Do you guys genuinely criticize Social Democracy? Because to me it doesn't seem like you people understand why Social Democracy is bad.
When the US and Europe adopted social democratic policies in the past, it led to genuine improvement in the standard of living of workers. It also led to the complete collapse of revollutionary communism, and even the communist parties themselves became SocDem in all but their name.
And then what happened? Everyone lived happily ever after? No, obviously when the RoP started hurting, all that was clawed back. And the bigger and more important criticism is that we don't want to put a bandaid on capitalism in the first place, we want to abolish capitalism entirely.
That's why communists of the past criticized social democracy. It was not an easy thing to criticize. We had to actively criticize people who were making genuine improvements to worker's lives, and that made real communism unpopular.
And now we are in 2026 with a minor resurgence in social democracy. People post Lassalle memes, but what I want to know is what are your honest thoughts?
Do you really have the guts to criticize social democrats at a time when the capitalist class is almost universally hated? Do you have the principles and persistence to explain why social democracy is bad and are you capable of explaining to the workers what communism is actually about?
Just want to hear your honest thoughts.
Nah
I've moved beyond this minor contratianism into "neoliberalism is good in theory but real neoliberalism has never been tried"
The record of communists can be split into three: countries too small to matter at a planetary scale, the dismal overrated failure of the USSR, and China, which adapted itself to most of the valuable insights of neoliberalism without giving up party control.
The biggest problem with current social democrats is not that they're wrong but that they're insufficiently ruthless. Before any social or economic reform for its own sake their fundamental task should be to decompose their opponents electoral base. In many contexts this would mean ostensibly "rightward" moves towards deregulation. (For a US example: car dealers vote Republican. Car dealers are a protected industry because car manufacturers are banned from selling directly to customers. It's therefore obvious any democrat, even a right wing one, should scrap this protection and expose them to market discipline - good for consumers, but best of all bad for the Republican party's finances.)
This is what Thatcher (sociopath LARPing as a neoliberal) did to the base of the British labour party, selling council houses to their residents below market rates and banning councils from doing more was a massive government subsidy program, but also a massive program of socially engineering people into becoming conservative voters. Her "privatisations" mostly put companies into protected state controlled markets, more an organized form of looting than a deregulated market situation. Not for nothing is the UK a dismal, reactionary little polity. It's dominated by that most hitlerite of groups: a non competitive capitalist class.
None of this is to say I've abandoned workers. Generally when you see such sentiments from "neo liberals" it's because they're tax cut obsessed sociopaths. What I've embraced is the value of competition and especially of trade. Civilisation is trade+urbanization, and a lot of people currently loathe both…
Social democracy never existed and will never exist
Real social democracy has never been tried.
>>2941709I’ll one up you, real social democracy has never even been theorized
>>2941696Everything lead to where we are today. Maoism and Stalinism are as inseperable from the status quo as Keynesianism. A consistent approach would recognize that all forms of repeating old mistakes mean applying not just a band aid, but greater injury.
>>2941716>Maoism and Stalinism are as inseperable from the status quo as Keynesianism. yes exactly.
>>2941716Pain and catharsis are good because it’s the main proof we are alive
>>2941717So is anarchism and left communism
>>2941695I get what you're saying, I've read your arguments many times neoliberal-san. My main critique would be that your political program ignores things like the falling rate of profit which is why capitalism moved towards the modern frankenstein "neoliberalism" in the first place.
Modern capitalism in advanced nations is only possible because of massive rentier and looting behavior like printing trillions of dollars, over-regulation to prevent new entrants, deliberately creating bubbles like housing, unproductive parasitic industries like insurance, education industry, health industry etc.
Brutally cutting all that fat is also going to destroy RoP which will make companies stop investment. So your govt will be overthrown by the capitalist long before you'll be able to do anything serious. Which means only a revolutionary dictatorship can implement those features, but when you're already a proletarian dictatorship, you can just straight up go to communism instead of these kinds of reforms.
>>2941690>but what I want to know is what are your honest thoughts? That Lassalle was not a social democrat and worker co-ops never gained popularity which is kind of a tragedy as we are stuck between two shitty systems now.
Correct me if I'm wrong but my understanding is that social democracy turning to reformism wasn't the original intention, really, but it happened as these parties focused more on the immediate demands of their transitional program.
Fast forward to today you can have a socialist party being the healthcare party (would be very fitting in the U.S.), and the people in the party could believe that it's an immediate demand that would necessarily "outstrip" itself to borrow Marx's phrasing and "necessitate further inroads upon the old social order." But then in reality that doesn't actually happen or the party just becomes the "healthcare party" and tends to that. So that's what happened to the social democratic parties and they gradually dropped the socialist part later on. But that wasn't how the original social democrats saw themselves, they saw themselves as putting forward an immediate program while also having some conception of moving beyond capitalism to a different mode of production.
>>2941690> all that was clawed back.nah, only some of it. most of the suffering was simply outsourced to the "underdeveloped"
Lassalle memes are so fucking obnoxious because it's so clear it's just virtue signaling from internet leftcoms who will never be part of the real movement in their lives.
>It also led to the complete collapse of revollutionary communism
Social democracy didn't cause the downturn of the world communist movement, opportunism within the movement caused splits, confusion and reformism to take hold, which ultimately led to the overthrows of 89-91. The problem was internal, not external, although outside pressures certainly contributed.
>the bigger and more important criticism is that we don't want to put a bandaid on capitalism in the first place, we want to abolish capitalism entirely.
well said, but also that these measures are ultimately temporary, taken back at the first sign of hardship for the bourgeoisie (falling profit, accumulated excess capital etc.)
