[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


 

Do some of you still find the concept of the Old Left, particularly those who hold socially conservative views while maintaining economically left-wing or anti-capitalist positions, politically foreign or difficult to reconcile with contemporary left-wing politics in America?

I'm asking this because a little while ago, a person sent me a message saying that the concept of socially conservative leftists was somewhat foreign to them, as the variation of leftism that most people here are exposed to tends to incorporate both economically left-wing and socially progressive values. Initially, they assumed an inherent contradiction between being socially conservative and economically left-wing, since the two are often treated as politically incompatible in contemporary American politics.

However, historically, that hasn't always been the case, especially when you look at older generations of leftists, traditional labor movements, and socialist movements outside the Western world(e.g., Christians for National Liberation (CNL) in the Philippines, Nyerere's Ujamaa in Tanzania, Nasserism in Egypt, and Ba'athist Arab socialism in Iraq, etc.), where anti-capitalist economic positions have often coexisted with socially conservative attitudes toward religion, family structures, gender roles, etc.

I grew up in this tradition, as did my father and his father before him (none of whom were particularly religious, btw). The men in my life believed that a post-capitalist society would still need socially conservative values in order to promote a functional collective because, say, for example, if you're trying to build a society around collective ownership and mutual responsibility, how exactly would that society function if everyone prioritized their individual desires over their obligations to their families and communities?

From their perspective, simply abolishing capitalism wouldn't mitigate selfishness or the tendency to prioritize personal interests over the collective good. They believed that traditional family structures, intergenerational obligations, and certain cultural expectations helped cultivate the sense of responsibility necessary for a socialist society to function. In other words, economic collectivism needed to be accompanied by a social and cultural framework that encouraged people to place the well-being of their communities above their individual interests. My father isn't a campist either, and he doesn't believe leftists should automatically defend authoritarian governments because they oppose Western imperialism; his social conservatism is rooted more in his connection to our culture and his desire to preserve cultural continuity and collective responsibility across the generations.

Since migrating here in my youth, I've obviously adopted many socially progressive values that differ from those of my father, grandfather, and my entire hometown. However, my support for these values largely comes from my belief that people shouldn't be forced to adhere to traditional cultural expectations simply because they're considered essential to maintaining social cohesion or preserving cultural identity. I tend to view it through an analogy where a particular therapeutic modality might be appropriate for one person but not necessarily for another. Just because someone finds a culturally conservative life meaningful or fulfilling doesn't mean we should assume that everyone else would benefit from following that same path.

But I digress. Do some of you still find socially conservative leftists hard to wrap your head around, or is this something you're already familiar with
89 posts and 8 image replies omitted.

>>2945359
that's right brother. nazbol gang rise up

>>2945359
>Marxism is when you dickride a bourgeoisie

>>2944695
>Do some of you still find the concept of the Old Left, particularly those who hold socially conservative views while maintaining economically left-wing or anti-capitalist positions,
Never seen it, outside of a few fringe microparties/glorified cults who are not worth wasting a single thought on.
>politically foreign or difficult to reconcile with contemporary left-wing politics in America?
Stopped reading here. Fuck off to /USApol/.

>>2944710
>Revolutionaries will succeed because they enjoy mass support
False. Majority isn't needed. Just enough

>>2944710
it's really not hard to understand tbh. the masses are homophobic, transphobic, etc. etc. so anyone wishing to utilize the power of harnessing the masses must appeal to their id

>>2945522
no one thinks less of the common people than the slopulist

>>2944734
>When Stalin
Dumbass lmao

>>2944695
Families can be a source of practical solidarity, of course. But neoliberal ideologues argued that the family was the bedrock of their system, too.
Mrs. Thatcher in Britain famously said that there was no such thing as society, just individuals and families.
Then she died alone and senile in, I think Claridges might have been the hotel.

But what could replace the family? Cool people on the internet, present anon company excepted, are just going to want your money. Or leverage the attention into mediocre acting or screenwriting careers. Sorry if that's mean, it's still better than a normal job.
Even new age travellers their own hierarchies. You need your own van or you're a hobo.

Test

File: 1793907706140-1.webp (58.62 KB, 764x1044, licensed-image.webp)

>>2944695
It's quite simple what they believe: "Destroy the homosexuals — and liberalism will disappear."

