A thread focused on discussing the parasocial relationships cultivated by the
Almighty Algorithm to generate profit off of our atomization and society's commodification of petty internet drama.
Brace through the hyper-real lacanian void together!Reminder That None of This Is Real!™
ɢʀᴀʙ ᴀ ᴘᴀɪʀ ᴏꜰ sᴘᴇᴄᴛᴀᴄʟᴇs
—————————————————–
CORE THEORY >The Society of the Spectacle (1967) by Guy Debord📖 •
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/debord/society.htm📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0blWjssVoUQ
<The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction (1936) by Walter Benjamin📖 •
https://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/ge/benjamin.htm📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blq9sCIyXgA
>The Culture Industry from Dialectic of Enlightenment (1944) by Theodor Adorno & Max Horkheimer📓 •
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm📖 •
https://libcom.org/article/dialectic-enlightenment-philosophical-fragments-theodor-adorno-and-marx-horkheimer📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hSLdd8R8mY
<Understanding Media (1964) by Marshall McLuhan📖 •
https://leftypol.org/edu/src/1782045945238-0.pdf📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09ML9n5f1fE
>One-Dimensional Man (1964) by Herbert Marcuse📖 •
https://libcom.org/article/one-dimensional-man-studies-ideology-advanced-industrial-society-herbert-marcuse📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ZCoLbEkAqs
<Discipline and Punish (1975) by Michel Foucault📖 •
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/michel-foucault-discipline-and-punishment📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s82uU4iRuko
>Simulacra and Simulation (1981) by Jean Baudrillard 📖 •
https://leftypol.org/edu/src/1782045945238-1.pdf📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Yxg2_6_YLs
<Manufacturing Consent (1988) by Edward S. Herman & Noam Chomsky📖 •
https://libcom.org/article/manufacturing-consent-political-economy-mass-media-noam-chomsky-and-edward-s-herman📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34LGPIXvU5M
>The Sublime Object of Ideology (1989) by Slavoj Zizek📖 •
https://leftypol.org/edu/src/1782045945238-2.pdf📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TtIckkHsUQ4
<Postscript on the Societies of Control (1990) by Gilles Deleuze 📖 •
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/gilles-deleuze-postscript-on-the-societies-of-control📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hu4Cq_-bLlY
>Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (1991) by Fredric Jameson📖 •
https://leftypol.org/edu/src/1782045945238-3.pdf📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4k26xGx1zI
<Spectres of Marx (1993) by Jacques Derrida📖 •
https://libcom.org/library/specters-marx-jacques-derrida📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJr0NwXWb6Q
>Capitalist Realism (2009) by Mark Fisher📖 •
https://libcom.org/article/capitalist-realism-mark-fisher📺 •
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Cb5XJH4NMI—————————————————–
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL
>Precursor Material to Post-modernity and Critical Theory📖 •
Karl Marx - Book 1, Chapter 4 of
Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts (1844)
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/manuscripts/labour.htm📺 •
Why Marx Was Right: Alienation - PlasticPills
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPRxxN4Kh30📖 •
Georg Lukács - Chapter 4 of
History and Class Consciousness (1923)
https://www.marxists.org/archive/lukacs/works/history/hcc05.htm📺 •
Marxism After Marx: Reification - The Marxist Project
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZiI-QKxBKI 📖 •
Antonio Gramsci - Book 1, Chapter 1 of
Selections from the Prison Notebooks (1929)
https://www.marxists.org/archive/gramsci/prison_notebooks/problems/intellectuals.htm📺 •
Hegemony: WTF? An introduction to Gramsci and cultural hegemony - Tom Nicholas
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LI_2-qsovo📖 •
Louis Althusser -
Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses (1970)
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/althusser/1970/ideology.htm📺 •
Althusser's Concept of Ideology: A Discussion with Anthony Gavin - Acid Horizon
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtOqXxkKwvw
<Documentaries•
The Society of the Spectacle (1974) by Guy Debord
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjF6I6SYjgA•
Manufacturing Consent (1992) by Mark Achbar & Peter Wintonick, with Noam Chomsky
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Li2m3rvsO0I•
The Pervert's Guide to Cinema (2006) and
The Pervert's Guide to Ideology (2012) by Sophie Fiennes, with Slavoj Zizek
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYuI4SFw4g0https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBcFLmu_tlc•
HyperNormalisation (2016) by Adam Curtis
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bv3Tr3jvZM&rco
>Easy-Bake Breadtube (for absolute beginners)•
We're All Fake Now - Wisecrack
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTW1mPOJJ_Y•
Are Cell Phones Replacing Reality? - PBS Idea Channel
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8AXIAM7dTTg•
The Cultural Significance of Cyberpunk - Cuck Philosophy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nvor7hhDKTs•
Introduction to Critical Theory for the 21st Century - Nathan Dufour
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7stVZPGxIw•
The Work of Art in the Age of Surveillance Capitalism - Brendan Morris
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNKiBJJFXZI
<Situationist Archives•
https://situationist.org/•
https://notbored.org/SI.html•
https://bopsecrets.org/SI/index.htm—————————————————–
RECOMMENDED OP-EDS•
I Don’t Want to Be an Internet Person by Ginevra Davis
https://www.palladiummag.com/2022/11/04/i-do-not-want-to-be-an-internet-person/•
Pluralistic: Tiktok's enshittification by Cory Doctorow
https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys•
Facebook's Threads is so depressing by Jason O. Gilbert
https://jogblog.substack.com/p/facebooks-threads-is-so-depressing>>2955343>>2954970>>2954949Interesting discussion and something that is central to my existence. I don't think I can wade into every aspect of what you two are talking about, but I'd like to give my own take and I think I can explain it very simply without jargon or making it overly complex since I've tried to espouse it to so many people over the years. It has similarities to a lot of different views, and I believe that, if there is an objective truth, then everyone will come to the same conclusions naturally. Like the world being a globe, the Earth orbiting the sun, etc. etc. If it is objectively true, then with enough time and study, everyone will come to the same conclusions.
I believe "god" is the one true thing in existence. I'm god, you're god, everyone and everything is that thing. Everything that exists is purely imaginary. Like when you have a dream, everyone and everything in that dream is purely you right? That is how it is with the universe/existence whatever. Now that thing is the only thing that has ever existed or will ever exist or could possibly exist. We are all imaginary subdivisions of that infinite, solitary thing. One and infinity are the same thing. UNIverse. There is no "other universes" there is only that one thing. Our whole concept of things, being in a container, being BOUNDED, by some other concept or thing are irrelevant to that universal thing. In fact, all concepts are irrelevant. Things that exist can only exist in contrast to their opposite. This universal thing has no opposite, has no other. It is good and evil simultaneously, up and down, left and right, old and young. There is no before or after. That thing is qualitiless, because qualities are finite and only exist in the form of their imaginary opposite. Our, it's only existence is pure qualitlessness. It is suffering and pleasure at the same time, forever. It is literally ineffable, something else would have to exist for it to be described, since it is the only thing to exist, that's not possible.
Now back to the core question, why should a existence exist? Simply to pass the time. We have an eternity to work through. Time is an irrelevant concept to that thing because time is also imaginary.
So what is the purpose in even knowing this(or rather having an inkling, because it is impossible to know the truth, we are known, we can't know it.) Well it is like(back to the dream analogy) gaining lucidity in a dream. You come to have power over that dream. Does it matter at all in some grand scheme of things? No it doesn't, nothing matters at all. It really is a question of ending this cycle/existence whatever, faster or slower, but that is also irrelevant because we still have an eternity of existences to go through. I believe that all things gravitate to this truth and will become one with it in enough time eventually. I like to say that we are beyond the event horizon of god/that thing. Because it doesn't matter if you move left/right/up/down in relation to anything else, because you are always on a trajectory to it.
>>2955345>If you can't physically present a thing to me, you can't prove it.Okay then present to me a thing using categories independent of our conscious reasoning of the thing.
>>2955349Intelligence, omniscience, is the true nature of that thing, because this existence is imaginary. Ignorance is purely imaginary. God/that thing is imagining, "what if imaginary ignorant things did this and that, that and this." That is why things evolve, and move towards intelligence, because that is our/its true nature, because we are just imaginary things it is imagining. This whole existence could rather be thought of as a thought experiment or a hypothetical, because in reality, nothing is happening or ever will happen. The thing is ineffable and immutable. It's more a thought experiment like "what if I could be described?" "What if I could change?" But that's just an illusory idea that will work itself out, then another illusory idea will be entertained, and so on and so forth forever.
To put more simply and emotionally, I think it is lonely being that thing, it creates imaginary friends to pass the eternal time.
>>2955349>>2955353That thing is where all concepts and opposites terminate or rather they were nonsensical paradoxes in the first place. In that way too, absolute freedom is a prison. That thing has freedom to do anything, but there is nothing to do anything to, freedom to go anywhere, but there is nowhere to go to.
>>2955349>existence is a dreamThis is the view of Bernardo Kastrup, who I would recommend for you.
In art, there is also Lovecraft's Atazoth, Kanye West's "Ultralight Beams" (e.g. "We're in a God-dream") and Adventure Time's Prizmo.
>oneness is without qualities, yet is the source of quality.We could call this Brahman, as exposited in the Hindu Upanishads;
The ground of everything which resembles nothing, like the Tao.
>unity is absolutely distinguished from diversityWe could say that this how the Platonic Monad and Dyad operate. In the Dyad is duality as you describe, which is the Heraclitean Logos. In Christianity as well, the Father (Monad) begets the Son (Logos), and only through the Logos is anything made. This is also seen in the Tao.
>Simply to pass the timeWould you characterise this as a "fall" into time or matter?
>It really is a question of ending this cycle/existence whateverIn our discussion on Hegel, the Christian point would be that a cycle of completion involves the negation of negation, which like in all of these mystical traditions, is about "ending the cycle" of suffering. In Plato and the Mahabrata, it is characterised as an astrological cycle.
>>2955353Loneliness is surely only a relationship of opposition, though?
>>2955356>This is the view of Bernardo Kastrup, who I would recommend for you.Interesting, I'll try to check him out. Add it to my list.
>In art, there is also Lovecraft's Atazoth, Never got too deep into Lovecraft but also maybe I will check out whatever that is from.
>Kanye West's "Ultralight Beams" (e.g. "We're in a God-dream") and Adventure Time's Prizmo.I like Adventure Time, not a big fan of Kanye. I think I remember Prizmo a little, never finished the whole thing.
>We could call this Brahman, as exposited in the Hindu Upanishads;I'm pretty big into Hindu philosophy. It's what has resonated with me more than anything but I don't like into get into subscribing to this system or that. I like what Vivekananda says about books becoming useless once you touch that thing and gain knowledge of it with practice.
>The ground of everything which resembles nothing, like the Tao.I like what I've read of the Tao Te ching, but I think maybe it is too abstract instead of trying to explain clearly and thoroughly, not that I think that is truly possible.
>unity is absolutely distinguished from diversityI'm not saying that. I'm saying UNI is the same thing as infinity. To be infinite, it has to be unitary. This goes back to what I was talking about, about all paradoxes and contrary concepts meeting their opposite.
>Would you characterise this as a "fall" into time or matter?Not in the sense typically meant.
>Loneliness is surely only a relationship of opposition, though?I said it was an emotional, humanistic kind of simplification, I would say that I believe our true existence is "unbearable" which is why that thing always creates imaginary existences.
>In our discussion on Hegel, the Christian point would be that a cycle of completion involves the negation of negation, which like in all of these mystical traditions, is about "ending the cycle" of suffering. In Plato and the Mahabrata, it is characterised as an astrological cycle.The suffering never ends. Our true existence is more insufferable than anything possible in the imaginary existence of creation. Like I said, for us to imagine as humans what that is. Nothing means anything, nothing is pleasurable or painful, or it is both in equal measure. It will never end. The only thing that thing can do is imagine imaginary realities where these kind of concepts have meaning.
>>2955358>Adventure TimeI think I'm the only person who knows that Finn and Jake represent the boy and dog on the Fool (0) Tarot Card. Esoterically, this seems to refer to the sun and sirius (e.g. the dog star).
>I think maybe it is too abstract instead of trying to explain clearly and thoroughlyWell, the point of the Tao is that it cannot be described.
Like Brahman, since it is emptiness, it lacks description.
A proper reading of Plato yields the same result for the Good.
Negative theology also encounters the ineffibility of God.
>To be infinite, it has to be unitary. I would call this a contradiction
>The suffering never endsWhy live, if existence is suffering?
>>2955369>I think I'm the only person who knows that Finn and Jake represent the boy and dog on the Fool (0) Tarot Card. Esoterically, this seems to refer to the sun and sirius (e.g. the dog star).I like The Holy Mountain too.
>Why live, if existence is suffering?Because there is no other choice. Like Arjuna, like The Fool. They say The Fool represents both the beginning and the end.
>In the cyclical structure of the Major Arcana, The Fool (0) represents both the absolute beginning and the seamless return to the infinite, acting as the bridge that connects the end of one journey to the start of the next<The Starting Point (0): Numbered zero, The Fool stands outside the numbered sequence (I to XXI), embodying pure, unmanifested potential, innocence, and a blank slate before stepping into life's experiences.<The Return After The World (XXI): After passing through all the archetypal lessons, trials, and-accomplishments of the Major Arcana culminating in The World, the cycle does not simply stop. Instead, The Fool loops back around—carrying the wisdom, scars, and integration of the entire journey—to step off the cliff once more with a renewed, transformed innocence<The Continuous Ring: Rather than a straight line from birth to death, the Major Arcana functions as a continuous spiral or ring where every ending births a new beginning
>Well, the point of the Tao is that it cannot be described. >Like Brahman, since it is emptiness, it lacks description.Yes I agree and I see the truth in it and many other things. Sometimes some vague abstract poetical statements resonate with me, sometimes not. I think the truth is beyond thinking and indescribable like I said, but thinking sometimes gets the ball rolling from my experience even if it loops back around to not thinking, the fool.
>I would call this a contradictionBut it's not. Seeming opposites are all really the same thing is a point I kept bringing up. "Two sides of the same coin." In a more direct sense, it is literally baked into the English language. UNI, meaning single. The universe, meaning all that is. To hold everything, it must be singular. If there were things that were not a part of it, then it wouldn't be universal. If there were multiple infinities, they wouldn't be infinite(don't bother me about mathematical set theory whatever, I am talking about true infinity in the original meaning.)
A concept you haven't brought up I like is Maya. Specifically the idea that pleasure creates suffering, good creates evil and vice-versa. In some aspects this is literally true, like to create things in this illusion, we have to destroy things. Our bodies have to destroy life to survive, to create our bodies. But even if those physical laws could be overcome, on a moral inescapable level, pleasure creates suffering. The more you love someone, the more it will hurt when they inevitably die, the more your enjoy something, the more it will hurt when its over, etc.
>As we increase our power to be happy, we also increase our power to suffer, and sometimes I am inclined to think that if we increase our power to become happy in arithmetical progression, we shall increase, on the other hand, our power to become miserable in geometrical progression. We who are progressing know that the more we progress, the more avenues are opened to pain as well as to pleasure. And this is Maya.
>“"The sum total is always the same. Wherever there is a wave in one place, there is a hollow in another. If one nation becomes rich, others become poor. Good balances evil."But why am I a leftist, a "materialist" in some regards and how can any of this provide some useful material benefit? I think knowing the truth makes you realize how easily we could overcome the smaller and easier paradoxes/contradictions of life. We could easily create a utopian world where everyone is beyond the basic problems of hunger/disease etc. etc. The greater insurmountable paradoxes will always be there, but we could at least have respite from such basic silly problems. I find in life, people tend to artificially create simple problems in life(self-destructive behaviors) to keep their minds from contemplating the real, insurmountable ones(I'm often one of them.) I think that explains so much about why human society is the way it is. We all could solve the basic problems so easily.
