[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/gulag_archive/ - Gulag Archive

Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Not reporting is bourgeois


File: 1670428733854.jpg (18.44 KB, 622x447, FB_IMG_1670346163835.jpg)

 

Probably not really the worst, but people in lefty spaces online are always so much more concerned with whether white people are allowed to say the N word or who is technically the most oppressed than actually liberating the intersectionally largest group of oppressed people in the world (the working class).(ban evading spam and astroturf)(Mentally ill fag that spends hours of his life nearly every day trying to spam and spread right wing astroturf and generally shit up the place)
55 posts and 9 image replies omitted.

>>2161
> some dumbfucks are triggered that we use that quote as a reference to that
it's not about being "triggered" it's about the fact that it is not being used as a reference. the vast majority of times I've seen people be called JN on here, it was just as a flat insult, without any of marx's letters being referenced at all. it was used purely as a shutdown, without any cleverness behind it. And now some of the visiting /pol/yps know it's a way around their word filter: a way to complain about their two least favorite groups at once.
> making both polyp and reddit tourists seethe
if the purpose of something is simply to make people new people seethe and leave (thus keeping the community small and alienating) then it is immature and pointless. that was my point all along. it was pointless when marx said it, it was pointless when we say it now. Like there is nothing to be gained by making an obscure refernece to something marx said. Yes, bourgeois liberals bring it up to "cancel" him in bad faith. Fuck those people. Doesn't mean we need to step into the pile of shit they left on the floor to prove how little we care.

also idpol has been weaponized against us, as every genuine marxist-leninist tried to warn you all about a decade ago.

liberals have no ideology, only an identity, and so for them idpol is a natural weapon.

File: 1670447868982.png (717.41 KB, 1000x667, ClipboardImage.png)

>ITT whiteoids feeling persecuted because they can't say uyghur
Most fragile race.

>>2134
>claudia jones grave is to the left of marx's for a reason
She was great. Highly influential figure.

>Her time within the CPUSA further developed her Marxist-Leninist politics. An adept writer, organiser and theoretician, she utilised her position in the party to advocate for poor Black women workers, bringing together theoretically: race, class, gender and anti-imperialism. Although her approach highlighted the limitations of the CPUSA, she remained determined to develop this intersectional ideological framework for Black radical feminists to further expand upon.

https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/5030-the-forgotten-legacy-of-claudia-jones-a-black-communist-radical-feminist

>What made her intersectionality socialist was that Claudia Jones differentiated between the ruling class that generated and that benefited from oppression, and the working class that internalized oppressive ideas and behaviors despite their class interests. This meant organizing a working-class strategy of fighting oppression, as she summarized in her 1949 essay “We Seek Full Equality for Women,”: “The triply-oppressed status of the Black woman is a barometer of the status of all women, and that the fight for the full economic, political and social equality of the Black woman is in the vital self-interest of white workers, in the vital interest of the fight to realize equality for all women.”


>This didn’t mean subordination issues of oppression to the class struggle, but of challenging the women’s movement, trade union movement and her own party to fight every manifestation of sexism and anti-Black racism in order to raise the level of struggle: “We can accelerate the militancy of Black women to the degree with which we demonstrate that the economic, political, and social demands of Black women are not just ordinary demands, but special demands, flowing from special discrimination facing Black women as women, as workers and as Blacks. It means first, to unfold the struggle for jobs, to organize the unorganized Black women workers in hundreds of open-shop factories and to win these job campaigns. It means overcoming our failure to organize the domestic workers…And it means that a struggle for social equality for Black women must be boldly fought for in every sphere of relations between men and women so that the open door of Party membership doesn’t become a revolving door because of our failure to conduct this struggle.”

https://springmag.ca/claudia-jones-intersectional-socialist

>>2170
Agreed, they're second only to blacks who feel persecuted over the word in the first place.

>>2166
people who have been here for years frequently argue with other people who have been here for years while other people who have been here for years accuse people who have been here for years of being new

>>2172
It's not necessarily a feeling of persecution as more of an observation of the obsessions of Anglos.