>>2945317
>>2945317
>really, though, when socialist states try to compete on the (anarchic, capitalist) global market you end up with really weird revisionist shit like NEP, dengism, etc. given the level of authority these governments had it is rather odd that they felt the need to cooompete with outsiders in the first place.

No amount of abstract "authority" can change the fact that when you establish "socialism" in a single country, you still exist in a hostile world market, surrounded by enemies, and are reliant upon imports to maintain your current standard of living.

>>2944695
>e.g., Christians for National Liberation (CNL) in the Philippines, Nyerere's Ujamaa in Tanzania, Nasserism in Egypt, and Ba'athist Arab socialism in Iraq, etc.), where anti-capitalist economic positions have often coexisted with socially conservative attitudes toward religion,
Lol your post was more interesting until this point. Yes the social conservatism of "classical MLs" is interesting. "Socially conservative attitudes towards religion." Classical communism has no compatibility with religion and believing in nonsense mythology. That said, I think it would probably be better to take the liberal approach and let religion and mysticism die off naturally through education rather than outright banning it. Heavily restrict it and give it no play in the political sphere but treat it as "let people have fun" just like whatever liberal hedonistic nonsense as well.

>From their perspective, simply abolishing capitalism wouldn't mitigate selfishness or the tendency to prioritize personal interests over the collective good. They believed that traditional family structures, intergenerational obligations, and certain cultural expectations helped cultivate the sense of responsibility necessary for a socialist society to function.

I do think there is something to it and that communist culture wouldn't and doesn't value hedonism and individual "self-expression" so much as we have in our nihilistic liberal capitalist societies of today. I think there is some value in traditional "conservative" culture, but definitely not religion and not persecution of people who are LGBTQ or whatever who I think most people now accept are a fact of life.

File: 1794373489521-5.jpg (806.52 KB, 2048x1406, IMG_9664.jpg)

>>2952471
To expand more on what I mean by nihilism and individualism(atomization) is the culture that is widely celebrated in the west. The outlaw, the rebel, who breaks the rules simply for the sake of it. They litter, destroy society around them, destroy other people, destroy themselves, live fast die young, criminality. All these things are celebrated because they are the pinnacle of the empty soul of capitalism. Nothing matters anyway, why not impact the world as much as you can even if it's all negative? I don't think it is compatible with social cohesion, or socialism.

>Ignorance–for it has never entered the head of any socialist to “promise” that the higher phase of the development of communism will arrive; as for the greatest socialists’ forecast that it will arrive, it presupposes not the present ordinary run of people, who, like the seminary students in Pomyalovsky’s stories,[2] are capable of damaging the stocks of public wealth “just for fun", and of demanding the impossible.


So yes, I believe in freedom of the individual, and other liberal shibboleths, but I think that a better way will be encouraged both in the actual material framework of society and in the culture promoted by it.

>>2944695
>Do some of you still find the concept of the Old Left, particularly those who hold socially conservative views while maintaining economically left-wing or anti-capitalist positions, politically foreign or difficult to reconcile with contemporary left-wing politics in America?

That left-wing is fake, it's literally a psyop by the USSR to gain loyalty, trust, and willingness to fight from the people after a series of failed attempts at creating a communist society directly after the revolution. This included abolishing the family, forcefully separating them, forcing people into orgies, getting people to use as much drugs as possible etc. Ultimately the stopped after the navy started to revolt over rations. Social conservative socialism doesn't exist, none of it is seen as good by any of marxist intellectual, and it's just a lie communist regimes put forward to stabilize, stall or buy time until the social fabric has been reformed enough.

>>2952544
>That left-wing is fake, it's literally a psyop by the USSR to gain loyalty, trust, and willingness to fight from the people after a series of failed attempts at creating a communist society directly after the revolution.
Blehh,
>This included abolishing the family,
This is Engel's term
>forcefully separating them, forcing people into orgies, getting people to use as much drugs as possible etc.
nah I don't think he was into that even.
>Social conservative socialism doesn't exist, none of it is seen as good by any of marxist intellectual, and it's just a lie communist regimes put forward to stabilize, stall or buy time until the social fabric has been reformed enough.
Can't even parse this sentence.

>>2944772
I agree if you advocate for Chinese social policies in the West you'll be laughed out of the room (or called a fascist).

