It's insane how everything Marx said would happen is happening. The MOP is constantly being revolutionized, people are constantly being pushed out of their jobs, the rate of profit is constantly falling so they have to find new ways to squeeze the proles. The contradictions are intensifying. Young people are increasingly waking up to the scam that almost every aspect of life is. Some might be doomers, but I am feeling pretty optimistic with how Porky can't seem to help himself. They used to give us treats to calm us down, but ol' Pot Belly can't even be bothered to do that anymore
You proles are so ungrateful. We have given you so much. You could be a hunter gather, serf, or slave. Even the early proletariat had it worse off than you. We have abolished child labor for you. We have sent all the worst jobs to the periphery in order to develop them along the same lines you were developed. We have given you gaming PCs and video game consoles and cell phones and porn. Yet you are still ungrateful. You say you want the end of class society. Don't you understand that you have it better than 3rd worlders? Don't tempt me. I'll end class society and you'll beg for me to come back.
It's pretty cool how you (OP) cited all the parts of Marx that are still very very relevant in the contemporary world.
Yeah, sometimes when engaging with his work, it's crazy how he anticipated so much stuff it makes your head spin, and as long as capitalism exists, it will keep being relevant, that's the craziest part. Keep it up lad.
The problem is proles have hundreds of ways to distract and soothe themselves, including by posting here
>but ol' Pot Belly can't even be bothered to do that anymore
They hunger for infinite growth
>>2943161hey at least leftypol posters are self soothing without consooming
Honestly people give too much credit to Marx for things people notice by themselves. You don't need to cite Marx for this
>everything Marx said would happen is happening.
From 1867–86, Marx and Engels predicted the imminent collapse of capitalism, and it never came true. False prophecies spawn religions.
>the rate of profit is constantly falling
This is conjecture. Where exactly is the data?
>>2944201>From 1867–86, Marx and Engels predicted the imminent collapse of capitalismNo, they predicted that capitalism inevitably falls into crisis due to the falling rate of profit. But there are mechanisms that save capitalism from that crisis such as destruction of capital (human and infrastructure), integration of rural peasants into cities,…
>>2944213>NoRead (1867):
<Let us not deceive ourselves on this. As in the 18th century, the American war of independence sounded the tocsin for the European middle class, so that in the 19th century, the American Civil War sounded it for the European working class. In England the process of social disintegration is palpable. When it has reached a certain point, it must react on the Continent.Read (1875):
<the universal crisis. That crisis is once again approaching, although as yet but in its preliminary stage; and by the universality of its theatre and the intensity of its action it will drum dialectics even into the heads of the mushroom-upstarts of the new, holy Prusso-German empire.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p3.htmRead (1886):
<The decennial cycle of stagnation, prosperity, over-production and crisis, ever recurrent from 1825 to 1867, seems indeed to have run its course; but only to land us in the slough of despond of a permanent and chronic depression. The sighed for period of prosperity will not come […] we can almost calculate the moment when the unemployed losing patience will take their own fate into their own hands.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p6.htmAfter this is Bukharin's failed prophecy (1914):
<the capitalist organism continues to be subject to its periodical convulsions, and only very simple people can still believe that capitalism can be cured with the aid of reformist patchwork. The historical mission of the bourgeoisie has already been fulfilled all over the world. It is now approaching its end.https://www.marxists.org/archive/bukharin/works/1927/leisure-economics/introduction.htmToo, Sombart terms "late capitalism" in 1925.
We have apparently had over a century of "late capitalism":
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disconfirmed_expectancy >>2944223and they were right, we live now in bourgeois socialism chud
>>2944223love also how you leave out this part:
>study led to the conclusion that, at least in Europe, England is the only country where the inevitable social revolution might be effected entirely by peaceful and legal means. He certainly never forgot to add that he hardly expected the English ruling classes to submit, without a “pro-slavery rebellion,” to this peaceful and legal revolutionergo fascism, ww1 and ww2, october revolution etc…
>>2944238>bourgeois socialism?