>>2151
it is literally just work with the underclass and remember we are all oppressed by the upper class so stop fragmenting

it is literally anti-ID pol and the fact you seem to think otherwise tells me you havent actually read claudia jones work lol

>>2173
The jewish nigger quote is a classic and long time board staple because of how crass and absurd of a mistranslation it is, I have never seen even one argument over it until now.

>>2176
How is it a mistranslation? Lol even if he said Black/African/negro it wouldn't change the context of the quote in the slightest. This has got to be the lamest defense I've heard yet.

>>2177
You fucking autist that's not the part of the post you should focus on.

>>2171
americans pretend to understand what it is and have associated it with liberalism because they suck mainstream medias cock without noticing and have internalized the anti-sjw narrative surronding it and/or have been exposed to liberals bastardizing it online (which is basically the same thing)

Its a ML perspective and in line with lenins ideas around the underclass + she advocated for the USSRs progression for women as a great example ect

>>2178
Why not?

>>2167
>It was the German-backed puppet republic’s attempt to normalize bourgeois morality into law that proved the final straw for the proles of Russia.
Cut the moral lecture crap and read a book about the October Revolution

>>2167
>The status quo is the status quo, and the bourgeoisie typically lean towards libertine social morales.
what matters is that the bourgeoisie owns the means of production, not their "social morales"
> It wasn’t outrage over the mean ol bigot Tsar Nicholas that caused the Russian Revolution, he was ousted in a bourgeois coup.
You are mixing things up. People hated tsar nicholas for many reasons. For his tsarist autocracy and for his (and by extension, the army and the okhrana's) antisemitism. Lenin denounced tsarist and white army antisemitism frequently and reminded the workers that there were jews among both bourgeoisie and proles.
>It was the German-backed puppet republic’s attempt to normalize bourgeois morality into law that proved the final straw for the proles of Russia.
it was kerensky's government insisting on staying in WW1 while people were starving that was the final straw, not liberal social values or some shit. you're spooked. It was the Germans who actually opportunistically helped Lenin return to Russia thinking he would sue for peace or at the very least sow chaos. Lenin signed Brest-Litovsk while Kerensky would have kept fighting the Germans like England and the USA wanted him to. Lenin bringing an end to WW1 made Russia's allies in WW1 seethe hard and accuse *him* of being a German puppet. But none of this had to do with the social politics. Nobody overthrew Kerensky because of women's suffrage or some shit like that. They overthrew him because he insisted on continuing to fight the same imperialist war that the tsar had been fighting before he abdicated.
> The same pattern can be found in communist revolutions across the world.
the completely ahistorical bullshit you are saying does not constitute a "pattern."
>Like it or not when the time comes the communists and social conservatives will be one and the same
The communists in the USSR were militant atheists who opposed the church and other socially conservative institutions you absolute pseud. Private property is also a conservative institution. Conservatism is defending the bourgeoisie as they currently exist. Liberalism is bourgeois incremental reform. Reactionaries wish to return to how things used to be. None of these are socialist.
> the radical liberals will be on the side of international capital
liberals and conservatives are both bourgeois. they just have different emphasis in strategy. Socialists are separate from both liberals and conservative bourgeoisie.

>>2176
It's not a mistranslation, someone posted the handwritten manuscript in this very thread. I have also seen the original printed German. he called lassalle a JN. It's not worth rubbing in people's faces.

>allowed to

File: 1670449134466.jpg (105.61 KB, 680x683, lassalle crow.jpg)


>>2171
based

>>2176
Its not a mistranslation you dick. We went over this already. Sure, the N word and antisemitism didn't carry the same weight in 1800s Germany as it does in 2020's America, but he literally did say Jewish nigger. You could say he said Jewish negro, at best, but the word he used was literally an N followed by an i, then two g, then an e, then an r.

>>2176
>a mistranslation
lol
>>2187
yeah I mean just check out the photograph of the actual letter that one anon posted a while back

>>2187
It wasn't antisemitic though. He put German and Jewishness on par with each other, as compared to basic negroid stock on the other hand.

