[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


File: 1793488207860-8.png (1.19 MB, 2048x1041, ClipboardImage.png)

 

What is the point of pretending that nation-states are an organic and useful political project in the modern world? Lenin most famously promised nations of Russian empire independence (with some tactical considerations, mostly regarding colonies). Not every swampy town with dozen people automatically has some god given right to secede and form a new country as long as they fight for it, nor should we applaud it.

Europe and Persian Gulf has many sorry mistakes of countries with around million people, not a hint of economic independence, no real military, no influence, only real political "independence" is to choose who they vassalize themselves to, and if they choose poorly the people will pay the price. The current UN system insists (thanks to historic precedence) that they should be treated mostly the same as world superpowers in international affairs. Most of eastern Europe is full of this "small business owner" tier of a country.

I'm not arguing against people's right to govern themselves or local governance. But to me it's obvious that this is one major fault in current world politics. Many countries in UN are literally just extra votes for one superpower or another, bought and paid for by financial dependence and assistance. How do we remedy this? Restructuring or collapse of the UN system is coming in the not so far future. People are talking that security council does not represent the actual balance of power anymore while it includes countries like France and UK, but excludes countries like India, Brazil and Iran. People don't look at the issue of small countries and their minuscule and still outsizes influence that creates distortions and makes it even harder to move forward in international affairs. Not to speak of the inefficiencies it creates when every mini and micro state has it's own laws, social services, police, etc (because that makes them a state). In many places the differences between countries are minuscule and are already eroding by cooperation between countries. European federation would make sense to me if in practice all the people pushing it wouldn't be the fucking EU and liberal closeted fascists and idiots.

>>2943062
at least one advantage is that is one of the state makes a bad decision or passes some shitty law all of the other states doesn't automatically have to follow it

>>2943071
How does this differentiate from arguing that power in city and municipal level should be maximized because the top level government can fuckup? Also the worst and most harmful and suicidal national legislations and policies are usually pushed by foreign entities and smallest countries are usually too weak to say no.

>>2943062
imagine being a bong on airstip 1

File: 1793502321732-0.jpg (63.92 KB, 290x379, IMG_9615.jpg)

>>2943062
>I'm not arguing against people's right to govern themselves or local governance.
I am. How are we supposed to achieve communism if these reactionary morons who have been Stockholm Syndrome'd into believing that the ideas of the ruling class is "their culture"? Or even worse, the dumb shit their inbred monarchs from hundreds of years ago forced onto them onto pain of death and torture is "their culture"? Don't even get me started on religion. It's nonsense. Federalism is just an excuse to let heckin' wholesome local flavored bourgeoisie continue their dominance over the local population.
>European federation would make sense to me if in practice all the people pushing it wouldn't be the fucking EU and liberal closeted fascists and idiots.
Like you said, it would be one thing if people could realize that their culture is fake and forced onto them, but the prolecattle with fight and die to the last breath for their masters because it's all they know. We would have to destroy all remnants of bourgeois culture first for us to even begin discussing this.

I agree, Canada should be annexed ASAP.

>>2943157
Why stop at Canada? The US already rules a Spanish speaking population in Puerto Rico, so why should Mexico or any other Latin American country exist?

How about no nation-states?

>>2943239
imagine

>>2943157
MURICA FUCK YEAH!! EVERY COUNTRY WILL BE A U.S. STATE, GO TO MARS IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT

>>>/libpol/

Why do people have a right to a state? Was Lenin an idealist for this?

>>2943062
It's just an underlying default assumption and conceit that everyone goes along with. The point of pretending is that it's a collective delusion that everyone shares.
The solution is not to unify more, but optimally, to break up or devolve more power. (the distinction doesn't really matter). Most should be governed as locally as possible. The inefficiencies of duplicating laws, services, police, etc, are nothing compared to the inefficiencies that spring up when an entire country level institution goes bad. The UK is one big worked example of what a farce it is when you have most decisions for 60 million people made in London, complete with its own inbuilt worked example of what happens when you push power even a little bit locally. Scotland and Wales have many of the same problems as Northern England, but they have local assemblies and Northern England doesn't… and as a result, their public services are much better, usually at lower cost! Because London doesn't care or makes bad decisions.

