Some Opinions as Chinese

Posting mode: Reply [Return]
Name
Options
Subject	Spoiler Image
Comment
Verification
Flag
File
Embed
Password	(For file deletion.)

File: 1754639802826.jpg (50.52 KB, 329x196, 059.jpg)

Some Opinions as Chinese A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 07:56:43 No.2423093

As a Chinese citizen, I have noticed that there is surprisingly little discussion about China on leftypol. I would like to remove some of your filters on China and express some of my own opinions:

Yes, China's society is undoubtedly superior to the United States and is about to become the world's number one in a decade.

Yes, the average living standard of the Chinese people is higher than that of the US, but not much higher.

No, China and the US are similar in many places, with bureaucratic, rigid, corrupt, and stratification that are exclusive to major powers. In the corners where no one sees it, there also exists' The other China ', according to Michael Harrington, filled with remnants of feudal and pre-modern times.

Yes, the political environment between us is quite stable. Even if faced with an idiot like Trump, these two countries will not easily collapse.

No, most Chinese people are extremely eager for a war against Japan. Fortunately, our ruling party prefers peace, for unknown reasons.

No, Chinese society is not that stable either. Here are the major social events that have caused public critism in the past month:

1. Wuhan University Accusation Gate
Yang is suspected of academic misconduct, false accusations, and has been publicly protected by the government, which is considered gender discrimination against the male.

2. Jiutai Pilot Recruitment Gate
Jilin Province has recruited the only pilot who has strabismus, which is considered an improper use of relationships.

3. Jiangyou Bullying Gate
14-year-old female student in Jiangyou was bullied. The police not only failed to protect, but also began to bully the relevant masses, which was compared to the "Gwangju Incident" on the internet and triggered a large-scale mass demonstration.

Of course, we will find that the above three things are negligible in the United States, but they have all sparked significant public opinion in China.

Yes, 'Mai 68' may be the only viable option for both countries. Although the "October Revolution" and the "Meiji Restoration" were impossible, society was not so indestructible.

What we need is to gather the majority of people and 'make more friends and fewer enemies', according to Mao.

PS: Surprisingly, why don't you have a DESCENT ORGANASATION in the USA?!! It's illegal and dangerous in China. But it's safe in the USA! Leftists do worse than SCP Foundation!

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 08:08:45 No.2423104

Image Origin: https://scp-wiki-cn.wikidot.com/scp-cn-059
Image and post are irrelevant.
The mention of "Mai 68", aims to stress the importance of "courage". The system is stable, but not indestructible.
By the way, I can hardly see your(leftists', except the dems') actions on the Internet, except continuous argument and RPG(the same to us Chinese leftists). May I get some examples from you?

Anonymous 08-08-25 08:30:24 No.2423120

You can thank the FBI and CIA for the lack of decent organizations in America.
I wish I could tell you of some recent left-wing victories but I live in an incredibly reactionary area.

Anonymous 08-08-25 09:01:54 No.2423141

Thank you for your post passing Chinese man. I am Greek. The situation there is beyond salvation.

Anonymous 08-08-25 10:03:11 No.2423405

>>2423093
First I want to say that I am from Europe, not the US or from China, so I might be wrong. But I honestly believe your view of the US is too positive.

But hey let's judge for yourself.
Some news from august
>Trump fires the chief of the bureau of labor statistics, because he's unhappy with the bad job growth they're reporting.
>A lot of the connections between Trump and Jefferey Epstein resurfaced
>The Republicans in the state of Texas issued arrest warrants for the Texas Democrats, because the Texas Dems didn't want to vote for a bill that would redraw the voting districts.
>The Us government introduced a policy that would bar disaster-preparedness funds from states / cities if they were to boycott Israel. This policy was undone a few days later, though.
>CNN (one of the mayor American news channels) had some controversy because they interviewed an AI of a dead school shooting victim
>there was a flood in Taxes that killed 135 people. The US government got a lot of criticism because they happened to cut the funding for weather services relatively recently.
>Colombia university expelled some of the pro-Palestine protestors.
These are just some news stories from the last month.

