[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Not reporting is bourgeois


File: 1749964707623.jpg (13.02 KB, 201x255, Fact chad.JPG)

 

we can all agree that trump is a fascist right?
>”America First” and says “Americanism not globalism”
>deporting minorities
>deporting political opponents
>supporting a fascist state in the Middle East
>sending the national guard to beat protesters
>has a cult of personality
>attempts to be expansionist
>obsessed with the military lately
Capitalism is clearly in decay so it makes the most sense to me

No. Saying the word "fascist" hurts the feefees of leftypol

>>2325953
>>”America First” and says “Americanism not globalism”
he said that 8 years ago and didn't mean a word of it
he's full of shit

Yeah, only person here that would have qualms with that is Haz, but it's good to offend him so that's more reason to say it on top of it's truthfulness.

>America first
>Look inside
>Cash for India
H-… HOG?


>>2325953
>every amerikkkan president ever
>>2326036
trump isnt fascist. https://fascipedia.org/index.php/Fascist_Manifesto

Read fascist manifesto. The social democrat has more in common with fascism than trump/

>>2326041
>The social democrat has more in common with fascism than trump/
So close.

>fascism
<look inside
<liberalism

>>2326050
Well it is just more authoritarian liberalism.


>>2325953
If by fascist, you mean paper maiche ruler who does what daddy Thiel says (among others), then yes. Trump is a fixer at heart, who copied the entire working model of Roy Cohn, who Trump called a father figure. He was also close to Epstein, who did the same thing.

So what did Trump do? He captured the office, then sold it to the highest bidder. But at the same time, he has things that even he has direction on, and that's where you know who his masters are. It's clear that he's expanding the military-industrial complex and its police state, but he's not particularly good at it. This is also a function of the general ineptitude of the deep state at winning any wars at all right now.

The scary thing is how high he could actually be. He's by no means the top of world power, but the fact that they chose him and allowed him to run shows how loose they are willing to play with the state of the world. Granted, they probably believe they could step in at any time, and I have no doubt that they could. It's just the sloppiness that indicates decay and definitely not what I think people mean when they "fascist". Generally, I think people mean high competence, which is a necessary factor of actual authoritarianism. At best, we have an uber wealthy elite that is content to shutdown dissent, unable to turn their nation into a loyal, happy, and productive class of slaves. We are slaves, but those of us with eyes can plainly see this.

>>2326122
>fascist wiki
get out of here

File: 1750013278356.png (199.24 KB, 617x785, speidel.png)

>>2325953
the american state has been a fascist one long before trump and it will be long after trump, providing its status quo is maintained. trump isn't even the actual 'fuhrer' of this fascist state, he's a strong-man figurehead, merely a marionette in the puppet show of american 'democracy'

>>2325953
It is useful to call him that cause it connects him with a tradition of right wing dictatorships and dominance of capital over human beings.

>>2327397
Dangerously based answer, everyone will ignore it because it's the fundamentally correct one.

Trump is a fascist, fascism doesn't necessarily equal nationalist public policies. It's funny to me how muricans consider him to be a patriot. A true patriot in any country would do a heavy industrialization of the economy.

>>2327397
>>2327718
It's not. Stating "America has always been fascist" diminishes what Fascism is structurally, as defined by the Comintern before WW2.
It's not simply racism or having a few genocidal henchmen as part of your administration.
Fascism is more like the final stage of bourgeois dictatorship. With the human face ripped off.
It's when (national) capital can only survive through perpetual war and violence, and the entire state is organized around this purpose. And the most loathsome sadistic elements are mobilized and given free reign against all forms of opposition, including communists.

>>2327777
>Stating "America has always been fascist" diminishes what Fascism is structurally
You're strawmanning your opponent.

>>2327397
Saying the US was fascist at any time in the past is so mindbogglingly stupid.
>b-but Reagan was mean
In the US you could vocally disagree and protest Reagan, the Vietnam War, etc etc. Try doing analogous things in 1930s Germany, late 1930s-to-mid 1940s Japan, 1930s Italy, Hungary, Chile, Argentina, etc. Honestly Americans saying this shit is so stupid. "I'm in the anti-fascist resistance, just like the underground partisans against the Independent State of Croatia!" You're definitely like the people in Hue gunned down by Ngo Dinh Diem.
>b-but imperialist war, and racism
The bourgeoisie generally agrees on waging imperialist war, they generally agree on oppressing minorities, they generally agree on plundering the colonies. This is consistent across bourgeois states because even with freedom for the bourgeoisie to dissent, these are not the issues that are disagreed on. It is not what determines something is fascist or not. Fascism is when a bourgeois democratic system where bourgeois concerns are bickered about (which is something that is freely happening to this day, see the No Kings rally for an example of a rival bourgeois clique freely protesting against the ruling bourgeois clique) gives way a circle of financial capitalists who maintain a cobbled-together "unity" of the bourgeoisie, demanding discipline even from the bourgeoisie itself which normally wants to politically compete with each other over their petty differences.
The USA, UK, and France have never been fascist, excepting the Vichy regime.