>>2955377>ArjunaBut what Krishna says to Arjuna concerning the Dharma is that one does not need to suffer where he has consciousness of Krishna. I take the position that Wisdom means detachment from possessions and so a liberation into bliss. Suffering comes from our attachments; our identities in other things. Krishna consciousness is self-identity.
>Sometimes some vague abstract poetical statements resonate with me, sometimes notThe fact that all wisdom is encoded in myth shows that the truth can't be revealed excepy by symbols, like Jungian archetypes and so on. It is impossible to grasp the ungraspable. Like with Medusa, we may only view her by a mirror, backwards. To look directly is becoming stone; petrified. Like Arjuna's glimpse of Krishna's infinite form, it is unbearable. This is maybe why drug trips can't be perfectly recalled.
>Seeming opposites are all really the same thing>MayaBut isn't Maya a trickster? To confuse good for evil is unwise, no?
>We could easily create a utopian world where everyone is beyond the basic problems of hunger/disease etc. I consider myself a political Taoist (verse 80):
<If a country is governed wisely, its inhabitants will be content. They enjoy the labor of their hands and don't waste time inventing labor-saving machines. Since they dearly love their homes, they aren't interested in travel. There may be a few wagons and boats, but these don't go anywhere. There may be an arsenal of weapons, but nobody ever uses them. People enjoy their food, take pleasure in being with their families, spend weekends working in their gardens, delight in the doings of the neighborhood. And even though the next country is so close that people can hear its roosters crowing and its dogs barking, they are content to die of old age without ever having gone to see it.https://terebess.hu/english/tao/mitchell.html >>2955380>>2955378Guess it didn't work out with Tamara either huh
>>2955381>But what Krishna says to Arjuna concerning the Dharma is that one does not need to suffer where he has consciousness of Krishna. I take the position that Wisdom means detachment from possessions and so a liberation into bliss. Suffering comes from our attachments;I think that detachment brings relief from the suffering resulting from those attachments. But ask yourself, why would god create suffering and attachments in the first place.
>But isn't Maya a trickster? To confuse good for evil is unwise, no?Good and evil only exist within a context and framework. It is bad to kill, it is good to kill to save others lives. Trolley problem etc. etc. The absolute is neither good nor evil or it is both in equal measure. I'm not saying we cannot define good or bad within a certain context like creating a better world for humans, life on this planet, etc. But the absolute is what created good and evil in the first place. In fact you can only have good in relation to evil.
I said the true existence is suffering, but that is not exactly accurate, it's ineffable. I do not feel like it is a peace of any kind otherwise why would this thing keep creating universes filled with suffering? It's not exactly a heart warming message to be sure. To me god is neither good nor evil. Creation is neither good nor evil. To me if I have to describe the ineffable, I would say god is just a victim of their reality. But they are their own reality. So god is a victim of itself. And in our world of creation it surely is because it is playing both the victim and the oppressor. To describe what the feeling is of the true existence to me, it is like a perfect bipolar state where you're laughing and crying at the same time. Boundaries melting away. You spoke of a "fall" it is falling into yourself. But you can't describe it as good or bad, pleasurable or painful, peaceful or violent. It is just the state it has always been and will ever be in. We can't really understand how comfortable the illusion of time and directionality is of scale and dimension, of being bounded. Maybe I am just projecting too much of my own feelings on to it, but again I say ask: Why would thing keep creating these imaginary creations/universes? Or why would god not just create an existence of pure pleasure and bliss? Because qualities can only exist in regards to their opposite qualities. In the extreme end, bliss becomes pain. Eventually everything becomes unbounded and that's the end point and the starting point all over again. That's why it becomes the fool again because knowing kinda sucks if I had to put a quality on it. Some say some stuff like "god comes to better understand itself" blahh blahh, but there is nothing to understand. It's true existence is answering its own question before it even asks it. In that way too, even the creation is just a 'blink of an eye' but actually even shorter than that because it exists outside of time.
>>2955361Bro is desperate to have a king
>>2955399>why would god create suffering and attachments in the first place.Great question.
As we see from ancient ethics, the Buddhist "middle way" and the Aristotelian "golden mean" both preach moderation. Extremity in either direction causes suffering by disequilibrium. As I have discussed above, the medical theory of the humours is a theory of imbalance. As for suffering in general, it comes from the flesh, or the illusion of Maya. Both Plato and Jesus saw the flesh as the cause of suffering. We see in Genesis how after the fall of man, God clothes them in "animal skins" by which this means material bodies. Hesiod too sees man descend from being an incorporeal spirit into a body. So, all pain exists in the body, which is why the mystic wants to escape the body. Evidently, man "falls" by a primordial sin, but what is the sin? Either way, the ancients speak of reincarnation (metempsychosis) unto the final release of a soul from this material "vale of tears" toward God.
>why would this thing keep creating universes filled with suffering?If life is a dream, a terrible life is a nightmare.
When we wake up (e.g. die) we realise how silly suffering really is, no?
>why would god not just create an existence of pure pleasure and bliss? Krishna says that when we die we receive our rewards in the heavens. Too, Plato writes that in death, we return to our soul-star to have bliss. It's clear that this world is only temporary and our true selves persist.
Read what Plato writes here:
<He who lived well during his appointed time was to return and dwell in his native star, and there he would have a blessed and congenial existence. But if he failed in attaining this, at the second birth he would pass into a woman, and if, when in that state of being, he did not desist from evil, he would continually be changed into some brute who resembled him in the evil nature which he had acquired, and would not cease from his toils and transformations until he followed the revolution of the same and the like within him, and overcame by the help of reason the turbulent and irrational mob of later accretions, made up of fire and air and water and earth, and returned to the form of his first and better state. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1572/1572-h/1572-h.htmLife is some sort of a test where souls are perfected by suffering.
>>2955417>>2955417>But if he failed in attaining this, at the second birth he would pass into a woman, Lol.
>>2955417>Life is some sort of a test where souls are perfected by suffering.Yes this is a common line of thinking. That is generally the Christian way of thinking.>>2955417
>and would not cease from his toils and transformations until he followed the revolution of the same and the like within him, and overcame by the help of reason the turbulent and irrational mob of later accretions, made up of fire and air and water and earth, and returned to the form of his first and better state. Yes that is sort of what I am saying.
I believe in reincarnation and persistent souls across lives, but at the end of time and creation I believe we become one but with the original soul we are just a fragment of. Indivuation of any kind is also illusion.
So why does that perfect soul create existence, the imperfection, then come back to perfection, then create imperfection again, endlessly? That thing is immutable. It cannot change. To put it simply, I say to pass the time of eternity. That perfect state is itself not perfected, or it can find resolution or peace. Things move through a cycle of creation back to perfection and unity, then another imperfect creation of imaginary division springs into existence. As for us, all we can do is move towards perfection once again, but is no true end point. We are that thing trapped in the endless cycle.
>>2955546>>2955567The people who don't understand how "I would sell my kids to Epstein if it meant deportations" could've POSSIBLY lost at the ballot box don't understand how numbers and history work? Whaaaat?
>>2954568You sound very confident. When it doesn't happen you need to upload a video of you drinking your own piss or something.
>>2955761He looks as dumb as a fish
>>2955761Isn't he about to have a kid with his wife?
>>2955819He might want to put that on the back burner.
>>2955393>Guess it didn't work out with Tamara either huhShe was a fan. It was over the moment she seen him for who he is over who she has imagined in her head based off of on-screen performance.
>>2955546What % is it acceptable to start complaining?
>>2954342The H3 Pocast was promised to Hila 3000 years ago
Print edition of HOUDINI Magazine available until Dec 31st. Profits go to supporting my legal case fund.
https://erikhoudini.com/books/>>2956025Damn, what a pig
>>2954560>>2954567He has Tourette's so he's naturally twitchy.
>>2956040The scratches on his legs look symptomatic of drug use to me.
>>2956040watch old clips. he wasn't as twitchy. as all rich bicoastal USAnians he is a cocaine fiend and probably abuses antidepressants.
>>2956045You cant abuse antidepressants.
>>2956045>as all rich bicoastal USAnians he is a cocaine fiend and probably abuses antidepressants.How the fuck do you abuse anti-depressants lol. Those aren't a drug you can just take willy nilly. You have to carefully titrate to a dose and titrate off. You don't just swallow a megadose of them and get euphoric or something. I guess Wellbutrin works since it's similar to amphetamine but it would be way weaker.
>>2956046I guess it works for Wellbutrin since it's a weak stimulant. But no, it doesn't work for SSRIs.
>>2956047My bad, it is actually more like weak Ritalin.
>>2956052Chuds really thought Malfoid wasn't another coprorate fad lol
>>2956056You don't know what you're talking about. Which antidepressant are you talking about specifically?
>>2956052Why do these faggots think any of this shit matters man? Why are they so fond of gender bending an underage boy from a children's film
>>2956061Could rightwingers be "secretly" attracted to kids and transgirls?
>>2956063>>2956062I guess I'm more interested in the first question rather than the latter. If this was just like "haha we turned a character from some fantasy film into a tsundere anime girl that's funny lol!" Or "uhhh the bad guy from popular sci fi film is actually bbbbased" then whatever. But no: "The young right is RECLAIMING CULTURE and libtards are MAD", are you fucking serious man? What a fucking joke. I wonder if these are the same guys posting about le kekistan in 2016 now in their 30s.
>>2956066Well look at the second part of the title
>…,and liberals are mad about it!That's all their "politics" boils down to.
>Hehehe we trolled the libs ebic style again!The Harry Potter thing I guess because they found a way to celebrate Harry Potter, which triggers the libs because JK Rowling is antitrans, while separating themselves from the average fan and into their own special category of old men who jack off to Japanese cartoon kids. The Annakin is just stealing the "sigma grindset" meme which has been around for like a few years now with Annakin edits which seemed to always be mostly ironic to me, whereas now they're going "no I'm being fully ironic, bad guy cool because he White and he don't give no fucks!"
>>2956052>reclaiming culture>harry potter and star warsThe right have literally become milennial soyboys
>>2955551>why does that perfect soul create existence, the imperfection, then come back to perfection, then create imperfection again, endlessly?I would say that its because we have sinned in some way.
We fall into the cycle of time/matter by desire.
How did the angels fall? By seeking to mate with human women, etc.
>>2956056Okay genius, which Antidepressants could he be abusing and what makes you think this?
>>2956124IDK who that is.
>>2956277japs literally live in the lap of superprofits and these druggies want to jump off a bridge because of "social awkwardness" or some bs, no, fuck you. Fuck you.
>>2956277wish i had a suicidal japanese girl to hug and to love
Apparently the h3 podcast is imploding even more
>>2956197Edward from Twilight and he was “The Batman” in 2022, which was a pretty good remake of Se7en but with capes
>>2956319Generally the less physical suffering you have, the worse mental illness is if it hits you, pain is weakness leaving the body in a literal sense if it’s not enough to cripple you
>>2956319Huh? You're saying she's a druggie and the tweet you are replying to is implying there are no drugs in Japan. What is the connection?
>>2956277>>2956326Exactly, it's such a tragedy because it's such a waste of great ass and titties. Why could she just let someone lobotomize her so she could fulfill a purpose as a human sex doll or something like in the hentais.
Reminds me of Gantz where the MC takes home that chick who killed herself after they got reincarnated and he's like:
>Well, why not be my fuck pet then? >>2956366IIRC she requested to be his pet. Shame about how that manga had such an anticlimactic ending. Was one of my favorites until that
>>2956372Yes, you're right, then he was like:
>Well I used to pet my dog, can I fondle your tits then?Or something like that.
It was funny how his guilt over how he treated her ended up becoming such a large role in the story. Didn't they say he was going to be her son in his next life or something?
>>2956331How can it implode more with its star gone and its crew all shitcanned?
>>2956388I don't remember that part… Haven't reread more than the first few volumes since it ended though
>>2956365Personally I hold no envy for the rich, but I'm always sincerely confused by their lack of generosity - until I remember that financial acquisition is habit-forming the same as any drug. Many of these people are quite simply addicted to acquiring fame and fortune the same way a heroin addict or a grandma at penny slots is.
If I was ever to agree to any kind of legitimate "re-education", it would be for people like this, giving them the Christmas Carol treatment so that they'd stop being Scrooges ruining themselves and everyone around them with their hollow greed. I feel pity for them more than anything. I wouldn't even want to take their wealth from them, just help them break their addiction to it once and for all - after all, they can't take it with them.
>>2956414I really wish Gantz wasn't so retarded.
>>2956422No idea. I'm just thinking about how they brought up matrix vampires in the story, made one of them one of the main character's siblings, then totally forgot about them.
Also the tall girl with huge tits was superior to babyface uguu-chan.
>>2956413The only argument against it is that if the other apes don't have the know-how to gather bananas, then beating the hoarding ape and taking his bananas doesn't solve the real problem - namely, that the ape mob don't know how to acquire bananas. Of course, the rebuttal to that is the question: Why didn't the hoarding ape teach the others how to acquire/cultivate bananas, and give enough bananas away so the others wouldn't starve in the process of teaching them?
If ape together strong, why strongest ape not helping weaker apes? Out of selfishness, obviously, though perhaps also out of fear; fear of being overwhelmed by apes who are as-yet incapable of gathering bananas, fear of going hungry when the incapable apes take everything you have by violence. This is how wealthy people often perceive the ignorant, payday-loan visiting, credit-card maxxing, debt-enslaved poors that wouldn't know what a budget is if it smacked them in the face.
Even with those rebuttals and that perception however, I couldn't bring myself to do nothing if I were in the hoarding monkey's position. I doubt I'd give all my bananas away, but I'd be happy to show the others where the banana trees are and tell them they can bury bananas in dirt to grow more banana trees. I've been in the position to help in real life before, and even if I'm too poor and greedy to give them money all the time, I've at least been willing to lend an ear or help move a couch or something, y'know? I dunno. There but for the grace of God go I, who knows how I'd behave if I had the kind of wealth some of these people have. Were we ever meant to have so much material? As stewards perhaps, but not as hoarders.
>>2956426I forgot, what was their last appearance in the story? When they kill Kurono?
>>2956427Noooo. It was a sweet arc of Kurono becoming less of an asshole and learning to love with his plain jane GF that he asked out as a prank. I was mad they kept not resurrecting tomb raider chick. I guess she got one short resurrection.
>>2956430I say it goes back to the mother. Either he's disrespecting his mother's teachings, his mother was neglectful, or she was a greedy bitch herself. Regardless, he at least deserves a severe beating, such that he learns his place, for refusing to help his brethren yet still expecting to be accepted and reap the benefits of their companionship
>>2950989He worked as a laborer willingly, for Pete's sake. There's a time for work and a time for rest, a season for all things. He is not anti-work, though He is absolutely anti-greed.
Matthew 19:24
And again I say unto you, It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God.
Of course, He follows this up by saying that "With men this is impossible; but with God all things are possible", even something as seemingly impossible as a rich man entering the kingdom of God. It's best to read these things in their full context, which I did not provide, as there are way more verses in that chapter alone, let alone the entire Gospel or the theological allusions to the Old Testament (and further) and the cultural background of the Second Temple period. There's so many layers to reading good literature, the more you learn the more you can re-read with new understanding. Some reading lenses can only be acquired through experiences, like through prayer or through becoming a father. There are some things written that simply can't be understood without having participated in prerequisites that shape how you perceive everything, from literature to a warm sunny day and an ant walking on cracked concrete underneath a swaying tree and the smell of wildflowers and the sound of cicadas and the taste of a crust of bread with a glass of wine and a bit of cheese.