>Now, this blend of Jewishness and Germanness, on the one hand, and basic negroid stock

>>2187
I just don't get why marx said it at all. his political criticisms of lassalle were valid, why package it like that? I think it was his heavy drinking, coupled with his expectation that his correspondence would remain private. I don't think marx was racist. he celebrated the end of american slavery and spoke fondly of the emancipation of black people from that bondage. So I hate when liberals bring up that quote to "cancel" marx. I've seen conservatives do it too. Their tone is different. It's more like "you say we're racist but look at what YOUR GUY said!" then people on here bring it up to be edgy. all 3 cases are stupid and pointless.

>>2189
ok got it, thanks

>>2190
>I think it was his heavy drinking, coupled with his expectation that his correspondence would remain private.
Very likely true. Also Lassalle basically told Marx to basically sell Marx's daughter (sell to Lassalle?) for marriage in order to pay his debt to Lassalle. Lassalle was an arrogant prick as well and was collecting on debts from Marx. Meanwhile Marx had already sold basically all his belongings to keep afloat.

>>2190
Lincoln was the one who freed the slaves and was an abolitionist before taking office even but he was racist as fuck. Why is it so hard to think someone could simultaneously not agree with slavery but also think Blacks are inferior?

>“There is a physical difference between the white and the black races which I believe will forever forbid the two races living together… while they do remain together there must be the position of superior and inferior, and I as much as any man am in favor having the superior position assigned to the white race.”

>>2193
lincoln was not an abolitionist, he was a free soiler. he advocated making the western territories free states but allowing the south to keep slaves. the south was triggered by this because it would mean non-slave states would eventually get a majority in the senate and do peaceful abolition. the south wanted to secede to prevent that from ever being a possibility. it was lincoln's more radical republican colleagues like thaddeus stevens who were abolitionist. Lincoln was a centrist free-soiler. Emancipation proclamation exempted loyal southern states and only applied to disloyal states. 13th amendment had a loophole for carceral slavery. slavery was never really 100% abolished but marx did celebrate the end of agrarian chattel slavery.

>Why is it so hard to think someone could simultaneously not agree with slavery but also think Blacks are inferior?


>“There is a physical difference between the white and the black races which I believe will forever forbid the two races living together… while they do remain together there must be the position of superior and inferior, and I as much as any man am in favor having the superior position assigned to the white race.”



yes I'm aware many abolitionists were racist, and I'm aware of this lincoln quote. people argue over whether it was calculated to win the election or not, since he said it on the campaign trail. people make history, but they are not free to do it as they please.

>>2193
The only negative comment you see of Marx to black people, it is this letter and particularly that line. Because of that reason, people try to cancel him on Marx's antisemitism, which includes this line, but also his response to Bauer, the famous OTJQ, which is misconstrued by the right to be a denunciation of Jewish people. That is basically the most dirt they have on him, besides being an alcoholic, relying on Engels for patronage, and having an affair, which the right also brings up frequently.

There is simply no strong evidence to support this hypothesis and strong evidence to support the contrary.

As for Lincoln, yeah I don't know, but also not surprised.

>>2118
>>2120
He's referencing Marx's letter to Engels about Lassalle.

>>2188
Look at those words. Poor Jenny.

>>2175
Intersect-pol is indeed theory that has a tendency to fragment the working class

>>2113
it all depends on where you go, canada's communists are kinda stuck in a bit of idpol autism vortex

File: 1670451090105.png (6.54 MB, 2448x3264, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2197
Jenny wrote Capital and gave Karl credit because of patriarchy

File: 1670451193780.jpg (27.2 KB, 220x510, reagan tinfoil.jpg)

>>2200
>the moids know

>>2200
Honestly, Marx's handwriting so is indecipherable, he probably wrote something down crap that no-one really understood and the Jenny Gang all formulated what came to be known as Capital.

>>2197
it looks like hebrew lol, maybe /pol/ was right.

File: 1670454010249.png (742.49 KB, 1080x1036, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2185
>person who made a bunch of images with the same message tells others they're unoriginal

>>2165
They want to grow, and are self-admittedly stagnant (see fbi.gov leaks and general accusations of being feds by target audience) at around 200 people. They're not ready to die for a cause and they don't have enough people to make that worth it anyway.

Honestly, do you think they have a path to victory by beating up cops? It's the same people at each protest, they can't afford to be perma-arrested, just slaps on the wrist by cops who probably don't hate them as much as anteefus.

>>2204
It's not about the n word or not.

