[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


File: 1773869402492.png (152.09 KB, 850x900, alunya question.png)

 

Previous thread: >>2381106

Dump all the seemingly pointless, dubious, and frivolous questions that don't deserve their own shitty threads.

Got a question that's probably been asked a million times before? You're in the right landfill, buddy. Post it here.

Threads that otherwise might go in here will eventually find themselves become merged to this thread.

Previous QTDDTOT Archives
https://archive.is/ga3OG
564 posts and 93 image replies omitted.

>>2936935
That wiki is libtarded to the gills.

Belarus and Nicaragua are both socialist. Belarus is the only European country where Communists can actively attack liberals in the streets and receive the backing of the security services when doing so. If you read Belarusian opposition media it's very funny when they publish an article whining about the Communists in Belarus beating people up or participating in writing the education curriculum. Nicaragua experimented with social democracy for a bit to try to see if the West would ease up, and then Ortega and the FSLN said "fuck it the Americans hate us anyways", and they took back power and recently banned the bourgeois opposition.

Venezuela under Chavez & Maduro was also arguably moving towards socialism as well.

As for the anti imperialist question that's obvious. It is America and Europe in control of the global financial system, from the IMF to the World Bank. The current capitalist order is based upon American and European financial and military hegemony. That hegemony is a net negative for humanity as their structural adjustment programs and military campaigns constantly destabilize and destroy other countries, retarding economic development and delaying the onset of an active class struggle by forcing entire countries to regress into struggle for subsistence, or turning them into active warzones. When a rich country like Libya or even a moderately prosperous one like Syria gets wiped out, it doesn't just cause waves of immigration and refugees outwards to other countries, it also permanently undercuts the viability and prospect of socialist revolutions in those very areas. Therefore the anti imperialists argue that for socialism to succeed Western unipolarity must first be weakened. After all, competing capitalist powers is what allowed for the first socialist state in Russia to be born, in the aftermath of WW1.

This logic also applies to Ukraine which was badly damaged by an IMF mandated economic program that turned Ukraine into the poorest country in Europe even before Russia invaded. Western hegemony in Ukraine has resulted in harsh austerity, massive poverty and inequality, endless debt, and the banning of all left wing political organizations within Ukraine itself. It is therefore the duty of every socialist to push back against NATO and NATO-aligned states in order to create more breathing room for worker organizations which will eventually lead socialist revolts when they become confident and widespread enough.

>>2936968
>That wiki is libtarded to the gills.
Yes, I can see that.

>Belarus and Nicaragua are both socialist. Belarus is the only European country where Communists can actively attack liberals in the streets and receive the backing of the security services when doing so. If you read Belarusian opposition media it's very funny when they publish an article whining about the Communists in Belarus beating people up or participating in writing the education curriculum.

Doesn't that make the government just sympathetic to communism, no? I understand that Marxism is not a dogma, but this hardly gives the impression of Belarus being a socialist country, unless there are other things which I am unaware about.

>Nicaragua experimented with social democracy for a bit to try to see if the West would ease up, and then Ortega and the FSLN said "fuck it the Americans hate us anyways", and they took back power and recently banned the bourgeois opposition.

This does feel a bit closer to what I had in mind regarding Nicaragua, thank you for clarifying this.

>Venezuela under Chavez & Maduro was also arguably moving towards socialism as well.

I will take your word for it on this one.

>It is America and Europe in control of the global financial system, from the IMF to the World Bank. The current capitalist order is based upon American and European financial and military hegemony. That hegemony is a net negative for humanity as their structural adjustment programs and military campaigns constantly destabilize and destroy other countries, retarding economic development and delaying the onset of an active class struggle by forcing entire countries to regress into struggle for subsistence, or turning them into active warzones.

Yes, exactly. This is what I was asking. Why support any of the side in the war? The lesser of two evils is still evil, after all. The endless wars they wage for profit are a net negative, better to reject them, no?