>>2944240>october revolutionMarx also thought socialism came out of capitalism, not feudalism.
Marx only saw England as potentially revolutionarty in a deterministic manner. As per the article I linked on failed prophecy, you either accept that Marx was wrong, or you live in cognitive dissonance.
>>2944241>?communist manifesto, describing the welfare state
>Marx also thought socialism came out of capitalism, not feudalism. Marx only saw England as potentially revolutionarty in a deterministic manner. As per the article I linked on failed prophecy, you either accept that Marx was wrong, or you live in cognitive dissonance.no, especially not in the case of Russia, since he theorized the communal system could serve as a base for socialism, actually read Marx for once
>deterministicso incorrect infact i would question your sanity
>read muh wiki article on failed prophecynot relevant
>>2942995>It's insane how everything Marx said would happen is happening.<200 years laterYou know predictions are only useful within a certain timeframe right?
>>2944241Something i want to add: Marx and Engels were both overly optimistic regarding capitalist progress, however, not only did both major wars and the october revolution interfere in capitalist development but also old feudal relations, like for example in China, dampened it, meaning it was alot slower than they first assumed. This has more to with their bias towards analysing yurop and north american countries, both at the frontier of capitalist development than with a "faulty" analysis itself. They lost sight of the underdevelopment of much of the world at that time. Marx did try at one time to tackle this huge project but having read mostly anglo books thats gonna lead to some conclusion that leave out huge caveats.
>>2944248Christians still think their 2,000 year-old prophecies hold water.
>>2944256>overly optimisticRight, so they were incorrect.
That is all that has to be admitted.
>>2944244>welfare state is bourgeois socialismNowhere is this written. Cite exactly what you are referencing.
>the communal system could serve as a base for socialismYes, which as Marx writes, must still have a capitalist basis:
<Precisely because it is contemporaneous with capitalist production, the rural commune may appropriate all its positive achievements without undergoing its [terrible] frightful vicissitudes.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1881/zasulich/draft-1.htmMarx did not have in mind the feudal peasant commune, like you do.
Stop contradicting Marx and read him on his own terms.
>incorrectStrange how you accuse others of not reading Marx:
<these laws themselves, of these tendencies working with iron necessity towards inevitable results. The country that is more developed industrially only shows, to the less developed, the image of its own future.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p1.htmMarx sees that historical determinism is an "iron necessity".
>not relevantYou are a cultist who is cleaving to failed prophecies.
Christianity itself came from the same origin:
<The history of early Christianity has notable points of resemblance with the modern working-class movement.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894/early-christianity/ >>2944257>You are a cultist who is cleaving to failed prophecies.no argument
>these laws themselves, of these tendencies working with iron necessity towards inevitable results. The country that is more developed industrially only shows, to the less developed, the image of its own future.where is he wrong?
>Marx did not have in mind the feudal peasant commune, like you do.what other commune then he is talking about?
>only England was potentially revolutionary in a deterministic manner: that’s wrong. Marx/Engels expected revolution in the advanced countries generally; England was special because peaceful/legal means were conceivable there, and Marx immediately added he hardly expected the ruling classes to submit without a “pro-slavery rebellion.” its a prediction, yes, but very conditional
i do love that you not only leave out both world wars, but the revolutions in europe as a whole where the proleteriat lost, in similar fashion to the 1848/1849 revolutions
>>2944372>that’s wrong. Marx/Engels expected revolution in the advanced countries generally; England was special because peaceful/legal means were conceivable there,America as well.
>You know that the institutions, mores, and traditions of various countries must be taken into consideration, and we do not deny that there are countries – such as America, England, and if I were more familiar with your institutions, I would perhaps also add Holland – where the workers can attain their goal by peaceful means. >>2944257>Yes, which as Marx writes, must still have a capitalist basis:<Precisely because it is contemporaneous with capitalist productioncontemporaneous means "concurrent", "alongside", "at the same time" english is not even my native language, how the hell do you make such an error? in that quote he doesnt even imply that lmao
>>2944372>no argumentSelf-evidence is not argumentative.
