[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/siberia/ - Off-topic

"No chin, no right to speak."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Not reporting is bourgeois


File: 1757861662217.jpg (51.68 KB, 640x825, hm43gto781t91.jpg)

 

>invade finland to secure the border against leningrad
>all it does is guarantee finland will invade during operation barbarossa and all the land ends up getting reconquered by the finns during it and leningrad gets encircled anyway.

What exactly was stalins masterplan here?

>>709514
You just said dummy

I wonder how OP doesn't realize that this vindicates Stalin

>>709520
In what way?

>>709514
true,he should've annexed finland

>>709521
Stalin was right that Finland would invade

Stalin was a pussy
HE hould have went to the end with the Finnish Democratic Republic

>>709524
*should

>>709523
I wonder if stalin invading finland and taking their land had something to do with that.

>>709526
>their land


>>709521
Finland joined the axis lol (and never got punished)

>>709531
Whats wrong with allying with the nazis? The ussr did it aswell so they could invade another country.

>>709531
"there's still time to punish Finland nazis" - Norman Finkelstein

>>709523
Why didn't he attempt to create a non aggression pact with Finland then? Even if Finland violated it, the Winter War not happening would mean the Red Army would be in better shape and the rest of the Allied powers would have had a lot less reservations about supporting the USSR.

>>709514
>know there is going to be a war
>get land before war
>have more land to trade for time once war starts
it was the correct move. treaties are just paper and borders are just imaginary lines, what matters in the end are the material conditions

>>709544
>know there is going to be a war
Except the war was never going to happen unless they they invaded and took finnish land first.
>have more land to trade for time once war starts
For what? Time all the finnish front accomplished for the russians was the loss of hundreds of thousands of troops dead that would've been way better used fighting the germans.

He was having a Putin moment.
It's ok though he got over it and took half of Europe later.

>>709545
>Except the war was never going to happen
you are mentally retarded. read mein kampf or a history book or something, the fascist plan from day 1 was to invade the soviet union
and finland was always going to join because they were fascist and why the fuck wouldn't they. don't worry about the thousand troops, they killed more finns than they lost troops so it was worthy. matter of fact, the only error stalin made was not nuking helsinki right after the first successful soviet nuclear test

>>709552
>you are mentally retarded.
Pure projection
>and finland was always going to join because they were fascist
The werent.
>and why the fuck wouldn't they
Why the fuck would they invaded a superpower when they had no reason to and nothing to gain from it.
>they killed more finns than they lost troops so it was worthy.
What the fuck does this even mean?
>only error stalin made was not nuking helsinki right after the first successful soviet nuclear test
Nah the only error stalin made was not dying of a stroke 15 years earlier.

>>709555
>the only error stalin made was not dying
the fascist shows his true face

>Pure projection

what a comeback. you have the brain of a dog

>Why the fuck would they invaded a superpower

to stop the revolution, to discipline their own working class, to annex land to placate their internal contradictions (that had led to the civil war), to give contracts to both local and german manufacturers, and generally the same reasons their main ally, both politically and ideologically, nazi germany, did

>>709557
>to stop the revolution, to discipline their own working class, to annex land to placate their internal contradictions (that had led to the civil war), to give contracts to both local and german manufacturers, and generally the same reasons their main ally, both politically and ideologically, nazi germany, did
Wow you literally just make a bunch of shit up lol.

>>709555
finalnd wasn't 'going' to join the war effort, they already had joined it, allowing nazis to use their territory for operation barbarossa, supporting nazi industry economically, aiding in the siege of leningrad, etc.

>>709559
They never would've done any of that in the first place had the ussr not invaded and taken their land during the winter war

>>709558
again, read mein kampf (a source that you, being a fascist, will trust more than my word). they saw organized industrial labor and big cities as a cradle for communism and wanted to replace it with a society of small landowners and farmers. their plan from day 1 was to expand east and exterminate the slavs so germans and their allies could settle there. emulating through the fascist state what the americans had done thought public-private means

>>709560
>source: trust me
dog brain

>>709562
Wtf does mein kampf have to do with finland?
>dog brain
But enough about yourself

>>709563
>Wtf does mein kampf have to do with finland?

