This guy's video is wrong, he's wrong, Stalin was a marxist, its just that marxism itself goes against Marx - Marx himself rejected "marxism" and "marxists". Stalin was indeed a marxist, a socialdemocrat like the other "marxists".
>muh starvation
He didn't eat the grain or cause famines on purpose.
>muh collectivization
Collectivization is necessary, what the fuck is this NEP babble?
>muh peasants
Fuck the peasants. The workers are the revolutionary subject.
>muh kulaks
Death to kulaks.
>anyone who owned a property and didn't want to give it up
Well deserved death.
The gravedigger had many issues, but this video is full of shit. The channel seems like a retarded trot.
>>2792231The channel also slanders Lenin, who the fuck is he to claim Lenin was out of line?
Top comment: "Marx would probably oppose Lenin's sick lack of empathy to the people"
LMAO fucking moralist libtards
>>2792234LMAO
Marx of all people to pity the conservative religious reactionary backwards trash and the bourgeois succdem liberal mensheviks
What good is being a marxist?
Stalin, Trotsky, Bordiga, Gorbachev and Deng are all Marxists btw
Marxists not agreeing with each other and arguing is normal btw
I would rather have a thousand gravediggers like Stalin spawn than have to listen to this libtard youtuber any second longer
>>2792238Marx and Engels never argued, at least not over political economy
That especially goes for the communist ones too. Not just the libtarded ones.
>>2792243They were scientists when the others were idealists.
>>2792239I would rather have communism than either of the mentioned
People who pre-judge Stalin as a brutish, revisionist nationalist know absolutely nothing about his theory or practice. Stalin was a Marxist intellectual and a true believer. Trotsky's reaction against Stalin was fanratical and unfair.
>>2792267Stalin’s “theory” is irrelevant to the greater communist discourse. He provides nothing, though he has taken much, including much of the coherency of the discourse. One could stay with Marx and Engels, avoid Stalin, and be better off for it. It is embarrassing to see.
A brute? A nationalist? A revisionist? Unnecessary? He was all of those things. But now? He is also irrelevant.
>>2792271What did Stalin get wrong theoretically and practically?
>>2792293The red army already had a problem with rape in its ranks, you think allowing conscripts to assfuck each other during a total war of extermination is a good idea?
>>2792293Fuck off libtard, holodomor wasn't manmade
>>2792239Okay maybe not all leftcoms deserve to be shot
>>2792308>Today revolutionary workers' movement is at its lowest ebb and capitalism is more powerful than ever.>1940if only he knew how much worse things would become
>>2792234>>2792236Lenin was actually very tolerant ofreligion in the sense that he won't actually persecute religious people because that would actually end up being beneficial to the clergy. Hell he would even let a priest join the bolsheviks if he sticks to the party's program.
>>2792231The only criticism of Stalin that is worth hearing comes from Trotsky
>>2792239ok then stop visiting his channel and reposting it here. litterally close the tab
>>2792245>>2792251>>2792306don't pat him on the back for spraying shit all over the walls and then denouncing the shit
>>2792332this video is good but replace "they were more terrified of stalin" at the end with "they were more terrified of a Communist Japan" or "they were more terrified with an end to class society." and you will have the true essence of it.
>>2792345>no anime>no 2ch>no 4chan>no moot-epstein connex>no alt-right>no magawhy did they stop at sakhalin???
>>2792345What are the material conditions that lead to anime?
>>2792351Lots and a lots of idealism
>>2792345Isn't the beginnings of anime heavily intertwined with Soviet animation and left-wing artists?
We'd probably have anime but based in this alt-history tbh.
>>2792363maybe,but manga is heavily inspired by disney if we go by tezuka's experience (and honestly that was true before the second world war too)
>>2792340>dont pat himcrackkas ass think he can tell what to do
>>2792280Russification of the USSR under the pretext of anti nationalism
Cult of personality
Purging the military while watching a neighboring fascist power expand
>>2792402>while watching a neighboring fascist power expandthey were preparing for the invasion
>>2792356Holy shit yeah you are right. There's awfully a lot of idealism displayed in anime
>>2792231>>2792234kill behead rape butcher m*ralists
>>2792231A planet of falsifiers deserves the gravedigger.
Unique IPs: 19