[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)


File: 1736536504183.jpg (204.59 KB, 1024x576, FO3_loading_capitalpost3.jpg)

 

https://theconversation.com/how-the-u-s-could-in-fact-make-canada-an-american-territory-246877

<In one treaty, the U.S. annexed the present-day states of California, Nevada, Utah, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas and Wyoming. It subsequently illegally invaded Indigenous territory in the west.


>Canada could be next — perhaps not immediately as the 51st state, but quite possibly as a U.S. territory that would deny Canadians any voting rights for Congress or the presidency, allow only some autonomy and make questions of citizenship ambiguous. The constitutional architecture exists in the U.S. to make it happen.


<That’s the wrong reading. How Trump could make good on the threat can be found in the U.S. Constitution. There is both potential and precedent for the U.S. to acquire territory through cession or subjugation.


what is the chance this happens in practice? How does NATO figure into this?

>>2109380
Well, first, the whole of Canada wouldn't be a 51st state. They would annex each Canadian state.
Second, it isn't going to happen. Canada is gonna get govern by trumpoids after Trudeau. So Canada is likely gonna enter in a special socio-economic structure with the US. With a shared army. Apart from NATO.

>>2109422
>Well, first, the whole of Canada wouldn't be a 51st state. They would annex each Canadian state.
nah

File: 1736539575580.jpg (128.9 KB, 764x1024, 1736481121741122m.jpg)


>>2109422
>Well, first, the whole of Canada wouldn't be a 51st state. They would annex each Canadian state.
Most populous US state, California, has like half a million less population than the entirety of Canada. In terms of size, add together the 20 biggest US states to get the size of Canada.

File: 1736539787315.png (31.28 KB, 683x359, 1736523213955.png)

>>2109434
>Danish

Americans react to Trump's comments about making Canada part of the U.S. | WATCH

>>2109434
>zog
wtf we just allow nazi memes now on leftypol?

>>2109422
The tariff shit threw the election and it's increasingly likely that the conservatives are losing lol

do canadians really care? let's be real, they're just feigning outrage.

>>2109380
>what is the chance this happens in practice?
It seems unlikely since it would be extremely and unnecessarily disruptive. It would alienate America's allies and neutral countries, win Trump no political favours, and create a long term political headache for no real gain. Even if it did go ahead I can't see the next dem president seriously putting in the effort to maintain it. It could happen, but honestly even if he ordered a takeover I'm not confident that the military would even go along with it.
>How does NATO figure into this?
It doesn't. I'm sure the rest of NATO would protest but Europe is basically completely disarmed. They need the Americans to stay because they literally can't defend themselves.
>>2109432
Quebec at least would have to be a separate state if they didn't want to be dealing with constant unrest over language rights. That means that the maritime provinces would probably be their own state as well since they would be split off from the rest of Canada. The western provinces would probably push hard to be their own state too since their heads would explode if all their policies were dictated by Ontario. If the Americans wanted to be able to actually govern the country without issue then they would need at least 4 states.
>>2148709
If they continue this simping behaviour instead of taking a strong stance in favour of Canadian independence then they will probably lose, or at least get stuck with a minority government. Honestly the fact that our right have been such suckups to the Americans even after this could seriously damage their long term prospects. Personally if I were PM I'd invoke section 33 of the constitution and make it illegal to advocate for annexation, then crack down hard on them. Vidrel. I'd also probably start looking into a nuclear deterrent and security cooperation with Russia and China, but ofc no spineless lib politician would ever do that.
>>2148710
They're not feigning it, people would be pissed. Nobody here wants to be part of the US except for a handful of right wing schizos, and even ordinarily right leaning military types have been talking openly of armed resistance. Whether they would meaningfully resist and to what extent though is another question.

