[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/siberia/ - Off-topic

"No chin, no right to speak."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Not reporting is bourgeois


File: 1755930169902.jpg (81.04 KB, 1280x486, 734 - stirner.jpg)

 

>I swear bro, we just need a few more years of state capitalism
> you just need to work like a slave in the uranium mines for one more decade, I swear bro then you'll own the means of production, trust me bro

>bro just one more rival tendency needs to be purged
>just one more disagreement and we'll finally crack it I swear

Make Spookposting Great Again™

if communism has to be worldwide and is impossible in one country then socialist states are in a holding pattern while they wait for you to overthrow your own bourgeoisie. The required productive forces for defense of the revolution is always relative to the external forces that seek to overthrow it, and revolution is the one job that cannot be outsourced.

>i just wanna smoke weed and play video games


if everyone were like you nobody would get taken care of in maternity wards or old folks homes. buildings wouldn't get built. surgeries wouldn't get performed. snow wouldn't get shoveled. grass wouldn't get mowed. mold would grow in houses. the standard of living would rapidly decline.

>>702387
and what if everyone were a little bit lazier? the state would come in and force people to work, just like they did during the industrial revolution. people refused but they were threatened with death for not complying. your sick vision of a productive world is from the gaze of a slave master. maybe we need less buildings and maybe more people need to die, so that everyone else can live.

File: 1755938876498.png (58.21 KB, 1319x2357, grapes of wrath.png)

>>702390
>and what if everyone were a little bit lazier?
the development of the productive forces in a post-capitalist world enables massive abundance and fewer working hours, while under capitalism, the ruling class uses strategies like artificial scarcity, planned obsolescence, and the deliberate destruction of the productive forces to keep people working even when they don't need to be, and to keep necessities scarce even when they would otherwise be abundant.

>>702391
but if there were less people then we would have more stuff anyway. the focus on productivity itself is a curse.

File: 1755940017838.png (201.14 KB, 480x480, ClipboardImage.png)

>>702397
>but if there were less people then we would have more stuff anyway
we don't just need stuff. we need caretakers when we get old. also you're repeating malthusian errors and confusing population growth with the growth of productivity. productivity can grow even when there is less people and things by simply making things more efficient. miniaturization of computers is one example .

>you just need to work like a slave in the uranium mines for one more decade
Amazing that people keep repeating this shit at face value as if it were true. Workplace discipline in ML states was very lax, the pace of work was relatively slow, workers enjoyed extensive rights to vacation and other paid time off, they couldn't be fired, they could openly criticize management, and they participated directly in the administration of the workplace.

File: 1755943134988.png (1.11 MB, 828x1034, ClipboardImage.png)

>>702402
stirner anon just wants to smoke weed, play video games, and lie about communism while capitalists do pic related

File: 1755945278440-1.png (726.47 KB, 1290x1729, go directly to gulag.png)

File: 1755945278440-2.png (610.5 KB, 1290x967, Ccdd.png)

>>702390
You are not a communist; you're a parasite!

>>702374
I’m personally fine living in a place like China that actually attempts to set limits on working hours and puts their bourgeois to death for stepping out of line occasionally. Their weed laws do suck tho

>>702414
tankies proving that they are just red fascists once more

>>702387
>>i just wanna smoke weed and play video games
he basically wants to be a billionaire or an absentee landlord

>>702416
>>702390
>>702374
I find it amazing that leftist complain about MLs being dictators just for wanitng a more efficient form of production yet they want all the freebies that life can bring them

>>702496
production = slavery

>>702504
If you think production is slavery, then you should be content with living like a nomad.

>>702374
> the only way people would want to bud things and save lives or invent is if you force them at gunpoint

Amazing, thr projection never stops

File: 1755969773419.png (407.47 KB, 1290x1690, engels on auth.png)

>>702416
I guess Engels was also a "red fascist" 😂🤡

>>702523
yes, he was.

File: 1755969935689.jpg (42.41 KB, 750x389, engels-authority.jpg)

>>702523
He was an imbecile, that's for sure.

>>702526
My toilet has authority over my pooping habits

>>702523
He was a capitalist and it is very obvious from his writings

File: 1755970276153.png (5.96 KB, 534x534, u1f614_u1f42d.png)

>>702529
Toilet fascism

>>702533
We must free ourselves and start shitting on the street!!

>>702520
>>702438
>>702416
>>702526

This.
All the complaints against MLs for wanting productivity is just lazy ass liberals who think leftism is giving out consolation prizes for life's biggest losers.
These are the same people who talk about state mandated girlfriends.
Yet they have a problem with a state mandated work schedule

>>702537
You are incapable of envisioning a better world, solidarity for you is not a possible trait of humanity thus it must be forced upon everyone. You are anti-social.

Doing communal work is great, working (even intense and long hours) is actually rewarding of it's own and you are unable to imagine that, I pity you

Everyone ITT is stupid except for me.

My problem with all hitherto existing MLism is that, in terms of actual material existence, rather than abstract ideology, they're indistinguishable from the various forms of capitalism. The Soviet Union functioned like monopoly capitalism, China functions like Keynesianism, etc.

I'm of the opinion that an actual DotP, one that maintains its goals of workers rule and the eventual achievement of full communism (a classless, stateless society) cannot be achieved with anything but some form of direct democracy. Unless the workers are managing themselves in a very literal sense, you're going to see the same social relationships as capitalism emerge, where two distinct segments of society with distinct material interests emerge; those that control and manage the means of production, and those that participate in it.

>>702556
Identical except for imperialism, genocide and colonial oppression being central to their mode of production

>>702535
India is Anarcho-toiletry

>>702374
>strawman of MLs!!!

>>702387
>oh yeah well strawman of anarchists!!!

>>702560
I did not say identical, I said indistinguishable. Definitions are for chumps, but I do pick my words deliberately.

China and the especially the Soviet Union are definitely different from the US and the UK, particularly in terms of how they treated the rest of the world, but the baseline social relation of employee and employer, the thing that defines capitalism as a system, was preserved in both. You can say I'm being reductionist, I say you're getting caught up on implementation details.

>>702575
>social relation of employee and employer, the thing that defines capitalism as a syste
Midwit

If there is no immediate reduction of working hours its not le communism


Unique IPs: 22

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]