Footnote 30: This ideology is based on a critique of liberalism in the name of freedom from imperialism, as evidenced by the National Conservatism movement and its founder, Yoram Hazony. In an insightful essay published in Jewish Currents, Suzanne Schneider states: “The clearest instantiation today of Hazony’s ideal is neither Donald Trump’s America nor Boris Johnson’s Britain, but the hilltop settlements located deep in the heart of the West Bank: tight-knit communities made up of large, traditional families, united in the face of the enemy, producing legions of young soldiers who have been schooled in the fusion of state violence and spirituality. This is the template that Hazony now offers to the world via the neutralized language of National Conservatism. Like his Zionist predecessors, he too imagines Israel as a light unto the nations—an illiberal model for the international nationalist brigade.” Suzanne Schneider, Light Among the Nations, 28 September 2023,
https://jewishcurrents.org/light-among-the-nations. Contrary to the unfounded claims of some contemporary journalists and politicians, the resurgence of nationalism that we are witnessing today cannot be equated with the historical European movement of the same name. The latter was characterised by a secular and anti-clerical stance, inspired by the universalist values of the Enlightenment and spread by a network of revolutionary secret societies, including the Carbonari in Italy and the Filiki Eteria in Greece. Yoram Hazony’s National Conservatism movement appears to be an attempt to export the ideology and practices of the Zionist movement from the Middle East to Western countries in their most illiberal form. After all, the founder’s biography has always been consistent with his ideals, beginning with his encounter with the extremist Meir Kahane at Princeton in 1984.
Footnote 31: Carl Schmitt, The Concept of the Political, University of Chicago Press, 2007.
Footnote 32: René Girard, The Scapegoat, Johns Hopkins Univ Press, 1989
Footnote 33: In 2015, former Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett stated: “Israel is in the forefront of the global war on terror. This is the frontline between the free and civilized world and radical Islam. We’re stopping the wave of radical Islam from flowing from Iran and Iraq all the way to Europe. When we fight terror here, we’re protecting London, Paris, and Madrid.”. Antony Loewenstein, The Palestine Laboratory – How Israel Exports the Technology of Occupation around the World, London – New York, 2023, p. 18 (e-book).
Footnote 34: In an article about the misuse of René Girard’s ideas by Peter Thiel and the oligarchs of the US techno-right, Paul Leslie writes: In today’s world, political leaders and influencers often invoke victimhood to justify aggressive policies or silence opposition. Claims of oppression become a rhetorical strategy, turning the concern for victims into a justification for making additional victims. Our growing awareness of how scapegoating works affects the culture in strange ways. Coming to understand scapegoating as wrong, we increasingly justify our violence by portraying ourselves as victims, or by aligning ourselves with others we allege have been victimized by our enemies. This paradox lies at the heart of many modern political movements, where claims of victimhood mask new cycles of exclusion and violence. In a meeting from February 1993, Girard observed, “We have reached a stage where the only way you can be violent is against the violent ones. That’s why everything today is propaganda… . You always claim to be fighting the violence of others.” Paul Leslie, From Philosophy to Power: The Misuse of René Girard by Peter Thiel, J.D. Vance and the American Right, Salmagundi 226-227, Spring – Summer 2025,
https://salmagundi.skidmore.edu/articles/1176-from-philosophy-to-power.
Footnote 35: Anthony Loewenstein, op. cit., p. 124.
Footnote 36: The case of India is paradigmatic. Azad Essa, in a 2019 article, notes: “Israeli-India relations have intensified since the election of Narendra Modi in 2014. India is Israel’s biggest purchaser of arms, amounting to $1bn per year. Both India and Israel have used the spectre of Islamic terror to justify their security policies and the need for partnership.” Azad Essa, “India consul general in United States calls for ‘Israeli model’ in Kashmir”, Middle East Eye, 26 novembre 2019,
https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/india-consul-general-united-states-calls-israeli-solution-kashmir.
Footnote 37 In an interview given in 2022, Volodymyr Zelensky outlined his vision for the future of post-war Ukraine as follows: “I think all our people will be our great army. We cannot talk about ‘Switzerland of the future’ – probably, our state will be able to be like this a long time after. But we will definitely become a ‘big Israel’ with its own face. We will not be surprised that we will have representatives of the Armed Forces or the National Guard in all institutions, supermarkets, cinemas, there will be people with weapons. I am sure that our security issue will be number one in the next ten years.” President of Ukraine Official Website, For the Ukrainian state, the issue of security should be in the first place for the next ten years – the President, 5 April 2022,
https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/dlya-ukrayinskoyi-derzhavi-pitannya-bezpeki-maye-buti-na-per-74113.