>Therefore the anti imperialists argue that for socialism to succeed Western unipolarity must first be weakened. After all, competing capitalist powers is what allowed for the first socialist state in Russia to be born, in the aftermath of WW1.

I see, but I think this furthers the question of helping build dual power instead of taking sides in an inter-imperialist conflict, unless we need one of the sides to be brutally defeated like Germany was. Also, the material conditions during WW1 are vastly different from today, can the same principles still be applied?

One question which still wasn't answered, just what does "critical support" mean?

(sorry if I come of as retarded with these questions, I am new to all this stuff)

>>2934346
Thank you very much.

>>2937033 (me)
bumping for an answer/clarification

Were Bundists anti-Zionist?


Why Analytical Marxism isn't popular around here?

>>2940822
What even is analytical Marxism?


>>2940822
People are obssessed with "le dialectics" and think they can divine what is the dialectical way of acting

>>2940847
Are you speaking of people here or the analytical marxist?

>>2940822
Wouldn't Cockshott be considered one

>>2940888
As so far I understand, Cockshoot doesn't like mainstream economics, while Analytical Marxist embrace the findings of mainstream economics.

Is it really the jews?

>>2942332
How do you mean?
Did the Jews make me a sub-5 male? No.
I remember seeing a very odd post on xitter where someone claimed that in a non-Jewish world they would be able to marry their sister, so cursed their enemy. 'Scapegoating' gets thrown around, but its true. Either, Jews are responsible for the failure of all our fantasies; if they're not, then what should we blame them for? Only what they do. But what do Jews do? Only what other people do. No race is virtuous.

>>2942332
Nah, that's just a simplification, people want a easy explanation for problem that they suffer and see

What are some economic alternative to planned economy that still respect the ideas and goals of socialism? I heard that market socialism is a good system.

>>2942344
But I've seen so many memes. Jews running western states, jews running the media, jews starting wars, jews holocausting arabs. Jews running the left, jews running the right. etc. And when it comes to the mayonese, they are extremely overrepresented, so we can say the mayonese is jewish: In capitalism, jews profit the most, most communists were also jewish. Then there is Marx, explaining the same in his writings on the jewish question. Then there is Hitler, explaining the same. Then there is the arabs, explaining the same and when you go back in history, pretty much eveyrone hated the jews for the very same reasons. Globalism seems to be the goal for the NWO. If you read the Talmud, it seems like that everything is perfectly in line, to make their new world order for real, so their messias will come back and rule the earth.
Did I just fall for stupid memes and should get medication?

>>2942362
Bro, jews has SOME influence out there, but aren't the only players around the town, there other people with power and money, jew don't run the world by themselves, also which jews? Majority of jews aren't rich bilionares, they are poor to middle class without much power to do thing, if you want to know who rules the USA seek a real academic the spent time on the question: https://whorulesamerica.ucsc.edu/power/class_domination.html

Don't seek info from some mentally ill chud online saying that because of jew he can't even shit.

>>2942362
Muslims also wamt to rule the would if you read the Quran. Abrahamism has lots of influence. Itis mostly jewish in the west and mostly muslim in the east. But the people with the most influence just care about their own profits. Only few terrorists, jewish and muslim, really care about their religion.

File: 1793445181111-7.png (38.43 KB, 554x554, images.png)

