[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


File: 1767086646606.jpg (138.89 KB, 1080x1440, 1739246024900583.jpg)

 

Singapore is an economical and social miracle undoubtedly, low rate of corruption, high rate of employment, FDI, Income and quality of life in general.
All this achieved through a strict neoliberal economy, Lee Yew is practically worshipped by Neoliberal for not only his policies but also for his Anti-communist operations.
Marxist (atleast I haven't found any) can point out to any contradiction plaguing Singaporean multicultural society.
Does this economical path is the way to prosperity, as an alternative to liberal western ideology.
What does /leftypol/ say on this? Can he be refuted by Dialectical Materialism?
58 posts and 12 image replies omitted.

>>2618307
Do you lack reading comprehension or just dumb in general.
I am in no way denying that housing is a small achievement, just the population is not that big. Consider providing housing in Bangladesh. How are you gonna generate the capital. Out of Air?
Fucking read and answer dumb fuck.
>>2618308
Give example or fuck off.

>>2618318
You are an absolute moron

>>2618305
>There is no conflict of class and neither race or ethnic.
>discounts the riots in 1969 and 2012 by the Tamils and the Malays
>most unequal society in Asia
>>2618305
>That is why I conclude that Singapore might just be outside dialectical materialist progress of history. History has ended for them.
Tbh you're not wrong, but they can easily collapse.

>>2618306
>Observations about ethnicities isn't necessarily racist
I hate nationalists

File: 1767107609200.jpg (339.54 KB, 1080x1408, 1742077461514144.jpg)

>>2618319
Hmm, I had knowledge about the 1969 riot but the 2013 one was not known to me and it also happened after 44 years since the last riot of 1969. At last something has come up.
There is contradiction indeed. Thanks OP.

I am sorry comrades, There are contradictions, history has not stalled yet, it will be interesting to see in the future how these get resolved.

>>2618358
There's nothing nationalistic about that factual statement.

>>2618388
Ok nazi

>>2618387
Don't worry comrade, greater knowledge will help you develop your own framework for the future.

File: 1767109511883.png (479.14 KB, 1000x805, 1743168488674124.png)

>>2618410
>>2618387
Upon researching more it made sense why Singapore society seems "peaceful".
The racial discrimination does exist and is a reality. But neoliberal economy policies bind it together.
>How?
Neoliberalism influenced global migration binds the already rich upper class (not going by ethnicity) to use the lower class migrant population.
And the lower class migrants permit it because their origin country is comparatively a shithole and pay is good in Singapore. This two class are in a social contract, not push everything down the line. Bourgeois promises not to become full on fascists and the lower class promises not to become communists. The governmet is like a refree at this point.
But how many years will this contradiction go on, that is interesting to think about? And I genuinely fear this system where the labour class just accepts their fate (evident in western countries).

What are your thoughts comrade?

File: 1767110000469.jpg (123.01 KB, 720x536, 1717522196525103.jpg)

>>2618420
Anon you might honestly be right. Similar situation in the Gulf coast. Dubai and Qatar being prime examples, the contradictions seem to hold them both together. Millions of Filipino and Indian immigrants over in both countries.
>But how many years will this contradiction go on, that is interesting to think about?
I suppose until the ideology, fizzles out, or if the social class no longer sees a benefit in staying over there. As in, if there is an increase in the martial crisis(war, riots), and if there is an increase in the economic crisis(sanctions, depressions). Or, if the ruling ideology collapses, as in, a more unruly strain comes in and disrupts the class.
When do you think it'd collapse?

File: 1767111551604.jpg (76.61 KB, 551x800, 1756626513189883.jpg)

>>2618431
I found an answer in China's recent endeavours . Recently China developed their own EUV prototype despite the sanctions on modern equipments.
Partly because retired ASML scientists of chinese-origin were invited back to their country, and they accepted because the material conditions are so good in China along with government grants. Until the migrant's origin country does not develop rapidly and in their favour, things will things will hardly change in MY OPINION.
After that history will tell.