>>709565
Yeah why dont you tell me

>>709566
check >>>/siberia/709552
fascism needs war to manage it's contradictions, be it germany or finland (by their own admission btw)

>>709567
finland wasnt facist and mein kampf is about nazism not facism
germany motivations for invading the ussr were not the same as finlands nor was its ideology youre literally just making shit up as you go

>>709568
>nazism not facism
lol. lmao. dog brain

>not the same as finlands

they literally did ethnic cleansing and settler projects on the land they stole, who are you trying to fool

>>709569
>they literally did ethnic cleansing and settler projects on the land they stolen
they never did either of the those unlike the soviets did to ingrian finns

>>709570
bro you are embarrassing yourself right now

More projection lol

>>709570
>>709565
Come on, both of you. Finland was not fascist or Nazi. They almost certainly would not have joined in on Operation Barbarossa without the invasion, just like how Sweden didn't join in.
However, Finland had some settler projects created on land they captured. This was almost certainly done in "revenge" for the Soviets taking land from them and sending Russians/other Soviet citizens there. Basically it was the "two wrongs make a right" fallacy applied to geopolitics.

Doesn't matter JDPON BBC won

>>709514
The original plan was to annex the entirety of Finland. It didn't happen.

I personally believe that the finnish ultimatum was to acquire fortified finnish lands for further steps of annexation just like baltics

I don't really care about whatever haphazard excuses the Soviets made at the time, fact of the matter is that conquering capitalist cities and enforcing a socialist economy there is based and good. Vyborg only ever saw socialism because the Russian People rightfully conquered it. If the Finns want to be vessels for capitalist relations it's only natural they be expelled.

>>709631
>enforcing a socialist economy there is based and good.
Why? The russians turned those places into absolute shitholes even to this day karelia remains poor.

File: 1757886712511.png (1.93 MB, 1000x2200, MRPact.png)

>>709532
>The non aggression pact was an alliance
no it was buying time.

>>709636
Yeah it gave the germans time and the natural resources to conquer all of europe the german tanks that crossed into the soviet union during operation barbarossa were running on soviet provided oil lol

>>709637
>Germany conquered Poland and France because of Soviet grain
Open a history book.

>>709634
1. the soviet union was a multi-ethnic country, you saying "russians" is your xenophobia slipping
2. the soviet union, specially at that time, had better growth prospects than the west because of the socialist planned economy. that's how they out-produced the nazis and their finnish allies (among others), for example. or how the average soviet citizen had a better diet than the average westerner

>>709638
Yeah, even if the USSR didn't sell them grain, the German army faltering relies on a bunch of assumptions on what others would do. Not that I'm in any way saying that MR was moral.

>>709514
Thats nice and all, but Charlie Kirk is still dead.
Haha.

>>709638
I'm not talking about grain i'm talking about oil retard.
At the eve of operation barbarossa 67% of german oil stockpiles were from the soviet union.
Had the soviets just not traded oil to germany then the nazi's wouldn't have even had enough oil to mount an invasion of the soviet union.

>>709637
>Yeah it gave the germans time and the natural resources to conquer all of europe
And it gave the Soviet Union time to restructure their army, modernize their military equipment, motorize their logistics and mechanize (to some degree) farming. The "all of europe" the nazis occupied was the europe that only offered testimonial resistance because the dominant classes and the military were ideologically aligned and complacent with the invaders (austria, czechoslovakia, poland, france), the same europe that allowed the fascists to intervene and turn the spanish civil war in favor of franco because they understood that socialism was their common enemy. It was a brilliant move by Stalin to trade such scum for 2 invaluable years.

>>709642
>source: literal nazi propaganda
retard

>>709642
Honestly you could be right or wrong, something like amount of oil sold is a lot harder to quantify the effects of than "how many men and weapons did you need to send to this front", which is what this thread was originally about, what was the purpose of the winter war, it basically only hurt the red army.

>>709645
What fucking nazi propaganda? This is literally public information the soviets had commercial agreements with germany from 1939-1941 during which they provided them with multiple million tons of oil ton.
You can literally just look this up.


Unique IPs: 21

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]