>>2942349
It depends how you define "socialism".
The Owenites in the early 19th century were pioneers of a cooperative movement. Marx actually supported them in their immediate aims:
<We speak of the co-operative movement, especially the co-operative factories raised by the unassisted efforts of a few bold “hands”. The value of these great social experiments cannot be overrated. By deed instead of by argument, they have shown that production on a large scale, and in accord with the behests of modern science, may be carried on without the existence of a class of masters employing a class of hands; that to bear fruit, the means of labor need not be monopolized as a means of dominion over, and of extortion against, the laboring man himself; and that, like slave labor, like serf labor, hired labor is but a transitory and inferior form, destined to disappear before associated labor plying its toil with a willing hand, a ready mind, and a joyous heart.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1864/10/27.htm
The issue he had with it was that it was too undeveloped in form:
<At the same time the experience of the period from 1848 to 1864 has proved beyond doubt that, however, excellent in principle and however useful in practice, co-operative labor, if kept within the narrow circle of the casual efforts of private workmen, will never be able to arrest the growth in geometrical progression of monopoly, to free the masses, nor even to perceptibly lighten the burden of their miseries […] To save the industrious masses, co-operative labor ought to be developed to national dimensions, and, consequently, to be fostered by national means. Yet the lords of the land and the lords of capital will always use their political privileges for the defense and perpetuation of their economic monopolies.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1864/10/27.htm
So, Marx supported cooperative support of businesses; e.g. the basis of a so-called market socialism. Marx himself of course never wanted this as an end in itself, however, but only as a means to an end. The theory of market socialism is problematic, because it presupposes conditions like that of protected labour under trade unions, e.g. that shares of revenue (in the form of cooperative dividends) will be incentivised by a profit motive, leading to gradual unemployment. Von Thünen described this in the early 19th century. Similarly, guilds had restrictions on who was able to be hired as an apprentice, etc. This is why the biggest employers in the world are monopolies which intensify wealth inequality between workers and owners, as a strategy of employment itself. The sacrifice of gains cannot be easily afforded. But I'll ask you; say you have been a shareholder in a company for 5 years – is it even ethically correct that a new hire should receive an equal share to you? So then, the status of ownership reproduces the relationship of capitalist to worker. Furthermore, if we permit owners to sell their shares, there will naturally be fewer and fewer owners.

What's the end goal of Leftist politics?

also

is it worthy to read about continental philosophy?

Is anarchism left wing?

>>2942362
> Did I just fall for stupid memes and should get medication?
Yes

>>2945536
>What's the end goal of Leftist politics?
Abolish capital, end wage labor, eliminate class society

Am I bourgeois if I have a million dollars, but no private property?

>>2945581
No, you just have a million dollars

>>2942362
Believing in memes is never a smart move.

>>2942332
it's da bourgeoisie. Jewish elites are just part of the elite.

>>2945581
No, in fact the state will pressure you to invest that money in capital

>>2942332
>>2942362
Are the Jews overrepresented in positions of power? Yes. Do they sit at the top of the pyramid? No. Is the ordinary Shlomo to blame? Absolutely not.

>>2945587
>>2945713
Okay, but what will happen to me after the revolution? And will there be any consequences for me if, on top of that, I’m an aristocrat?

>>2946212
>Is the ordinary Shlomo to blame?
Ordinary Shlomos aren't any better that banking Shlomos. Both believe that non-believers are literally untermenschen and that they should become their slaves. Its' fascism - the religion.

File: 1793784863075-0.jpeg (61.63 KB, 480x639, images.jpeg)

>>2946899
>fascism - the religion
Its still more merciful than Christianity and Islam (of which make up over 50% of the entire world). Followers of these religions believe that unbelievers are tortured forever by the creator of the universe. At least Fascism gives death as a release. Hell as a belief system is unending cosmic horror. And for what? For not believing a carpenter is actually God, or for not believing some paedophile had an angel talk to him. What is so evil about Judaism which is compared to these religions?