>where is he wrong? By the continuity in what he writes – that the continent follows in line with England, and that England is on the brink of revolution. Marx saw that the revolution would begin in England, then on mainland Europe:
<In England the process of social disintegration is palpable. When it has reached a certain point, it must react on the Continent.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p1.htm<what other commune then he is talking about?You tell me to "actually read Marx for once", but you're clearly ignorant of the point you want to even make. You're a very dishonest person. As I have directly quoted, Marx sees that the commune in Russia can only become revolutionary where it adopts capitalist conditions, e.g. machinery in production, and so on. Marx saw socialism developing out of capitalism – this is an entirely non-controversial point.
>Marx/Engels expected revolution in the advanced countries generallyAnd it never happened. It only happened in undeveloped countries.
At least you are admitting their prophecies failed.
>similar fashion to the 1848/1849 revolutionsThose were revolutions against the aristocracy, not the proletariat…
The basis of Free Trade in England (e.g. Corn Law abolition) has this as its precept, and so on. But tell me, what losses did the proletariat suffer from the revolutions of 1848/9?
>>2944382You haven't read the text so you don't understand it.
Nowhere does Marx say that Communism can come from feudalism.
You're an amateur. You throw shit and hopes something sticks.
>>2944386>At least you are admitting their prophecies failed.Engels admitted that.
>But history has shown us too to have been wrong, has revealed our point of view at that time as an illusion. It has done even more; it has not merely dispelled the erroneous notions we then held; it has also completely transformed the conditions under which the proletariat has to fight. The mode of struggle of 1848 is today obsolete in every respect, and this is a point which deserves closer examination on the present occasion.
>History has proved us wrong, and all who thought like us. It has made it clear that the state of economic development on the Continent at that time was not, by a long way, ripe for the elimination of capitalist production; it has proved this by the economic revolution which, since 1848, has seized the whole of the Continent, and has caused big industry to take real root in France, Austria, Hungary, Poland and, recently, in Russia, while it has made Germany positively an industrial country of the first rank — all on a capitalist basis, which in the year 1848, therefore, still had a great capacity for expansion.But really it wasn't a matter of prophecy for them. They were actually going out there and trying to do things and learning from their mistakes. Prophecy is the realm of the modern left who treat Communism like a religion and the "heads" writings as scripture.
But I post these quotes where they admit the errors of their previous statements after learning from experience, but I never even get a reply because if the pseuds acknowledged it, it would destroy their whole worldview.
>>2944396>Engels admitted that.Good.
>it wasn't a matter of prophecy for themIt was to Marx, who was attempting astrology:
<It is a question of these laws themselves, of these tendencies working with iron necessity towards inevitable results.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p1.htmThis talk of historical "laws", necessity, inevitability, etc.
Engels himself provides astrological speculation:
<we can almost calculate the momenthttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p6.htmEvidently, he couldn't actually read the stars.
Now, if only other Marxists could be more sceptical.
If only historical materialism was able to be reasonably criticised.
>it would destroy their whole worldview.These are the errors of seeking a "worldview" in the first place.
>>2944386>Zasulich you’re misreading “contemporaneous with capitalist production.” it means the commune coexists with capitalism. it does not mean it must adopt capitalist conditions. the sentence says the opposite: it may take capitalism’s achievements without its frightful vicissitudes.
>1882 prefacethe Russian path is conditional on Western revolution. not “communism from feudalism.” i never claimed that. strawman argument
>“Only happened in undeveloped countries”false. Germany 1918–19, Hungary 1919, Italy 1919–20, Spain 1936–39. advanced yurop, happened and lost
>1848not proletarian revolutions and i never claimed they were. workers did however lose: june days thousands killed and deported. sozialistengesetze in germany as a reaction to paris commune
insults are not arguments. cite the line where Marx says the commune “must become capitalist.” You haven’t.
