>there is no israeli left
>there is no amerikkkan left
>there is no japanese left
all sentiments I have heard on leftypol over the past week. i ask you, are these sentiments truth nukes, or nationalist identitarian essentialism? and are these meant to be permanent statements, i.e. "there can be no [insert reactionary country] left" or is it meant to say that these countries are merely currently too reactionary to have a left, but might be able to have a left in the future. and is "left" here meant in the way that Bordigists mean it "left wing of capital" or does it mean "anti-capitalist left" as originally intended in the title of this website? do these countries have t be destroyed for there to be a left int hem, or would even that not be enough? and by "destroyed" do we mean literally every person nuked, or do we simply mean the destruction of their governments? and how to bring about the destruction of their governments without revolution if there can be no left within these countries? and what about class? do these countries not have a proletariat? do they not have proletarians? are they too statistically insignificant to matter? and if certain countries are simply too reactionary at the foundational core to have a proletariat, or a "left" then is not the primary contradiction national identity rather than class? try to answer the questions in good faith.
>who are you quoting
various anons, I have included 1 as an example
there is no left
>>2956274do you mean that ontologically or chronologically? as in "there can be no left" or "there isn't a left yet"
>>2956272japanese parliament has members of the communist party in it though
>>2956281is the communist party of japan actually communist in practice or is it one of those parties that members of this website would regard as revisionist, reactionary, liberal, settler-colonial and/or social democratic?
>>2956284its revisionist but the party has the word "communist" in its name so it's still better than in other liberal democracies where there is no communist party in parliament eh?
>nationalist identitarian essentialism
This. If you're truly a communist, you must be an internationalist and recognize that nations don't exist, and that in bourgeois wars there's no point in choosing sides, much less hating entire peoples.
>>2956294no it is not sarcastic
>>2956299ok - respectfully - thank you for clarifying
next query… why is it better to have communist in the name of a revisionist party than to have a revisionist party that is correctly labeled? doesn't that run the risk of giving people the wrong idea of what communism is, or making communism seem more electorally successful than it actually is?
>>2956304communism is a fairly intuitive thing to understand, it's just any movement which seeks to move toward the state described as "communism" in the works of marx, even if it happens to be revisionist in nature. because if you identify as a communist that implies that you won't back down until communism has been established since that's the end goal
the JCP is pretty based anyway:
>A staunchly anti-militarist party, the JCP firmly supports Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution and seeks to dissolve the Japan Self-Defense Forces. It opposes Japan's military alliance with the United States as an unequal relationship and infringement of Japan's national sovereignty. >>2956272Materialist critique is supposed to highlight that on an ontological level existing superstructure such as national idenitity came to and are limited to the material base. Therefore the measurable ultra reactionary false consciousness and lack of historical class conflict of [insert country here] outside of reformism should be understood to not just be dialectically a temporary state. For example, the material conditions for an industrial Japanese nation state that doesn't participate in imperialism or neo imperialism has never and will never exist due to its barren geology. Most bordigists and other idealists subscribe to historical amnesia and the belief that spiritual solidarity can somehow overcome decades of propaganda and the entrenched depotism designed to make backwards modes of productive more geopolitically competitive. Dialectically failure, collaspe, and sometimes even elimination of entire peoples and identity happened as historical progress synthesized by Marx.
>>2956306>communism is a fairly intuitive thing to understand, it's just any movement which seeks to move toward the state described as "communism" in the works of marx,aren't a lot of people convinced that communism is when starvation, gulags, no iphone, etc., and haven't even read a single word of marx?
> even if it happens to be revisionist in natureis it still seeking to establish communism even if it's revisionist?
>because if you identify as a communist that implies that you won't back down until communism has been established since that's the end goalisn't it possible for malicious groups to "identify" as communist publicly without actually being so?
<the JCP is pretty based anyway:>A staunchly anti-militarist party, the JCP firmly supports Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution and seeks to dissolve the Japan Self-Defense Forces. It opposes Japan's military alliance with the United States as an unequal relationship and infringement of Japan's national sovereignty.Thank you for sharing, that is interesting that they both want to keep the military suppressed but at the same time kick out the USA. How do they propose to do that?