What would compel you to be socially conservative though and why? God isn't real and identity politics are just the rich man's trick to take the heat off the billionaires' backs and onto a poor ethnic or sexual/gender minority, who ever is the scapegoat of the decade.

>>2952672
There are plenty of reasons to be socially conservative that don't involve religion/god/etc.
>Harsh anti-drug policy
Results in population 99% free of drug addiction. See: China, Singapore, North Korea, etc.
>Pro-natalist/anti-abortion policy
Increases birth rates and prevents extinction of society. See: Stalinist USSR, Romania under Ceausescu.
>Anti porn/prostitution/etc.
Reduces revenue for criminal groups, focuses women on more productive fields See: Higher rate of women scientists in Eastern Bloc compared to the West.

File: 1794417362752-8.jpg (251.3 KB, 1200x1200, photo1jpg.jpg)

>>2945255
>Socialism isn't about "loyalty to class", it's about abolishing class society.
I think the main divide on the left about this is really about this. There are people who want to have some kind of imagined proletarian moral order or ideological fantasy as opposed to a classless society. It's a kind of reification where certain social attitudes, traditional gender roles, whatever are imagined as naturally or permanently proletarian and you have to reconstruct society around that.

What’s the actual point of gender roles when we don’t live on farms anymore? In a feudal context patriarchy makes practical sense. You marry one person so you know the kids are yours and it gets passed down to your first born when you die and the more kids you have the more labor you don’t have to do, they also take care of you as you age. For a proletarian a child is literally nothing but a burden for 40 years until you get old and hope they don’t throw you into a home. If your civilization is so fragile that someone taking estrogen or a cock up their ass rots it, your civilization was fragile trash in the forst place.

>>2952677
>Pro-natalist/anti-abortion policy
<Increases birth rates and prevents extinction of society. See: Stalinist USSR, Romania under Ceausescu

Ironic that those societies are extinct, or maybe it's just the inevitable fate of social conservatives

"Socially conservative" in the west in 2026 is LARP, and not even a succesful one. It's only an excuse for various type of libertines to enact sadistic measures on transgenders only since it's barely anti-gay or anti-feminist anymore, it is completely out of steam and have zero moral or popular legitimacy.
I would argue it is also a dead meme in most developped countries, just look at their TFR.

>>2952677
China has a trillion dollar alcohol industry, alcohol is a drug, one of the deadliest too, you can’t be “anti-drug” and pro alcohol, that’s hypocrisy, contradiction.

>>2952710
Has there been an agricultural society without alcohol? Seems very lindy.

>>2952701
Actually if you look at the stats, the liberal Russian Federation birthrate is below the Soviet birthrate and capitalist Romania has a lower birthrate than socialist Romania. Clearly capitalism is driving both countries towards extinction.
>>2952710
>Alcohol is a drug
The cope made by all druggies. Alcohol is not and has never historically been considered a drug by virtually any country.

File: 1794509432571-5.jpg (254.91 KB, 1125x1614, 493wjqg7e8ca1.jpg)

>socially conservative
>socially progressive
But what exactly do these terms mean?
The USSR decriminalised homosexuality in 1917, decades before the so-called Liberal West, but it's not as if the USSR also had Pride Parades; that is a Western, anti-social invention, since as it is said, "Stonewall was a riot", literally and figuratively. What is "progressive" is that which embraces individualism, simply. It is not an orientation to civil rights, but either a pro-social or anti-social attitude toward the very fabric of public morality. The interesting reversal occurs though, where vice becomes virtue, and so to be conservative is to appear as threatening the "new" public morality, where it is really a restoration. My advice is to have a bit of self-respect. Don't be such a whore.

>>2953312
it's almost like birthrates have nothing to do with capitalism vs socialism and are, instead, a function of other factors. the Congo has one of the highest birth rates in the world, and that's not because they've built AES!

>>2952481
>The outlaw, the rebel, who breaks the rules simply for the sake of it. They litter, destroy society around them, destroy other people, destroy themselves, live fast die young, criminality. All these things are celebrated because they are the pinnacle of the empty soul of capitalism. Nothing matters anyway, why not impact the world as much as you can even if it's all negative?

Must…not…gigaquote…

>>2953412
Lol. I'm guessing you aspire to what I provide as the negative description. Let me say even more simply one of my simplest revelations. It is much easier to destroy than build. Only life can build. Inanimate things can destroy. Viruses and even inanimate chemicals and matter. I believe life is good and death is evil. I love life and hate death. This is the crux of "morality" I believe. This is the one living world that we know of in this infinite universe.

