>>1899113>I read the article, it's retarded. >Immigration doesn't hurt anyone. Only one ousting yourself here as an idiot is you because it covers more than "immigration". It's VERY clear you didn't read.
From the article
<The Soviet Union gave diplomatic recognition to Israel on May 17, 1948, just three days after its declaration of independence. It was the first state in the world to do so — long before the United States. <The CPUSA and associated publications for Jewish people had always rejected Zionism and the idea of a Jewish state. When the Zionist “union” in Palestine, the Histadrut, tried to boycott Palestinian workers, the American communists referred to it — correctly — as a “Jim Crow” institution. The CPUSA, despite its Stalinist politics, had a proud tradition of struggle against racism — and it denounced the racism of the Zionist colonization project.
<In 1947, however, the Soviet Union surprised the world by announcing that it would support the UN plan for partitioning Palestine and creating a Jewish state.
<Stalin’s shift to support for Zionism was vital — one could say that Israel might not exist in its current form had the Soviet Union not offered its backing. Historians suspect that Stalin hoped to weaken the position of British imperialism in the region — perhaps he saw the Jewish colonists as a kind of national liberation movement. But in reality, the prediction of all serious Marxists came true: the new Jewish state became a gendarme for imperialism.
<Soviet support for Israel was not limited to diplomatic means, either. Via Czechoslovakia, the Soviet block sent arms to the Zionist militia Haganah, which used them to begin the ethnic cleansing of Palestine. In other words, Stalin gave material support for the Nakba. The Soviet-aligned Communist Party, the MAKI, became an important conduit of support for establishing the Zionist state.So just to be clear the man had a hand in
arming and
recognising a settler colonial
ethno-state which was hellbent on killing Palestenians and genociding them- this is what the whole NAKBA was founded on, and Stalin, idiot that he was
decided to support it
<There is no collective punishment, you idiot. Punishment implies those people were repressed. Do you consider slavs and jews getting evacuated from the Western USSR a collective punishment, too? What about population exchanges? Stop being idiotic. YAY, LET'S KEEP PEOPLE ROOTED TO THEIR PLACE EVEN IF IT WILL LEAD TO GREATER BLOODSHED, because BOURGEOIS law says it's BAAAAAD to move people around, even if people themselves are happy with the changes. Despite, again, evidence contradicting your views, and once again,
proving that you don't fucking read. I suppose we should state that Israel
isn't committing war crimes because those too are framed under the category of
bourgoise law.
Once again, the Stalin dickrider does the whole
<well Stalin did it, so what? This wasn't a populating exchange, this was a forced deportation and liquidation of their republic and was done with the intent of collective punishment as stated by the NKVD. Here's some more sources which you'll no doubt
not read and call "bourgoise propaganda" that clearly point out collective punishment, which, remember
is a war crime.
And again, this also carries onto the Volga Germans. Translated from the article linked (which again, you totally read):
<According to reliable information received by the military authorities, among the German population living in the Volga region there are thousands and tens of thousands of saboteurs and spies who, on a signal given from Germany, are to carry out explosions in the areas inhabited by the Volga Germans.
<None of the Germans living in the Volga region reported to the Soviet authorities about the presence of such a large number of saboteurs and spies among the Volga Germans, and consequently, the German population of the Volga regions hides in their midst the enemies of the Soviet people and Soviet power.
<In the event of acts of sabotage initiated by German saboteurs and spies on the orders of Germany in the Volga German Republic or adjacent areas, and bloodshed occurs, the Soviet Government, in accordance with the laws of wartime, will be compelled to take punitive measures against the entire German population of the Volga region.
<In order to avoid such undesirable phenomena and to prevent serious bloodshed, the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the U.S.S.R. recognized the necessity of resettling the entire German population living in the Volga regions to other regions so that the resettlees would be given land and that they would be provided with state assistance in settling in the new areas.
<Areas of the Novosibirsk and Omsk regions, the Altai Territory, Kazakhstan and other neighboring areas, abounding in arable land, have been allocated for resettlement. In connection with this, the State Defense Committee was ordered to urgently resettle all the Germans of the Volga region and to endow the resettled Volga Germans with land and land in the new areas. <Chairman of the Presidium of the Supreme of the Council of the USSR M. Kalinin Secretary of the Presidium of the Supreme of the Council of the USSR A. Gorkin
>inb4 but they were allowed to re-settle with aid of the governmentTHIS JUST IN FOLKS, THE RESERVATIONS FOR INDIGENOUS AMERICANS WHO WERE FORCED OFF THEIR LAND AND FORCED TO LIVE ON WEREN'T VICTIMS OF GENOCIDE! Never mind how Cherokee people were allocated land to "farm on". That makes it a-okay! No ethnic deportation whatsoever
I guess the indigenous Australians who are """"supported by the Australian government""""" aren't victims of genocide either!
The moustached fuckwit was complacent in ethnic deportations.
COPE This just in folks: war-crimes and collective punishment and ethnic deportation are a-ok because "something something bourgoise law"
>You are accusing Stalin of 1) not being heavy handed enough as to overrule Soviet democracy 2) of not being clairvoyant enough to foresee that in the future psychiatry, i.e. all the authoritative sources, would stop thinking that gay is a disease. This is idiotic, againAgain, more evidence you don't read. I stated he was
complicit in it, in the same way that Joe Biden's complicit in the same way how trans and LGBTQ people are being treated in the USA- what with hundreds of anti-trans/gay bills that are still being put in affect. And again, Stalin to his credit tried to introduce further democratic reforms. Where did you get this fuckwit strawman visage of my argument.
It's almost as if you
didn't read the articles linked >>1899129Kind of hard to defend that when the Soviets dissolved these republics for these ethnic minorities- you know the republics which were established to
protect them and ensure they had autonomy.
Clearly, someone hasn't read Lenin and the national question. But then again, considering you don't read at all, this isn't exactly hard.
>>1899127
>Oh, and banditry. <muh banditry We're not talking about the banditry that occurred in the Ukraine you fuckwit, we're talking about the Crimean Tartars and Volga Germans. I'd talk about the Koreans but it's clear that seeing as you haven't read about the previous two groups, or no groups at all it diminishes the purpose.
>Consult the following pic, and also realize that bandits from back then were even more vicious than today's Ukrainian Nazis. If today's Ukrainian Nazis have at least a decency to put people on trial for "betraying" Ukraine, back then they burned whole fucking villages of Ukrainians for "betraying the nation". But again, we're not talking about the Ukranians dude, stick on topic.
<That's how ethnic mafias and banditry operate, they are a fucking blight on their nationals, and nationals are LIBERATED by bandits getting killed. So, Soviets moved nationals away from bandits' affected areas, and bandits fucking STARVED to death without food and recruits. It happened in Caucasus, it happened in West Ukraine, in happened in the Baltics. That's why worshippers of SS Galicia fucking HATE IT to this dayAgain, you talk about "banditry" but at the end of the day, you're using a buzzword. The intent spelled out by the soviet union was clear- collective punishment on the belief that the population was in collaboration with the Nazi party.
And as mentioned, collective punishment
is a war crime. If you don't think any of this is wrong, you may as well be siding with Israel when they target Palestenian non-combatants.