Cant wait for this to be yet another Afghanistan style clusterfuck

its just like da movieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
its like the movie

It will. The oligarchs surrounding Trump are pushing for this too. They have commercial interests and Canada and Greenland (KoBold Mining) and are obviously also after oil and gas reserves. (Also land, timber)
It's the new "Russia will NEVER invade Ukraine". They're going to destroy the economy, then make deals with individual provinces. Crush the rest with force/PMCs or "local supporters".
NATO is a collection of vassals who have been melon scooped by both the peace dividend, neoliberal policies pushed by the EU and the war in Ukraine. They have no say in this. They're completely dependent on American LNG exports keeping the European economy afloat. Whilst the Russian pipelines have either been shut down or damaged.

>>2148717
Tbh they could probably do it fairly easily if they took the time to actually study the country and govern it in ways that are as non-disruptive as possible. They would need to be sensitive to the tensions between Quebec and Anglos, plus the West and the East. They would need to fast-track statehood so we can get single payer healthcare, control of criminal law, a state constitution, and a degree of autonomy back. There would inevitably be unrest so they would need to handle that gently and not crack down on it too hard, and eventually it would die down. It would probably be smart to keep treaties with Indigenous people on the books to avoid obstructions to resource development. Basically if they make sure that things change as little as possible and go about it carefully it could be done without much issue. However I have absolutely no confidence in Trump's ability to do any of that shit, so he would almost certainly botch it and make a huge mess.

>>2148716
>It seems unlikely since it would be extremely and unnecessarily disruptive.
<Skullfucking and looting the western hemisphere (and perhaps other places as well) ensuring the US becomes the largest country on the planet, with the largest oil, gas and mineral reserves, a working age population rivaling China, and 95% surrounded by ocean
vs
<Letting American power decline in order to prop up recalcitrant shitlib never-Trump eurocrats and Canadians who try keep out American businesses with regulations and tariffs, whilst letting the Chinese squeeze out what's left of American market share and soft power
That's the play here. It's obviously very disruptive, but what are the Europeans going to do, send strongly worded letters and condemn the US at the UN?

File: 1739213907611.png (782.96 KB, 1130x617, civil_war_end_pic.PNG)

>>2148720
>pic: Trump's death in 2033 when the liberal separatists kill the boss of liberal and liberalism has to go back to its normal process before breeding and electing another liberal fascist (synonymous)

>>2148729
I meant that it's disruptive to America's own interest. They would be trading in a loyal and subservient ally for a restive region that could be a thorn in their side for decades. Canada is not and has never been an obstacle for American companies or resource development.

>>2148734
They only really need the resources. That's what, Alberta? The Ring of Fire? Add in Greenland, and there's still barely anyone living in those territories compared to the rest of the US.
I don't think they care about allies anymore. What's happening in America is the formation of a "open terrorist dictatorship of the most reactionary, most chauvinistic and most imperialist elements of finance capital" as described by Dimitrov. With the caveat that tech/industry are also onboard with this.
America's interests are the interests of it's ruling class. Who explicitly want this. Like who among them is seriously opposing this? Mark Cuban?

>>2148741
Yeah pretty much all opposition from the ruling class has been at best do nothing lawsuits that will be ignored and at worst
>umm Mr.Trump, I'll have you mo liquidating the congress and invading Canada is not as your supporters describe "based". It very much is rather unbecoming.

File: 1739214756081.png (441.17 KB, 800x800, border contradictions.png)

This is all desperate yakkkubian idpol to reverse "muh white genocide."

>run on """anti-immigration""" (they took r jubs)

>really only anti immigration for brown people
>meanwhile import ukkkrainian refugees
>meanwhile annex Klanada
>meanwhile continue to allow zionazi SSettlers to hold dual shitizenshit
>meanwhile turn EU into one giant vassal

all the MAGAcoms who spent months shilling anti immigration on here as being about "muh foreign reserve army of labor pushing down muh wages" are going to be deafmutes suddenly when millions of Ukkkrainians and Canadians pour in overnight.

>>2148733
all history since 1789 has been libtard infighting change my mind

>>2109438
But the GOP would be interested in having more rural provinces be independent and not have a single Canadian state. It also gives them more senators

>>2148766
Every province except maybe Saskatchewan and Alberta would be solidly Dem.