Footnote 38: Antony Loewenstein, op. cit., p. 21.
Footnote 39: Jessica Buxbaum, cit.
Footnote 40: Peter Thiel is a pioneer in the fields of techno-finance, social networking services, and the application of artificial intelligence technologies to the global pharmaceutical industry, defence, surveillance, and intelligence. He was one of the founders of PayPal, alongside Elon Musk, and is an investor in SpaceX and Tesla. In 2004, he became Facebook’s first institutional investor and supporter, inspired by Girard’s “theories of mimetic desire”. He has funded Vance’s Senate campaigns with over $30 million and has mentored him since 2011. As Whitney Webb wrote, ‘The profile of Vance, one of the PayPal co-founder’s leading protégés, has grown in recent years, as have those of other Thiel protégés, such as Sam Altman of OpenAI and Palmer Luckey of Anduril’. Thiel is also one of the main financiers of the National Conservatism movement, founded by Yoram Hazony. He has spoken at conferences held by the movement in Orlando, Florida in 2021 and Miami in 2022.
Footnote 41: “They’re a group of men who were at the top, the founding of PayPal, all of whom, in some way or other, grew up in South Africa as children. You’ve got Musk himself, who was born in South Africa and lived there, went to high school there ’til he was 18, and then moves to Canada. You’ve got Peter Thiel, who was a co-founder with Musk of PayPal. Thiel was born in Germany but brought to South Africa as a young child. His father was a mining engineer, lived in Johannesburg and then moved to South West Africa, which was then a South African colony, is now Namibia. And he went to school in Swakopmund, which was notorious as probably the last place on the planet where people still openly greeted each other with “Heil Hitler” and celebrated Hitler’s birthday. He went to a German school there before moving to the United States when he was 10 or 11. You’ve got David Sacks, who was born in Cape Town. He was big in PayPal and is now Trump’s AI and crypto czar. He moved to Tennessee as a relatively young child but grew up in the white South African diaspora there. And you’ve got Roelof Botha, who is the son of Pik Botha — sorry, the grandson of Pik Botha, the last foreign minister of apartheid South Africa. He was the acceptable face of apartheid. You will remember, he used to run around the United States trying to put a gloss on how they were reforming things and that everything was getting better, which apparently it wasn’t. But, so, you see those four key people at the top of PayPal, and they all have this very intimate connection to South Africa.”, intervista di Amy Goodman a Chris McGreal,
https://www.democracynow.org/2025/2/10/elon_musk_doge_south_africa_apartheid, 10 February 2025.
Footnote 42: Leo Strauss, a prominent ideologue of those neoconservatives integrated into the Bush administration whose parents were “Trotskyist militants, anti-Stalinists and belonged to the movement of the 1930s to the 40s that arose when Leon Trotsky abandoned the Soviet Union and denounced Stalin as a revisionist and a dictator. Of course, the United States supported with all its might the Trotskyist movement, which was spread worldwide; this included here in New York the CIA’s organizing their congress at the Waldorf Astoria in 1949 (The CIA and the Cultural Cold War, Frances Stonor Saunders) The children of the made-in-the-USA Trotskyists, their names are Wolfowitz, Perle, Kristol, Feith, David Wurmser, etc., became part of the liberal anticommunist movements between the 1950s and 70s. Later they converted themselves into neoconservatives and transformed Trotsky’s theory of Permanent Revolution into Permanent Conquest based on Strauss. Then they put it into action after taking power, calling it Permanent Expansion, justifying it by saying that ‘everything that is good for America is good for the world’ and that ‘the United States has the right to attack any country if it perceives the existence of any danger.’” Bill Vann, The historical roots of neoconservatism: a reply to a slanderous attack on Trotskyism,
https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2003/05/shac-m23.html, 23 May 2003.
Footnote 43: Peter Thiel, Straussian Moment, in “Politics and Apocalypse”, ed. Robert Hamerton-Kelly, Michigan State University Press, 2007, pp.189-190.
Footnote 44: Caroline Haskins, “‘I’m the new Oppenheimer!’: my soul-destroying day at Palantir’s first-ever AI warfare conference”,
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/may/17/ai-weapons-palantir-war-technology, 17 May 2024.
