class

>>2875111
>makes all of them, Marxist Leninists included, irredeemable fascists
DSA Marxists: "Of course I will never defend the Iranian regime, Venezuela is a dictatorship, we must work with our fellow anti-Stalinists to SMASH THE STATE! Buh? why would I ever stop sneering at the genocide survivors in North Korea???
>>2875116
>they're actually fascists
"Graham Platner is a committed anti-fascist because he said trans rights, the real nazis are tankie Assadists who oppose the creation of Greater Israeli. Real fascism is pointing out how we fight Israel's wars and post screenshots of your tweets of antisemitic tropes for them. You're not allowed to judge our PMC class, only we can surveil you!!!!"

>>2875122
>You dont know what work they've done
Jelly Roll fans and 100 gecs fans: "fuck you, you don't know me, I'm not like those other liberal morons, I'm a brave rebel from the system. I'm a neoliberal who believes in smashing The State for a based and revolutionary reason"
>your own dogma that gives you an excuse to do nothing
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2875037
bro he's making fat bank, and will likely remain as a fixture of future wars even after ukraine because he's some sort of mini luckey palmer funding drone warfare companies left and right. like this guy will start his own PMC in like 10 years. from comedian to war lord. fucking alan moore couldnt write this shit.

>>2874556
NOOOO THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY BELONGS LATTE SIPPING PMCs LIKE ME!

The audacity of these people.

>>2874459
>This will more likely than not lead to remaining popular institution to take advantage: Ths military.

I agree with most of what you're saying but I don't see any popular general raising to power or the general chief of staff taking over. The military could come to power in a collapse situation. But theyll likely splinter in that situation. You would have a bunch of bases becoming bandit camps or little military firfdoms worst case. A bunch of them would dissolve back into civilan life or serve a state directly. I think we would see some PMCs rolling up on congress and installing Jeff bezos or Elon Musk before we see the military take over. The bourgeois have been looting U.S institution to fund private parallel institutions for decades.

>>2874032
I'm feeling good about the future of socialism in America. The ruling class has been on its backfoot managing the public perception since 08. The could try and Co-op the DSA but without serious concession and even then they would only be delaying the inevitable.

>>2873838

I unironically have no idea. The nevertrump/Islamophobic neoliberal centrist cross-over faction is a tiny minority at this point and only exists within a very slim pmc beltway stratum.

>>2873293
>Deng
"Wow! we need more deregulation like this!" - explosive diarrhea fandom who fight for the rights of intestinal parasites and the Legionnaires disease and, of course, the unregulated Chinese wet markets that produced Covid19
>Mao
"Neoliberal free market praxis is so much more inspirational to my PMC Zionist friends. I'm baffled that people would be screeching about having to pay your landlord by being their sex slave. What if New Yorkers rationally consent to serving the Epstein class of Zionist landlords???"

>>2872587
They did emphasize that Wagner is a private military company. Strange thing for communists to support. Blackwater was also a PMC. It's also pretty stupid as mercenaries can cause you a lot of trouble. Machiavelli:

>Now, the armies a ruler is depending on to defend his state will either be his own, or mercenaries, or auxiliaries, or some combination of these. Mercenaries and auxiliaries are useless and dangerous. If you are counting on mercenaries to defend your state you will never be stable or secure , because mercenaries are ambitious, undisciplined, disloyal, and they quarrel among themselves. Courageous with friends and cowardly with enemies, they have no fear of God and keep no promises. With mercenaries the only way to delay disaster is to delay the battle; in peacetime they plunder you and in wartime they let the enemy plunder you. Why? Because the only interest they have in you and their only reason for fighting is the meager salary you’re paying them, and that’s not reason enough to make them want to die for you. Sure, they’re happy enough to be your soldiers when you’re not at war, but when war comes, they run for it, or just disappear.