The older I get, the more I realize how much of a travesty it is to take isolated quotations from whole works. Excerpts are somewhat better, but there's nothing quite as wonderful as speaking with someone who's truly read the material you have, especially at or around the same time, and with the work available for you both to pour over together. Dialectical pedagogy is awesome, especially when you do it for fun with cool books with people you enjoy conversing with. Even the disagreements and arguments become a joy! It's like a book club, but better.
>>2956447>He worked as a laborer willingly, for Pete's sake. There's a time for work and a time for rest, a season for all things. He is not anti-work, though He is absolutely anti-greed.He is tho. He quit his job when he had his awakening and became the Christ and then went around convincing other people to quit their jobs as well. He was also a homeless bum. He posits that you not need to "reap, sew, nor stow away in barns" nor "labor or spin" to get clothing or food because god loves us more than birds. It makes sense that he would tell people to quit fishing because he found the infinite fish duplication glitch. Jesus was anti labor.
You are the one removing context.
>>2956365>free markets built this countryLiterally the opposite.
The American School of political economy prioritised protectionism in the North while the South chose laissez-faire slavery. After the Civil War you have the massive state-sponsored program of Reconstruction, leading in part of the Robber Barons in the Gilded Age, who monopolise industry. This is broken up in the early 20th century by anti-trust laws. Too, the Federal Reserve is established in 1913 on the eve of WW1. Alexander Hamilton himself supported a central bank early on in American history. After WW2, you get the GI Bill and the state-sponsored creation of the suburbs. You also get programs like tax-paid higher education. With Reagan you get what is called "neoliberalism" in the 80s, continuing into the 90s, where Clinton deregulates the housing and banking sector, eventually leading to the Great Recession of 2008, following Bush's War on Terror. Afterwards, this continues into Obama and beyond, exploding the national debt in an unprecedented way. What small government "free markets" are part of this transformation except that which only contributes to economic dysfunction? Now you have millions of young people in debt slavery for their whole lives to fight "muh stalinism".
>>2956539Maybe their paymasters have realised that people haven't just stopped talking about Epstein as they hoped so they're going to have to do a limited hangout and produce some people to blame for his death so that people feel like justice has been done
>>2956563Literally just keep scrolling if it bothers you. Talking about the circumstances of his death or even just mentions of him in the news is anything but moralfagging
>>2956563Nice try funny man, but it's an in-team rule to only namefag with mod tags on.
>>2956574its fake. probably the jucheschizo's new tactic.
>>2956563I'm willing to bet a certain schizo is gonna repost this in the future without the ban message.
>>2956595Faggot. Stop meme posting here and actually clean the website instead. We both know there are many reports you are ignoring.
>>2956365an occasional crumb thrown to the masses will draw out capitalism for hundreds of more years, lucky for us american porky is uncompromising and stupid
>>2956698Okay. So stop clearing reports to obvious low-effort shitposting and bait. Admitting that you think and actively decide that all the low-effort trash that is reported is great posting deserving of staying up is not quite the epic own you seemed to think.
You people will not be happy until the whole forum devolves in two the same 6 retards posting the same 3-word max posts alternating between 'U', 'no u', 'u', 'no u' into affinity. It's got so bad that most people don't even bother to check the generals anymore, let alone post news and so on in them. It is disgusting and you should be somewhat ashamed of yourself.
>>2956701They could just be talking about Texas specifically, where the dems don't have enough seats to pass the bills, and gun control there is usually a losing issue even among the democratic voter base. But also all the freaking out is just an attempt at radicalizing the right-wing base anyways, in an attempt to get people to start committing acts of violence so they can live out some petty revenge fantasy where they kill all the "leftist demonrats" and whoever else they don't like.
>>2956754>>2956754Yeah the first guy is talking about Texas specifically, the Republicans still control the state senate.
The thing is, Texas has a lot of legislators at the state level, and the legislature only meets once every two years because our constitution was rewritten during the reactionary post-Reconstruction period, and the people who wrote it wanted to limit the powers of the state government over towns and counties as much as possible. There's also a weak governor (arguably the lieutenant governor is more powerful). So once the filing period starts, which is now, they will file thousands of bills, like 8,000+ bills, and maybe a few hundred of them pass.
This used to be grist for liberal slop media, because the Texas GOP would also file tons of bills that wouldn't pass (although sometimes they would) but which would do unconstitutional or otherwise just very right-wing things like banning Palestinian flags, allowing children to sue drag queens because a drag queen looked at them and gave them AIDS, or whatever. Also even though the Democrats didn't control the House, they could have enough seats to prevent legislation from reaching the floor for a vote, so a lot of this stuff would never get anywhere, but it was great material if you were Rachel Maddow and wanted to have a segment on the show about crazy ultra-conservative Texas. So now we're seeing right-wing conservative slop accounts do the same thing but from the other direction. There will be a bill from some Democrat saying that Texas recognizes God is non-binary.
Also ironically one reason why Abbott lost was that he had been governing with emergency powers (so he became a relatively strong governor) and was fast tracking data centers and running roughshod over local school districts over an extremely regressive school voucher program, which really pissed off a lot of people (including rural people, who are actually harmed a lot by that). There was also shit you probably heard about where the state would threaten to cut off funding if a city council somewhere voted to condemn Israel, college towns like San Marcos. So now the Republicans are freaking out because Hinojosa is going to inherit these emergency powers which the Republicans gave the governor.
>>2956839Do people actually take these videos seriously
>>2956848>namefag>>2956844It was quite interesting concerning Marx's early literature.
The virtue signalling about Marx being a chud was gratuitous, though.
>>2956844yes they do. Tatsyua jap does.
The way this works is through selective memory so you only pick those facts which align with the narrative while rejecting those that don't.
>Muh revolution requires purges therefore it's not ascentEvery revolution had its purges and non-revolutions had their own purges
>>2956852Marx was a chud, just look how he wrote about lassalle. He would be a 4channer if he was alive today.
>>2956853>Marx was a chud, just look how he wrote about lassalle. He would be a 4channer if he was alive today.Fuck man get help
>>2956858Why? He's right.
You think Marx would use Reddit, instead?
>>2956864Lassalle would be a redditor because he was an incel and an opportunist
>>2956869Marx, 4chan
Lassalle, reddit
Lenin, youtube
Kautsky, tiktok
Stalin, kick
Trotsky, newspaper
>>2956880Marx: 4chan
Engels: 4chan, Reddit (after Marx death)
Lassalle: Reddit
Lenin: Youtube, 2ch (when exiled)
Kautsky: Wordpress
Stalin: Twitter
Trotsky: Bluesky
>>2956890Stalin would be on bsky, he would appreciate the endless and insufferable moderation
>>2956869>Lassalle would be a redditor because he was an incelWhat?
<In 1854, the Hatzfeldt affair finally concluded. Through intrigue and blackmail involving the Count's estate agent, Stockum, Lassalle forced Count Hatzfeldt into an acceptable financial settlement.[75] Countess Hatzfeldt received over 300,000 thalers. Lassalle himself secured an annuity of 4,000 thalers from these funds (later increased to 7,000 thalers), an arrangement he later explained was compensation for his sacrifices and to ensure he was not under too great an obligation to the Countess.[76] For the rest of his life, he could live as a rich man.[77]
<Following the Hatzfeldt settlement, Lassalle initially stayed in Düsseldorf with the Countess, maintaining his connections with local workers.[78] He entered into an affair with Agnes Dennis-Street, daughter of Georg Klindworth, a political intelligence agent. Klindworth became a source of information for Lassalle, useful for both political insights (which he passed to Marx) and stock exchange speculation.[79] Agnes gave birth to Lassalle's daughter in 1855
>Lassalle was undoubtedly a man of impressionable heart, and had many affairs such as Heine had; but they were not deep or lasting. That he should have made a favorable impression on the women whom he met is not surprising, because of his social standing, his chivalry, his fine manners, and his handsome face.
>We ought not to be surprised, then, if he was a favorite in drawing-rooms; if both men and women admired him; if Alexander von Humboldt cried out with enthusiasm that he was a wunderkind, and if there were more than Sophie Solutzeff to be jealous.
>Furthermore, he was very far from resembling what in those early days was regarded as the typical picture of a Socialist. There was nothing frowzy about him; in his appearance he was elegance itself; his manners were those of a prince, and his clothing was of the best. Seeing him in a drawing-room, no one would mistake him for anything but a gentleman and a man of parts. Hence it is not surprising that his second love was one of the nobility, although her own people hated Lassalle as a bearer of the red flag.
>This girl was Helene von Donniges, the daughter of a Bavarian diplomat. As a child she had traveled much, especially in Italy and in Switzerland. She was very precocious, and lived her own life without asking the direction of any one. At twelve years of age she had been betrothed to an Italian of forty; but this dark and pedantic person always displeased her, and soon afterward, when she met a young Wallachian nobleman, one Yanko Racowitza, she was ready at once to dismiss her Italian lover. Racowitza–young, a student, far from home, and lacking friends–appealed at once to the girl’s sympathy.
>At that very time, in Berlin, where Helene was visiting her grandmother, she was asked by a Prussian baron:
<“Do you know Ferdinand Lassalle?”
>The question came to her with a peculiar shock. She had never heard the name, and yet the sound of it gave her a strange emotion. Baron Korff, who perhaps took liberties because she was so young, went on to say:
<“My dear lady, have you really never seen Lassalle? Why, you and he were meant for each other!”
>She felt ashamed to ask about him, but shortly after a gentleman who knew her said:
<“It is evident that you have a surprising degree of intellectual kinship with Ferdinand Lassalle.”
>This so excited her curiosity that she asked her grandmother:
<“Who is this person of whom they talk so much–this Ferdinand Lassalle?”
<“Do not speak of him,” replied her grandmother. “He is a shameless demagogue!”
>A little questioning brought to Helene all sorts of stories about Lassalle–the Countess von Hatzfeldt, the stolen casket, the mysterious pamphlet, the long battle in the courts–all of which excited her still more. A friend offered to introduce her to the “shameless demagogue.” This introduction happened at a party, and it must have been an extraordinary meeting. Seldom, it seemed, was there a better instance of love at first sight, or of the true affinity of which Baron Korff had spoken. In the midst of the public gathering they almost rushed into each other’s arms; they talked the free talk of acknowledged lovers; and when she left, he called her love-names as he offered her his arm.
<“Somehow it did not appear at all remarkable,” she afterward declared. “We seemed to be perfectly fitted to each other.”
>Nevertheless, nine months passed before they met again at a soiree. At this time Lassaller gazing upon her, said:
<“What would you do if I were sentenced to death?”
<“I should wait until your head was severed,” was her answer, “in order that you might look upon your beloved to the last, and then –I should take poison!”
>Her answer delighted him, but he said that there was no danger. He was greeted on every hand with great consideration; and it seemed not unlikely that, in recognition of his influence with the people, he might rise to some high position. The King of Prussia sympathized with him. Heine called him the Messiah of the nineteenth century. When he passed from city to city, the whole population turned out to do him honor. Houses were wreathed; flowers were thrown in masses upon him, while the streets were spanned with triumphal arches.
>Worn out with the work and excitement attending the birth of the Deutscher Arbeiterverein, or workmen’s union, which he founded in 1863, Lassalle fled for a time to Switzerland for rest. Helene heard of his whereabouts, and hurried to him, with several friends. They met again on July 25,1864, and discussed long and intensely the possibilities of their marriage and the opposition of her parents, who would never permit her to marry a man who was at once a Socialist and a Jew.
>Then comes a pitiful story of the strife between Lassalle and the Donniges family. Helene’s father and mother indulged in vulgar words; they spoke of Lassalle with contempt; they recalled all the scandals that had been current ten years before, and forbade Helene ever to mention the man’s name again.
>The next scene in the drama took place in Geneva, where the family of Herr von Donniges had arrived, and where Helene’s sister had been betrothed to Count von Keyserling–a match which filled her mother with intense joy. Her momentary friendliness tempted Helene to speak of her unalterable love for Lassalle. Scarcely had the words been spoken when her father and mother burst into abuse and denounced Lassalle as well as herself.
>She sent word of this to Lassalle, who was in a hotel near by. Scarcely had he received her letter, when Helene herself appeared upon the scene, and with all the intensity of which she was possessed, she begged him to take her wherever he chose. She would go with him to France, to Italy–to the ends of the earth! >>2956970That was everyone's experience. 'Why isn't he shouting? This isn't funny. Next'.
>>2956908its time to accept he mogged marx to death
>>2956970He doesn't deserve the gorilla emoji if he's not even gonna go apeshit
BE and Socialism 4 All are slap fighting
>>2957009BE stopped being a serious voice a long time now and at this point is just an engagement farmer
>>2955417it sounds like you're saying life is a transitional period towards what really matters. why not just kill ourselves now and skip the illusion/dream stage?
>>2957009Why? S4A is based and a pretty serious guy.
turd worldism is a disease
>>2957023Bad Empalada is correct.
I came from a maga qtard background. I got attracted to communism as a consequence of seeing maga going against its populist message. The more money I make the more I am interested in communism, for most people it's the opposite.
>>2957024Third worldism is correct about socialism not being worth the risk of death and jail for first worlders, the issue is it ignores that this is also true of the third world, as any country develops, its proletariat gets less and less revolutionary with every passing year and GDP point going up.
>>2957023BE is a retard and by his own admission not a communist. The idea that concessions to first world workers are extracted from the third world is objectively false. Unless those first world proles are consuming more surplus than they produce (i.e. unless their employers are losing money by employing them) then the entirety of their consumption is furnished by their own surplus. At the same time, the extraction of concessions eats into porky profits and undermines the resilience of the entire system through the exact same mechanism as a third world revolution. Simply pointing out that concessions have historically led to pacification is flawed for two reasons. First, they can only lead to pacification if the system is in a position to sustain those concessions, and if it is in such a position then revolution is quite simply impossible. Second, the exact same pattern has played out in the third world, with national bourgeois or even socialist governments improving things somewhat before settling in to a subordinate position in the world economy and slowly turning into compradors. The fact is basically everything that is pointed to as some unique malaise of the first world is in reality a universal problem.
>>2957031Then why was there never a British revolution by its proles?
>>2957033Because you touch yourself at night
>>2957031~We are Treatler Kirk!!!
We carry the treats.
We fight for the porkies
We honor their profits~
>or something like thattreatlerism is a universal problem because of human nature
>>2957033Why was there never an Indian revolution by its proles?
>>2957038Because the licensing raj did not give out a license to do a revolution.
>>2957038The truth is there was in both, both failed, diggers for England, Naxalbari for India
>>2957023>convincing Americans that socialism is in their self-interest won't work!<it is really woke-scolding that will get to want to sacrifice for revolution!The political genius of our generation.
>>2957041He’s saying the opposite, that Americans are following their material interests by working for IBM and Electric Boat or any other MIC company
>>2957040Yes and both failed for the same reason, which is that as a rule, capitalism has thus far been able to deliver improvements that are sufficient to undermine support for revolution. The only kernel of truth in third worldism is that first world countries in general have an easier time with this. However the conclusion (that third world countries are not capable of it) simply doesn't follow and has been proven empirically to not be true. The differences between the two are really differences of degree rather than something fundamental. I think this is the real reason why third worldism is an exclusively first world phenomenon. Actual third world socialists can't treat the third world masses as some kind if idealized abstraction, rather they observe directly the same tendencies towards compromise, social democracy, labour aristocracy etc.