>We had to actively criticize people who were making genuine improvements to worker's lives, and that made real communism unpopular.
Not at all. Social democracy has definitely sullied its reputation by further collaborating with the bourgeoisie at the expense of the working class (SPD, PSOE, Syriza, PS) which has in turn made the working class bitter with leftism and social democracy. In countries without prominent communist parties (i.e. most of them), this popular anger and dissatisfaction has been utilized by far-right populist parties. Social democracy has definitely NOT made worker's lives better, Venezuela and Spain are good examples.
>Do you have the principles and persistence to explain why social democracy is bad and are you capable of explaining to the workers what communism is actually about?
Only if you're organized in a Communist Party, which - if you are, you shouldn't be posting here.
>>2941695>neoliberal anon back again with being wrongkek
Generally when people are talking about social democracy here, it's just a denigration against socialist states and aes. Real social democratic states like in the eu are hardly ever criticized as such, same for actual socdems which make up the vast majority of leftists out there
>>2942229What you're talking exists even if you abolish labor vouchers and go into higher stage socialism. There will still be a part of social product used not for personal consumption, but for investment and caring those who can't work.
Labor vouchers are simply a temporary practical solution to the initial problem of distribution as we emergency from capitalism. Labor based accounting allows rationalisation of production. The goal is to eventually eliminate as many products and services from this kind of system as possible. This was already possible in Marx's time. In 2026, with all the gigantic improvements in technology and now AI, this will be a cakewalk.
>>2942239>What you're talking exists even if you abolish labor vouchers and go into higher stage socialism.Yes, that was my point. No free people would work 12 hours in factory.
>>2942235Marx said if the stated owned everything it would still be capitalism, it's just the state would be the universal capitalist. Same with "society" (as if the adminstration of things won't have bodies of armed men).
>>2942246No one would be working 12 hours in a factory under socialism. They don't even do that in capitalism. Under communism, maybe 5 hours a day, for 4 days a week.
>>2942247There is a huge difference between a society consciously controlling it's production and distribution and the current system of private property, alienated labor, competition, commodity fetishism, money etc.
>>2942255It's better to have higher wages than lower wages, is it not?
The issue thus becomes internal struggle in the working class itself.
As an example, anti-immigrant rhetoric is pure social democracy.
Even Bernie in my clip says "fuck 'em, we want treats"
>>2942255>>2942274To put it in Hegelian terms, tragedy is a struggle between two rights
Immigrants are right, and social democrats are right. History decides.
There are essentially two ways in which social democracy (i.e. a reformist path to socialism) can fail. It can run out of steam because the capitalist order has proven capable of reforming itself in such a way that the militancy and ambition of the working class is sapped. Or it can reach the limits of what the bourgeoisie will tolerate, fail to recognize the danger, and be crushed violently. The former case is Western Europe in the postwar period, while the latter is Latin America in the 70s.
Where a lot of Marxists lose the plot I think is where they criticize social democracy in the first scenario, as if without the reformists ruining everything there would have been a revolution. But the reality is that even without the reformist socialists to drive the process, a system capable of such reforms will implement them. In that situation revolution is effectively impossible, since even without social democrats any competent bourgeois leader would recognize the need for reform to preserve the existing order, as Bismark did in the 19th century. As OP notes, under conditions where social democratic compromise is possible, even communists tend to become social democrats in practice.
FDR failed
Rule of capital is not compatible with free society
The only good things liberals can say about themselves is that they better than feudalists and allow labor to flow more freely
>>2942405>that they better than feudalists and allow labor to flow more freelyFeudalism was objectively better and Communism is a return to feudalism and an upgrade over it. Dialectics.
>>2942431Should I become a Lasalle enjoyer now? I never understood why Marx hated him.
>>2942440>>2942441Very well. I have transitioned to becoming a Lasalle supporter.
How do I look?
Is the shape of my head and the way my hair grows testifies that my paternal grandmother interbred with a negro who accompanied Moses’ flight from Egypt? I have not even started on my importunity which is very… Lasallean-like.
>>2942437Lassalle pwnt Marx in the marketplace of ideas when Marx begged him for money and so he seethed forevermore.
>>2942458That is so faggy on Marx's part. Why did he lose in the marketplace of ideas? Did people not agree with him on labor vouchers or something?
>>2942461Marx begged him for money, so Lassalle said he should just prostitute out his daughter if he wanted money so bad. And Marx so seethed at this that he split the Social Democracy movement permanently.
>>2942460>So you see, phrenology is not the baseless art which Hegel imagined.I said it before and will say it again, if Marx was alive today he would be a 4chan regular and a theorylet.
>>2942464>Lassalle said he should just prostitute out his daughter if he wanted money so badOk that's faggy on Lasalle's part. What's with these jewish lawyers and cuckoldry?
Social Democracy offers a decent living standard for the working class and a good environment for socialists & communists to dwell and develop. Thus it's preferable to all other forms of class society and bourgeois rule. Real Social Democrats are reformists and cling to bourgeois society, but at least they aren't anti-communists.
SPD, PS, Labour and the like aren't Social Democrats though, despite the name. They're far-right neoliberals and their political program is to undo everything what the OG Socdems achieved in terms of worker's rights.
>You need to fuck the workers so hard that they'll start a revolution!!!
No, fuck you. That’s not how it works + I don't want to suffer even more.
>>2942481>I don't wanna be exploited!Sorry,
the bourgeois surplus expropriation will continue.
Unique IPs: 27