>>2872345
>the USSR vindicated Bakunin
anti-Stalinists in Ukraine:
<"We need to work alongside our nazi and Soros NGO agent comrades to destroy what little remains of our nationalized sovereignty and control over the economy. Our president is anti-democratic for exploiting his democratic mandate to veto liberal integration with the EU. Its disgusting and offensive to us woke leftists to oppose open borders for sex workers, what if Ukrainians consented to visiting Epstein's private island??? Shipping mail-order brides is praxxxxiiiiissssssss. That's the real Marxian free association between free producers of our liberal anti-fascist utopia"
TOTAL VINDICATION OF FOX NEWS BOOMERS LOL

>>2872337
>predictions in the social sciences
Gabriel Rockhill sociology reading 100 gecs fans: "I predict this PMC anti-Stalinist is secretly an intimate friend with a Zionist pedophile"

>>2872229
They're Duginite Nazbols at best and Nazis at worse.
They are anti-communists LARPing as leftists to try to drag people into reactionary thought.
They do nothing but seethe about gays and say (unironically) that Islam IS communism.
Bro is wearing a t shirt repping a Russian PMC that beheads puppies and who's found has SS and Totenkopf tattoos.
They do NOTHING to help America. You think a handful of hyper reactionary social democrats in a streamer's cult will save your shithole country? For the love of Marx start reading theory.

>>2867494
>What happened?
TRPF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tendency_of_the_rate_of_profit_to_fall

>>2867535
>neoliberalism, in which the ability for capital to innovate and build anything was entirely abandoned in favor of what is essentially a scam
There were innovations. The '90s info-tech boom (and its aftershocks with Uber/social media slop and now AI) and also the biomedical revolution were notable. Melinda Cooper wrote about stuff like Monsanto patents of biology

>>2867970
>the stereotypical Gen X angst was rooted in the feeling that there was too much abundance and security, that life somehow "sucked" because they had to show up every day to a clean, comfortable office cubicle, which was treated as if it were its own kind of hell.
nu metal like Korn = working class chud music for the pioneer footsoldiers of the satanic empire
hipster alt-rock like The Strokes = petite bourgeois cannibal settler music for the downwardly mobile Jeffrey Epstein PMC class

>>2868237
>communist parties
>>2868355
>utterly incompetent and so have basically just given up
there aren't any workers organizations that are allowed to exist after the last century of counter-revolution against militant organized labor. Did you hear about this:
https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/UAW-shawn-fain-neil-barofsky-recording-israel-gaza

>>2868322
>They're too woke
"Israel killed JFK and Charlie Kirk and bought TikTok to silence black women about this" - American workers

>>2868550
>failed experiment
There are no failed experiments, science is a dialectical method
>the world has moved on
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

>plenty of 'neoliberal' places with
>high standards of living
For billionaires and pmc court jesters

Class consciousness will come about naturally as the means of production develop to a point where the Capitalist class increases it's repression as their position becomes obviously pointless to even 80IQ wife beaters.
This is why I'm actually an AI accelerationist. AI is absolutely the technology that makes it pretty fucking obvious "Why do you exist?" a question to swaths of the PMC and Capital class when AI outperforms them in every way.

Just a normal day at the beach in the burgerreich

https://6abc.com/post/blue-angels-conducting-review-jet-flies-florida-beachgoers/19516614/

>PENSACOLA BEACH, Fla. – Officials with the U.S. Navy's elite Blue Angels flight demonstration squadron said they're conducting a review after social media footage showed a jet flying low over a crowd of beachgoers in Pensacola Beach, Florida, on Wednesday morning.

>"During an arrival maneuver, an aircraft flew lower than standard profiles, resulting in a disturbance on the beach that affected civilian chairs and umbrellas," the statement said, calling it a "low-altitude pass."

>North Florida ABC affiliate WEAR reported the flyover happened during a "Breakfast with the Blues" event.

<"I've been coming for 10 years and I've never seen a pass like that in my life," Ashley Korn told WEAR. "I literally thought we were going to be taken out by Blue Angels, but it was amazing."

How many fucking bystanders they've killed over the years at these fucking airshows.

>Thousands of people have died at airshows globally since the early days of aviation, though the exact total is historically fragmented. For context, one major academic review spanning 1993 to 2013 alone recorded 104 civil airshow fatalities in the United States
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2865169
Omfg, you are like a meme of what an annoying lefty is.