This wasn't always the case, either. Local councils and other local institutions in the north were strong until Thatcher embarked on a massive project of centralisation, destroying council autonomy (as well as no small amount of private industry etc that gave the north a separate economic power-base.) although the 1940s nationalisations didn't help either, not because they were taking things into public ownership, but because that public ownership meant central administration from london. that caused its own problems, but the biggest one was then that all it took was one bad set of ideas to take hold in London for everything to go to hell… Today, Britain is the most centralised country in Europe and, not surprisingly, Leeds is the largest city in Western Europe without a mass transit system…

>>2943080
It doesn't.
All power should be devolved more or less as locally as possible. You can have some central redistribution mechanisms if you want, but actual delivery should be locally accountable. e.g. in the UK, hospitals are controlled centrally, or by geographic health boards which are only answerable to central government, which means they are in practice completely unaccountable. If local councils (which are still too big in many cases, but are an obvious existing institution you could hand things to) ran their local hospitals, you'd immediately be able to go: right, it's literally impossible to get seen for condition X in locale Y, fix this or I won't vote for you again.
(e.g. for an actual example: the waiting list for a first appointment for a transgender person in glasgow is 200+ years. this was raised in Glasgow council, who were powerless to do anything about it, but it has never been raised in the Edinburgh parliament that actually runs healthcare, or the London parliament that actually runs the entire country, because both of those can always talk about a bigger issue. Glasgow has a geographic health board, but it is not funded by or accountable to Glasgow council, so the problem goes unsolved.)
Councils could also make different decisions about the relative trade-offs of different policies (e.g. an area with lots of young people may spend less on healthcare, more on education, and an area with lots of older people can do the inverse), or try new things: if an experiment is a disaster, only one area is impacted rather than the whole country. If an idea is good, other places can copy it.

Local governments should, effectively, compete with one another to be the nicest place to live and people should move between them freely. In principle I would even expand this to areas like legislation around public morality and so on. Want a nudist local authority? Fine, good! Don't like it - just move!
The main counterargument would be that none of these entities is strong enough to stand up to large companies or whatever, but national governments are already entirely uninterested in that and the idea that this will change in the short to medium term is a fantasy. (Of course, the idea they'll give up power to councils is also a fantasy, but relative realism always makes the fantasy more interesting.) In principle, one would expect more democratic accountability at lower levels. A council may not be able to totally change the policies of large companies, but it could impose some limited conditions in exchange for planning permission for those that want premises. A council could always undercut those conditions, but the council would still be accountable to voters, and so on.
(The reason councils would be accountable, as I've not yet said it explicitly, is because you're talking far fewer people. A councillor may only get about a thousand votes, while an MP gets tens of thousands. Tens of "I won't vote for you again, dickhead" e-mails are a joke to an MP and a serious problem for a councillor.)

>>2943271
how are you going to dispossess porky's assets when he can move from Town A to Town B and keep all his shit?

>>2943112
>I am. How are we supposed to achieve communism if these reactionary morons who have been Stockholm Syndrome'd into believing that the ideas of the ruling class is "their culture"? Or even worse, the dumb shit their inbred monarchs from hundreds of years ago forced onto them onto pain of death and torture is "their culture"? Don't even get me started on religion. It's nonsense. Federalism is just an excuse to let heckin' wholesome local flavored bourgeoisie continue their dominance over the local population
based and arguably the authentic™ position

>>2943271
its impressive how confident you are in being this wrong
>Today, Britain is the most centralised country in Europe and, not surprisingly, Leeds is the largest city in Western Europe without a mass transit system…
kek, delusional

>>2943273
You take the MoP. Those are far less easy to move and matter far more.