>It is now quite plain to me — as the shape of his head and the way his hair grows also testify — that he is descended from the negroes who accompanied Moses’ flight from Egypt (unless his mother or paternal grandmother interbred with a uyghur). Now, this blend of Jewishness and Germanness, on the one hand, and basic negroid stock, on the other, must inevitably give rise to a peculiar product. The fellow’s importunity is also uyghur-like.


Whatever, Marx didn't like jewish niggers, negroes, whatever word you want to use. It's not the beginning and ending of a person.

File: 1670455400424.png (138.77 KB, 300x422, ClipboardImage.png)

Jewish nigger and Marx is old hat. What about Engels?

>My dear Laura, My congratulations to Paul le candidat du Jardin des Plantes—et des animaux. Being, in his quality as a uyghur, a degree nearer to the rest of the animal kingdom than the rest of us, he is undoubtedly the most appropriate representative of that district. Let us hope the animaux will have the best of it in this struggle against the bêtes." (Marx/Engels Collected Works. Vol. 48. Letters 1887-90. [Engels to Laura Lafargue in Paris. London, 26 April 1887]. pp. 52-54).

>>2124
Sakai does not say this. It's called "mythology of the white proletariat" or i.e. the lies white labour leaders tell about their history.

>>2138
> Probably going to directly cause large scale ethnic repression.
It already is. Look at Ukraine and the Donbass region right now.
It’s woke to call Russians a bunch of homophobic orcs who need to be genocided.

>>2206
> It's not the beginning and ending of a person.

of course not. i'm against 3 things
<liberals bringing up this quote to "cancel" marx and his economic ideas
<conservatives bringing up this quote to "prove" communists are more racist than capitalists
<leftypolers using the word filter exception to insult other leftypolers they don't like and then immaturely pretend it's just to make redditors seethe or that it's OK because it's a "reference" to something marx said

File: 1670455865421.png (191.25 KB, 474x343, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2207
https://wikirouge.net/texts/en/Democratic_Pan-Slavism_(1849)

>How did it happen that over Texas a war broke out between these two republics, which, according to the moral theory, ought to have been "fraternally united" and "federated", and that, owing to "geographical, commercial and strategical necessities", the "sovereign will" of the American people, supported by the bravery of the American volunteers, shifted the boundaries drawn by nature some hundreds of miles further south? And will Bakunin accuse the Americans of a "war of conquest", which, although it deals with a severe blow to his theory based on "justice and humanity", was nevertheless waged wholly and solely in the interest of civilization? Or is it perhaps unfortunate that splendid California has been taken away from the lazy Mexicans, who could not do anything with it? That the energetic Yankees by rapid exploitation of the California gold mines will increase the means of circulation, in a few years will concentrate a dense population and extensive trade at the most suitable places on the coast of the Pacific Ocean, create large cities, open up communications by steamship, construct a railway from New York to San Francisco, for the first time really open the Pacific Ocean to civilization, and for the third time in history give the world trade a new direction? The "independence" of a few Spanish Californians and Texans may suffer because of it, in someplaces "justice" and other moral principles may be violated; but what does that matter to such facts of world-historic significance?

>>2209
>It’s woke to call Russians a bunch of homophobic orcs who need to be genocided.
it's reactionary is what it is. "woke" is a stupid buzzword that means something different to whoever is using it. it ought to be wordfiltered to "bourgeois"

>>2164
Lassalle was literally mixed race, no shit

>>2213
My father got beat up for being mexican when he was a kid and working at a sweatshop in the USA, the kids who abused him were from union families that wanted to keep out immigrants to corner to labor market. Intersectionality is a good development in the backwards society of the USA, libs obviously push it so as to choke out class consciousness, but its still good.

>>2214
oops, meant to reply to OP

File: 1670456511211.png (228.12 KB, 429x511, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2211
That was another Engels quote. My bad.

File: 1670444750145-0.png (345.29 KB, 485x600, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1670444750145-1.png (326.79 KB, 1618x1131, ClipboardImage.png)

>>1295175
Not antisemitic at all. How many times can you have it explained? It's about being mixed with uyghur and not pure superior Jewish blood. Is this meme anti-white?(not pol, it is explaining pol logic)


Unique IPs: 20

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]