>UMMM EXCUSE ME, HAVE YOU DONE YOUR HOMEWORK AND READ ALL MY FAVORITE BOOKS YET????

Plz learn to express your thoughts through words instead of quotes and book recommendations.


>>2865157
Anti-Semitism just is Class Consciousness for retards. Think about the richest fucks who own everything. Are they operating out of self-interest to make themselves even richer, or out of a magical desire to please some dogshit minority religion no one would even give a fuck about if not for Israeli influence on politics? Israel is a state, they're more interested in amassing geopolitical power and doing racism than anything particularly religious. Most Jews I know are PMCs or working class. That's not to say that no influential Jews exist in media and banking, they do. They're just not the primary problem we're facing. Even the richer ones are usually just Zionist fucks or shitlibs.

It's all about the money, follow the money. Who has the money? The bourgeoisie. Who's interest do they work for? Their own, their only religion is the Almighty dollar. They've tricked you into believing in magic money people who are secretly the "REAL" ones running the world, while they do it out in the open. It is in their interest to pit the working class against each other, keep them fighting about retarded bullshit and idpol, thus keeping the working class from rising up and doing anything to stop them.

>>2864572
anarchists have nothing but vibes, basically dreaming of a utopia that ends with a mass genocide campaign on the 8 billion people currently alive, how is that different than the Jeffrey Epstein class utopia?
>humans have been driving the 6th great extinction and are enslaving themselves and the planet
Marxist PMC liberal Zionists: "we need AI, not degrowth. I agree with my fellow Elon Musk sci-fi reading pundits in the Abundance movement of YIMBY Zionist landlords"

>>2862878
>>2862881
a shitload of modern western feminism is specifically Professional Managerial Class women who are trying to make working class women feel like they're constantly under threat by half the population so they get their own personal army.
A lot of the worst of the modern feminist movement is coming from these PMC types who actually have the capacity to write advisories for lawmaking, drive major ideological thrusts, etc.

Not to say that there aren't a lot of women who are actually victimized, but there's a very real class manipulation once you look at who's doing what.

>>2862648
Only like 4 percent of the DSA's members are actually proles who do stuff like work in trades, the bulk of its supporters and members are just PMC white collar types who have jobs that practically function like small capitalists working in service of larger ones in addition to being paid enough to live in suburbs as homeowners

>>2858713
>communism isnt an ideology
French cultural Marxist ideology: "its impossible to tell if Jeffrey Epstein is a rapist, what even is truth? What if the Ukrainian sex workers consented???? There's no such thing is globalism, Soros does harm reduction. The real problem with society is paternalist Stalinist state that controls bodies in spaces. No one should ever defend the Iran regime!"
historical materialist Marxist critique: (scorned and dismissed as 'outdated' and 'class reductionist' by the compatible left of woke AOC liberal Zionists who somehow believe they are antifascists doing harm reduction)

https://monthlyreview.org/article-author/gabriel-rockhill/
https://thephilosophicalsalon.com/author/gabrielrockhill/
know the difference between actual materialist science that studies political-economy VS pseudoscience of PMC petite bourgeois careerists that reduces philosophy into irrelevant little intellectual word games so they can build careers out of saying obscure words no one has any use for

>>2861394
>The bigger quesiton
the chattering classes on twitter are useless PMCs that are mind raped by the algorithm and need to be hysterical all the time.
but who cares, he's a democrat. i piss on his grave

>>2856089

>A bit of a reach tbh, it just describes disparity in general income levels of different parts of the world. Maybe you can say it's implying there's some conspiracy to facilitate this? That would be very bad faith interpretation of that term imo

"golden billion" is a conspiracy theory that exists amongst american nazis and ukraine and russian nationalists already. thats why i said be careful. i'm not accusing you of going off on a georgia guidestone tangent but be careful

>You can call it PMC if you want or beneficiary proletariat or something, but it does have its roots in what Lenin described as LA imo. I don't know also if I would say they aren't exploited at all and would never revolt. Again just that there relative position in the global system of capitalism might preclude them in several ways from finding interest in revolutionary class politics.

this is the exact contrast between what is called "TW-ism" and anti-imperialism in general. if you think the LA exist as an active group that are incentivized to suppress socialist and revolutionary politics amongst other parts of the working class then you're just a regular leninist. if you think there is no proletariat in the west or you think no western worker can be called materially "exploited" then you are a TW-ist or MIM theorist.