>>2957045Not to mention national and ethnic chauvinism. What percentage of Tutsi are looking to kill and overthink Paul Kagame? I’m guessing it’s not many
>>2957047Additionally, if you look at the trajectory even of successful socialist revolutions in the third world, the tend to follow the same basic pattern as first world social democracy.
>socialists come to power>improve things somewhat>complacency ensues>begin drifting to the right>become functionally neoliberals There are some exceptions (Cuba, DPRK) and intermediate examples (China, Vietnam) but as a rule, this is the path socialist states all over the world have taken.
>>2957043Huh? I just repeated what he said in the green text. The orange text is a summary of his rhetoric and praxis as far as it can be. Lol he's complaining about long diatribes, and then he goes and posts an even longer one and really provides no actual tactic other than what can be assumed is his praxis of just calling Americans spoiled meanie doo doo heads online.
Ok, social democratic reforms for Americans are going to make them less likely to sacrifice for revolution. So what then, a weird looking Greek expat getting into stupid shitpost battles with social democrat Americans is going to keep them from getting those concessions?
>Time to adapt.What the fuck is his adaptation?
>>2956712Bro he is just a janitor on the internet
>>2957050The things he would suggest to undo the contradictions between first and third world workers are not things you can suggest on tor let alone the clearnet
>>2957050I mean if Americans not passing social democratic reforms and making their lives better is the crux of his strategy, how is arguing:
>I don't want you to pass reforms that make your lives better because I want them to get worseonvince people not to do that? The natural reaction is:
>Wait a minute, the guy says he wants my life to get worse says I shouldn't do that….maybe I should right?It almost feels like this whole bit he does must be reverse psychology and he's American Social Democracy's strongest soldier.
>>2957052tor is full of cp tho
>>2957050>Ok, social democratic reforms for Americans are going to make them less likely to sacrifice for revolutionThis is also ass backwards idealist reasoning. If a system is capable of delivering reforms that pacify the populace, then it accomplish this even if every socialist is a 100% maximalist calling for the immediate revolutionary overthrow of the existing social order. In that situation you would simply get some other force advocating for (effectively) social democracy. Marxists need to recognize as a common sense principle that revolutions can only happen when the contradictions of a system can no longer be effectively managed. If pacifying reforms are possible then by definition the contradictions are manageable. As a matter of practical tactics though, communists should absolutely advocate for short term reforms, since if the situation is truly revolutionary then the ruling class will be incapable of delivering these. Meanwhile, if the situation is not revolutionary then simply making maximalist demands won't will revolution into existence.
>>2957049So there is a little something to that cliche that socialism has never been tried. It’s very very very hard to not come to doomer conclusions when you look at the overall picture. Because that leads to nihilism, and nihilism is what gives you permission to give in to all your worst instincts, that’s not good for you or anyone immediately around you.
>>2957057I don't think doomerism really needs to result from these observations. It's just a question of reaching a point where capitalism as a world system is no longer capable of containing its own contradictions. This will depend on the rate of profit more than anything else.
>>2957054I’m talking about actions that would fall under the broad definition of terrorism
>>2957058My gut tells me that there will be a new imperial center away from the United States, the baton will probably go to China or BRICS the way the baton was passed from Venice and Genoa to the Dutch to the Brits and Frogs then to the US over the last 500 years
>>2957059why doesn't he do it then? why is he hiding in argentina when he could be doing terrorism in australia?
>>2957062Maybe, but then the question becomes whether the system can be sustained indefinitely by simply rotating imperial hegemons, or whether it will reach a point (due to automation, market saturation, etc.) where it doesn't matter who's on top, there's simply no room left for capital to grow.
>>2957064Combine that with dropping birthrates because having a child in this mode of production is like having an expensive pet if you’re rich and an albatross around your neck if you’re even middle class, let alone actually proletarian.
>>2957052>contradictions between first and third world workersI'm increasingly of the opinion that no such contradictions exist, or that they're at best non-antagonistic. If we apply such logic then there is a contradiction between me and my neighbour, because why would I show solidarity with him when I could just bash his head in and steal his TV? It only follows from an essentially Hobbesian outlook where everybody has a vested interest in fucking over everybody else instead of cooperating.
>>2957023This guy is fucking pathetic and S4A needs to just ignore him.
>>2957063Everyone wants to be Lenin, Stalin, or Mao. No one wants to be that one PLA guy who strapped dynamite to himself and waited for the tank to be over his trench
PedoEmpanada is a chud, but so is Stalinism 4 All.
>>2957022first worlders are really fragile about this
>>2957077My last words to my JDPON executioner will be “fair enough, it’s one life, who cares”
>>2957081non sequitur but ok you do you buddy
>>2957082I’m not fragile about the points either BE or S4A are making, the “non sequitur” is supposed to be a demonstration
>>2957084well it's not. but you do that bro. whatever you want. cool w me
>>2957077Communists tend to react negatively when anti-communists spread bourgeois narratives yes.
>NastyEnchilada
>National Socialism 4 Some
hahaha fucking children
>>2956595>>2956597Oh thank god. Haven't visited here regularly for over a year so I thought maybe it had just gotten even worse since I last did. A couple years ago, shit started getting really strict here so I noped out. Definitely more trolls than I remember but, otherwise, it's definitely better since back then
Is BE a sectarian?
>>2957022Firsties that do this are incredibly cringe, just remind thirdies they are poor and envious, it's that simple.
>>2957022Labor Aristocracy is a thing that exists in marxist theory, so I don't know why he has such a problem with that
>>2956864he's be a twitter user/podcaster obv
>>2957028trvke, americans simply got treatlerfied first but its actually a global thing, very grim
>>2957028This implies that the third world are being granted a seat at the imperialist table and are developing and modernizing. That is clearly not the case. Just look at countries like Argentina. They're being raped to death. So the idea that the global south is being bribed into complacency is clearly incorrect.
>>2957179but if we don't buy it,they will surely run out of money in the next 10 years for sure !!!
people don't understand that companies now can live out not making any money for more than a century,you will die before your boycott works even if everybody was on board
>>2957355It's so funny how inconsistent the leftypol admins are with their userbase, libs get drawn in with these stupid ass twitter posts and get shocked and upset when they read what socialists are saying in the actual threads
China is capitalist and imperialist.
>>2957378Hellenism was killed by its own creation?
>>2957377lazy bait zzzzzz
>>2957380By the time Christianity was taking off in Greece, the idea of what we consider the Greek pantheon was already near death. There were so many imported gods and foreign religious influences, the cult of Isis, the Mithraic cult within the military and even forms of pseudo-monotheism, with the belief in a single divine mover. Even Julian, the famous pagan emperor, outright stated that he didn't believe in the gods in the traditional sense, but rather believed that the gods were expressions of a singular divine essence, basically Neoplatonism that had become increasingly accepted among the elites. He was arguably a monotheists he just didn't believe in Jesus as God.
>>2957393Indeed bro, China will push the socialism button in two more weeks
https://www.forbes.com/lists/china-billionaires/ >>2957378>>2957380>>2957399I would suggest you read both Yonatan Adler and Russell Gmirckin on the 3rd century creation of Judaism. And yes, Hellenism devolved into Judaism by way of Plato; already described by Nietzsche as alienation in the form of "tragedy" (e.g. the Greek playwright genre pioneered in the 5th century BCE, with Aeschylus' Prometheus). Tragedy moves to resentment, self-denial, slave morality, etc. up to the Christian spirit, which Nietzsche describes as "Platonism for the masses".
>>2957405Nietzsche had some killer lines, but no serious academic or historian takes his writings on history and theology seriously. Hellenism didn't "devolve" into Judaism. When Judaism was created Greek intellectual traditions upon a Semitic people. The idea of a "slave morality" is absurd. Were the Gauls possessed of a slave morality? What about the northern and southern Italians? They were also conquered at various points in history and subsequently assimilated. Does being conquered automatically mean adopting a slave morality?
>>2957411>Hellenism didn't devolve.Yes it did, which is why after the 4th century, Greece is irrelevant.
Greek culture is pioneered from the 8th century to the 4th century, afterwards we have the Roman period, lasting until the Dark Ages. We have thrice the invention of the Olympic Games, Homer and Hesiod in the 8th century BCE. In the 6th century you get coinage, leading to the presocratic philosophers and tragedians in the 5th century, up to the philosophers and sophists in the 4th century. After the 5th century Pelopponesian War with Sparta, Athens is victorious, but declines within a century. Alexander the Great has tutoring from Aristotle, as an intellectual connection to this lineage, and this settles Greece's legacy. There are no more great Greeks after Alexander, are there? The Hebrew Bible is officially compiled around 270 BCE by Greco-Jewish elders, and so the world-spirit moves forward into Roman usurpation.
>slave moralitySlave morality is the priestly morality of pity and agape; it is opposed to master morality. The Christian ethic is one of masochism, so can be seen as a religion of inhuman torment unfit for healthy persons.
>Does being conquered automatically mean adopting a slave morality?Most of the time. If you are a slave, your ancestors were cowards, and only with cowards does resentment develop into repressed violence, rather than actual or efficient violence.
>>2957417monoculture is back baby
>>2957415What the fuck are you talking about? Even after the Roman conquest, Greek culture remained enormously important. Greek was essentially the lingua franca of the eastern portions of the Roman Empire and the second language of educated Romans throughout the empire.
Again by your logic, the Romans themselves had a slave morality, because, with the exception of those from central Italy, many Roman soldiers were descendants of peoples such as the Samnites, who had been conquered and assimilated by Rome. Were the Romans victims of their own morality?
Also it's an insane take to suggest that there were no important Greeks after Alexander. Euclid alone was arguably more influential than many figures before Alexander. His Elements became one of the most influential mathematical works ever written and that's not even mentioning Eratosthenes and Archimedes
>>2957421>Even after the Roman conquest, Greek culture remained enormously important. Greek was essentially the lingua franca of the eastern portions of the Roman Empire and the second language of educated Romans throughout the empire.Right, English is a global language, but we don't talk about England.
The culture passes on from its possessors to its inheritors. Greece becomes irrelevant as a people, not as the bearers of a spirit, which by this time has already developed into different strands of unfoldment.
>the Romans themselves had a slave moralityMost people in society do, since most people are slaves.
The predisposition of Christianity is a generalised slavery (e.g. the enslavement of Catholics to the Pope).
>Were the Romans victims of their own morality?Of course; you only become vulnerable where you become weak.
>Euclid, Eratosthenes, ArchimedesRemnants of the 4th century into the decaying 3rd century
>>2957415>the Dark Agesno such thing
>>2957425What do you call the period between the decline of the Roman Empire and the rise of the commercial revolution of the 10th century, giving us what is then termed "the middle ages"?
>>2957432Early Middle Ages
>>2957421>>2957424It could also be seen that with the Nicean Council and the officiation of Christianity in the 4th century, leading to the German barbarians destroying Rome in the 5th century that the world-spirit is German. This is how Hegel understands it. We see the Anglo-Saxons arrive in England at this same time. We could disagree with Hegel here, since its now the Arabs who inherit the Greco-Roman culture, as Germans struggle to unify themselves (all the way up to the 19th century). Islam also arises at this time. With the Crusades, you get a world-historical conflict which during commercial revolution, inovates economics, especially with Fibonacci's incorporation of Arab numerals. The Normans take over from the English to establish feudalism and so on.
>>2957439Seems reductive.
You don't agree that the decline of Rome led to a decline in culture?
>>2957424>The culture passes on from its possessors to its inheritors. Greece becomes irrelevant as a people, not as the bearers of a spiritAnd did you get that from the sicky phrenologist with tummy aches.
>Of course; you only become vulnerable where you become weak.I'm talking about the general roman population the Italians who made up the bulk Empire, they were conquered and subjugated at one point as well.
>Remnants of the 4th century into the decaying 3rd centurySo you would consider Galen also part of this remnant of the 4th century?
You didn't answer the first question, the fact that Judaism, as a religion we know it today is a product of Greek intellectual traditions. The word "synagogue" itself is of Greek origin. Before this Judaism was a living tribal religion. But when Greek methods of inquiry, debate, and philosophical reasoning became influential, the role of the rabbi changed from that of a priest to that of a scholar, adopting Greek rhetorical and philosophical traditions that are still used to this day. So what does that make Judaism, then? I'm not talking about Christianity, but Judaism itself.
>>2957445>You don't agree that the decline of Rome led to a decline in culture?In terms of military affairs, European tactics and methods during the "dark" Ages were far ahead of those employed by Rome at its peak. advanced fortifications, motte-and-bailey castles, heavy cavalry shock tactics, and mounted archery.
>>2957447>but are a modern, capitalist technique of persecution.It was clearly feudal. Best trvthnuke about how life was in medieval times is that these people were full of parasites when archeologist found their fossilized excraments.
>>2957399>There were so many imported gods and foreign religious influences, the cult of Isis, the Mithraic cult within the military and even forms of pseudo-monotheism,This is true.
>>2957446>PhrenologistNot sure what the implication is here.
>GalenHe was surely a crackpot.
Plato already complained about medicine in his time being in decline.
He also didn't invent the theory of the four humours.
>You didn't answer the first question, the fact that Judaism, as a religion we know it today is a product of Greek intellectual traditionsYes, I agree. Christianity too.
You are perhaps misunderstanding me.
The ideas are not dissolved by newer cultures, but are developed into them. We speak English, deterritorialising it from England, etc. I think Judaism is purely Hellenic from Adler's and Gmirckin's writings. Before Judaism was a disparate Yahwehism, but it had no real laws.
>>2957452>clearly feudalLet's see:
<In the early modern period, from about 1400 to 1775, about 100,000 people were prosecuted for witchcraft in Europe and British America.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witch_trials_in_the_early_modern_periodwomp womp
>>2957445>You don't agree that the decline of Rome led to a decline in culture?No, and neither do the historians.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Ages_(historiography)#Modern_scholarly_use >>2957454>from about 1400 to 1775, Are you implying this timeline isnt feudalist?
Isn’t the contemporary consensus that there was no such thing as “feudalism”? Each country and kingdom had its own forms of agrarian mixed economy and about a dozen competing classes. “Feudalism” loses its meaning when “feudalism” in the Tang dynasty looks and operates completely differently to France, The Mamluks, Iran, or the HRE.
>>2957457>neither do the historiansNeither do some historians from the 1970s onwards*
And to say that the Dark Ages had cultural value isn't in any sense to compare it to the heights of Rome.
>>2957458>feudalistCapitalism develops into the 16th century
And more, we can see where persecution was highest and lowest (picrel)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witch_trials_in_the_early_modern_periodWhy is the 16-17th century in particular so harsh?
>>2957459It's not a clearly-defined system, no.
But its a good shorthand.
>>29574644 to 8 million people died in 30 years war in the same time period. Witch trials only relelevance is some present day demagogy of academic scholars.
>>2957469Medieval peasants were not filthy, superstitious idiots.
That is a modern prejudice projected back by witch-burners.
I only had one point to make on that.
>>2957487If you’re raising livestock, you’re getting dirty, you’re dealing with feces. Didn’t most peasants have a cow or a pig or a goat?
>>2957487Its a massive cope to romanticize this period.
>>2957489>Didn’t most peasants have a cow or a pig or a goat?If they were wealthy. Farmhands slept in the barn with animals.