>>2953312
>aaaaah if I don't pump out 10 children per mom I will literally go extinct

>>2953396
>that is a Western, anti-social invention, since as it is said, "Stonewall was a riot", literally and figuratively. What is "progressive" is that which embraces individualism, simply. It is not an orientation to civil rights, but either a pro-social or anti-social attitude toward the very fabric of public morality.
Well "public morality" is hypocritical a lot. A lot of gay bars in the 1960s in American cities were seedy, illegal vice places run by organized crime. Stonewall was owned / operated by variously Gambino and Genovese mobsters who paid off the cops. It was also common for prostitution (in general) in American cities to operate via paying off the police, like funneling bribe money via bail bondsmen into police unions who'd then donate some funds to local political candidates. The more you know. In any case the going theory is the police raided Stonewall because they wanted to get paid, they'd padlock the doors and wait until the mob guy showed up and paid them so they'd remove the lock, and it turned into a riot unexpectedly because the patrons felt they were being harassed for no reason.

>>2953413
This is true as it goes, but stagnation is just living death. It's possible to blunder and make good on the "die young" in "live fast, die young", but if you're so focused on avoiding dying young that you forget to live at all, you've fallen into an even worse failure state. Death is, for now, inevitable, so it's important to actually live during your limited time on earth.
(Which fortunately, for most people, is less "do heroin" and more "learn to draw and stop worrying about your early work sucking", "make friends instead of sitting rotting retreading boring old arguments on imageboards", "accept that you're a homo/transsexual if you are… and embrace it instead of making yourself miserable for no reason", and so on…)

>>2953417
>Well "public morality" is hypocritical a lot
But public morality is public morality.
All human civilisations have codes of modesty, and so on.
If we instead say that people should treat the public space as a private space, you abolish the very concept of a public. Talk to most "conservatives" and what will they say? "Do what you want – in the privacy of your own bedroom".

>>2953413
>Only life can build. Inanimate things can destroy. Viruses and even inanimate chemicals and matter. I believe life is good and death is evil. I love life and hate death. This is the crux of "morality" I believe. This is the one living world that we know of in this infinite universe.
Its a good starting point I guess, but life isnt necessarily good by default and destruction is not bad by default. Life can be about suffering a lot of the time and to stop that suffering destruction is needed (im not talking kys).

Sure, life is for the living. I am for whatever promotes life and human beings are the greatest examples of life that we know of. I said before I do believe in the freedom of individuals. I personally am a drug user and like using drugs. I think people should have perfect freedom to use drugs as far as it doesn't interfere with anyone else(which can be a hard question with drug use, but the most ubiquitous drug, alcohol, is one of the worst drugs when it comes to interference with others' lives.)

>>2953422
>If we instead say that people should treat the public space as a private space, you abolish the very concept of a public.
A division between the public and private is an inherently alienated form of social relations though. You have a privatized aspect of your life that is split off from the public and it's this public space which then becomes some abstract moral community. That's bourgeois society and bourgeois "morality."

>Talk to most "conservatives" and what will they say? "Do what you want – in the privacy of your own bedroom".

Sure but that's because they're also pretty well known to have degenerate personal lives.

>>2953432
>A division between the public and private is an inherently alienated form of social relations though
Question; does a liberated society mean people shitting in public?
>You have a privatized aspect of your life that is split off from the public
Yes… If you don't believe in privacy, post a picture of yourself now or you're a hypocrite. We all know why you're posting anonymously.
>That's bourgeois society and bourgeois "morality."
It's literally been the code of every civilisation.
These stupid buzzwords like "bourgeois" prove your unoriginality.
>they're also pretty well known to have degenerate personal lives.
Yes, behind closed doors. It's called being decent and polite.

>>2953422
What I find ironic is that I have a "conservative" stance to conservatives. That is, I do not care if someone privately holds conservative views and beliefs, but I take issue when that information becomes public.

>>2953436
>It's literally been the code of every civilisation.
It absolutely is not. "Do what you want in the privacy of your own home" is a very specific morality to a very specific civilisation. Insofar as it exists outside that civilisation, it's almost entirely down to people not knowing what you get up to in private. Stop projecting familiar things backwards in time. People used to - and still do - engage in all sorts of utterly insane and alien cultural practices. The world isn't all mid-century America with the serial numbers filed off.