File: 1793785873732-0.jpeg (36.52 KB, 499x400, fr.jpeg)

>>2945574
Anarchism develops from Proudhon's mutualism by way of Bakunin. Proudhon called himself a socialist, but was also a reformist. Marx accuses him of being "bourgeois" (by which he really means "leftist"). Proudhon had utmost concern with equality by means of Justice, with liberty being defined as ensuring Justice. Bakunin on the other hand was a libertine who privileged unconditional liberty by the means of deconstructing authority itself. This concern with liberty contradicts a concern with equality (that is to say, it is a false view of what freedom entails. Bakunin is more de Sade, than Kant). I think Proudhon was a leftist, but Bakunin was less so. Anarchism isn't one unified doctrine.
>>2945536
>What's the end goal of Leftist politics?
Egalité, fraternité, liberté.
This is why I don't think Marx was a leftist: >>2931363
Leftism is the radical wing of the bourgeois revolution – consequently, socialists took over the red flag of egalité (of the red, white and blue) without the others. Leroux complains of the Saint-Simonists (1834):
<Ask the partisans of absolute socialism how they reconcile the liberty of men with authority, and what they make, for example, of the liberty to think and to write: they will respond to you that society is a grand being of which nothing can disturb the functions […] At the end of the day, to adopt either individualism or socialism, is to not understand life […] What I attacked under that name [socialism], were the false systems advanced by the alleged disciples of Saint-Simon and by the alleged disciples of Rousseau led astray following Robespierre and Babœuf, without speaking of those who amalgamated at once Saint-Simon and Robespierre with de Maistre and Bonald.
https://www.libertarian-labyrinth.org/working-translations/pierre-leroux-individualism-and-socialism-part-1/
It is easy to contrive Marx and Engels as Saint-Simonists in kind, with the desire for an "administration of things" to replace a government of men. Similarly, neither of them seem particularly concerned with liberty.

File: 1793797594592-2.jpeg (96.62 KB, 440x499, IMG_0201.jpeg)

>>2946999
>What is so evil about Judaism which is compared to these religions?
Tbh most of the bullshit in Christianity or Islam is a legacy of Judaism.

>>2947150
The worst idea ever conceived doesn't come from the Old Testament, but derives from the New Testament; the idea of eternal Hell, given from the Greek Hades, but modified to depend on faith, not works, as it is in the case of Plato, for example. This is reproduced in Islam.

>>2947017
Lefty is usually pro-state and righty contra-state. Since Anarchism wants to get rid of the state, I assume it being the extrene right. But! Anarchism is also the micro version of communism as in having a socialist village ruling itself, which pretty much is left wing - well, liberal left wing. Correct me, if I'm wrong.

>>2946999
Well, its the entire Abrahamism, actually. Muslims too think that non-believers are just like animals (kuffar). The difference to Judaism is: you can convert or you die. They dont want to have slaves. At least thats what the Quran says. At the end, the entire thing is schizo-fascist. It begins with the the chosen people (moloch jews), then Jesus appears (according to jews a sourcerer now boiling in feces), making the sect even more chosen and then comes Muhammad, knowing everything better than the previous sects (we must fight, or breed to win). And everyone thinks the other sect is animals, who need to die. It you're part of any of these sects, youre the cancer of humanity. Or you just leave the club. I would respect every jew, muslim, or christian leaving these inane sects.

>>2946999
Imagine Epstein entering heaven because Jesus being forgiving.

>>2947332
To clarify, "left-wing" refers to the left-wing of the General Assembly during the French Revolution; proponents of the "ancient parliamen", as opposed to the right-wing, who supported the "ancien regime", or the monarchy. The left-wing supported the Republican values of egalité, liberté and fraternité. The American Revolution was also leftist since it pioneered the same ideals. The difference between them is that the French Revolution was based in Rousseau, while the American Revolution was based in Locke, but both were Liberal.

