>>2947332To clarify, "left-wing" refers to the left-wing of the General Assembly during the French Revolution; proponents of the "ancient parliamen", as opposed to the right-wing, who supported the "ancien regime", or the monarchy. The left-wing supported the Republican values of egalité, liberté and fraternité. The American Revolution was also leftist since it pioneered the same ideals. The difference between them is that the French Revolution was based in Rousseau, while the American Revolution was based in Locke, but both were Liberal.
These revolutionaries were not pro-state, but only saw it as "necessary evil", as Thomas Paine wrote. This is because they saw the state as simply protecting man's natural rights, rather than granting him rights. To a liberal, the purpose of the state is to protect man's "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness", but concretely, to protect his property. This idea did not begin with liberals, but can be seen in Ancient Rome; Cicero declares that the purpose of a state is to protect property. Now, the socialists agree with this, but see that the state unfairly protects the ruling classes from the working classes. Marx conceives of the state as an instrument of class rule. So then, he imagines that if the state was purely representing one class, it couldn't rule any others, so would cease being a state. Marx then was anti-state, but only by way of entering everybody into it. If everyone is in the state, there is no state, is Marx's idea. This is continued into Fascism, where ᴉuᴉlossnW and Gentile, following Hegel and Marx, conceive of "totalitaranism", where everything is in the state, and so nothing is outside of it. This is itself an attempt to overcome the state as an antagonistic force, by seeing it as an integrated reality. National Socialism and is volkish ideas had the same thing. Now, for Anarchists, the case is intuitive. What we see, however, is that all modern politics is not really politics, but is anti-political, anti-state. It is a utopian attempt to overcome the fetters of mediation and so to make social life an immediacy. So, I don't define politics as pro/anti-state, since in the first case, politics itself is simply about the state, and in the second case, left/right is a bad measure of anything besides Republican ideals. If one favours either: libery, equality or fraternity over another, they are lopsided, as Pierre Leroux shows us. I think liberals support liberty over equality, and I think socialists support equality over liberty. Thus as he writes:
<At the end of the day, to adopt either individualism or socialism, is to not understand lifehttps://www.libertarian-labyrinth.org/working-translations/pierre-leroux-individualism-and-socialism-part-1/>Lefty is usually pro-state and righty contra-stateI wouldn't say so. Maybe a leftist will support more welfare, but they may also not support the military. It is the opposite case for the right. In either case, it's not really about the state as such, but about the redistribution of wealth – once we talk about where tax money goes, the state just operates as a type of private subscription, not a régime. But let's think about it. If the state converted into a private company and performed the same tasks, there would be no difference. In some way, the state has already began its process of being abolished, no?
>Since Anarchism wants to get rid of the state, I assume it being the extrene right.Well, anarcho-capitalists are seen to be far-right, but maybe left/right is generall flawed in describing politics. If one is against the state, they don't really have politics, they have anti-politics.
>liberal left wing.To me, "liberal = left-wing = bourgeois". They're all the same, really.
>Correct me, if I'm wrong.You're not wrong, since that's the way people understand the terms.
I would say that culture is wrong, so makes us wrong, instead.
I think that if we stopped using terms like left/right, we begin to see things more clearly. If politics was about real, concrete policies, not fan clubs – which is to say, if politics was seen to be about class rule.