>>2328118
I do think in case of the current admin, it's going there. And like the other places mentioned, it's been building up to it for a while.

>>2328126
I agree, many previous fascist systems were preceded by the bourgeoisie trying to patch up their bourgeois democratic system for their purposes in a variety of ways before just scrapping the whole thing. But I think its wrong say, "We're here! It's fascism now!"
Now is just a time when the American bourgeoisie is trying to prune elements of the bourgeois democratic system that they think are hampering their goal of maintaining US military and financial domination around the world. If this doesn't work, perhaps in a several number of years they will rubbish the whole thing and erect a fascist state in its place. I don't discount that. But to say, "Our government is officially fascist now!" or even, "We have been fascist for who knows how long!" is nonsense.

>>2325953
No, I don't agree.

America first is reheated jacksonian populism

>>2327777
>With the human face ripped off.
the most common word used to describe Zucc or other post-neoliberals is "soulless"
>national capital can only survive through perpetual war and violence, and the entire state is organized around this purpose
https://www.newyorker.com/books/under-review/the-palantir-guide-to-saving-americas-soul
>>2328118
>In the US you could vocally disagree and protest Reagan, the Vietnam War, etc etc
"If you ignore our holocaust, we're actually woke anti-racists who love the people trapped in our nazi ghettos!" Typical soy radlib
https://eji.org/news/nixon-war-on-drugs-designed-to-criminalize-black-people/

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/sep/08/ferguson-protest-leader-darren-seals-shot-dead-burning-car

>>2325953
amerikkka has supported the forces of fascism ever since the end of WW2, this is nothing new

>>2328915
>"If you ignore our holocaust, we're actually woke anti-racists who love the people trapped in our nazi ghettos!" Typical soy radlib
Speak some english faggot. And your links have nothing to do with the US being fascist or not. Liberals love racial oppression and crushing of the worker's movement! No shit! Try reading my whole post next time.

>>2325953
Dumbass, that is like every American president to one degree or another. The fact that you made a thread for this. It's just liberalism. It's probably you who has the idea of liberalism being "nice" or "peaceful", therefore they can't do a heckin militarism or beat up protesters.

I wish he was a fascist because then we'd get at least the bare minimums of corporatism and he'd lead us into a retarded war. Instead, he's just an ultra neolib. No, he's just a Bonapartism liberal, he even managed to seduce gusano, latino street gangs to support his senile ass. Deportations, racism, militarized police, fragrant disregard for law and so on aren't exclusive to fascism. It's been a part of pretty much every system of governance.

>>2325953
He is not a class-collaborationist, he is opposed to class-collaborationism more than any other politician in recent memory. He is not a fascist. The dems are infinitely closer to being fascist than he is.

>>2326115
>having a federation of worker councils or socialist republic or a bonapartist tyrant is meaningless slop
Absolute state.

>>2325953
Borderline at best. Hes still a republican democratically elected president instead of a honest despot ruling as a sovereign over the country and torturing and killing everyone who disagrees with him like traditional fascoids do. Liberals have this facade of humanism over their actions and drumpf still enjoys this.

>>2326024
>Wtf nationalism is a deluded lie by porkies
<Wtf Hitler didn’t actually care about muh heckin volk?

>Leftypol is fascist
Wow heckin awesome shocking reveal this thread was, this definitely hasn’t been the status quo since at least 2021 🙄

Israelis are goblins

>>2330495
I mean, here is a definition https://iask.ai/q/Define-fascism-3rrdafg going point by point : 1) (America first) leftwing nationalism exists, Stalin was a patriot 2) (minorities) illegals, as long as the concept of countries exist, they won't be the same. 3) (deport political opponents) I don't recall it, but supposing he did, that would make him an authoritarian, but does that make him "fascist" ? 4) (support fascist state) does supporting something, means you are it ?, Nixon supported Mao against the USSR, does that makes him maoist ? 5) (beat protesters) again authoritarian 6) (cult of personality) at which point narcissism ends, and cult of personality begins ? Trump is a narcissist, but does he makes statues/portraits of himself and spreads it around ? 7) (expansionism) did he tho ? wanting to buy greenland isn't fascism 8) (obsessed with military) this one hits closer Can't we just call him an oligarch with authoritarian tendencies and call it a day ?

>>2330568
Give up trying to format 😭

>>2330536
please stop insulting goblins

File: 1750090327528.jpeg (13.08 KB, 299x168, IMG_0512.jpeg)

I feel that war is pretty much inevitable at this point. A third world war is inevitable. And it will be the fascists and ethnonats who gain the most

It’s so over. Democracy is over. Civil rights is over. We lost

>>2330602
nuclear war is the best option atp

>>2330668
Don't waste water, recycle, eat vegan.

>>2325953
Here's the thing. Fascism isn't less bourgeois democracy. Fascism is the very peak of bourgeois democracy which occurs when the contradictions of finance capital begin to become a limit to its own development.

>>2327777
This, burgers are having it bad but it is not LE SCARY FASCISMUS, read this useless chart done by a liberal!!!. In turbulent times there are monsters and really it's all really mild comparing it to the historic precedents and what true Marxist theory shows.