These revolutionaries were not pro-state, but only saw it as "necessary evil", as Thomas Paine wrote. This is because they saw the state as simply protecting man's natural rights, rather than granting him rights. To a liberal, the purpose of the state is to protect man's "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness", but concretely, to protect his property. This idea did not begin with liberals, but can be seen in Ancient Rome; Cicero declares that the purpose of a state is to protect property. Now, the socialists agree with this, but see that the state unfairly protects the ruling classes from the working classes. Marx conceives of the state as an instrument of class rule. So then, he imagines that if the state was purely representing one class, it couldn't rule any others, so would cease being a state. Marx then was anti-state, but only by way of entering everybody into it. If everyone is in the state, there is no state, is Marx's idea. This is continued into Fascism, where ᴉuᴉlossnW and Gentile, following Hegel and Marx, conceive of "totalitaranism", where everything is in the state, and so nothing is outside of it. This is itself an attempt to overcome the state as an antagonistic force, by seeing it as an integrated reality. National Socialism and is volkish ideas had the same thing. Now, for Anarchists, the case is intuitive. What we see, however, is that all modern politics is not really politics, but is anti-political, anti-state. It is a utopian attempt to overcome the fetters of mediation and so to make social life an immediacy. So, I don't define politics as pro/anti-state, since in the first case, politics itself is simply about the state, and in the second case, left/right is a bad measure of anything besides Republican ideals. If one favours either: libery, equality or fraternity over another, they are lopsided, as Pierre Leroux shows us. I think liberals support liberty over equality, and I think socialists support equality over liberty. Thus as he writes:
<At the end of the day, to adopt either individualism or socialism, is to not understand life
https://www.libertarian-labyrinth.org/working-translations/pierre-leroux-individualism-and-socialism-part-1/
>Lefty is usually pro-state and righty contra-state
I wouldn't say so. Maybe a leftist will support more welfare, but they may also not support the military. It is the opposite case for the right. In either case, it's not really about the state as such, but about the redistribution of wealth – once we talk about where tax money goes, the state just operates as a type of private subscription, not a régime. But let's think about it. If the state converted into a private company and performed the same tasks, there would be no difference. In some way, the state has already began its process of being abolished, no?
>Since Anarchism wants to get rid of the state, I assume it being the extrene right.
Well, anarcho-capitalists are seen to be far-right, but maybe left/right is generall flawed in describing politics. If one is against the state, they don't really have politics, they have anti-politics.
>liberal left wing.
To me, "liberal = left-wing = bourgeois". They're all the same, really.
>Correct me, if I'm wrong.
You're not wrong, since that's the way people understand the terms.
I would say that culture is wrong, so makes us wrong, instead.
I think that if we stopped using terms like left/right, we begin to see things more clearly. If politics was about real, concrete policies, not fan clubs – which is to say, if politics was seen to be about class rule.

>>2947332
>>2948365
If we look at history, the term "left/right" or "left/right-wing" was never used by Marx to describe anything or anyone. It was never used by the socialist movement from 1789–1910, and only had a limited lexicon thenceforth to describe anything else besides liberal republicans. During the 1910s, Left Wing was adopted by various socialists, not in contradiction to capitalism, but in their attitude to parliamentarianism. It only grew a common meaning of how we use if today with the New Left during the 1950s, culminating into the protests of May, 1968. It is still often conflated with "Liberal" today, which seems appropriate. In any case, attempting to draw out a science of terminology will fail.

>>2948365
Thank you very much.

>>2948374
Don't thank me too much. I'm only shitposting. 😅
Just to sum up my points for you:

left/right refer to French parliamentarians/monarchists. The class of bourgeoisie (e.g. burghers, or townspeople, the middle class) supported the parliament to restrict the power of the aristocracy. The aristocracy supported the monarchy and wanted to crush the liberals. It was the same in the English civil war (1642–51). It was the same with the American Revolution (1776), where the middle class fought against the aristocracy. Struggles all the way up to 1848–9 saw the victory of the middle classes over the aristocracy, establishing liberal politics – or the political virtues of "rule of law", liberty, equality, and so on. We see in this that liberalism/leftism is just the ideology of a radical bourgeoisie – so a leftist is someone who in essence, has the same ideals as classical liberals. The socialists are of many kinds. Some are supportive of liberalism, and others don't think they go far enough. For example, some say we don't have "real freedom" or "real equality" today, so still use the slogans of the French Revolution. It is the opinion of Marx that as time went on, particularly from the 1830s onwards, the liberals became reactionary, or conservative, and so ended up betraying their own values. By 1850, the middle class had become the ruling class everywhere. Now the working class must be revolutionary – however you take that to mean. Marx sees that the anarchists are too bourgeois, too liberal. Thus he writes:
<the foolishness of those socialists (namely the French, who want to depict socialism as the realization of the ideals of bourgeois society articulated by the French revolution)
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch05.htm
Marx criticised these ideals in his early work. So, is Marx a leftist?
Classical liberals are known as "libertarians" today, like Alex Jones.