>>2944401Well to me, learning from past mistakes and coming up with new hypotheses is what separates science from religion.
I like Lenin's NEP speech too.
>Why? Because our previous economic policy, if we cannot say counted on (in the situation then prevailing we did little counting in general), then to a certain degree assumed—we may say uncalculatingly assumed—that there would be a direct transition from the old Russian economy to state production and distribution on communist lines.
>At that time, when in the heat of the Civil War we had to take the necessary steps in economic organisation, it seemed to have been forgotten. In substance, our New Economic Policy signifies that, having sustained severe defeat on this point, we have started a strategical retreat. We said in effect: “Before we are completely routed, let us retreat and reorganise everything, but on a firmer basis. “ If Communists deliberately examine the question of the New Economic Policy there cannot be the slightest doubt in their minds that we have sustained a very severe defeat on the economic front. In the circumstances it is inevitable, of course, for some people to become very despondent, almost panic-stricken, and because of the retreat, these people will begin to give way to panic. That is inevitable. When the Red Army retreated, was its flight from the enemy not the prelude to its victory? Every retreat on every front, however, caused some people to give way to panic for a time. But on each occasion—on the Kolchak front, on the Denikin front, on the Yudenich front, on the Polish front and on the Wrangel front—once we had been badly battered (and sometimes more than once) we proved the truth of the proverb: “A man who has been beaten is worth two who haven’t.” After being beaten we began to advance slowly, systematically and cautiously.
>The surplus-food appropriation system in the rural districts—this direct communist approach to the problem of urban development—hindered the growth of the productive forces and proved to be the main cause of the profound economic and political crisis that we experienced in the spring of 1921. That was why we had to take a step which from the point of view of our line, of our policy, cannot be called anything else than a very severe defeat and retreat. Moreover, it cannot be said that this retreat is—like retreats of the Red Army—a completely orderly retreat to previously prepared positions. True, the positions for our present retreat were prepared beforehand. That can be proved by comparing the decisions adopted by our Party in the spring of 1921 with the one adopted in April 1918, which I have mentioned. The positions were prepared beforehand; but the retreat to these positions took place (and is still taking place in many parts of the country) in disorder, and even in extreme disorder.
>During the past four years we have fought many hard battles and we have learnt that it is one thing to fight hard battles and another to talk about them—something onlookers particularly indulge in. We must learn to ignore all this ideology, all this chatter, and see the substance of things. And the substance is that the fight will be even more desperate and fiercer than the fight we waged against Kolchak and Denikin. That fighting was war, something we were familiar with. There have been wars for hundreds, for thousands of years. In the art of human slaughter much progress has been made.We Must Not Count On Going Straight To Communism
>…The difficulty lies in creating personal incentive. We must also give every specialist an incentive to develop our industry.
>Have we been able to do that? No, we have not! We thought that production and distribution would go on at communist bidding in a country with a declassed proletariat. We must change that now, or we shall be unable to make the proletariat understand this process of transition. No such problems have ever arisen in history before. We tried to solve this problem straight out, by a frontal attack, as it were, but we suffered defeat. Such mistakes occur in every war, and they are not even regarded as mistakes. Since the frontal attack failed, we shall make a flanking movement and also use the method of siege and undermining.
<(in the situation then prevailing we did little counting in general), then to a certain degree assumed—we may say uncalculatingly assumed<Such mistakes occur in every war, and they are not even regarded as mistakes. <We must learn to ignore all this ideology, all this chatter, and see the substance of things.Even Lenin can admit mistakes in Leninism but modern communists are incapable.
>>2944401>He feels himself obliged to metamorphose my historical sketch of the genesis of capitalism in Western Europe into an historico-philosophical theory of general development, imposed by fate on all peoples…”— Marx to the editors of Otechestvenniye Zapiski, 1877 (link)
Marx himself says the “fate on all peoples” reading is imposed on him.