>But regardless, it is a factor to consider rather than disregarded out of fear that it might be true. Lets say for example that 20% of the western proletariat is labor aristocrat or PMC or bought-out or whatever to a global average of 5%. It's only a small difference and neither is a majority, but it could drastically affect strategy and approach

for my own thinking i wonder if "bought out" or "bribed" is outdated. since what the contemporary LA has is maybe not significantly more wealth but a very pampered and fluffed up position in left politics and intellectual culture around it. for example - the DSA isn't just made up of gentrifiers and downwardly mobile P-B. there are lots of poors involved. however the cultural halo around them confers all kinds of cultural and hegemonic status that cant be cashed out in rent or healthcare. you get the whole world bent around your interests, your tastes are listened to, your trivial pPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2855995
I am not arguing that western imperialism, is some immaterial force exerting itself from above reality. To me it is simply the highest stage of capitalism as an economic system, that we have seen so far. The particular composition of that system come out of historical reality, ie there are various concrete reasons for these particular political and social blocks of people to develop into the positions they have
I think that a persons position comes out of their process in the world, as in the things they do, the way they sustain their live, it is in essence just a reflection or an extension of that process. It is not a static thing that you can beep boop some numbers and get a static predisposed outcome, if that is what your think I believe

>"golden billion" runs close to conspiracy theory imo. im not saying its that but be careful.
A bit of a reach tbh, it just describes disparity in general income levels of different parts of the world. Maybe you can say it's implying there's some conspiracy to facilitate this? That would be very bad faith interpretation of that term imo

>what do you mean by "growth" here?
That in Lenin's time the labor aristocracy was a handful of leaders in the labor movement that were able to enrich themselves due to their entrenched position in said movement. But in the century since then ,the position of labor in these countries has changed drastically and in my opinion this has changed the shape or form of this labor aristocracy to expand and incorporate a broad range of people into this higher fraction, managerial, social democrat types that work to placate the masses and manage both the workers and their movement on the behalf of the ruling class. Now these are not exclusive to the first world by any means, but I think it's a larger fraction because those people are useful to the bourgeoisie and they have the money to afford to support them. I don't think that Lenin's category, nor anything really, should be essentialized, but Im having a hard time seeing how it would be translated into racial terms. You mean like whitey is the labor aristocracy or something?

>nowhere in early anti-imperialist do i get the impression that it is COMFORT and CONSUMPTION that makes the labor aristocracy THEMSELVES notPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2854056
>no different than gangs and gangsterism
bro your entire thing is anarchy, your motto is "be gay do crimes", are you stupid? That's like Jeffrey Epstein saying "I hate pedophiles"
>anarchist resistance is able to take say, the PNW,
The PNW has traditionally been controlled by you anti-state libertarian guys:
https://www.kuow.org/stories/why-there-are-so-many-white-supremacists-in-the-northwest
>if you seriously think they'd just let them have their little autonomous region, you're ignoring history
>f you're native or a person of color, you'll be put down too if you're not with whatever the settlers want
if you look at the statistics, the CHAZ killed more (black) children in its short existence than their also Jewish reddit PMC counterparts in Israel have killed their apartheid racial caste.
The same shockingly high statistics of murders is true of the the Spanish anarchist program

>>2854127
>Anarchists want to operate on vibes, MLs want to operate on vibes but with jargon
I learn new science everyday, but not from the western left who are all influencers and movie critics who soyface over Zionist film slop
https://scholar.google.com/

>>2852956
exactly.
if the term has relevance today it is noticing who is joining and running unions and governing "labor politics" in the present world and the positions they hold within public service, academia and media.