>By the way, I can hardly see your(leftists', except the dems') actions on the Internet, except continuous argument and RPG(the same to us Chinese leftists). May I get some examples from you?
In terms of active protests, I think there are still pro-Palestine protests. There are also still anti-Ice protests.
I don't know if this is well-known in china, but 2 months ago trump used the National Guard against the anti-ICE protesters
https://www.aljazeera.com/video/newsfeed/2025/6/8/trump-deploys-national-guard-against-anti-ice-protests-in-la

There was also a CEO that got shot a few weeks ago
https://subscriber.politicopro.com/article/2025/07/blackstone-exec-killed-nyc-shooting-00481573

Anonymous 08-08-25 10:06:50 No.2423407

>>2423405 (me)
>Colombia university
*Columbia University

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 12:13:01 No.2423482

>>2423405
Thank you for your reply. Affirmatively, as Chinese, I am too ignorant about the situation in the US. Actually, the examples you list, do NOT belong to leftism in China. I used to regard them as anti-establishment.
Pro-Palestine is usual and normal among Chinese, as the protection of basic humanity, instead of leftism values(like equality). (Interestingly, the invasion to Ukrain is considered as “recapture”. However, public tends to Ukrain as well, as time goes by.)
Anti-ICE is considered as the conflict between the state and the federation. As we know, dem stand for the state for so long, but after Trump got its power, their position get a reverse.(lol), which didn't get wide report by the official, due to the potential risk of provocation(the fear of another in China). And no one mention ICE.
I am sorry for the cultural difference.

Well, the news you list prove and falsify my view at the same time.
> The system is stable, but not indestructible.
But I hold a firm belief that there are worse situation than the present in history. But the system didn't change for a inch.
Alright, to speak of Maoism again, though I'm not a Maoist. Mao used to critisize both of "defeatism" and "adventurism"(速胜论与亡国论), and present "protractism"(持久战), to stress the time will stand on our side, during the 2nd sino-jap war.
That's what I mean by "The system is stable, but not indestructible."

Anonymous 08-08-25 12:16:16 No.2423488

>Surprisingly, why don't you have a DESCENT ORGANASATION in the USA?!! It's illegal and dangerous in China. But it's safe in the USA!
It's technically legal but in practice the government conjures up all sorts of excuses to suppress and distrupt these organizations, and when they can't come up with any excuses they just do so illegally, up to the point of assassinating people.

SAGE 08-08-25 12:16:21 No.2423490

>As a Chinese citizen
shut the fuck up cracker no you aren't.

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 12:24:36 No.2423502

>>2423405
Luigi Nicholas Mangione and Aaron Bushnell are heroes in our hearts.
As some netizen say:
"Guns are ubiquitous in the US, but only Luigi get the usage."
We, Chinese(not including me. I knew americans are reactionary) are quite surprised by the conflict in Califonia - that doesn't arise a revolution? All people have guns but no one use them? What do you mean that mexicans are waving their national flag in LA and hit the police car by wooden stick? Where are their godamn guns?

Our official textbook even encourage the actions of revolution. So no way we can't understand that.

Anonymous 08-08-25 12:28:23 No.2423507

>>2423093
>It's illegal and dangerous in China. But it's safe in the USA!
I would say it's dangerous in both countries, but for different reasons.

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 12:30:04 No.2423511

>>2423490
？
对了，现在我这里的北京时间是八点半，傍晚。你们那儿现在应该是早上，甚至刚刚日出。
说实话，Cracker这个词我用Bing搜索了半天才明白是什么意思。
不过，谢谢你的夸奖，这应该是对我英语水平的认可（只要不是说我文化水平和美国人一样就行，他们确实煞笔）。

By the way, the current Beijing time here is 20:30, in the evening. It should be morning there now, even just after sunrise.
To be honest, I Bing it for half a day before understanding what the word 'Cracker' means.
However, thank you for your appreciation. This should be a recognition of my English level (as long as it is not that my autism score is the same as that of Americans, they are really retard).