File: 1750104740891.jpg (15.95 KB, 474x294, magic.jpg)

>liberal nation-state does thing I don't like
>it magically becomes fascism
abracadabra

feels like leftoids cant care about capitalism if they dont label it with hysterical ahistorical terms

>>2330775
>when the contradictions of finance capital begin to become a limit to its own development.
retard pseud. how was this case the case the only time fascism happened in germany and italy a century ago. it was the middle class revolting against a strong proletariat you fuck

>>2331341
Germany was a modern imperialist state ruled by finance capital
What a stupid fucking forum

>>2330568
I already agree that the grand Bourgeois Union was hardly distinguishable from any other autocratic bourgeois regime

>>2331468
nice buzzwords fag-o-tron

le imperialism is the stage of capital where monopoly capitalism is directed by finance capitalism. ignore that this pretty much applies to all fully capitalist countries today and says nothing about fascism as a specific moment in history LOL

>>2331504
>Wtf if every country is imperialist who am I supposed to root for!?!?!?
90% of modern “communists” (liberals) unironically

>>2326036
even haz is against trump now, maybe the sleeper republican acp cells didn't wake up

>>2325953
He obviously is.
>NOOOOO REAL FASCISTS ONLY EXISTED IN ITALY FROM 1922 TO 1943!!!!!!!

File: 1750108851484.jpg (68.04 KB, 1022x731, 1570285838971.jpg)

>>2331608
please tell me where there is currently a labor movement as strong as it was during the year before the rise of fascism in italy and germany lmfao

>>2331617
>Being retarded enough to think fascism, which always arose after retarded cunt leftists led workers to their deaths, requires a strong labor movement to emerge
>90% of leftoids unironically hope capital will protect them from itself until they’re strong enough to threaten it
<Leftoids are unironically choosing to be at the mercy of the bourgeoisie because they think their enemies are like them, too stupid to learn from the past

>>2331687
>fascism, which always arose after retarded cunt leftists led workers to their deaths
take your meds you subhuman

>>2331703
>No how dare you point out that worker’s movements are consistently destroyed when leftoids encourage them to take retarded maneuvers, from voting for war credits to refusing to strike to demobilizing to engage in adventurist sectarian actions that solve nothing!?
<Obviously our enemies are supposed to play fair so we have a decent shot at victory
<<Anyway let me explain now how the powers of capital won’t happily mobilize fascist movements to destroy the emergent worker’s movements before they gain enough force to threaten capital again

>>2331608
How is trump a fascist

>>2326037
USA has to bribe BJP treatlerites or China will do it.

>>2327777
>It's when (national) capital can only survive through perpetual war and violence, and the entire state is organized around this purpose. And the most loathsome sadistic elements are mobilized and given free reign against all forms of opposition, including communists.
USA falls apart without MIC, anon.

>>2331749
He offends me 😢 I don't like him 😭

>>2331791
FDR was more fascist than trump going by fascist manifesto.

>>2325953
His intent is fascism, but he hasn't achieved it yet. He himself can probably be considered a fascist politician purely through messaging and intent "MAGA"/reactionary narrative.

Trump is a transphobe bigot who loves the poor and doesn’t support furbaby adoption

Trump wants to take away all of my drugs and dildos

>>2333149
😱 😭🤌

>>2331749

He is a puppet of Israel, which is a fascist regime.

>>2333275
but israel is collapsing right now because of trump command

>conservative parlementary democracy and crooks is fascism
I hate the right and even i find this idiotic. They are not even fascists at the cultural level, they are as liberal as Obama they only hate trans people to distract from ethnic replacement of whites and the fact our elites created a society that is not worth living in for most people. They don't even believe in the eugenic stuff they claim to desire.

>>2326122
Completely missed my point, read Bordiga.

>>2333372
no. bordiga is a trotskyite. trotskyites are fascists.

>>2333393
>no. bordiga is a trotskyite. trotskyites are fascists.
Bruh, what?

>>2333306
>to distract from ethnic replacement of whites
Fact Check: Wrong.
There are more white people living in America today than there were 40 years ago.

Let me aks you a question. At what point did Hitler turn from a democratically elected liberal into a fascist despot? There is the line between fascism and liberalism

>>2333654
Enabling Act of 1933

>>2333463
Doesn't this simplify to Lenin^(Lenin+Lenin) = Lenin^4 ?

>>2333463
bordiga was a trotskyite. This is simple

>>2333636
Yes but you know what i mean. Theres lots of non-whites and whites feel bad about it for a various of economic and cultural reasons.

>>2333698
Complete individual control over the state its not even an oligarchy but despot and its advisers.

>>2327777
>Fascism is more like the final stage of bourgeois dictatorship. With the human face ripped off.
Its not just because Trotsky said it.
>It's when (national) capital can only survive through perpetual war and violence, and the entire state is organized around this purpose. And the most loathsome sadistic elements are mobilized and given free reign against all forms of opposition, including communists.
That's literally America before Trump idiot.


Unique IPs: 51

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]