>>2953439
>It absolutely is not.
Not every civilisation has had a public space distinct from a private space? Show some examples.
>"Do what you want in the privacy of your own home" is a very specific morality to a very specific civilisation
What is the point of a private space if it isnt private?
For the majority of the history of human civilisation, the common folk did not care what you did in your spare time behind closed doors. It has only been the state which has politicised private morality, most especially in the capitalist period.

>>2953443
>For the majority of the history of human civilisation, the common folk did not care what you did in your spare time behind closed doors.
lmfao, this anon has never met a old woman

>>2953462
"old woman" is a modern concept, a few centuries old at most

>>2953443
i can tell in advance you're going to engage in sloppy thinking, blurring between a private/public distinction based on the relationship between the individual/family and wider public, and one based on the relationship between the individual/family/society and the state. i am not, therefore, convinced it's worth my time to go into the interesting ways in which other societies have been organised because you will simply try to shoehorn things into whatever definition is most convenient at the time. Why not define everything from the Eruv to the absolute insanity that happened inside single room multi family homes as "private" because state agents aren't present, and romans conducting state business from their personal houses as private, and shitting in communal lavatories as public, because that's easier for you than imagining that people who genuinely believe they're god's chosen people, who've got no other option than to live stacked a mile high, or who used to decide their military affairs by watching a chicken eat grains might've all thought differently to you.

but i suppose i've done it anyway.

>left: liberal reformcuck
>right: liberal reformcuck
Leftards really be searching for a lost cause lmao

>>2944695
>in America?
burger general

>>2953436
>Question; does a liberated society mean people shitting in public?
There are public restrooms.

>Yes… If you don't believe in privacy, post a picture of yourself now or you're a hypocrite. We all know why you're posting anonymously.

I believe in privacy and personal boundaries. You're not really engaging in my argument and are trying to get away from it by doing some personal gotcha thing.

>Yes, behind closed doors. It's called being decent and polite.

Sure. But then there's attempting to impose a hypocritical morality on everyone else. I'm not talking about having sex in public, but the people I'm talking about don't want to see same-sex couples holding hands in public. That's just an example but you see this all the time, they don't like it but find that behavior acceptable when it's between heterosexuals. Or just openly talking about relationships. There are different standards but one is held up as this universal "public morality" and if you stray from it then you should "keep it in your bedroom," but they don't. At the end of the day the actual relationship that they want to keep private is a social relationship split off from public life.

>These stupid buzzwords like "bourgeois" prove your unoriginality.

But it is bourgeois in a very precise way. It's not even conservative. This is the argument Marx makes in On the Jewish Question about the splitting between the individual and citizen in public life. It's true.

>>2952689
That makes sense because you cannot abolish class but you can create a new identity and attune culture and morality to it. I just wish people would be supportive of that instead of clinging to the fantasy of "muh classless society"

Immegernce of Fembois in our social strata is the best thing that ever happenned and I will not let any socially conservative moron say otherwise.

>>2953462
An old woman doesn't want to string you up.
>>2953465
Okay, so you give up trying to prove your incorrect point. Got it.
>>2953616
>public restrooms
These are fundamentally private spaces.
But again, tell me, does a Communist society mean people shitting in the street?
>I believe in privacy and personal boundaries
You mean you believe in an alienated state of existence?
You said that privacy entails alienation.
>hypocritical morality
Everyone in society is compelled to follow a public code.
>don't want to see same-sex couples holding hands in public.
So what? Until it is politicised, it's not an issue.
>different standards but one is held up as this universal "public morality"
It is universal. No one can stop you from holding hands.
>the actual relationship that they want to keep private is a social relationship
You have no consistency. Having sex is surely part of this partnership, yet you also say we shouldn't publicise it. You know the difference.
>the splitting between the individual and citizen in public life
You think we should have boundaries between the public and the private. You have no real disagreement with me yet posture a conflict.

>>2953752
people are hostile to that idea because if you're taking up socialism after marx's critique and you understand what you're talking about, you know that's not going to change that much if anything

>>2953794
  1. you make it too obvious you engage in bad faith
  2. your fingers should be broken off and fed to wild dogs for doing that ugly line-by-line gotcha reply style.


Unique IPs: 37

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]