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 12:34:50 No.2423514

>>2423511
wait, I mean "knowledge" rather than "autism score"

Anonymous 08-08-25 13:19:12 No.2423554

>>2423093
>As a Chinese citizen
Oh joy. Never say this exact line again.

>Yes, China's society is undoubtedly superior to the United States and is about to become the world's number one in a decade.
>Yes, the average living standard of the Chinese people is higher than that of the US, but not much higher.

Some more elaboration and specifics would be lovely here.

>No, China and the US are similar in many places, with bureaucratic, rigid, corrupt, and stratification that are exclusive to major powers. In the corners where no one sees it, there also exists' The other China ', according to Michael Harrington, filled with remnants of feudal and pre-modern times

More specific details please

>Surprisingly, why don't you have a DESCENT ORGANASATION in the USA?!!
Because of FBi infiltration and events such as the red scare.
>It's illegal and dangerous in China. But it's safe in the USA! Leftists do worse than SCP Foundation!

>But it's safe in the USA!
Nonononononono. The law is not to be taken too literally here. It is very dangerous to form an organization in the USA. The red scare made certain of that, and they’ve made extensive use of the patriot act as well. Still have laws directly against it’s formation being made to this day as well, such as the Crucial Communism Teaching Act. Infiltration, political sabotage, and even assassination of individuals and organizations are still existent threats. They never stopped with Fred Hampton. And they’ve done so much to prevent the formation of them as well. Malicious designs and manipulation on a grand scale. The very roads are hostile to the worker, and they made the police force ever more into a full fledged militaristic occupier. Everything has gotten evermore expensive, and public third spaces have dwindled intensely, so it’s much harder for meet ups. They fucked up bad on the internet though, despite their history of intensive spying and subterfuge. Now they’re trying to lock that down too.
>Leftists do worse than SCP Foundation!
SCP Foundation has extradimensional objects and anomalies to work with, along with the luck of having been able to keep inertia after several decades.

A Passing Chinese 08-08-25 14:37:58 No.2423618

>>2423554
>Yes, China's society is undoubtedly superior to the United States and is about to become the world's number one in a decade.
>Yes, the average living standard of the Chinese people is higher than that of the US, but not much higher.
>No, China and the US are similar in many places, with bureaucratic, rigid, corrupt, and stratification that are exclusive to major powers. In the corners where no one sees it, there also exists' The other China ', according to Michael Harrington, filled with remnants of feudal and pre-modern times

I thought these were self-evident consensus.

There is no deep government or complex community of interests in China (such as military industrial complexes, medical groups, etc.). Private monopolies are strictly restricted (although the left is still dissatisfied, a slight comparison reveals that China's situation is far better than that of the West).

The Chinese government is committed to solving poverty, and currently there are no absolute poor people in China (according to official statistics). The Chinese government is carrying out large-scale infrastructure construction in every village and town to ensure the complete popularization of high-quality water and electricity.

Environmental protection is no longer a problem, and the Chinese government has handled it surprisingly well. Nowadays, the leaders of Shanghai, the largest city in China, have gained such tremendous power through environmental protection.

The main social contradictions in China are concentrated in:
1. Gender inequality. LGBT individuals are discriminated against. Men are ignored. Women are underestimated. No one is satisfied, to the point where netizens once joked, 'The essence of all problems is gender conflict,' as a mockery of 'class conflict'.
2. Imperfect legal system. Conviction does not require evidence.
3. Lack of political rights such as news, speech, protests, and marches.
4. Uneven development between urban and rural areas. Yes, this is not allowed in China because our official ideology is communism.

It is almost impossible for the US not to decline after four years of Trump's presidency. Chinese politician(沈逸, his name) once joked:
“This America is not worth my hard work for years for a PhD”
“Fuck! How can the USA be this way? ”

Though I hate the current system, but I cannot smudge it too. CPC did well, not perfectly though.

Anonymous 08-08-25 15:57:42 No.2423703

>>2423514
>wait, I mean "knowledge" rather than "autism score"
It's a site word filter that filters 'I,Q' to 'Autism score' because I,Q doesn't really mean anything and just a prop for race science most of the time.

Unique IPs: 9