TW-ism holds explicitly that the western working class are not proletarian and not exploited. these are both anti-marxist positions that reduce exploitation and proletariat to just emotive words without a technical meaning. Lenin is explicit that the labor aristocracy are proletarian and not bourgeois. only bourgeois inside the proletariat. they are still in an uncertain and risky position. therefore bribing them with privileges (and not just consumption or treats) is effective because it gives them something that they lack. to the extent that that will now fight to define it. TW-ism just plays word games around this and selects things based on how emotive they are

the one trap is going from a principled critique of TW-ism to saying labor aristocracy is just another name for PMC. it isnt and cant be. >>2852992

this same argument can be made about any class who went to revolution. why would they since they have X perk or lack X drawback compared to another group? every group of people can be made too look privileged compared to another group if you want to make bad faith comparisons. the grass is always greener or less greener. this is just word games.

bringing up 401k or freedom from prison or war is just "but capitalism made your iPhone" from a different direction of social conservativism/individualism. please consider the historical links between European Maoism and the emergence of "Horseshoe Theory" bullshit and think about how online TW-ism and ReadSettlers garbage is just the same thing cleaned up for a smugger, less well read generation

>>2852538
This new magazine 'Geese' wrote an interminably pretentious article about why we should support AOC 2028, which makes me view them as PMC liberals like anyone at The Atlantic 👎
https://www.geesemag.com/articles/enter-daedalus-2028
<the word 'liberal' does not appear here, but they mention 'communism' three times and 'socialism' 34 times
Ideology is that which cannot be named, like fish swimming in water. You know you're ideological when you cannot ever critique something, as if it is the unquestionable axiomatic laws of the universe
>If I thought that AOC was an opportunist, that hope in her campaign was overly optimistic, that her presidency would give rise to the rapid growth of potential opportunities to expose elements of Zionism, reformism, capitulationism, you name it–that would not detract from my cause, but exceedingly bolster it. For the first time, the left’s prophecies would be proven correct, and the opportunity would open up for an actually meaningful intervention from this perspective, to reclaim socialism from her opportunism through the gauntlet of the mass political experience. Until the ideology of AOC has run through such a gauntlet of governance and hegemony, there should be no reason for us to expect her progressive working-class base to become disillusioned and seek a radical alternative
bro their argument is literally just "we need to wake up the sheeple" 😭
>"In response to the vacillating nature of AOC on issues like Palestine, infantile calls to instead pedantically endorse Rashida Tlaib because she is, allegedly, “more principled” are now arising. The truth is, however, that ‘principality’ versus ‘vacillation’ is not what is on the line for us—this is a schema that is irrelevant for the purposes laid out here and would only serve to push Democratic Socialism back into marginality at this decisive opportunity for intervention"
(severely circumsized jerking off motion)

>>2852667
>insurrection
the so called "United States" has been controlled by CIA/Israeli MPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2850956
what if you live in a large city, and your commute to work is a half hour's walk and a half hour standing on a train, then your commute back is the same thing carrying groceries, and whatever you do after if you have a healthy life requires walking too, if it isn't an activity with exercise as a component itself.

"exercise" was never really a concept in a lot of human history and not in many cultures, at least as a distinct activity. people just maintained fitness by living and surviving.

it is ironic that the urban dwelling latte sipping PMC is more congruent with a human in a state of nature than a chud in the decaying burbs.

that is if you are okay with cctv every inch that clocks your personal mug and never gets deleted

>>2850710
Do you really think the over educated PMC college grads that make up DSA membership are going to stick by you?

>>2849964
They arent even marxist either lmao. They are also against nationalizing land. They want to break up latifundia to produce a large class small family farms.
They'd go further politically if they went for the nationalization angle. It would also benefit the urban proles.
Another huge problem in LATAM is social movements are led by middle class intelligentsia/PMC or last remenants of peasantry in the hinterland.