>>2618420
>This two class are in a social contract
Social contract theory is bunk liberal nonsense, fyi.

>>2618420
neoliberalism is when you have state enforced ethnic quotas among your government housing units

>>2618464
It is because of my lack of proper words, I beg your pardon. I know the labour class is following the self-interest and the bourgeoisie their own.
The social contract theory might be debunked but a nice word to explain the liberal word.
>>2618465
Neoliberalism when state takes it hands off the mode of production and destroys any and every collective or social endeavor. So I don't what the fuck you mean by that.

>>2618464
Really?

>>2618464
Are you autistic? He clearly isn't Hobbes.

>>2618252
Sad to be honest.

LKY is and was the perfect Fabian, in the sense of the Fabian society rather than the Fabian strategy.
Dengism is just big Singapore under a communist party. (Rather than arguing about whether that makes Singapore based or China cringe, it's more useful to see how they've played the game, more interesting to speculate on whether China's trying to win it or topple the board in the end…)

>>2619183
>>2619035
>>2618472
You can read about HOW "social contract theory" is bunk (from a Marxist perspective) in this very nice book that I am attaching.

>implying Americans/golden billioniods read

hahaha, still….

>>2618165
>All this achieved through a strict neoliberal economy
Singapore is not neoliberal. Housing, transportation, energy etc are all contingent on the State (with some being entirely owned by the state). The Singaporean government economically hermecize the individual from the market by providing him with enough to survive.
In marxian terms, the gov protects the individual from some of the capitalist contradictions which exist.

>Lee Yew is practically worshipped by Neoliberal for not only his policies but also for his Anti-communist operations.

Not really. He's worshipped by libertarians who don't understand how their economy works, ironically often not realizing that the """freedom""" loving Lee has had to create the biggest investment fund in existence and some of the most extensive social policies to guarantee said-freedom to individuals.
And more interestingly, he's also worshipped by illiberal asian countries (like China) for developing an undemocratic yet prosperous society.

>Marxist (atleast I haven't found any) can't point out to any contradiction plaguing Singaporean multicultural society.

Singapore is a tax-heaven, depends on foreign labor work who seek citizenship, and is essentially fiscally limited on some enterprise to exist. What do you think happens if these enterprise disappear and labor source ?

>Does this economical path is the way to prosperity, as an alternative to liberal western ideology.

No because it's contingent on certain criterias which can't be extrapolated to the entirety of western societies. It's the same reason as to why every european country didn't lower taxes like Ireland to prosper.
It's like saying that the gulf model can be extrapolated to european countries.

>Can he be refuted by Dialectical Materialism?

Its existence is actually a pretty good example of the material dialetic given that the people there don't seem to be concerned for their democracy as long as their material needs are ensured.
Even more, its entire existence is predicated on an economic reality : that of having a tax heaven alongside one of the biggest social safety net to safeguard the population from immeseration

>>2618228
Marxism can't explain fascism because fascism has "idealist" (and not material) cause.
Fascism is essentially a population forfeiting their liberal rights to safeguard their country from a percieved threat (immigrants, jews, sexual minorities etc). This is why fascism is fundamentally a reactionary right-wing regime. It doesn't try to change societies, but only to radically safeguard it.

>>2619486
>Housing, transportation, energy etc are all contingent on the State (with some being entirely owned by the state).
So its a socdem tax haven?

>>2619487
Yeah somewhat but it's not democratic. So it's more of a social-tax haven
But most tax heavens like Ireland or Bahrein use the funds to redistribute to the population too so it's not entirely surprising.

This country is a prison

>>2619490
It fits the traditional fascoid definition of fascism but im allergic to these apes defining anything.

>Singapore is an economical and social miracle undoubtedly, low rate of corruption, high rate of employment, FDI, Income and quality of life in general.
It's a vapid shithole filled with a cattle-like population, devoid of any identity or intellectualism, but steel and glass is impressive to some people, apparently.

>>2619566
>It's a vapid shithole filled with a cattle-like population, devoid of any identity or intellectualism, but steel and glass is impressive to some people, apparently.
This, it is entirely empty of any culture. It's disgusting.