>>2943263
>Why do people have a right to a state? Was Lenin an idealist for this?
He mainly talked about fighting the 'great Russian chauvinism' basically idea of russian-superiority in the wake of Russian empire over the outlying nations, which was just a subset of great power chauvinism of every empire. In general it was basically the right of colonial-states to secede from any empire. In Russian context every nation should have the right, but not all should secede, or every russian region to just fragment into billion statelets. I understand that Ukrainian SSR for example was formed out of this basis, or was allowed to.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1914/self-det/index.htm

>>2943062
cultural-national autonomy is fundamentally Zionist and incompatible with marxism. just read lenin to understand the true significance of the amalgamation of nations

>rights

>>2943112
>I am. How are we supposed to achieve communism if these reactionary morons who have been Stockholm Syndrome'd into believing that the ideas of the ruling class is "their culture"?
we're not. people have an inherent fear and disgust of the foreign and the different. multi-national countries never worked and never will.

>>2943273
Nobody's going to do that anyway in the short to medium term (the same question arises on the national level as well, incidentally.), but in the broadest case: porky has to live somewhere and in Britain it isn't traditional to build the kind of house that you can pick up and move elsewhere. Factories are even harder to move though admittedly the machinery in them is not. But beautifully, porky can't just leave entirely: you can have a pretty high tax are and so long as it's still profitable or break even, porky will still have shops there. (Though we can imagine an area experimenting with municipal coops etc too)
One can in any case imagine a large cross-council socialist revolution if they like. What's that phrase again - all power to the… Something…
>>2943282
Not at all delusional. 95% of UK tax revenue goes to Westminster. Even in the devolved administrations power is centralized in Edinburgh and Cardiff. The next most centralized country in the G7, italy, is half as centralized as the UK. Leeds does not have a mass transit system. It has been trying to build a team for nearly 30 years and frustrated at every turn by central control. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leeds_Supertram
https://www.centreforcities.org/reader/fiscal-devolution-for-london/the-uk-is-very-fiscally-centralised-limiting-growth/
https://economy2030.resolutionfoundation.org/reports/centralisation-nation/

>>2943366
Early capitalism required nation states to have a single internal market and unified language and legislation, etc to grow. Now mature capitalist system requires free trade, free movement of capital and people, monoculture to expand capital abroad. Wouldn't socialist/industrial capitalism require the death of small states and birth of larger political entities to facilitate production/capital expansion. The actual state power in smaller to medium states even if not captured by liberals is veining from small states anyway thanks to global trade.

Multi-national states have the issue that when times get tough and the center of power can't reach the periphery, the periphery will usually get the fuck out if it can and it can gain benefit from doing so. The fault lines are somewhat baked in the national and regional lines if there is no economic co-dependence or something.

>>2943366
you forgot your flag fren

>>2943413
Lenin argues that national liberation struggle is precisely how to achieve this. It kind of worked in the USSR and China. IMO it didn't really work in Africa.

>>2943383
kek, you literally just reposted a new burnham policy. Repackaged neoliberalism

>>2943782
  1. I was posting about this before Burnham became PM.
  2. He's unlikely to follow through on it, although I'll give some credit if he does. He's a fraud, although a fraud who at least does the bare minimum and pretends to be doing something.
  3. The idea it's repackaged neoliberalism is funny but I'm not telling you why. If you read /leftybritpol/ more, you'd know and be in on the joke.

>>2943062
>Fuck the Balts - Thread

OP is a Tamiloid

>>2945585
I dont mind small 1million population countries.
I mind them a lot when they use their small size as an excuse to be ultra-nationalist, overtly fascist, and refuse any compromise or negotiation.

so yeah, fuck da baltiKKKs

>>2943062
While I agree that states should merge getting rid of small ones fixes nothing.

>>2946980
it's a material process, agreeing or disagreeing wont change shit

>>2946980
>>2946987
Yeah, whole baltic statelets' existence is propped by Washington neocons and Nato.

If we assume a country is dependent on external help for it's defense and existence, then the long term destiny for them is either vassalage and then absorption or invasion. Now their liege is Nato and EU if that ever goes away, then countries with third of their population already russians are gonna get absorbed back into Russian orbit quite fast, even without any Russian state's use of force or subterfuge. Even peace with Russia is a threat to countries like the Baltics and their so called independence..

>>2949864
>Now their liege is Nato and EU if that ever goes away, then countries with third of their population already russians are gonna get absorbed back into Russian orbit quite fast, even without any Russian state's use of force or subterfuge.
they could always deport russians to russia


Unique IPs: 21

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]