>>2957459Considering asian countries mostly didn't even have serfdom, making the urban/rural divide much less drastic and encouraging local artisans, yeah, that's why "the asiatic mode of production" thing came about (also called the tributary mode, where citizens are subjects without delegation of lordships owning people)
>>2957464>Capitalism develops into the 16th centuryAbsolute state of these retards thinking capitalism was a dominant mode of production during this period.
>>2957495It’s not dominant but the merchant republics of Venice and Genoa were punching far above their weight in the centuries prior, I wouldn’t call them full capitalist but they didn’t operate like France or the Khanate or Poland Lithuania
>>2957496Capitalism indeed were born in these merchant states but capitalism became dominant mode of production only in the late 18th century.
>>2957489You are able to wash yourself.
>>2957491>RomanticiseIt's just facts.
Modern society (e.g. capitalism) is more brutal and superstitious than the medieval and renaissance era. The protestant reformation brought hell along with it.
>>2957495I'm just taking Marx and Engels' word for it:
<we come across the first beginnings of capitalist production as early as the 14th or 15th century, sporadically, in certain towns of the Mediterranean, the capitalistic era dates from the 16th century.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch26.htmThey see it developing into the 16th century from the world market.
But please enlighten us and tell us when capitalism is developed.
>>2957503
They’re literally happening right now though, there’s still witch camps in Ghana
>>2957499>Modern society (e.g. capitalism) is more brutal and superstitious than the medieval and renaissance eraare you trying to bait marxoids into writing walls of text of capitalism apologism?
>>2957522not everyone that disagrees with you or has a different worldview is trolling
>>2957516Marxoids should have no problem admitting it:
<The Romans are the rationalists, the Germans the mysticshttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/ch05.htm<Up till now it has been thought that the growth of the Christian myths during the Roman Empire was possible only because printing was not yet invented. Precisely the contrary. The daily press and the telegraph, which in a moment spreads inventions over the whole earth, fabricate more myths (and the bourgeois cattle believe and enlarge upon them) in one day than could have formerly been done in a century.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1871/letters/71_07_27.htmWith commodity production comes commodity fetishism, etc.
>>2957522How am I a troll?
The protestant reformation and its consequences are uniquely evil.
>>2957526I do agree modern society is more superstitious but I dont think its more brutal, however that doesnt mean humans are more free now, social control just operates in more refined ways than naked brutality
>Marxoids should have no problem admitting itthey often think the perfectioning of the state is progress, thats why you are getting accused of "trolling" now
>>2957527meds
>The protestant reformation and its consequences are uniquely evil.
I dont like protestant churches because they look boring compared to the catholic ones, but aside from that, whats so uniquely evil about it?
What's the ISG CONSENSUS on the YouTuber called President Sunday?
>>2957540He seems like a miserable person.
>>2957531>I dont think its more brutal>we are more free nowKeep in mind that slavery in the US was only "abolished" in 1865 and that segregation was only legally challenged in 1965. I think people have a very narrow idea of what capitalist "freedom" entails, or even what it means. Workers in Britain couldn't vote until the 20th century.
>social control just operates in more refined ways than naked brutalityIt is a rape of the mind and body, rather than just the body.
>>2957532The Reformation led to the Wars of Religion, a series of endless conflicts which lasted for around 150 years:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religionThe "protestant work ethic" also underlied the capitalist orientation of England in its seizure of property and eradication of holidays. Marx:
<Protestantism, by changing almost all the traditional holidays into workdays, plays an important part in the genesis of capital.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch10.htmProtestantism is the capitalist religion.
Not that Catholicism is "better", or anything.
>>2957540Why he seems like a miserable person?
>>2957550Why he's a liberal?
>>2957556He seems to spend all of his time criticising everybody to a cult audience. He's never collaborating but just by himself. I don't think I've ever seen him smile or laugh. At least from what I've seen of him.
>>2957031>The idea that concessions to first world workers are extracted from the third world is objectively falseIt's objectively true. Higher relative wages, quality of life, infrastructure, educational institutions and much more. All made possible solely through the extraction of superprofits from the third world. That is the reality, regardless of any hypotheticals about global redistribution in the future
>>2957560>All made possible solely through the extraction of superprofits from the third world.Unless you believe that first world workers cost rather than earn their bosses money, then you must admit that their consumption is furnished by their own output. According to your logic everybody "benefits" from imperialism so long as they aren't at the absolute bottom of the system, since more intense exploitation of people below them allows for their own lives to be easier. Taken to its logical conclusion it essentially posits that socialism is impossible because every worker will simply just try to screw over others to get ahead instead of ever showing solidarity. Why would a Mexican worker risk their relatively privileged position for the sake of a Bolivian worker? Why would a Bolivian worker risk their relatively privileged position for the sake of a Haitian worker? Third worldist reasoning tells us that all these people should side with their own ruling class against the people below them.
>>2957557He gives me that vibe
>>2957560cuba has a higher life expectancy than the united states. unfortunately you have fallen for porky propaganda
>>2957564Obviously first world workers are still workers, that is irrelevant to the question of whether they receive benefits at the cost of workers in the global south.
It doesn't matter what dumb conclusion you draw from this, what matters is if it is factually correct or not. Which it is. It boggles my mind how you find it so difficult to grasp that what matters is the truth and not whatever you find to be the most convenient story to convince people to your ideology
a haitian, bolivian and mexican worker are all much more similar to each other in terms of exploitation (materially, not morally) than they are to a western worker. The difference between periphery and semi periphery is fairly moderate. The difference between those and the core is enormous
>>2957572Irrelevant. I did not mention life expectancy, but quality of life
first worlders benefiting from third world exploitation is not mutually exclusive with first workers also generating surplus value
like, mathematically, there's nothing preventing that from being the case
>>2957564>Unless you believe that first world workers cost rather than earn their bosses money, then you must admit that their consumption is furnished by their own output.you're operating under the assumption that the labor market operates freely worldwide, when in fact it is tightly restricted, and is getting steadily more restricted to preserve high salaries on the core. literally only retarded US commies believe this, even MAGAs know that their high salaries must necessarily come from violently refusing migrants at the border, killing them if possible. you need to be obstinately obtuse to not understand how are salaries in the first world preserved, when even retarded reactionaries intuitively grasp it.
>everybody "benefits" from imperialism so long as they aren't at the absolute bottom of the systemdestitute hobos are entirely irrelevant to the question, they are not workers.
>Why would a Mexican worker risk their relatively privileged position for the sake of a Bolivian worker?they don't, mexicans heavily enforce their own borders too
>>2957540I like him, he's relaxing to listen to. I guess some of you watch him too because he's getting pushed onto my youtube frontpage more and more. He strikes me as more of an idealist, but he's ok.
>>2957543 >Keep in mind that slavery in the US was only "abolished" in 1865 and that segregation was only legally challenged in 1965. I think people have a very narrow idea of what capitalist "freedom" entails, or even what it means. Workers in Britain couldn't vote until the 20th century.I'm not saying its not brutal, just not any more or less brutal than feudalism and others more than in a quantitative way, which is undialectical to the marxoid brain that yearns to chose between a lesser evil between class society
>It is a rape of the mind and body, rather than just the body.correct
>The Reformation led to the Wars of Religion, a series of endless conflicts which lasted for around 150 yearsdamn, sounds like a proper historical event, way cooler than the current nothingburger forever wars, almost like a movie
>Protestantism is the capitalist religion.yeah thats true, I still dont see something uniquely evil about it, just regular evil
>>2957564No the reason why countries which only had capitalist economic development under nationalist policy for the past 60 years aren't as developed as countries which had that for 250+ years is solely due to superprofits.
>>2957678Holy shit, it's fucking Sinbad. The oldfag is sinbad. Fuck you sinbad you pulling my leg you fucker.
>>2957378the written word fucked the whole game up
>>2957816Israelis are famously notorious stoners that shit out south and south east asia.
>>2957816Look up 'kosher kush'
>>2957564
>Unless you believe that first world workers cost rather than earn their bosses money, then you must admit that their consumption is furnished by their own output.This is a non-marxist view. Measuring uses values produced vs. use values consumed or operating on purely monetary compensation is orthogonal to analysis of exploitation in terms of labour time.
Recall: A worker is exploited if and only if the labour time they put into production of commodities is less than the labour time equivalent of their total income (ie. monetary expression labour time adjusted income)
To illustrate how it is possible for a worker to not be exploited, consider a simple scenario wherein two agrarian worker coops with a single member each, operating in a capitalist market, selling a single product. Further assume that the differential productivity due to soil quality, and that each worker coop owns the land. Moreover, assume that for a full years worth of labour time (2000h) worker coop A produces 6000 tons & worker coop B produces only 4000 tons. Finally assume the labour time equivalent of the sales price per unit is exactly the 1 over the average productivity of the two farms (ie. 1/(10000t/4000h) = (4/10)h/t). Assume no other inputs.
Results:
Coop A: 2000h labour time into production but revenues of ((4/10)h/t)*6000t = 2400h. Net not exploited.
Coop B: 2000h labour time into production but revenues of ((4/10)h/t)*4000t = 1600h. Net exploited.
Now all that is necessary is to substitute the ownership of differential productivity land for ownership of scarce skills, knowledge, etc. which enables the worker in question to be less exploited or not at all.
Further one could also have this done by social democratic redistribution from such workers with such scarce skills towards those without in a given country, with resulting lowering or even ending of net exploitation for the workers in said country.
Some might classify such workers as functionally/actually petty bourgeois (at least if they are net beneficiaries of exploitation). The resulting absence of strong revolutionary sentiment as well as low amounts of apparent international class solidarity thus have an obvious material basis rooted in what is fundamentally divergent class interests.
>>2957816they keep it hidden in the community. there is a yiddish saying:
>"a shanda far di goyim"making a shame or embarrasement of yourself and the community for all the outsiders/goyim
>>2957895Does he have some sort of disorder or something
>>2957899he's from argentina
it's a criminal act for foreigners to slander the nation publicly in argentina btw
>>2957816>Stoner JewSeth Rogan…
>>2957902>he's from argentina*he's an Australian digital nomad gentrifying Buenos Aires
>>2957912He used to hang out with Zherka, and Zherka is a genuine barbarian.
Haz is a sophisticate, not a warrior, as you say.
Physiognomy betrays him: manlet and wonky eyes.
>>2957916damn older women are so ugly when they cry
>>2957920>she is 38DAAAAMMN
>>2957926No, since Lysenko explicitly recognizes the existence of chromosomes, and also recognizes that they play a very important role in heredity.
What he rejects is that they are sole factor influencing heredity, and there are no other important factors. He also believes that many acquired characteristics can be inherited fairly quickly.
>>2957916>I thought I knew himhe was always a piece of shit she just liked that he was being a piece of shit to other people.
the raider of ramallah turned out to be capable of feeling emotion, just not for palestinians.
>>2957926No because it isn't retarded enough
>>2957912>This is why Hasan is superior he embarrased himself recently on an interview too, he couldnt rebute even the most stupid rightoid talking points, why cant yank leftoids get their shit together? makes me sick
>>2958069I hope CPUSAnon cashed out
>>2957895it's good people are finally realizing what a retarded chud he is
Wired has a feature about pro-Israel billionaires from Silicon Valley being behind Visegrad 24. Not surprising but it's always good to follow the money behind this stuff. It has something for everyone because they gained a lot of followers from conservatives but also NAFO libs because they're very pro-Ukrainian. Then they began glazing Reza Pahlavi and making Project Veritas-style videos about American college students protesting Israel.
>Over the past six years, Visegrad24 has become a strangely ubiquitous force in right-wing social media, its feed a reliable kaleidoscope of dehumanized, brown-skinned aggressors and their alleged depredations against innocent, often white-skinned victims, alongside global news from a nationalist perspective. On any given day, V24 might show you a stomach-turning video of a camel being abused at a wedding in the West Bank, a parade of cell phone clips showing violent crimes being committed by alleged “migrants” all across Europe, or an interview about the Great Replacement Theory.
>From its headquarters in Warsaw, V24’s lean pseudo-news operation has proven itself almost preternaturally adept at virality on Elon Musk’s X. It even seems to have become one of the oligarch’s own favorite accounts. For a period after November 2024, Musk became especially fixated on British far-right politics, posting nonstop about “rape gangs” of South Asian men allegedly grooming British girls. To better understand Musk’s influences at the time, WIRED partnered with the research firm Bright Data to analyze his interactions with some 30 prominent European far-right accounts over a 45-day period ending in January 2025; we found that Musk engaged with Visegrad24, a major font of “grooming gangs” content, at least three times more than any other account on the list. Another dubious mark of distinction for V24: Of all the billion-plus accounts on X, Visegrad ranks 32nd in the number of community notes—crowdsourced fact checks—that have been attached to its posts.
>But in tandem with its drumbeat of demonized migrants, V24 has also excelled at capitalizing on the information wars that inevitably form around real, bloody conflicts like those in Ukraine, Gaza, and now Iran. The documents obtained by WIRED—to which [founder Stefan] Tompson responded with a blanket denial and an email from a lawyer—shed an intimate light on how this playbook evolved over the course of V24’s rapid rise. They provide an unvarnished case study of life inside today’s fractured and erratic right-wing mediasphere. And they reveal how the right kind of online influence, even when it’s strategically acquired by an entity just barely above the gutter of white nationalism, can command support from some of the most powerful people in the world.
>In late November 2023, Tompson wrote to [confidant] Boris with some exciting news. “Jewish VCs have created a group,” he texted. “Several. I’m in two of those groups that actively push back against founders who have supported Palestine.” In another message he described one of these encrypted text threads as “85 people. 84 Jews and me.”
>“They are slowly reaching out directly … Usually they want a retweet,” he wrote to Boris. “V24 is such a big part of the Israeli PR they all know what it is now.”
>“You’re in the belly of the beast now,” replied Boris (who requested anonymity for fear of legal retaliation).
>One of the groups to which Tompson gained entry was called Jewish Alliances, described by one of its members—someone going by the handle Sean Rad, which is the name of a Tinder cofounder—as a space to “bring together Jews and non-Jews working together to fight antisemitism.”
>On Jewish Alliances, Tompson came personally recommended by Shaun Maguire, a general partner at Sequoia Capital who led the firm’s investments in Elon Musk–affiliated companies. Like V24, Maguire had become vociferously pro-Israel after October 7—later explaining that the attacks galvanized him to engage in “information warfare” for the country. Maguire had even made introductions that eventually helped connect the Israel Defense Forces with Musk’s Starlink satellite communication network in the earliest days of the Gaza war. And now, on Jewish Alliances, he was throwing some weight behind V24.
>“Stefan / Visegrad is an incredible account if you’re not already following,” Maguire told the group thread. Privately, Maguire told Tompson, “I’ll give u $25k and try to raise the rest.” (Maguire later told WIRED that he ultimately had to stop short of making his donation. “I would have loved to donate to Visegrad, as I think their content is excellent, but I wasn't able to for compliance reasons.”)
>As for the other elite group chat that Tompson says he was invited to join, it appears to have been even more rarefied. In December that year, Tompson sent Boris a screenshot of a blurb from a Puck newsletter, headlined “The In-Crowd’s Hottest Text Thread.” Tompson had circled the item in red with an arrow pointing at it.