>>2948374
>>2948379
And just to provide a note on libertarianism.
Free trade as supported by Hobson in the 1840s led to the repeal of the Corn Laws in England (1846), which was the final strike against the landed aristocracy, but only in support of the industrialists. This new industrial mode of production (e.g. capitalism) caused political conflict among the liberals, since it clearly immiserated the people of a country into a mass of wage slaves, and so economic freedom for a few begins to override economic freedom for the many. Marx notes that during the English civil war, the yeoman farmer supported the middle class, since they wanted freedom in their land. Too, during the American Revolution, Jefferson wanted an agrarian country made of yeoman farmers, but when industry came to America, this disturbed him and he realised that the only way to have independence is to become capitalist. Capitalism then is contrary to the spirit of the classical liberals. John Stuart Mill, as a liberal during the 1850s, was disturbed by industry all the same, so saw that worker ownership would solve the problem over time. Too? Jevons in the 1870s saw that workers ought to own their own businesses over time. This is continued into the 1920s, with the English Liberals devising schemes for worker ownership of industry. Reagan in 1987 even had a speech where he advocates for worker ownership. Too, even the "founder" of libertarian ideology, Rothbard in 1969 supported nationalising private institutions if they receive tax money. Rothbard himself promoted his liberalism based on Locke's theory of property being based in labour, so Rothbard also supported things like reparations for slavery, and saw black poverty in the US as caused by stolen labour. There is then a complicated relationship classical liberals have to capitalism, where they support free markets, but also see that industry makes markets unfree, and so in one way or another, end up promoting socialism, i.e. worker ownership. So, libertarianism, when logically consistent, gives you socialism. People should never reject ideas, but should go all the way to the ends of ideas.

What is Fascism? I see this word throw around a lot, people use it as to insult their opponents, but I really don't know what Fascism mean in deep sense.

>>2948446
>The Fascist conception of the State is all-embracing; outside of it no human or spiritual values can exist, much less have value. Thus understood, Fascism is totalitarian, and the Fascist State — a synthesis and a unit inclusive of all values — interprets, develops, and potentiates the whole life of a people.

>It is not the nation which generates the State; that is an antiquated naturalistic concept which afforded a basis for XIXth century publicity in favour of national governments. Rather is it the State which creates the nation, conferring volition and therefore real life on a people made aware of their moral unity.


>For Fascism the State is absolute, individuals and groups relative.


— ᴉuᴉlossnW, La dottrina del fascismo / The Doctrine of Fascism, 1932

>>2948446
It's a political movement spearheaded by ᴉuᴉlossnW from 1919 onwards, around the same time as National Socialism in Germany. It is often seen as part of the Third Position (e.g. neither capitalism or socialism). Ideologically, it is extremely anti-individualist and conceives of man in a "totalitarian" manner; that is, of all spheres of life being combined (e.g. the state, civil society, religion, etc.) This bears resemblance to Hegel's thinking. Giovanni Gentile, a leading Fascist intellectual, was a Hegelian, but Hegel himself was a Liberal.

>>2948514
>ᴉuᴉlossnW
Do we have any more word filters?

>>2948671
Yes.
T-Word (1) = transhumanist
T-Word (2) = beautiful lady😍🥰
N-Word = uyghur
B.B.C. = British Broadcasting Corporation
I.Q. = autism score


Unique IPs: 33

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]