>>2619569
Wait ew you're a fash

>>2618297
>Don't know what is the obsession of /leftypol/ with Italian Fascists
Obviously I cannot speak for the entire board but I always found the various Mediterranean fascists to be much more competent overall and with more of a mass appeal than there northern european counterparts and ergo much more of a problem in the longterm. The various fascists regimes in Portugal,Spain and Italy held onto to power much longer than NSDAP ever did and imho over here in burgerland ᴉuᴉlossnW-esque rhetoric about le nation being realer than race has much more potential than telling every single person that isn't a white evangelical they need to die.

>>2619566
>>2619569
> It's a vapid shithole filled with a cattle-like population, devoid of any identity or intellectualism, but steel and glass is impressive to some people, apparently.
You described Canada with less of a homelessness problem. Great culture is built when artists have food and shelter.

>>2619599
>Great culture is built when artists have food and shelter.
Yes, but those are not the only conditions necessary. At least Canada has Rush. Singapore is just a literal temple of consumerism and little else.

File: 1767216641384.jpg (5.87 KB, 184x274, 1745126195770486.jpg)

>>2619566
Not this cunt again, you cannot walk a foot without stumbling upon this shit in 4chan /lit/.

File: 1767219556365.jpg (10.48 KB, 189x267, 1738366063566614.jpg)

>>2619486
>Not really
Oh you have no idea. He is like the "Communist bashing strict but good father" for them.
>its entire existence is predicated on an economic reality
True
>>2619579
>more competent overall
In which ways?
> le nation being realer than race
As long as I have seen "le nation" is the starting point, it only rolls down the hill.
First
>our state is in danger, protect it from outsiders
then
>our state is in danger, protect it from insiders
And then
>kill minorities
>kill women
>kill anyone who is not "US"
And this defination of US gets narrowed down as time goes by.

>>2619841
>In which ways?
Other than lasting longer in power, I would say unlike the attempt at carving up eastern europe into lebensraum they were all much more successful in there colonial ambitions and two of them survived well past the second world war.

>As long as I have seen "le nation" is the starting point, it only rolls down the hill.

I would agree that there a tendency to go from scapegoat to scapegoat(especially if said states aren't at war) but imho the biological racism of the northern european fascists movements makes them less flexible and not as good at recuperation. In a US context I just think it would be easier for a multiethnic empire in decline(Like spain or portugal) to embrace a doctrine where anyone can be in the ingroup as long as they meet some randomass woowoo-vibes based criteria on what it means to be a real american™

>>2618175
>There are other port cities also. It is not a special one.
It really is special though. Like 80 percent of global shipping squeezes through that trade corridor in the straits of Malacca where Singapore happens to sit. It was already an important entrepot at independence, and it was originally established precisely because the British recognized the area's strategic value.

>>2618175
>not just a financial capital like Hong kong.
You realize Hong Kong also had a lot of industrial enterprise and there was massive sweat shop and textiles industry there, just like in Singapore? Both benefited from permissive low tax environments with barely any regulation of capitalist enterprise, extremely cheap labor force that was highly disciplined by authoritarian regimes, strategic trade locations that facilitated trade with East Asia / China?

>>2618234
Malaysians were also stoking tensions though. They wanted a Malay and muslim supremacist government, which is what they have today I think. Honestly, Singapore has its flaws but it was much better being independent than sticking with Malaysia, which is an Islamic shithole in my crude opinion.

>>2620285
Yeah I knew that, and It could not sustain it after China's opening up, so it shifted towards finance. That is why I said Singapore "seems" to be in a better position compared to Hong Kong.

>>2620299
It is an Islamic Ethnocentric Country, a literal hellhole. Asian countries (mainly south east asian and east asian) tend to embody extreme types of discrimination, segregation and hierarchies. An anthropological test must be done on this phenomenon.

>>2620346
Check out Maldives. By law, only a Muslim can become a citizen. So it always has by definition a 100% Muslim demographic.

