>>28960Good post.
>/leftypol/'s cultural moment has sort of passed. The raison d'etre of /leftypol/ was to be anti liberal identity politics but still radical left.This. I'm not sure if the current userbase realizes it, but /leftypol/ was a breath of fresh air back in 2015.
/pol/ had completely taken over 4chan at this point, meaning you couldn't discuss video games on /v/ or music on /mu/ without people sperging about cultural Marxism and n*gg*rs.
On the other hand, you had many people supposedly from the left who routinely came up with arguments like "voting for Hilary Clinton is more radical than for Bernie Sanders because she is a woman".
It was a hard time to remain sane as a socialist, online discourse became increasingly more political yet people seemed to have lost the plot completely.
/leftypol/ was great because you had plenty of imageboard posters who were also tired of this shit.
People would post original memes, weren't afraid to use crude language, etc. It wasn't contrite like many other leftist spaces tended to be — both online and IRL — where people would take themselves very seriously as the harbingers of the revolution.
Moreover, quite a few posters came from /lit/ and had read at least basic theory. The userbase was diverse, there were MLs of course, but they weren't the majority, there were also a lot of anarchists, "leftcoms" (non-Leninist Marxists) and even a few socdems, and there was an invective to effortpost in order to prove they were right on such and such issue.
I learned many things about socialism during the first few years I started browsing /leftypol/ and I'm really grateful for this.
>The fact is the post-occupy wall street/sanders zeitgeist of the 2010s has passed and sanders losing+the failure of the 2020 BLM protests essentially blackpilled a bunch of lefties who either morphed into hipster reactionaries or just turned schizo or gave up on politics altogether.I don't think that's the case. In fact, I would say socialism is much more mainstream these days.
As far as I remember, talking about Marx wasn't seen in a positive light in the 2000s and early 2010s. Marx was equated with the bad aspects of AES, and movements like Occupy Wall Street were more inspired by democratic socialism and anarchism, but then most people thought of these movements as idealistic and utopian, even when they were asking for rather tame reforms.
This has changed since the late 2010s, and especially after COVID. A subreddit like /r/antiwork being talked about on TV was unthinkable, but here we are. Zoomers aren't afraid of Marx anymore because they don't envision better alternatives that would exclude Marxian theory.
In general, people are more polarized in their political beliefs nowadays, and therefore /leftypol/ kinda lost the edge regarding socialist theory it once had.
>Anyone smart from this site (who isn't addicted at least) who's read any theory at all realized this site is retarded and moved on to greener pastures, likely relatively obscure left wing reddits, dis.cords, or real life organizing.I realize posting on /leftypol/ has diminishing returns year after year, and I realize I should rather explore my other hobbies, which are more rewarding, and read books or good blogs rather than scrolling here, but like any addiction, there is always that little voice in your head that says "what if you took a little peak, just one last time" and next thing you know, you are posting in half-a-dozen of threads
>That leaves the remaining base as a bunch of theorylet ziggers/dengists who just cheerlead anti americanism, eceleb bullshit, and occasional hap00nings.The zigger/dengist thing is the logical conclusion of old BO's meltdown, /leftypol/ never really recovered from it IMO.
If you remember back then, it wasn't only about Rojava, but also about the Iranian protests of 2017-2019. Expressing online support for Iranian workers who were protesting against corruption and the shitty state of their economy on an obscure imageboard was deemed to be supporting American imperialism.
This mindset is due to the former realpolitik of the USSR, which has been throughoutly internalized by some Marxist sects, and made a comeback on /leftypol/ but also other places like
Twitter X.
Wasn't Old BO a Marcyite? I guess this is a reminder that getting involved in IRL orgs can be counter-productive sometimes. I also blame Paradox grand strategy games for this mindset, who tend to potray politics as something that happens from the top-down instead of the bottom-up.
>Plus like most imageboards the userbase is aging and getting too old to meme or even be bother to try and meme anywayThere are quite a few zoomers on the Matrix chat, but it's true that people who started posting on 4chan in the late-2000s/early-2010s are now in their 30s if not 40s, and you need to get a life outside of the internet at this point, even as a matter of economic well-being.