>“I learned this week that hundreds of the most powerful figures from Silicon Valley, Wall Street, and Hollywood have joined a sprawling, informal WhatsApp thread to share thoughts on how to build support for Israel and combat antisemitism following the attacks of October 7,” wrote media reporter Dylan Byers in the blurb. “The group, which is called Builders for Israel, includes the likes of Sheryl Sandberg, Bill Ackman, and David Marcus.”[…]
>As a platform for fundraising, the two group chats appear to have paid off pretty handsomely for Visegrad24. “Should have 75k on Monday,” Tompson wrote to Boris on November 18. There was $50,000 coming from “a very private man” at the Silicon Valley fintech investment firm Ribbit Capital. Ribbit's founder is Meyer “Micky” Malka, an early investor in Coinbase and promoter of crypto. Tompson would later tell Boris that Malka was allegedly planning to donate an additional $200,000. Financial records show donations of $50,000 and $200,000 roughly lining up with Tompson's messages, but Malka did not respond to requests for comment. Records indicate that Tompson also secured a $20,000 donation from the investment firm Hindenberg Research, with an additional $15,000 linked to an email address associated with the firm’s founder, the prominent Wall Street short seller Nathan Anderson. Tompson also claimed he had a “soft commitment” from the Israeli American investor Daniel Gross, a former AI lead at both Apple and Y Combinator. (Anderson and Gross did not respond to requests for comment.)
>Notifications from GiveButter, a site Tompson used for soliciting contributions, show that other donations were linked to email addresses associated with SimpleVenue CEO Michael Sinensky, Warby Parker founder Neil Blumenthal, Wix president Nir Zohar, Lux Capital cofounder Josh Wolfe, and deep tech venture capitalist Matt Ocko.https://www.wired.com/story/leaked-how-silicon-valley-elites-bankrolled-anti-migrant-pro-israel-propaganda-machine/>>2957895Who the fuck is Karl? Do i even need to know?
>>2958173You just condemned people with Down syndrome and other disabled people to death. Nice eugenics, Lenin!
>>2958173That mexican Nazi couldn’t even identify capitalism without some ideological predetermined bullshit
>>2958192No this is le inter-zionist war
>>2958182Maybe it's his family that's the problem
>>2958190Having sex with a woman is pretty fucking gay
>>2958237tyler is right and if you drink lemonade you are a faggot
>>2958156do you guys genuinely not understand humour
>>2958231What the fuck is wrong with dubheads
Also tip, if anyone's faction here ever captures me and throws me in a dungeon, if you want to torture me, just play a lot of reggae. Have you ever heard of one single person going around telling people about how hype reggae is? It's okay if you like it but I think it's bad music.
>>2958262
Twitter needs to be shut down and retarded chuds like the guy in the screenshot need to be put into labor camps to get this narcissistic childish and self-centered attitude out of their system.
>>2958262
I will now buy this game
>>2958267That type of attitude is baked into every medium of entertainment media, you would need to delete all fiction as a first step
>>2958298Because being anything other than a cartoon exaggeration of a viking berserker is being a cuck. These people have a true return to monke desire, they have the souls of badgers and wolverines but are trapped in human bodies.
>>2958262
GTA hasn't been relevant since the mid 2000's or so.
>>2958301You know I often feel like I would've liked life more if I was just a raider who took what he wanted from others instead of how I live now. I'd probably be dead by now with that lifestyle but at least I wouldn't have had to work.
>>2958315Or maybe being a drug trafficker that gets lots of snizz. Finally I could become a Don Juan.
Why do I feel like the GTA6 controversy, as shit or good of a game as it is notwithstanding, is just an attempt by rapedwingers to rile up their side for the 2028 election so they can point and say
>LOOK, LOOK!!! THE EVIL LEFTIST, SHITSKIN, FEMINIST, JEWS ARE STILL RUINING OUR VIDEO GAMES AND CULTURE
In an attempt to salvage their political relevancy after they got destroyed in the mid-terms by specifically targeting a massive release like GTA6? Most of the whining online from the usual suspects like Xitter or 4chan are just them crying about women, leftists or Indians. Must criticizing the latest AAA game be so politicized? Is nothing sacred anymore?
>>2958363
Having Niko bitch about the war and trauma was woke as fuck
Video games are dumb. You should write instead.
>>2958396write about video games?
>>2957868>Measuring uses values produced vs. use values consumed or operating on purely monetary compensation is orthogonal to analysis of exploitation in terms of labour time.I am talking about exploitation in terms of labour time. Do you really believe that Western workers can buy more with an hour's wages than what they can produce in an hour? Do you have any evidence of this? If not, then they are exploited and their consumption is furnished by their own production, not imperialism.
>with resulting lowering or even ending of net exploitation for the workers in said country.If workers in a given country aren't exploited then they are effectively a massive net drain on their employers profits, in which case there would be no reason to hire them at all since they would be a liability. Again, is this what you believe? Do you have any evidence of this?
>The resulting absence of strong revolutionary sentiment as well as low amounts of apparent international class solidarity This is a global problem that you lot continually refuse to recognize. Most third world countries do not have strong communist movements. The small number that do (India, South Africa) have parties that operate exclusively through electoralism, are functionally social democrats, and display the same labour-aristocratic and opportunist tendencies as Western parties have historically. This isn't the 1960s anymore, the predominant tendencies of first and third world workers have converged to the point where there are only differences of degree. The fact that this has happened while imperialism remains intact indicates that it was never actually the cause to begin with.
>>2957579>the question of whether they receive benefits at the cost of workers in the global south. Anon, simply not being exploited as hard isn't a "benefit". Again, any time there is somebody that is exploited more aggressively that you, this theoretically allows you to be exploited less. So this means that everybody "benefits" from this system as long as they aren't at the very bottom. But the way people talk about this issue is as if workers in the West are receiving direct subsidies that go over and above what they produce themselves. In reality all that's happening is lower rates of exploitation that are made tolerable for capitalists through higher rates in the periphery. Calling this a "benefit" is misleading because it implies some kind of direct beak-wetting by first world workers, when all that's happening is they aren't being squeezed as hard. Call it semantics if you want but it's obvious how this way of framing it is corrosive to solidarity.
>a haitian, bolivian and mexican worker are all much more similar to each other in terms of exploitation (materially, not morally) than they are to a western workerIf you look at the median income of every country in the world, they form a clear gradient from richest to poorest, with relatively small gaps in median income between one country and the next richest or poorest. There is no clear binary or dividing line between periphery, semi-periphery, and core. The poorer nations of the core are closer to the richer nations of the semi-periphery than they are to the richer nations of the core. But if we apply the kind of reasoning you're promoting, workers in every country have a vested interest in subjugating everybody below them since this spares them from worse exploitation.
>>2958422>But the way people talk about this issue is as if workers in the West are receiving direct subsidiesNice strawman.
>>2958435Okay well if you agree that this is simply a difference in rates of exploitation then I don't see how you can come to the conclusion that first world workers "benefit" from this system. And if you insist on seeing it that way, logical consistency would require you to apply the same reasoning to virtually everybody but the absolute poorest proles in the poorest countries.
the glowies seized my favorite mastodon instance
its over
https://boards.4chan.org/g/thread/110378738>>2958262
>wait 16 years
See, that's the problem.
>>2958301>These people have a true return to monke desireThey hear a single lightning strike at the darkest night in the hollowest forest, full of other apex predators like tigers and bears, and they will shit their internal 'badgers and wolverines' asses, causing massive and explosive bleeding diarrhea on their human asses.
if you have a favorite mastodon instance, you need to kill yourself
>>2958450whats wrong with mastodon?
>>2958450Boring answer but it’s Leviathan, Crack the Skye never did it for me
>>2958298>the game forces you to have an actual relationship where you bring your thicc Latina gf flowers and try to provide for her through DIY home repair and your ability to apply violence, for some reason this is incomprehensible to them and makes you a cuck.Actually based. You cannot love Minecraft and hate this. Good job Rockstar, I am impressed.
>>2958262>>2958298>>2958474I saw so many stupid posts about this, according to the AI(which is probably right)all these little minigames, or side-quests or whatever you want to call it are only available in the first chapter for the guy to up their relationship score when you only play as him while she's in jail before she comes out. Then after that their are just some standard interactions that apply to both of them and choices in the missions to up their relationship score, which influences which of the endings you get. But yeah, there are some little actions available for him specifically that give you a boost for the relationship score, picking up groceries, fixing the stairs, picking up her laundry, buying her a necklace. Then after that both of them have options to ask the other one out on a date and to give them compliments and other stuff, then options in the mission. I guess nobody has disclosed the ending or end game the main quest is 100+hours long.
>>2958228The kid is white and posted on 4chan about it.
>>2958190I almost feel bad for his girlfriend. Almost.
>>2958173>implying he’s confused>implying this isn’t purposeful>implying he gives a shit and wont grab whatever low hanging fruit he can for relevancyKys
>>2958413
>I am talking about exploitation in terms of labour time. Do you really believe that Western workers can buy more with an hour's wages than what they can produce in an hour?No you are not, you say so yourself right there (you are taking in terms of wages and what they produce in an hour). What they produce is not labour time but goods/services (commodities).
Labour time is measured in hours put into production, not the number of commodities produced in that time, nor their sales price. This is basic Marxist economics.
Did you even read my simple example? Are you aware that surplus value can be redistributed amongst producers?
>If workers in a given country aren't exploited then they are effectively a massive net drain on their employers profits.Are you actually serious? Are going to claim that actors earning millions of dollars are exploited? Or engineers earning a hundred thousand dollars a hear? Somehow they are putting like 20-50x ( or more like 1000x in the cas of top actors) of hours into production then ordinary workers around the world?
This isn't complicated at all. Just because an enterprise makes does not mean its direct employees are exploited & vice versa. They can gain surplus value by redistribution from the broder economy.
The market redistributes surplus value from less productive to more productive producers generally. These more productive producers have ownership over a relatively scarce resources. It can be a natural resource, knowledge, skills, technology, branding, social connections, etc. which means they can command a price for their products far in excess of their cost (in labour time).
>>2958572*just because an enterprise makes a profit
>>2958376Maybe, but it doesn't help that the premise of GTA6 IS pretty fucking stupid.
>The Romance GTAlmao
>THEY PUT THE WOKE AND GAY IN MY VIDYA GAMES!
Good. All gaymers should be put in the gulag, but this is the next best thing.
>>2958640I know we're supposed doing a culture war and being contrarian, but "Romance GTA" is a pretty fucking stupid idea, and I wouldn't want to be perceived as defending ideas this obviously dumb.
>>2958647Games are all stupid and I'm happy when gamers are mad.
>>2958645buzzword buzzword buzzword
>>2958673Majority of farmers in the U.S. hire illegal migrant labor or people with temporary worker visas then super exploit them.
No sympathy tbh
>>2958673kevin o'leary is such an incredible piece of shit even by porky standards
>>2958645well that's a word salad, though I doubt that even half of these are real words
>>2958645I hate small capitalists
>>2957678Jimmy Dore is a good example of what we called in Spain "perro flautas". People who want "change" and fight against "corruption" and hate "the system" but always wanna work within the boundaries of the capitalist nation-state. Before the 2020s they were associated with the left for participating in the anti-austerity movements of the 2010s. Some of these people cant shake up their cult for small capitalists, so they end up voting and supporting alt-right personalities.
>>2958772>Jimmy Dore is a good example of what we called in Spain "perro flautas".>People who want "change" and fight against "corruption" and hate "the system" but always wanna work within the boundaries of the capitalist nation-state.dont they have the word "social-democrata" in spaniard spanish?
>>2958773Jimmy would be more of a "market socialist"
>>2958776the difference being?
>>2958777Social-Democrats seek to promote a welfare state
A Market Socislist seeks workers to own the means of production
>>2958732American prudes are the worst
>>2958732Based. Nothing of value was lost.
>>2958779They don't care about the Eldians outside of Paradise either, while they accept the volunteer soldiers. The national genesis kind of starts out as just "us vs them" so everyone outside the island are the enemies and not included. And what Eldian Empire are they even trying to restore? Marley is basically what the old Eldian Empire was as an imperialist superpower. I think the Yaegerists would rather just wipe everyone out though.
In a way the Yaegerists are progressive anti-imperialists (outside of the rumbling), though also they would become imperialists themselves if they had the chance (like all bourgeois forces would). Paradise needs a national identity in order to fit into the modern world based around nations, and they need to protect themselves from Marley. I think with a communist anti-imperialist perspective, the Yaegerists are progressive up until the full rumbling.
>>2958732so this is what that other mastodon freak was whining about, pedos deserve the wall
>>2958779It's called bad writing
>>2958772Yeah
>>2958776I don't think there's a coherent ideology with Dore so much as a catch-all populism. That said I don't watch him but it's more "we the people" vs. "the elites" and ~let's get the left and right together~ to shake things up. It can sound very radical vis-a-vis the establishment, but it's very emotional and present-tense oriented and gets caught up in whatever anti-establishment figure comes along. Trump is the enemy of the establishment hmmm we can have some hope that… oh no he betrayed us WTF how could this happen!?!? Well that just proves Dore is right that the two parties are both part of the establishment wow, but did he ever reasses why he, Jimmy Dore, thought it would be different?
>>2958645The crazy part is that 100% haz has talked about every thing mentioned here. The years have really made this guy go even more esoteric. I miss the old chimping out gorilla haz tbh, this mysticism shit's so boring
>>2958865Well when National Socialism proved to be a dead end after fighting a war against the world and losing and then trying to rebrand itself to be more family friendly, the hardline adherents slipped deeper and deeper into mysticism until you had people like Savitri Devi and James Madole literally worshipping Hitler as a god. With Marxism Leninism on the way out it's no surprise to see the same pattern happening here, with its diehard adherents having to turn towards increasing esoteric idealism
>>2958867It looks more like haz trying to maintain relevancy as a streamer to his audience by creating a more and more niche internal language for their ecommunity. Rather than being some sort of weird universal ideological feature of both nazism and marxism leninism as you seem to be suggesting. Sorry man, but Im dumbfounded by what a reach that is lmao
>>2958867Super dishonest take. Haz and the ACP are hardly indicative of broader MLism. No other broad ML org does mysticism crap. I challenge you to point me to one. Haz swallowed up Duginism(which should be a nonstarter for any communist tendency) and it made him extra retarded for woo woo bullshit. And he's also a streamer lolcow looking for attention.
>>2958888MLs flirting with islamslop its nothing new
>lolcowalso applies to many MLs, I think even MLs can agree
>>2958888Haz is the king of LARPers. No other communist figure in the modern era has tried so hard to LARP as a holy Muslim man without attending mosques, fasting, abstaining from alcohol, abstaining from premarital sex, etc.
i dont get the strategy if he wants to build an audience by going deeper into woo woo and wierdo esotericism. unless rather than going for a mass audience he wants to build up brainwashed fanatical diciples to give him money?
>>2958891You answered your own question
>>2958572>Labour time is measured in hours put into production, not the number of commodities produced in that time, nor their sales price. This is basic Marxist economics.Yes, that's literally what I'm talking about. If a worker can't buy an hour's worth of their out put with an hour's wages then they are exploited. They are being compensated with a fraction of the exchange value produced by their labour power, and the difference is surplus value accruing to their employer as profit. What is the problem you have with this statement?
>Did you even read my simple example?Your example is irrelevant because you're talking about co-ops and employee owned businesses. I'm talking about traditional capitalist firms that account for the overwhelming majority of the economy.
>Are you actually serious? Are going to claim that actors earning millions of dollars are exploited? Or engineers earning a hundred thousand dollars a hear?You're derailing the conversation. I didn't mention actors or engineers. I'm talking about ordinary workers in Western countries.