>>2849520
Pretty much what >>2849522 said. Though I’d add that the white population of the United States also got first dibs on the jobs that reinforce capitalism (small business owners, PMC types) or otherwise have “buy in” to the system. The downwardly mobile, working class whites either embrace the politics of nihilistic reaction or become more open to socialist ideas.

>>2846867
Marx complained about the middle class.

<What [Ricardo] forgets to emphasise is the constantly growing number of the middle classes, those who stand between the workman on the one hand and the capitalist and landlord on the other. The middle classes maintain themselves to an ever increasing extent directly out of revenue, they are a burden weighing heavily on the working base and increase the social security and power of the upper ten thousand.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1863/theories-surplus-value/ch18.htm

<The great mass of so-called “higher grade” workers—such as state officials, military people, artists, doctors, priests, judges, lawyers, etc.—some of whom are not only not productive but in essence destructive, but who know how to appropriate to themselves a very great part of the “material” wealth partly through the sale of their “immaterial” commodities and partly by forcibly imposing the latter on other people—found it not at all pleasant to be relegated economically to the same class as clowns and menial servants and to appear merely as people partaking in the consumption, parasites on the actual producers (or rather agents of production). This was a peculiar profanation precisely of those functions which had hitherto been surrounded with a halo and had enjoyed superstitious veneration. Political economy in its classical period, like the bourgeoisie itself in its parvenu period, adopted a severely critical attitude to the machinery of the State, etc. At a later stage it realised and—as was shown too in practice—learnt from experience that the necessity for the inherited social combination of all these classes, which in part were totally unproductive, arose from its own organisation.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1863/theories-surplus-value/ch04.htm

If you read Capital Vol 2 Marx anticipated the PMC, a supposed hole in his theory. By chapter 5, he talks about a section of the workers and petty-bourgeois who are recruited as bookkeepers and managers, who watch over the production and circulation process. They don't directly ownPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2846321
I claimed to not believe in PMC theory - please learn to read.
>>2846322
Keep replying even though you "can't be bothered" to reply to me. 👍

>>2846297
PMC don't exist, so the analysis falls

>>2846276
>within capitalist society
Why would it have to be limited to capitalist society?
Such pseudo-historians as James Lindsay or TIKHistory attempt to trace the history of "woke" back to antiquity. We see examples of "vurtue signalling" in the gospels and artistic censorship in Plato, for example - but I feel that Richard Hanania is most incisive on this point; that "woke" is lawfare based upon the original architecture of the US Civil Rights Act, which overtime has expanded itself. The contradiction regards the status of the freedom of association, and so is a liberal (e.g. individualist) issue, not a class issue, as in the Marxist case. Alternative theorists such as James Burnham could point at the rise of the PMC for class analysis (e.g. woke as a tactic to promote oneself in a corporate hierarchy), but this I find more spurious.

>>2838931
>Prior to 2016 conspiracy culture was left-coded
yeah, the left wing of satanic capital!!!
Every crusty new age hippie socialists like Jane Fonda believe that 'we need human depopulation, Africans are having too many babies', exactly like their Epstein class friends who study human breeding in the Bill Gates Foundation.

Alex Jones had a cameo in the Philip K Dick movie adaptation A Scanner Darkly because that radlib "alternative" culture was always just degenerated reactionary liberalism from demons who would later reveal their true nature: Baal worshipers who literally slander children for being killed in schools by their gun worshiping fascist death cult.
>The cracks began with the Tea Party,
the petite bourgeois Karen astroturf movement created as a Koch Bros psyop is the most elitist and anti-populist. They literally called the cops on you for not fitting into their soulless Stepford Wives neighborhood aesthetic!