>>2148700
half this site is Strasserist /pol/ refugees, are you really surprised

>>2148790
>>2148766
Canada wouldn't be annexed as states, they would be unorganized territories like american samoa. Former canadian citizens would be therefore US nationals not US citizens and would not have the right to participate in federal elections or govern themselves instead a territorial governor would be appointed to rule them.

I.e. canada would become a colony of the US not part of it.


you're high if you think they will give Canadians the right to vote

>>2148804
If they didn't grant statehood asap then they might actually have to deal with armed resistance.

>>2148804
>you're high if you think they will give Canadians the right to vote
I dont know, this is a fellow white anglo country. So they will consider Canadians like themselves so they will not make Canada a colony unlike Puerto Rico, Greenland, Samao, Virgin Islands,etc

>>2109438
The population of New England is 15 million yet they get 6 states
Canada is basically an extension of the Northeast

>>2148700
since israel kicked the palestinian genocide into overdrive a lot of people stopped caring

>>2148807
MAPLE SYRUP SHALL DROWN THE EAGLE

>>2148807
I can’t wait to get killed by a second incarnation of the FLQ

>>2149059
We're coming for you beaver boy.

🦫🔫🦅

>>2148831
The best a Canadian can hope for under the burger Reich is honorary Minnesotian status. But fire real though, idk how this Canada shit will play out. I think the ruling class wants trump and his ghouls to prosecute the war and get the plunder. Than Ditch and denounce him and return the liberal order. None of the plunder will be returned but there will be 2 land acknowledgements at university to address the stolen land issue. That's if they're smart and there's an actual plan which I'm feeling doubtful still.

>>2149068
>The best a Canadian can hope for under the burger Reich is honorary Minnesotian status
Well, states do have considerable autonomy in the US, enough that if Canada became several states we could probably just recreate most of the things we'd miss like socialized medicine and French language rights. Plus they're allowed to have their own constitutions so they should be able to recreate a lot of our current constitution. Like I said if they put in the effort to actually understand the internal politics of this country and were careful in how they handled dissent then they could probably pull it off. However they're most likely too stupid to do it right and would either piss off large sections of the country by lumping them together with people they hate in a single state, or else crack down hard on pro-independence movements and generate escalating resentment.

>>2148831
>I dont know, this is a fellow white anglo country.
doesn't matter, they're too """left"""-wing.

I want China to colonize Canada and for Canada to be a Chinese protectorate. Please, daddy Xi save us.

>>2148766
>>2148863
>b-but C-Cope
nobody cares, literally.

The collapse of the US Empire will inevitably involve a series of COPES & ACCEPTANCES.

The Canada vs. USA war WILL become real!

>>2109572
>if we get free health care I'm interested
social democracy is the moderate wing of fascism yada yada

Isn't Musk trying to defund the entire US government rn
Would be kinda funny if the US tries to invade and it just fell flat on their face because none of the troops are being paid

>>2149845
That would be funny if the U.S just fell apart like a startup that ran out of money. Nobody is showing up for work, or if they are they're just looting office supplies.

>>2149845
>>2149865
I think the jury is still out on whether he will prove to be America's Yeltsin.

>>2109422
>>2109432
>implying we wouldn't just be made a territory

they haven't even allowed puerto rico to voot because it'd offset their stupid electoral system what do you think a country with a larger population where the vast majority of vooters would go democrat regardless of being conservative or liberal would end up doing to it ?

>>2148807
we would have:
>neo-FLQ nationalist terrorists
>anglo chetniks (royalists)
>weird scottish rednecks in nova scotia
>a lot of incredibly angry natives who all pack heat
>northern people who all pack heat

>>2149755
essentially, it'd be like how Charles I and his Bishops' War with Scotland was such a disaster it led to the English Civil War and eventually the English Revolution.

>>2150099
>anglo chetniks (royalists)
Well if there was significant resistance it would almost certainly come more from the left since our right is completely cucked to America. If Trump tried to annex us while Poilievre is PM he'd probably give him a blowjob on live tv before signing our capitulation. Maybe if we're lucky it will end up like Yugoslavia where the left ends up on top because they're the only ones willing to actually lead a national liberation struggle.