>>2956309>For example, the material conditions for an industrial Japanese nation state that doesn't participate in imperialism or neo imperialism has never and will never exist due to its barren geologyso what should happen? Should Japan just become part of China? Also how can an island with barren geology sustainably commit imperialist crimes if they have no material basis for the superior productive forces that would enable them to maintain monopoly capital. How would they be able to maintain a stranglehold on external colonies without any internal source of productivity and strength? Russia for example has a stockpile of every element on the periodic table, which is why it is so resistant to sanctions, but it might not have gotten that without the eastward expansion, annexations, and ethnic cleansing of the Siberian indigenous peoples that took place under the tsars.
There are Israeli and Japanese proles
"USian proles" is an oxymoron doe
>>2956311>so what should happen? Should Japan just become part of China?Not even the Chinese themselves want that.
>Also how can an island with barren geology sustainably commit imperialist crimes if they have no material basis for the superior productive forces that would enable them to maintain monopoly capital. How would they be able to maintain a stranglehold on external colonies without any internal source of productivity and strength? They didn't which is why they were nuked into irrelevence. The Japanese can't even feed themselves which is why they are experiencing urban starvation due to the cost of imports going up.
>Russia for example has a stockpile of every element on the periodic table, which is why it is so resistant to sanctions, but it might not have gotten that without the eastward expansion, annexations, and ethnic cleansing of the Siberian indigenous peoples that took place under the tsars.The difference is that the Russians and Americans were actually successful with their goals and brought new material from Siberia and the new world into global circulation whereas the Japanese thought they could achieve the same on one of the centers of human civilization.
>>2956313I think I better understand what you were saying. The Russian conquest of siberia and American manifest destiny were historically progressive because they brought Siberian and Native American lands into the global economic circulation while Japan was merely trying to conquer a place that was already part of the world economy. They were late to the game.
>>2956314
>Russia's fate now and sooner or later America's is to become stagnant raw material extraction zones and for Chinese capital instead of revolution.
As an American I feel this coming. I wonder if we will balkanize into more EU-like countries.
>>2956313 (me)
To continue further the historical purpose of the Great Game and the Columbian exchange was to be more competitive with the superior productive output of other imperial powers. Overextension was never a sustainable model for human civilization that ran it's course which is why Russia's present fate and sooner or later America's to become stagnant raw material extraction zones and for Chinese capital instead of revolution from within.
It's probably true that there really cannot be an Israeli left so long as the colonization of Palestine is ongoing. Space for socialist consciousness would likely open up only with the defeat of the apartheid regime or else the eradication of the Palestinians.
I've met actual Israeli leftists. They're revolutionary defeatists who rightfully believe that their role in the world stage is to help destroy the state of Israel from within and stir as much inner turmoil as they can.
Israel does its best to hide its rebels to create a fake image a complete unity and thus look less vulnerable. In this way its no different from america. I've never met japanese leftists though but japanese people are bizarrely elusive online.
>>2956315That's not the only difference. It is signficant if you're bringing progress to a people without writing, statecraft, ironworks, sanitation, or sophisticated trade networks, vs trying to lord over civilizations which were at the forefront of humanity for thousands of years.
>>2956309Japan was already industrializing before any lordship over Korea or China, in fact they only won those territories because they managed to beat Russia in a war in 1905.
I mean why, with your logic, if industrial development is based exclusively on your access to natural resources, would it ever even be possible for Japan to overpower Korea at all?
>>2956323The Meiji restoration was overwelmingly sponsored by western capital with them importing ships and the means of production directly from Europe until they set up their own colonies. Japan was always propped as a distant imperial partner by the West to counter China/Russia in East Asia, not as an autonomous people.
>>2956272More often than not its "there can be no left in [country I actually live in]" since this is an imageboard and some people still feel a need to seek out moral justifications for being an anti-social shutin with a normie resentment complex. Anons will talk about the necessity of building a vanguard but then explain to you how it just so happens that every single person around them are actually lumpen or petty bourgeoisie o algo
>>2956325By “always” do you mean since the Meiji revolution? Was the Imjin war sponsored by Spain or something? How about the whole Tokugawa period where they only traded with the Dutch as they lost the imperial mantle to the UK?
>>2956341>By “always” do you mean since the Meiji revolution?I thought this was clear as the conversation was about the industrial era. And the Imjun war was a failure due to material circumstances as was mentioned previously.
Unique IPs: 11