>>2839509
>ZOG was actually not a conspiracy or even an edgy term, it was always pretty straightforward.
<"This term came from neo-Nazi projects in the 1970s and 1980s as a way of explaining why the federal government was a lost institution: it had been captured by an alien influence. We have to consider how white nationalism reconstituted itself after the Civil Rights Movement made gains in undoing legally sanctioned segregation and Jim Crow laws and made public and legislative expressions of open racism less acceptable. Now, racists could not just run for office or push communities towards racialist conclusions; they had to engage in a revolutionary struggle because the government was no longer run by and for the white man" https://organizingmythoughts.org/we-dont-talk-like-nazis/
Neoliberal capitalism is undeniably a nazi movement for its counter-revoluion that seeks to reverse civil rights legal protections for workers.
But its very funny that these "anti-fascists" like this guy ultimately have the same political theories as nazis, insisting we must "SMAPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

I see "leftist" PMCs talking about "saving Afghan women" so theres a likelyCIA mission flaring back up.

>>2834821
>college
BOURGEOIS PMC COP CLASS TRAITOR DETECTED

>>2833464
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6515308/

I guess you'll just accuse the scientists behind the study of being nazis.

>>2832751
>Yes treating a group of people as second class citizens and refusing to protect them.
When did I ever say this ? Just because some rape shelters would be based on sex doesn't mean all would be, just like there should be some for men as well. But you have to protect both cisgender women and trans women.
As for Epstein, he raped cisgender women ? He litterally has nothing to do with what I'm talking about, and it just sounds like you're calling me a pedophile for diagreeing with you.
>Yes you're totally right we here at leftypol hate science and love basing our worldview on religious fabrications of how biology works, you definitely cannot change your sex in any way and the caste you're assigned into at birth should dictate your entire life, just like the revolutionaries wanted!
Biological sex exists and while you can change secondary sex characteristics
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7846503/
Studies show that despite medical treatement, there still exists a physical difference between trans and cis women. This is mostly important for sports.
There are also concrete material reasons for why socities divide people into men and women (one sex gives birth, the other gives the sperm) even if that model is simplistic. Those reasons are still relevent to this day.
As a general rule, don't try to claim "science" has some sort of objective truth about the world, science has perfecly been wrong in the past, and I doubt that every doctor agrees with you, consider you also pin them as murderers.

>I'm so glad the U.K. is refusing to give transhumanists breast cancer screenings, since they're not REALLY women and the increased risk of breast cancer is all in their heads! Calling it state-sponsored murder is reductive btw

Completly unrelated to anything I said, I don't think doctors should discriminate against trans people. But yes calling it state murder is reductive, plenty of people have died due to shitty medecine, but that doesn't make it murder.

You're smugly and angrily calling me a pedophile and trying to pin for the death of trans women to cancer. Simply because a fairly mild disagreement with yoPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2829333
So trans rights are a distraction, but the deserted shithole is the number two problem after the economy?
Also, you can't rely on economics alone anymore; the workers' situation is too good now, and a revolution on this basis is impossible (at least in first-world countries; the third world still suffers from unbearable economic conditions, which can be turned into a revolution with a couple of PMCs and a million dollars).

the solution to pmc virtue hoarding is unironic left-nietzscheanism. pmcs virtue-horde because they have internalized slave morality ressentiment making them feel bad for being in a position of economic privilege. it is no accident that idpol is sourced from refined parisian intellectualism while engels himself was a german so felt no moral qualms with using his position as a capitalist to further the worker's movement. there needs to be a transvaluation of morals evinced in the pmc and labor aristocracy if we are not to completely ignore them (an understandable gesture). obviously i am not suggesting they should adopt a "master morality", that is just silly. rather, they need a refined morality based upon a noble magnanimity in helping the working class. rather than be more "virtuous" by being more woke then impose such things on workers, they should have their energies directed into real change based upon the finances afforded them thanks to their class position

>>2398307
>>the left
>look inside it’s far right neoliberals
every American settler socialist movement over the last 15 years: "Google Bookchin, we must SMASH THE AUTHORITARIAN STATE for its racist regulations of consumer freedom for individuals"
People after googling Bookchin: "so wait, anarchists have 'no quarrel' with neoliberals who support selling children in the free market?"

lol PMC socialist literally dream of having woke versions of Jeffrey Epstein pagan temple islands, where sex workers are "liberated" from Stalinist oppression to cross borders to be servants of the class of redditors. Really makes you think about what Ukraine's "revolution of dignity" in 2014 was really about!