Footnote 45: Alex Koller, “Palantir CEO says his outspoken pro-Israel views have caused employees to leave company”,
https://www.cnbc.com/2024/03/13/palantir-ceo-says-outspoken-pro-israel-views-led-employees-to-leave-.html, 9 March 2024.
Footnote 46: Palantir, The Future of Warfare (Army vs Navy Commercial 2024),
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiiqiaUBAL8, 16 December 2024. In Tolkien’s sagas, the palantiri is a type of magic sphere used by the evil lord Sauron to watch, deceive and threaten his enemies in Middle Earth. During an interview, CEO Alex Karp said: “The Palantiri distort the truth”, “And those who look into them”, he adds, “only see what they want to see.” Andy Greenberg e Ryan Mac, “How A ‘Deviant’ Philosopher Built Palantir, A CIA-Funded Data-Mining Juggernaut”,
https://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/08/14/agent-of-intelligence-how-a-deviant-philosopher-built-palantir-a-cia-funded-data-mining-juggernaut/, 14 August 2013.
Footnote 47: “In-Q-Tel (autism scoreT), formerly Peleus and In-Q-It, is an American not-for-profit venture capital firm based in Arlington, Virginia. It invests in companies to keep the Central Intelligence Agency, and other intelligence agencies, equipped with the latest in information technology in support of United States intelligence capability. The name ‘In-Q-Tel’ is an intentional reference to Q, the fictional inventor who supplies technology to James Bond”. Wikipedia,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel.
Footnote 48: “As the war machine gets smarter, and every last bit of weaponry becomes AI-enhanced, the lines between Silicon Valley and the Pentagon start to get awfully blurry.”. Charlie Skelton, Silicon Valley in Switzerland: Bilderberg 2019 and the High-Tech Future of Transatlantic Power,
https://www.newsweek.com/silicon-valley-switzerland-bilderberg-2019-and-high-tech-future-transatlantic-1441259, 1 June 2019.
Footnote 49: Alex Koller, op. cit.
Footnote 50: Lucas Ropek, Palantir’s Billionaire CEO Just Can’t Stop Talking About Killing People,
https://gizmodo.com/palantirs-billionaire-ceo-just-cant-stop-talking-about-killing-people-2000560597, 7 February 2025.
Footnote 51: Anduril and Palantir to Accelerate AI Capabilities for National Security,
https://www.anduril.com/article/anduril-and-palantir-to-accelerate-ai-capabilities-for-national-security/, 6 December 2024.
Footnote 52:
https://www.anduril.com/.
Footnote 53: “Defense contractor and the father of modern virtual reality” Palmer Luckey, founder of Anduril Industries, “has created a VR headset that will kill the user if they die in the game they’re playing. He did this to commemorate the anime, Sword Art Online. Luckey is the founder of Oculus, a company he sold to Facebook in 2014 for $2 billion. This is the technology that Mark Zuckerberg rebranded as the foundation for Meta. Luckey’s killer headset looks like a Meta Quest Pro hooked up with three explosive charge modules that sit above the screen. The charges are aimed directly at the user’s forebrain and, should they go off, would obliterate the head of the user.” Matthew Gault, “Palmer Luckey Made a VR Headset That Kills the User If They Die in the Game”,
https://www.vice.com/en/article/palmer-luckey-made-a-vr-headset-that-kills-the-user-if-they-die-in-the-game/, 7 November 2022.
Footnote 54: Corey Walker, “Tech Entrepreneur Palmer Luckey Calls Himself a ‘Radical Zionist’ While Defending Israel’s Right to Exist”, 18 February 2025,
https://www.algemeiner.com/2025/02/18/tech-entrepreneur-palmer-luckey-calls-himself-radical-zionist-while-defending-israels-right-exist/.
Footnote 55: Jay Salley, Is Anduril Just a Shell Company for Peter Thiel?,
https://jasonsalley.medium.com/is-anduril-just-a-shell-company-for-peter-thiel-8ea02cef077c, 22 February 2025.
Footnote 56: Charlie Skelton, “Silicon Valley in Switzerland: Bilderberg 2019 and the High-Tech Future of Transatlantic Power”,
https://www.newsweek.com/silicon-valley-switzerland-bilderberg-2019-and-high-tech-future-transatlantic-1441259, 1 June 2019.