>Just because an enterprise makes does not mean its direct employees are exploited & vice versaIf a capitalist enterprise doesn't exploit its workers then it isn't profitable, since it would be paying them they equivalent of more than what they produce. In order for first world workers to actually benefit from superprofits (i.e. for their consumption to not be entirely furnished by their own productivity) then virtually every Western firm would need to be losing money on its Western workers.
>>2958901>If a worker can't buy an hour's worth of their out put with an hour's wages then they are exploited.What about the cost of upkeep of machines, R&D, and taxes for healthcare/other state services?
>>2958918What about it? All of that is paid for by the surplus produced by exploited workers.
>>2958925I don't understand your response: you seem to imply that I am arguing in favor of exploitation. My point is: under a socialist system where there is no private sector funneling surplus value into a few hands, there still won't be a 1 to 1 ratio between worker production and worker wage. Some portion of the wage will be retained for upkeep of mean of production and public services.
>>2958934are you following the argument anon?
Bourgeoisie vs Prolerariat
Who's going to win bros?
>>2958938gommon ruin of the gontending glasses :DDD
>>2958934>Some portion of the wage will be retained for upkeep of mean of production and public services.Yeah and? That's not really relevant to what we're talking about. In a socialist society production is operated by and for the workers, so how they choose to allocate their own surplus isn't exploitation. It's exploitation when it is pocketed by a private capitalist as private profits to be spent on whatever porky desires.
"Exploitation" is a buzzword when it used in regard to labor-power. The worker is not exploited in any sense when he works for an undertaker. Its a legal contract (from the standpoint of bourgeois society) between two free producers. "Exploitation" is a term sensible when used with resources. But labor power is not exploited. The way anons use the word here is a moralistic usage of "exploitation".
>>2958901>If a worker can't buy an hour's worth of their out put with an hour's wages then they are exploited.The "undiminished" proceeds of labor have already unnoticeably become converted into the "diminished" proceeds, although what the producer is deprived of in his capacity as a private individual benefits him directly or indirectly in his capacity as a member of society.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1875/gotha/ch01.htm >>2958867>Well when National Socialism proved to be a dead end … the hardline adherents slipped deeper and deeper into mysticismI think there's something similar with Richard Spencer on the right. His group started getting into Greek mythology.
>>2958884>It looks more like haz trying to maintain relevancy as a streamer to his audience by creating a more and more niche internal language for their ecommunity.>>2958891>i dont get the strategy if he wants to build an audience by going deeper into woo woo and wierdo esotericism. unless rather than going for a mass audience he wants to build up brainwashed fanatical diciples to give him money?It's possible he wants a narrower audience that will be more committed. Also he's writing that list of really baroque jibberism in an ironic or post-ironic way which suggests he's not seriously committed to any of it, so this is for instrumental purposes to deliberately alienate people with the trade-off being that some people think what he's doing is extremely based. But then I thought, they might not really have much of a strategy anyways. You don't "get" the strategy because there isn't one.
But the larger thing might be that there's just a contradiction between the economic incentives of being an internet content creator and also wanting to act politically as things are arranged societally right now. These guys really acted like they believed unwoke proletarian hardhat communism would make the thing really popular on mass scale. And being internet content creators, they're under a lot of economic pressure to communicate to a mass audience. But when a group doesn't feel for whatever reason like it actually has the capacity to act politically in a meaningful way, they can attempt to use mysticism to unlock some kind of power, like tapping into the wisdom of the ancient Greeks (the LaRouchites were big-time Neoplatonists) or Haz tapping into Fomenko new chronology hermeneutics. But again, this runs contrary to appealing to a mass audience (or doing mass politics, which is different from just having an audience) because what seems very based to his following is completely repulsive to other people, and part of that is because culture and tastes have become so varied now, let alone on social media which deliberately fosters cultural division and outrage in a million different directions all at once. So the technology they're attempting to use to create this mass following is also undermining their capacity to do that.
>>2958453Mastodon is the same as Twitter and Bluesky in design, which means it will engineer you into posting only what will get you bigger numbers. Anything with view/like/follower counters is poison.
>>2958952Forcing the worker to sell her labor-power or die is morally wrong and thus exploitative.
>>2958645>Haz levitation incidentNever heard of it. I did hear about Haz having a crazy tryst on Halloween 2021.
>>2958980>morally wrong and thus exploitativeproving my point
>>2958645>>2958972>>2958884It's just hipsterism. It's intellecualism signaling while also maintaining irony poisoned detachment. Dasha does the same shit.
Is BE marxist?
>>2958987Actually reminds me of "theory fiction"
>>2958952>"Exploitation" is a term sensible when used with resources.and how is labor-force not a resource?
>>2958989No he has openly rejected marxism and doesn't believe in broad historical narratives like ie: all history is the history of class struggle. He mentioned it in explicitly in one of his videos and it's pretty evident if you analyze his stuff.
That being said, in my view, he is more correct than his sometimes marxist detractors give him credit for. Come to your own conclusions.
>>2958997He mentioned it more than once, but off the top of my head this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FU5N9ZR9ruQ&t=3073s >>2958972I don't think building a political philosophy based on things like Neoplatonism is necessarily an anti-popular practice of politics, Marxism itself is pretty academical and has a worldwide mass following.
It's the esoteric bullshit that lacks any serious philosophical credentials. But the ACP also prefers the LaRouche way of building support, by networking foreign intelligence assets, rather than aiming for mass support. Their actual praxis is anarchist, like building greenhouses and gyms and doing charity, but I think it's mostly a front.
>>2958924i didnt read your post but i just want to say i want to have sex with she. thank you.
>>2959040Kinda right thougheverbeit, Russia was imperialist but not "first world" (equivalent even at the time). He's just changing the subject
>>2959040S4A is right though.
>>2959040Russian empire was not imperialist because it was not the highest stage of capitalism. It was mostly feudalism with elements of capitalism, almost all of which came from other countries. Hence why Bolsheviks cancelled the debts in 1918. Literally basic Marxism-Leninism is the difference between ancient empires like Rome and modern empires built on financialization like the British Empire (now America).
<Colonial policy and imperialism existed before the latest stage of capitalism, and even before capitalism. Rome, founded on slavery, pursued a colonial policy and practised imperialism. But “general” disquisitions on imperialism, which ignore, or put into the background, the fundamental difference between socio-economic formations, inevitably turn into the most vapid banality or bragging, like the comparison: “Greater Rome and Greater Britain.” Even the capitalist colonial policy of previous stages of capitalism is essentially different from the colonial policy of finance capital.https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ch06.htm >>2959050So the romans weren't imperialists because they weren't capitalists?
>>2959041>>2959050Lenin literally said himself that the Russian Empire was an imperialist power, just the least of the imperialist powers and consequently the weakest link among them (which is why it fell to a communist revolution). It had the least developed industrial capitalist economy, but it DID have a significant industrial capitalist economy and its economy was only semi-feudal.
>>2959050is modern day israel not imperialist because they have an insignificant financial sector? 0.03% of their exports are financial services
>>2959061>lenin said so therefore trueRussian Empire was not imperialist, Roman Empire was not imperialist, PRC is not imperialist, RF is not imperialist.
>>2959065Who's imperialist?
>>2959069The Great Satan, France, Germany, Japan, Switzerland, Britain, the Netherlands, UAE, quite a few. Notice their geopolitical alignment.
>>2959065>Empire was not imperialistinteresting, can you explain how this happens?
>>2959085It just isn't, okay?
>>2959072Yes, being into obscure things is definitely part of it. If some thing they like becomes too popular they won't like it anymore. Also they love doing things to be "ironic." They can't genuinely like or do things, they have to do it ironically as a defensive shield. Also they like to create an identity out of an eclectic mishmash to be more unique and ironic. I knew this one chick who was like a Mexican goth girl veering into Hipsterdom. I remember her wearing these colorful Air Jordans and I thought it was a strange contrast with her style and I asked her about and she said she was wearing them to be ironic. So yeah they'll probably have a weird mishmash of strange little things from around the world that they're supposedly super into, but ironically. Kinda like Haz and whatever was in that word soup he posted.
>>2959085imperialism is not when an empire is declared. Was the Korean Empire imperialist?
Socialism For All (S4A) posted a critical reading of Ernesto "Che" Guevara's 1954 article "The American Working Class: Friend or Foe?". He was spurred to make this video as a result of a spat he had with Bad Empanada on social media. As a consequence of those circumstances I think he made an uncharitable reading of the text. Usually the audiobooks and critical readings of various historical documents that S4A makes for his channel are made as a part of series following a certain historical timeline or ideological theme. As such he ordinarily provides necessary context throughout the readings with his commentary, which helps the listener understand the text better. He will mention what was going on around the time of the writing of the text, to whom it was addressed, and of course who was writing it. Uncharacteristically this video is not made as a part of any series and no such context is provided. Instead only critical comments are added throughout the video.
The broader point that s4a seeks to make about Guevara's article is that Che "gives up" on the USA proletariat. He claims Che comes to the conclusion that it is pointless to agitate amongst them and that socialists ought instead to prepare themselves to fight against all of the USA proletariat. But this conclusion is erroneous and he comes to it because he ignores the context. This article was originally written in Spanish and it was obviously meant for Latin Americans. When one considers this it becomes obvious that when Che writes for example "I insist that we cannot demand that the working class of the North look past its own nose. It would be useless to try to explain, from afar, (…) that the process of internal decomposition of capitalism can only be deferred for a while longer, but never stopped, by the totalitarian measures taken towards maintaining Latin America in a colonial state." he obviously means we the Latin American socialist movement (or movements).
And on that he is completely correct! It would have been impossible and therefore a waste for him and his comrades to influence from afar the proletariat of the USA. Socialists outside the USA must of course be pragmatic, they understand the obvious, that their struggles can only result in the cooption of local institutions, local governments (those of their own countries), and local productive forces. They can do nothing to prevent the negative portrayal of said victories, if they achieve them, by the USA media in the USA. They can do nothing to prevent the USA government aligning it's own imperial interests with the immediate petty material interests of the USA working class. They can hope, and they do, that the USA workers movement will be able to counteract those things, but they would have been and, would be today, very naive to plan their emancipatory movements around such assumptions. Instead the only thing they can do is prepare themselves for the aggression of the USA state
I thought I had a lot more to write but honestly it's all fluff. This is the main point. Considering to whom his article was addressed really invalidates virtually all S4A's criticisms of it.
Passions are high at this point, both parties in the beef have staked their prides. No one was to lose face so I doubt S4A will retract his video, but I think he should. He is facilitating a frankly chauvinistic view of not only Che but many other third world radicals who have reached similar conclusions for their own struggles. Naive young USAnian socialists are disparaging Guevara and all his work in his comments, and I think that is a shame. The younger USAnians are already more easily predisposed to engaging not with texts as they are considering their full context and instead are introduced to them as a part of stupid internet beefs and S4A is adding to that. For what?
whatever. somebody send this comment to him lol
>>2959061Was this before Lenin took power and realized how capitalistically bankrupt the Russian Empire was and had to introduce the NEP because that "significant industrial capitalist economy" was not that significant?
>>2959069You can measure if a country is imperialist if it offloads its manufacturing to other less developed nations while keeping a strong military and most importantly, financial sector that regulates trades with other nations. The citizenry of said imperialist country becomes excessively cosmopolitan and unable to live on their own merits because the opportunity cost of foregoing tertiary (PMC, service sector) industry employment is really high. For example, they would hire nannies from third world countries, pay teenagers to mow lawn and pool, order grocery deliveries/personal nanny cook/frequent take-out because their time is their most valuable commodity to generate entropy and compete with other PMC's for slices of porky's profits. Historically, the British Empire was imperialist, the French and German empires attempted to be imperialist but failed as they never offloaded their manufacturing at their pinnacle. The US is imperialist because it did offload its manufacturing, it does have a powerful military to buttress that offloading and it is the global financial system. If China were to have a counter-revolution, offload its manufacturing to Africa, create a massive military to buttress the belt and road, and then use their financial system to enforce this relationship, it would be definitively imperalist. The British Empire was absorbed into the American Empire and I hope God will not allow China to absorb the American Empire because then the Zionists and Fabians will overthrow the CPC and it's game over for communism conclusively.
>>2959106China is imperialist too bro
>>2959065all of those are imperialist
>>2959111Not yet, nice trips, but it might soon be if the socialist economy is overthrown.
>>2959105Good post that doesn't deserve to be in this thread
>>2959105Retarded post that deserves to be in this thread
>>2959124It's not even the working class who plans the economy, how can it be socialist broski?
>>2959129No socialist country had "the working class" planning the economy. "The working class" is a theological concept from which all sorts of authority is derived in much the same way liberalism claims legitimacy from "the people". Which people? The ones that voted you in? Or the ones that paid for your campaign? Or the ones blackmailing you? The working class was always represented by "the party". The party somehow knew what the working class wanted. The party selected the planning agency that set the targets for the centrally planned economy. Outside of market socialist experiments like Yugoslavia, I don't know where the workers planned the economy, if you can even call market interactions planning.
>>2959106>Was this before Lenin took power and realized how capitalistically bankrupt the Russian Empire was and had to introduce the NEP because that "significant industrial capitalist economy" was not that significant?They implemented the NEP after the Russian Civil War because the war had destroyed the old Russian industrial economy.
It is insane to me how many people just ignore the existence of the Russian Civil War.
>>2959132That sounds more like state capitalism to me. The state will never wither away like that bro and you are defintely going to have an overproduction crisis in a couple of yeara, you better screencap this post.
https://nubiapage.com/fr/top-10-richest-people-in-china-2023-chinese-billionaires-net-worth/ >>2959137don't you insult the people's billionares
>>2959137I posited that the state will never wither away because statehood is entropically favorable, it will simply persist under a new name. And there will still be commodity production under communism, also under a new name. State capitalism is the practical implementation of Marxism. Marxism-Leninism is esoteric feudalism. See my post where I defended feudalism as the default state of economic development.
>overproduction crisisYes, I believe this would happen in China and if the government does not give people more free time and normalize the scale of means of production, it risks counter-revolution and the restoration of capitalism, at which point, communism is finished.
>>2959139The people's billionaires are mostly faggots and Xi is a professional faggot wrangler.
>>2959141and you hate them not because they're are billionaires but because you consider homosexuality bourgeoisie decadence????
>>2959144He might not mean it in a homophobic way.
>>2958987haz and dasha are both paid by thiel and other dark enlightenment porkychuds btw
>>2959105>Bad Empanada is such a goblin he actually made Socialism4All do something low qualitywow shameful. sometimes you stoop to somebody else's level and they beat you with experience.
>>2959060imperialist in the classical sense of the word, not imperialist in the leninist sense of the word. words often have multiple definitions, and to make matters more confusing, they have context-sensitive definitions which are sometimes not in the dictionary or relegated to a particular field of study.
>>2959125>>2959126mods can i get a "samefag" check on this
>>2959105>And on that he is completely correct! It would have been impossible and therefore a waste for him and his comrades to influence from afar the proletariat of the USA.And not only is that true, it applies in reverse to American socialists who whine about China not being true socialists, as if they have any realistic means of influencing the CPC or the Chinese proletariat besides joining their capitalist imperialist CIA.
>>2959105>. The younger USAnians are already more easily predisposed to engaging not with texts as they are considering their full context and instead are introduced to them as a part of stupid internet beefs and S4A is adding to that. For what? our youth here in usano land lack critical thinking skills. our education system has bred a special type of narcissistic bourgeois stupidity and sometimes I am thankful for that because it will hasten the destruction of a system, since systems require clever and machiavellian people at the helm. compare your nixons with your hegseths and you will see that this place is moribund.