>>2620346
Yeah Malaysia is a literal apartheid state, not kidding.

>>2620346
>It is an Islamic Ethnocentric Country, a literal hellhole. Asian countries (mainly south east asian and east asian) tend to embody extreme types of discrimination, segregation and hierarchies. An anthropological test must be done on this phenomenon.
Is it because of insecurity? Or because having more outsiders would weaken the states influence and function?

File: 1767374233541-0.jpg (323.9 KB, 1080x797, IMG_20260102_223640.jpg)

File: 1767374233541-1.jpg (561.27 KB, 1079x1820, IMG_20260102_223711.jpg)

File: 1767374233541-2.jpg (458.36 KB, 1080x1204, IMG_20260102_223840.jpg)

>Bumiputera, literally translates as "son of the land" or "son of the soil". In Indonesia, a related term, "Pribumi", is used, although in Malaysia it more broadly denotes indigenous peoples.

>Following the 13 May incident in 1969, the government implemented the New Economic Policy (NEP), a set of measures granting extensive social, economic and political advantages to bumiputera communities.


>Although originally presented as a temporary solution to interethnic tensions, the policy has remained in force for decades and has been described as a form of institutionalised racism.


It seems, these are effects of Asian hierarchical racist/fascist ideology, present in many many east and south east asian countries. They became institutionalized as time went by.

>also look at Lee Yew's Quotes

Now I would like the opinions of others. Did Lee Yew has just shifted the hierarchy from Malays to Chinese in Singapore. Any resources on that?

File: 1767374443154.jpg (9.93 KB, 194x259, 1737469453950498.jpg)

>>2621376
>these are effects of Asian hierarchical racist/fascist ideology
Also mixed with the Sharia brain-eating virus.

Is this thread just racist Brit/Burger posters making up things now? You can be a citizen of Malaysia or Indonesia as a Christian.

>>2621872
You can be a citizen but you won't be a "Malay"

>>2621378
Sharia mind virus is really funny since Malaysia was far more secular before straight up becoming an apartheid Islamic state after the oil boom

>>2622062
What exactly is the Apartheid that the Christians are the victim of?

>>2624386
Bumiputera

The CPF mandatory savings ordinary accounts (to be spent on housing, education, retirement, or medical), sovereign wealth funds, and Development Bank of Singapore together with the Housing and Development Fund to me indicate a set of policies which are precisely as noteworthy and successful as they are illiberal.

That housing is afforded by three times as many Singaporeans as New Yorkers despite having 80% the GDP per capita is a novel achievement. This model was even part of what helped shape the Chongqing model in China - a sort of left-wing revival for a time.

That they've managed to develop from nothing but the trade route to among the greatest economies on the planet is also an achievement. In Africa and the Middle East there are plenty of places with abundant natural resources which are incapable of defending their interests sufficiently to exploit them to the benefit of the public.

Lastly it goes against notions that democracy is tied to development and good governance, and the natural interventionist - by US, IMF, World Bank, etc. doesn't matter - disposition that follows. It's more representative of strong statement in line with the "Bangkok Declaration". [^1]

Overall despite the means-testing, financialization, reliance on migrant labor, and apparent racism that designed the system that the country is a useful model in good governance, and even in particular policies where the state has successfully intervened in the market with a heavy hand directly shaping the society that we see today.

[^1] https://web.archive.org/web/20041124184022/http://law.hku.hk/lawgovtsociety/Bangkok%20Declaration.htm

>>2639460
>Bumiputera
Wikipedia says one sufficient condition for counting as Bumiputera is this (citing the Malaysian Higher Education Ministry):
<"If both of the parents are indigenous natives of Sarawak as stated in Article 161A (6)(a) Federal Constitution of Malaysia; thus their child is considered as a Bumiputera"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bumiputera_(Malaysia)
So we go to the Wikipedia entry for Sarawak:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarawak
And that article says about half of that population is Christian. Are you saying these don't count as Bumiputera?


Unique IPs: 23

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]