>According to the materialist conception of history, the ultimately determining element in history is the production and reproduction of real life. More than this neither Marx nor I have ever asserted. Hence if somebody twists this into saying that the economic element is the only determining one, he transforms that proposition into a meaningless, abstract, senseless phrase.”— Engels to Joseph Bloch, 21 September 1890
on crude determinist/religious reading which your supposed argument rests upon
>Marx’s whole world outlook is not a doctrine, but a method. It provides not ready-made dogmas, but points of departure for further investigation and the method for this investigation.”— Engels to Werner Sombart, 11 March 1895
the method becomes its opposite when used as a ready-made formula
>Our conception of history is above all a guide to study, not a lever for construction after the manner of the Hegelians.”— Engels to Conrad Schmidt, 5 August 1890 (link)
both warn against treating it as a closed system.
>What is certain is that I myself am not a Marxist.”— Marx, as reported by Engels to Eduard Bernstein, 2–3 November 1882 (link)
>>2944410It's just simple dogmatism.
>>2944405>>2944419>the commune coexists with capitalism. it does not mean it must adopt capitalist conditionsThen this plainly contradicts historical materialism.
Maybe you are right, but this only makes Marx and Engels wrong.
If the proletariat as a class is not prerequisite for Communism, then all of the hogwash about "progress" by brutality is bullshit. Engels:
<In order to create the modern revolutionary class of the proletariat it was absolutely necessary to cut the umbilical cord which still bound the worker of the past to the land. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1872/housing-question/ch01.htm<Without the slavery of antiquity no modern socialism.https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/ch16.htm>Marx to the editorMarx hated criticism and never owned up to it. We can read this:
<Nowhere do I speak of “the common social substance of exchange-value”https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1881/01/wagner.htmNowhere? We can read it quite plainly here:
<substance of the exchange-valuehttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htmI don't believe there's a single place where Marx apologises – certainly never for the confusion he brings to his readers, or loyal followers:
<Just as Marx used to say, commenting on the French "Marxists" of the late [18]70s: "All I know is that I am not a Marxist."https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1890/letters/90_08_05.htmLike all great men, he was troubled.
>if somebody twists this into saying that the economic element is the only determining one, he transforms that proposition into a meaningless, abstract, senseless phraseAccording to Engels, slavery is necessary as a precept to socialism. Engels was much less brilliant than Marx in everything he did, but we must still thank him for posthomously publishing Marx's work.
>a ready-made formulaBut you already agreed to the formula by saying Marx said nothing wrong, in asserting that the less developed follows the more developed. Or do you no longer believe in historical materialism, now?
>What is certain is that I myself am not a Marxist.Right. If Marxism wasn't good enough for Marx, why should people call themselves Marxists at all? Christ wasn't a "Christian", etc.
Revolutionaries should treat Marx and Kapital, the same way biologists treat Darwin and Origins, or physicists treat Newton and Principia.
>>2944461>Why does Marx have to be an infallible prophet Because people base their entire identities on him and call themselves "marxists".
Not everything. He detailed a useful framework to analyse human socio-economic systems, yes. And it is useful still today. The main one is determinism, but marxism (well, historical materialism) can be made indeterministic. Determinism was in vogue in Marx's time. It's like the geologists in the 19th using sediments to guess that the Earth must be older than the Bible said. And estimating around millions of years. After the discovery of radioactivity, we could learn that the Earth is actually much older, billions. So anthropology hasn't made the paradigm of Historical Materialism obsolete, it has updated it. There isn't a lot written cause many "marxists" aren't interested in political economy, just "politics" or "economy".
>>2944484yeah tbqh I don't give a shit about economy
>>2944494But economy isn't a science. Politics isn't either. The science is Political Economy.
>>2944505yeah tbqh I don't give a shit about political economy either
Unique IPs: 22