>>2150235
Charles I was on infinitely shakier ground before the bishops war anon, he was also a retard who didn't have the political instincts of his father.

>>2149865
that's exactly what will happen when bird flu gets going

Hmm is Canada class conscious?

“We’re insulted"| Canadian Foreign Minister on US tariffs and talk of the "51st State"

>>2150409
The four main parties are just different flavours of lib.

File: 1741237920875.jpg (190.9 KB, 1033x985, GlU1OF2WQAAXjHM.jpg)

>>2150245
I'm not a Canadian but I feel the patriotic option would be to join the armed forces of Canada.

>>2178246
Sex with Melanie Joly

>>2178282
if Trump takes canada it will be over too fast to do anything about it

>>2178691
This isn’t 1940, Blitzkrieg doesn’t happen anymore

>>2150397
people were basically obeying charles though till he shat the bed and tried to fight against the covenanters until he ran out of money and was forced to call parliament again. If he was smarter he wouldn't have done stupid things like impose the book of common prayer in scotland and other dumb shit and gradually change shit over time. It was absolutely possible to do that stuff gradually. Other monarchs did absolutism (but yeah this all comes down to Charles being an idiot. My point is that Trump is politically retarded in similar ways to Charles)

>>2178282
I already did and left lol. There wouldn't be much point apart from getting the training since our military could never put up meaningful resistance in a conventional sense. We simply lack the materials and manpower. The only possible resistance would be an insurgency.

>>2109434
Greenland is one of the last colonial possessions in the world. USA has most of those left (Puerto Rico, islands as territories in Pacific and Carribean), but Greenland is for sure the largest such landmass

>>2178733
What if China intervened

>>2178747
Greenland is autonomous since 2009. They decide all their domestic policy. It's just foreign policy and military they don't control. So it has more freedom than Puerto Rico and I assume those others but I dont feel like looking all of them up.

>>2178887
They wouldn’t.

>>2179072
Why wouldn’t Turkey be willing to send them drones? It worked for Azerbaijan

I'm a Canadian and I don't hate Americans. I respect America's founding values even if I don't agree with them. What I hate is Trump and the people who voted for him in 2024. I won't blame the entire country for this, same as in Russia, same as in China. Doing that would feel xenophobic to me.

>>2179363
You won’t say that when your door is kicked in by green berets, a lot of Iraqis were fine with Saddam being gone until the troops decided to stay in Baghdad and Fallujah, the same would be true of Toronto and Montreal.

>>2179484
An invasion of Canada would just crumble the U.S. It would at best look like the Ukraine war, doubly so because there's already a bunch of battle harden Banderas up there. That's best case because a Canadian invasion would also likely trigger a civil war. Then that opens the door for every international corporation, foreign intelligence agency, forgien volunteers, NGOs type operations, and redditor looking for karma creating a giant cluster fuck that would be the crisis of the 21st century.

>>2179363
>I respect America's founding values
how would you define this

>>2179653
genocide and big mac

>>2179656
Big Mac wasn’t here until german immigration was though, if anything it’s genocide and whiskey

>>2179363
>I respect America's founding values even if I don't agree with them
lol the founding value is kicking people off their land and taking it

so is this gonna happen or not?

You guys know America's MO right? First thing they'd do is bomb all your power stations, oil refineries, etc. No more electricity, no more gas. They'd probably do it right before winter too.

>>2185664
That would cause blackouts in the US because we supply them with electricity.

File: 1741799312558.png (223.09 KB, 1983x976, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2185666
Well Trump said he's going to use emergency powers to replace the supply. Obviously this war needs a little preparation.

>>2185669
I was listening to an interview with a US economist the other day saying that in order to reshore even basic industry like textiles it would take 4-5 years. They wouldn't be physically capable of disentangling our economies before the end of his term. Besides, if they want to annex the country then there would be no point in destroying the infrastructure.

>>2178890
no country is truly autonomous unless they control their own money supply imo

>>2185678
Yeah obviously the US isn't going to invade Canada. Come on. I'm sure the military command wouldn't do it.

>>2185689
He doesn't have the authority or the logistics


Unique IPs: 56

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]