[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/siberia/ - Off-topic

"No chin, no right to speak."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Not reporting is bourgeois


File: 1749373916783.webp (55.36 KB, 1000x750, schindlers.webp)

 

Is Schindler's List a left-wing movie?

>>675654
fuck no. it's lib entertainment

Fiction

>>675656
>>675658
You retards do realize everything in the movie actually happened right…?

Oskar Schindler was a hero who saved the lives of hundreds of Jews who would have been gassed in Auschwitz without his interventions. There are literally thousands of Jews living in Israel who would not be alive today if it weren't for Oskar Schindler's courage and defiance in the face of fascism.

File: 1749377037204.gif (70.52 KB, 136x102, risitas.gif)


Hm lets make a movie about a repentant nazi who saved a few dozen jews rather than about the red army who defeated the nazis and liberated the camps

>>675665
these would be 2 completely different movies

>>675666
So?
Don't make movies about heroic nazis

>>675668
well he wasted his entire fortune to save a thousand jews, not a dozen. its a good story

>>675665
>>675668
There were many in the East Germany government and military who were former Nazis. Everyone who was remotely successful or intelligent in Germany in the 1930-40s was associated with the Nazis in some way.

>>675673
Stalin should have given them the volga treatment

>>675674
Stalin actually supported the accomodation of former Nazis in the DDR. He even set up a political party for them and suggested bringing back the old Nazi-era newspaper as the party's official magazine.

>>675659
ya but he was a business owner

I read somewhere a long time ago that Schindler wasn't even doing it on some sort of principal but because he was a thrill seeker who got off on risking his neck. I have no idea where I read it, where they got their info, or anything but it stuck in my head. I think it would've made for a more fun movie but they obviously weren't shooting for fun.

>>675699
You don't risk your neck by bribing state officials.

File: 1749394751919.gif (348.13 KB, 350x233, 1705270096640.gif)

>>675659
sorry but we're nazbol gang here. move on.

It‘s liberal because it‘s about heroic individuals instead of systems and their transformation (e.g. socialists destroying fascism and therefore saving all the remaining European Jews from death). Liberalism always zooms in on individuals instead of informing people about systems, more precisely capitalism and class struggle. Almost like you are supposed to remain ignorant and in a limbo while cherry picking minuscule acts of heroism that wouldn‘t have changed much in the grand scheme.

well-meaning moral capitalists are still capitalists at the end of the day but points for the bougie failson for not simply just going with the flow with the nazi regime like a lot of other capitalists and megacorporations

Even in this lib movie, Schindler was a bougie adulterer even after he freed those jews. Not gonna trash him for doing the right thing, but he still was a piece of shit.

>>675729
>he saved the lives of thousands of jewish civilians during the holocaust but was mean to femoids so therefore bad

>>675731
I don't care that he was mean to women, I care that he was literally no different than people like Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos

>>675731
womyn are the most oppressed category of people. j*ws are barely even people, much less oppressed ones. educate yourself liberal

File: 1749407437169.jpg (36.31 KB, 622x619, 1648804591451.jpg)

>>675735
Strawmanning. Typical behavior of a glownonymous.

>>675734
Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos wouldn't give up their entire fortunes and risk their lives to save people who were viewed as subhuman. Also Oskar Schindler was barely scraping by for most of his life, he was very bad at being a capitalist.

>>675735
If given the opportunity I would anally rape you in a heartbeat. You would need a colostomy bag after I was finished with you.

>>675735
>Jews are not people

Feminists not beating the allegations of racism

>>675735
Also, you're wrong. Children and elderly are the most oppressed

It's holocaust industry slop valorizing the one good German porky and implicitly saying that people should have just been nice like this man and the holocaust wouldn't happen.

>>675659
>You retards do realize everything in the movie actually happened right…?
It's a fictionalized account of a real person who did real things. It's not a documentary.

>>675654
It certainly shows the mask off genocidal fascism but to me the real genocide was mass murdered communists.

its the SWINDLER'S list because he illegitimately took away workers from the socialistic republic of germany

>>675714
cool now make a movie about systems instead of people and try to find 1 person who would be willing to watch that shit. at this point youre just asking for a documentary.

>>675824
Terry Gilliam's Brazil is kind of about systems.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/80-years-ago-how-a-very-different-schindlers-list-helped-ignite-wwii/

>After officially joining the Nazi party in 1939, Schindler was called upon to prepare a false-flag attack related to the Gleiwitz tower. The borderlands were fueled with anti-Polish propaganda, and Schindler would help light one of many matches.


>Contrary to the film portrayal of Schindler entering Krakow on the heels of the German army, he started eyeing businesses and homes there before the invasion of Poland. During the period that Schindler was getting to know Krakow, his agents were gathering supplies for the coming false-flag attack at Gleiwitz — Polish army uniforms? Check. Weapons? Check. Polish cigarettes? Check. Necessities for the Gleiwitz operation were stored in Schindler’s apartment, according to his estranged wife Emilie’s post-war testimony.


>Collectively, the false-flag operations and anti-Polish propaganda were called “Operation Himmler.” One week before the planned invasion of Poland, Hitler warned his generals about the “propagandistic casus belli” being prepared, assuring them the “credibility” of any “justifications” for invading Poland would not be questioned after Germany’s ultimate victory.


>In keeping with Heinrich Himmler’s penchant for exploiting concentration camp prisoners, a number of them were murdered to stage the border incidents. After being dressed in Polish uniforms, the victims — known as “canned goods” — were given lethal injections and gunfire wounds. Their corpses were displayed at several strategic installations near the border as proof of Poland’s aggression.


>For the Gleiwitz operation, a German farmer known for sympathizing with Poland was murdered and his corpse left out for the press to photograph. He was meant to be the Polish “attacker” of the famous radio tower, killed by its German defenders. A fake Polish-language radio announcement about capturing the radio tower was heard with alarm by millions of Germans.

>>675837
he was just following orders


Unique IPs: 23

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]