If you ask me the answer is yes and no. Yes because you should never rip the flesh of a babies dick off without going to jail for child abuse but no because once that babies is 21 he can do what he wants.
The thing is though that it is really hard to oppose infant-circumcision without coming across as antisemitic because there are genuinely a ton of rightoids who oppose circumcision for the wrong reasons, and I never opposed it publicly before because I was never circumcised (Shout outs to my Mom for standing up to my Catholic great-Aunts and Uncles) so I don't even have an excuse. I still oppose it though because I know first hand the benefits of having foreskin, like I get why it is in the Bible because if you are an ancient Israelite in the desert and there is a sand-storm you don't wanna pull it back every time a grain of sand flies up your robes but we live in the age of showers now and all of that stuff and the bacteria that everyone uses as an excuse now just washes off. Also you can goon without lube because the head is always moist! However that is a downside though because since it has always been so protected it is really fragile, but that is the only real downside. It also annoys me that the same people who defend Circumcision are the same guys who oppose abortion because Circumcision happens after the baby is born and not when it is a clump of cells!
>>762297>once that babies is 21 its 11:40 give me a break on the typos
I think it should be illegal, FGM is illegal and its religious (kinda)but we still tell the ethnic and religious people who want to do this, that they cant
Jewish organizations know how to lobby
Look up how they acted when iceland passed a law
>>762297Logically it should be illegal cause consent and all that. Practically stamping out such practices are very tricky unfortunately, because people are absolute freaks about religious shit and will start doing it underground, improperly, with limited training in a back alley as soon as you ban it. Which of course results in all kinds of nasty issues. It's probably better to promote education and secularism to actually reduce the practice.
>>762297>>Should Circumcision be illegal? yes, and by extension any religion that commands it
Circumcising should be illegal
These same people who promote circumcision are against cognizant prime age humans deciding to switch their gender
>>762298I thought 18 is the age of legal autonomy?
Yes. One of the main reasons for inceldom behavior in the USA and sexual neurotic dysfunction too as well as in the ME and Africa.
it should probably be illegal but i really dont understand why americans make such a big fucking deal out of it
>>762314Well it is but at 18 people are still young and reckless I wouldn’t want them to do something they might regret
It should be one of the things that unlock when you get an ID at 18, alongside drinking, voting, driving without a passenger, porn, etc…
>>762413>but i really dont understand why americans make such a big fucking deal out of it Because Americans are porn-brained
>>762421no one ever becomes immune to making bad life-changing decisions, there needs to be a balance between accounting for the perils of inexperience and the need to give people control over their own life. people at 18 are finishing school and are already expected to make one of the biggest decisions they'll ever make.
>>762413Maybe because Doctor Kellogg created a neurotic society to stop masturbation.
>>762297>Should Circumcision be illegal?Why is this even a question? Should it be legal to mutilate baby faces for religious reasons?
https://neurolaunch.com/does-circumcision-cause-brain-damage/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7702013/OP, is like clipping the wings of a bird so it doesn't fly away. Circumcision will lead to a life of sexual dysfunction, you'll be easier to brainwash and become more militant, a lot of the issues with pedophilia are due to circumcision. A mutilated man gets hyperfixated with a child's purity and all of that because he can't have a healthy and functional sex life, add that religion into the mix.
Mutilating a baby's penis is a horrific crime. And the fact that it's done to millions of babies and billions across history is one of the biggest atrocities in human history.
The only reason people think otherwise is because white Western culture (and Abrahamic retardation in general) is accepting of it.
No, I hate uncut cocks
>>762297>picCircumcision started with Abraham not Jesus. Jesus in fact said that it's not necessary any more.
>Yes because you should never rip the flesh of a babies dick off without going to jail for child abuse but no because once that babies is 21 he can do what he wantsYeah body autonomy shouldn't be that hard of a concept AND YET
>The thing is though that it is really hard to oppose infant-circumcision without coming across as antisemiticNot even all Jews circumcise. There's reformist Jews that don't. Also ofc most people who do circumcise aren't Jews.
Obviously cutting off pieces of anybody is unjustifiable unless it has cancer or something, and even then you need consent.
>>762301Laws against FGM have been overturned on the basis of being discriminatory because they don't include banning male genital mutilation btw. Failing to combat MGM opens the door to FGM becoming more normalized. Imagine that, gender politics affecting everyone and all of us actually being on the same side of wanting to protect people's rights!
>>762302You stamp out mutilating children by abolishing the family or traditional community structures in favor of making child rearing a public matter. People oppose this because they want to have absolute power over children, and there is never a good reason for that.
>>762412We know for a fact genital mutilation is traumatic (duh) but any research on it gets suppressed. There was an fMRI study done that showed extreme trauma to infants but it was forced to be buried because the evidence of trauma meant that the study itself was considered to be traumatizing babies and therefore was ruled unethical. Wrap your head around that one. Who knows what the social consequences are when some of your formative experience in the world is extreme pain. Not to mention some of the nurses who've blown the whistle on it have said that it's common for doctors to jerk the baby off a bit first to get the penis hard so it's easier to work with. Imagine what THAT does to someone.
>>762413>why do people make a big deal about torturing and mutilating babiesbait or mental retardation
>>762605I mean it's kinda relevant since there's more post-Jesus Abrahmaic people circumcising their kids than there are Jews
>>762602>>why do people make a big deal about torturing and mutilating babies>bait or mental retardationNo, you're just whiny and dramatic. Nobody's life gets ruined because they were circumcised and major complications are extremely rare. FGM is only a big deal because the complications are worse, it wouldn't be a major thing otherwise either which is why a huge amount of women who go through it still support it. Basically, grow the fuck up. Your lack of foreskin is not the reason your life is dogshit. It's more likely because you're a retarded faggot. I actually hope more babies get circumcised just because of what a whiny little bitch you are, and I wish you had suffered more from yours.
yes it should be illegal.
t. circumcised at FIVE YEARS OLD, i.e. I REMEMBER IT
PS: (not jewish)
PS: my grandma got convinced it was "medically necessary for phimosis"
>>762641You need to look into foreskin restoration
>>762421People are still young and reckless at 35
>>762429That’s due to modern society infantilizing youth with excessive schooling and lack of industrial exposure
>>76242118 vs 21 is literally nonsense
There’s no significant difference at those age numbers. You’re just projecting your immaturity
>>762660I'm over it. I have had a good sex life despite the circumcision. I don't really want my foreskin restored right now. I have a family of my own and more important matters to attend to. Maybe later. The immediate aftermath of it was far more traumatizing than nearly 30 years since then.
>>762421Tom most people at 18 already get a high school diploma. That's the reason why we pick it as the age of consent. We're not picking it arbitrarily based on vibes, we tie it to the K-12 educational program
>>762735He’s one of those people who believe that young adults need to be infantilized for safety despite the fact that it’s exactly what caused immaturity in the first place
>>762297Criminalizing circumcision will have the same effect as criminalizing abortion: back-ally medical procedures. Often in places that are unsterile or ill-equipped.
First we need to stamp out religion and barbaric traditions generally so no one feels the need to mutilate their infant children.
>>762297btw its bot only jews some muslims do it to
>>762297Should mutilating baby genitelia be illegal? Gee I dunno.
>>767397>some muslims do it toNot all of them?
>>767514This is such an american dilemma, jesus
>>767514They will call you hysterical for framing it that way
Unique IPs: 25