>>2959105s4a is a atrasserite
>>2959173no it doesn't. american "socialists" are the enemies of global proletariat
che is not making a "le can't comvince from afar" argument here but exposing the class character of the american so called proletariat
>>2959105Funny how your critique of s4a here is that instead of falsifying theory to be compatible with the US labor aristocracy (by adding "context" to what are purportedly audiobook readings), he stooped so low as to reveal that he's an american chauvinist.
>>2959186I was reading this earlier, pretty interesting.
https://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/us/geras.htm<Which of them, however, is the appropriate point of view in the present context, the controversy about Marx and justice? Those according to whom he sees no injustice in the wage relation privilege the first, that there is an exchange of equivalents. Many (not all) of those according to whom he does regard the wage relation as unjust privilege the second, that there is not. Each side says, in effect, ‘This point of view is the only one relevant to the question of whether or not capitalism is for him unjust. But what of Marx himself? Well, Marx has it both ways, and that is at least one root of the difficulty. Note, here, that the problem is not that he affirms both points of view. As has just been said, they are mutually consistent parts of one doctrine. The problem is that he equivocates as to which of them is the one relevant to the moral question, so that it is legitimate in a way for each side to claim, about the two different perspectives: Marx really means us to adopt this one. For, he does say that, so far as justice is at issue, all that matters is that equal values are exchanged, in accordance with the laws of commodity production, and he thereby legitimates the view of one side in this dispute. But then, by a piece of dialectical wizardry in Chapter 24 of the first volume of Capital, he has these same laws turning into their very opposite. In his own words, ‘the laws of appropriation or of private property, laws based on the production and circulation of commodities, become changed into their direct opposite through their own internal and inexorable dialectic.’ He speaks here, similarly, of the occurrence of a ‘dialectical inversion’. The exchange of equivalents has now become, accordingly, only apparent, not an exchange of equivalents — in fact theft. A passage from the Grundrisse tells us ‘, in the same vein, that ‘the right of property undergoes a dialectical inversion, so that on the side of capital it becomes the right to an alien product.’ If the laws of commodity production and exchange have actually turned into their opposite, then that legitimates the view of the other side in this dispute as well, that, when all is said and done, there is no genuine equivalence or reciprocity here. >>2959192It's a much-stressed point to Marx that "labour" is to be separated from "labour-power" in the account of surplus, and this is the crux of his disagreements with Smith and Ricardo (e.g. Capital Vol. 1, Chapter 19). When one views "labour" as the commodity, equivalence is impossible. Of course, this is true in content, but not in form, which is the medium of capitalist exchange; of an obscuration in production:
<All the slave’s labour appears as unpaid labour. In wage labour, on the contrary, even surplus-labour, or unpaid labour, appears as paid.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch19.htmBut here is a problem. The confusion as to this appearance is only due to the "bourgeois" assumption of "labour" being the commodity, yet it is only in treating of "labour" generally that it can be seen to be unpaid. I personally disagree with Marx, since I think what is actually sold is "labour", which is simply undercut. A proof of this is that if real wages increase, profits decline; if real wages decline, profits increase, etc. But in this case, labour-power would be "over/undervalued". What do you think?
>>2959193>A proof of this is that if real wages increase, profits decline; if real wages decline, profits increase, etc. But in this case, labour-power would be "over/undervalued".I don't really follow here. Practically all commodities are under- or overvalued, I don't see how labour-power would be any different. Furthermore, usually wages increasing is reactive (at least, according to a Michael Roberts blog on inflation I read a while ago, this is probably contentious), i.e. labour power becomes "undervalued", workers organize some kind of political or economic action because of this after which they catch back up if you will. So the share of value going to labour and capital is constantly fluctuating with the rate of exploitation. My apologies if I'm missing your point, I'm not that well read tbh. To me the whole distinction between labour and labour power makes a lot of sense and explains exploitation well.
>>2959194>I don't really follow here.To Marx, the value of labour-power is the minimum wage.
If there is an oversupply of labourers, there is a diminishing demand, undervaluing labour-power below normal subsistence, and vice versa:
<Wages will now rise, now fall, according to the relation of supply and demandhttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/wage-labour/ch04.htmSo, if we presume the value of labour-power a priori, higher wages mean labour-power is overvalued according to market disequilibrium. This then makes wage protections an exploitation of the capitalist, if, say, the capitalist cannot fly to other markets (e.g. of cheaper labour).
>Practically all commodities are under- or overvaluedRight, but Marx's analysis presumes static equilibrium.
>To me the whole distinction between labour and labour power makes a lot of sense and explains exploitation well.I think that asserting "labour is underpaid" is better.
To Marx, there is no under-payment, but only payment/non-payment.
But of course, socialism isn't about "fair wages", but abolishing wages.
>>2959164>Erhm it's actually BE's fault that S4A is acting like a retarded chauvinist If anything this interaction has just revealed his actual beliefs, or lack thereof.
KEELHAUL BAD EMPANADA
>>2959196"labor is underpaid" is a revisionist line
the point of critique of exploitation isn't that it's "unfair" (it's completely fair according to the logic of capital, which is what marx explicitly said), but that it's contradictory: socialized production, but privatized surplus
you're not being "underpaid" for your lump-unit of labor, that's proudhonism. labor is always-already socialized, and you, as an individual or group don't have any more claim to the "real" value of commodity that exists the production process than the capitalist does, merely because you happen to work in the building it was assembled at, because the commodity already embodies the labor of millions in the rest of the economy. this is the logic by which western labor aristocrats justify their demands of higher wages at the expense of the rest of the world: "because the commodity I last touched is valuable, I deserve to capture more of that value, not the capitalist". essentially it's an argument for cooperative capitalist ownership of the factory.
>the value of labour-power is the minimum wage.Also no, wrong. the value of labor power is the cost of reproducing the laborer. not just physically, but as a whole, including the mcmansions, lifted trucks, and the hitler consciousness this produces. the capitalist pays not just for the physical reproduction of the laborer, but also for the hitler consciousness of the laborer.
there's cases where the price of labor power goes below what is required to physically reproduce the actual laborer, in which case the "extra inventory" is destroyed: like working an entire population to death, slavery, etc.
>>2959200>revisionismI already said that I disagree with Marx on this point.
>you're not being "underpaid" for your lump-unit of labor, that's proudhonismYes and I think Proudhon was right, about this and other things.
>demands of higher wages at the expense of the rest of the worldRight, so you would agree with Marx, that wages can be overpriced. The minimum wage is justified as the maximum wage, in effect.
>Also no, wrongWe can read Marx:
<The average price of wage-labour is the minimum wage, i.e., that quantum of the means of subsistence which is absolutely requisite to keep the labourer in bare existence as a labourer. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch02.htmMarx describes the value of labour-power as the minimum wage.
>>2959188>>2959190The thrid-world is just as reactionary as the USA and your promised JDPON invasion will never happen because said countries are still under the control of their own national bourgeoisie.
SaboTabby is right when he says in
>>2958413>This is a global problem that you lot continually refuse to recognize. Most third world countries do not have strong communist movements. The small number that do (India, South Africa) have parties that operate exclusively through electoralism, are functionally social democrats, and display the same labour-aristocratic and opportunist tendencies as Western parties have historically. This isn't the 1960s anymore, the predominant tendencies of first and third world workers have converged to the point where there are only differences of degree. The fact that this has happened while imperialism remains intact indicates that it was never actually the cause to begin with. >>2959204<She was just calling me the 'F Slur'<She would say 'Look at this faggot'Based Channer Tamara.
>>2959203Mao already demonstrated that national bourgeoisie can be subordinated because of their objective contradictory interests wrt the comprador and imperial bourgeoisie
for western chauvinist socialists, the existence of the national bourgeoisie is presented as an insurmountable problem for the third world proletariat, but the economic base of fascism in the west, the labor aristocracy, is spoken of as if teeming with hidden revolutionary potential
instead of analyzing the objective contradictions at hand, they argue backwards from a conclusion: the primary contradiction must be denied. so when the reactionary nature of the mass of western workers is pointed out, instead of doing the work of proving the opposite (which is a difficult proposition indeed), they, instead, move to attacking the third world, to "cut them down to size", and defend the first world at the expends of the third, by presenting them as "equivalently non-revolutionary".
the aim is to present labor aristocrats and the colonized as equally victims of imperialism, or equally complicit in it, doesn't matter, as long as the primary contradiction is denied
>>2958952>>2958983Late but I want to add that, while wage work is exploitation, capitalists aren't consciously exploiting workers. They aren't thinking to themselves how much surplus-value they could squeeze from workers and twirling their moustaches. They're only exploiting workers by acting as capital personified, i.e. by trying to accumulate as much wealth as possible. Maybe this was what you were trying to get at but you bungled it and ended up sounding like Ayn Rand.
>>2959202>Marx describes the value of labour-power as the minimum wage.Your quote literally states what the other anon said. What Marx conceptualizes is an abstraction, not a sum of money.
>>2958901
>Labour time is measured in hours put into production, not the number of commodities produced in that time, nor their sales price. This is basic Marxist economics.
>Yes, that's literally what I'm talking about. If a worker can't buy an hour's worth of their out putNo it is not. Not at all.
An hour worth of output =/= an hour of labour time. One is measured in units of use values the other in hours.
I don't know if I can make this any clearer: If an employee produces 10 screws in 2 hour, the output is 10 screws =/= labour time put into production = 2 hours.
They are not measured in the same units.
>If a capitalist enterprise doesn't exploit its workers then it isn't profitable.False, it can exploit workers in the rest of the economy.
Eg. Consider someone who owns a holding company that owns few houses with & rents them. Assume no mortgage or other costs. They have zero employees and yet make a profit (the whole rent in this case).
The surplus value obviously comes from workers in other sectors of the economy.
Hell go further: Assume the people who a renting these houses are also capitalists.
>Your example is irrelevant because you're talking about co-ops and employee owned businesses.Its the structure of the argument that matters. Assume instead of land, type A workers have scarce knowledge or skills that type B workers do not, which enables rhem to have higher productivity. In market of just both of these types, type A workers will earn a disguised profit, and with the numbers above, it will be 400h a year more than the labour put into production (2400h vs. 2000h)
>>2959202>I already said that I disagree with Marx on this point.No you don't. Disagreement requires a certain bar to clear: to disagree with an argument, you first need to undrestand it.
You are below that bar, therefore what you have is not disagreement, but confusion.
>>2958952All labor used for Capital, so to make a commodity, is exploitation of that labor, which should be used as needed.
>>2959220>not a sum of moneyThe sum of money is an equivalent exchange-value of labour-power…
>>2959224What have I misunderstood?
>>2959221>One is measured in units of use values the other in hours.>They are not measured in the same units.Marx equates both time-wages and piece-wages as identical:
<Wages by the piece are nothing else than a converted form of wages by timehttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch21.htmAs a commodity, a use-value is also an exchange-value, etc.
>>2959213>Mao already demonstrated that national bourgeoisie can be subordinatedexcept le national bourgeoisie ended up subordinating everyone else so all he proved is that class collaboration is a sham and a humbug which he would have known he had read marx
>>2959286its ok I used to cope like that too, it took me like an entire year to kick my dengcope addiction
I would go back in time to tell Lenin to use "ultracapitalist" instead of using a retarded monarchist term that would be raped by modernizers in the future.
>>2959287Responding only with memes and vine booms makes you look bad. It's like when libs try to define fascism and go by a checklist by Umberto Eco.
China is clearly a socialist republic in content.
>>2959294>China is clearly a socialist republic in contentso socialism is when you coexist with capitalists and sell your labor power to them? sounds great, I will now do my leninist duty and tell workers they have to die in revolution so they can coexist with capitalists and sell their labor power to them
>>2959302hmmm… how about we skip the dying phase?
>>2959303you are right, there is no need for it, they just have to go to work, since they already live in socialism
>>2958645i unironically believe in these things and take these dead serious. developmental bioelectricity meditation and its (post-)cosmist implications is like what my entire religion is about tho i came into islamic mysticism through andrew chumbley and david myatt. critical support to the acp for carrying out some of the aeonic goals of hidweh project .. i think i go further in certain themes. for instance hikmah and its relation to artificial intelligence should make way for fractal innervation and flesh technics. he seems to be gesturing to the eternal rechurn which is good but he has not yet contemplated the necessity of fleshcrafting or the relevance of lysenko to the embodied poetics of biokinetic ritual
>>2955343also sorry i was doing stuff so didnt respond
>But doesn't this imply an infinite series of particulars?yes but i would say what is important is immanence. i imagine begriff as a sort of hologram of various determinations. it is sort of like what bergson would call a qualitative multiplicity but i would say this latter concept does not take individuation for granted
>From what I perceive, Hegel presumes God to be caught in time.in terms of actual existence he is caught in time, but near the end of the phenomenology he talks about Eternity which is a recapitulation of the plotinian view of Eternity as this immanent interpenetration of forms. i guess one could think of the plant example again where its begriff that comprehends the entire process is immanent in each stage of the plant's development as it unfolds. but i would say that dialectical materialism takes the step of making the interplay of form and content one where there is more of a separation. for hegel the bourgeois state was basically the pinnacle of spirit, sort of akin to the seed at the end of the development of the plant which now comprehends every other previous development. marx meanwhile suspends this final moment of completion in the state as a false reconciliation. the ethical state might abstractly "complete history" but when we look at reality, it fails to actually measure up to its ostensible goals due to the mode of production it is situated within. it is sort of like chemicals in the water messing up a plant's development
>making all universals actually particularsi dont see a contradiction. they are universal in one sense and particular in another (of course hegel would probably just outright use the language of contradiction)
>Does a house have no bricks? Or is it simply many bricks?it is not any particular brick but rather their systematicity
>Zizek's view of contingency appears to be that telos is effected by accidenti think he really is trying to reconceptualize a sense of necessity that is simultaneously contingent. this is what he calls "retroactive necessity" and his recent book is titled "quantum history". i think here, the comparison to aristotle might lead to confusion. neo-confucianism might have a more apt concept then teloi. their adoption concept of li (理) can be translated to "coherence". it is this idea that things hang together harmoniously or they can not. ive seen some classical theists try and compare li and qi to form and matter (further translating "li" as "pattern"), but a crucial distinction is that there are multiple ways in which things can cohere. li as taken up by the neo-confucians becomes a sort of "generative compossibility". i think this is how to understand zizek's idea of retroactive necessity and quantum history - there are multiple ways in which the events in history can hang together in a coherent fashion. the symbolic is capable of radically restructuring itself
>Would you compare this to prima materia?very much yes. i would follow simondon in viewing materiality as having more structural capacity than we give it credit. also i like the idea of god emerging quite a bit. tbh although i still sorta use trinitarian ideas, my theology is much more like the neo-confucian view of heaven at this point, but maybe mixed somewhat w a sort of anthropotheism
https://hidwehproject.nekoweb.org/pages/phil/anacoord.html<my view: material cause is fundamental. even within a hylomorphist world view, matter already has “preformations”/“proto-intentionality” [note: in the original document there are links to articles]. wood has a grain to it and has a different consistency from metal. my indeterminate blobby gunky ontology motivates me to be even more suspicious of formal causality as a fundamental phenomenon. i do think that something like formal causality is an indispensable explanatory tool for biology, but if this formativity is not plastic, then michael levin’s experimental results remains a total mystery >>2959302>so socialism is when you coexistYes, but only after you've had a revolution and established the dotp
China is a socialist republic. If you're offended then get the fuck out from my country.
>>2959439I'm not even in your country.