[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


 

Someone posted this in the other thread about the right returning to intellectualism while the left succumbs to anti-intellectualism. Specifically, how the neoconservatives used to heavily rely on their own intellectuals for guidance when it came to crafting policies. Bucketloads of former students of Allan Bloom and Harvey Mansfield went to Washington where they implemented all sorts of neocon fuckery; meanwhile, Judith Butler's former students are all running soup kitchens and needle exchange programs in Oakland. The easy explanation for this is that the left has no real political power in America, so leftist intellectuals see no reason to strategically place their students into political positions.

Yet, given that the DSA has won several notable political victories in the past few years, one has to ask why they aren't relying on leftist (Marxist and anarchist) intellectuals to help them create and guide policies. For instance, why aren't DSA people using David Graeber's works on anthropology, bullshit jobs, etc. as inspiration for establishing localized economies and dealing with the overall soulless job culture? Why aren't DSA people openly consulting David Harvey or Richard Wolff to help them with their economic policies? Why isn't Judith Butler being invited to DSA meetings where she can advise people on gender issues and shit like abolishing the family? Or Mariame Kaba helping the DSA with prison abolition? Or any leftist intellectual who wrote largely about American imperialism helping the DSA become more anti-imperialist in their foreign policy plans?

Personally, the DSA members who have been elected to public office seem like regular left-Democrats. If they were hiring leftist intellectuals to be their "brains" their policies might look very different and much better.

I think leftists lack conspiracy thinking because you'll always be choosing between shit and piss.

Graeberian policies DSA could implement:

  1. Democratizing the workplace

  • encourage worker self-ownership and self-management
  • fund worker co-ops
  • establish legal requirements for worker representation on corporate boards
  • support democratic control over things like hiring, scheduling, working conditions, etc.


  1. Participatory democracy

  • creation of neighbourhood councils
  • community control over development projects, infrastructure, and public services
  • introduce democratic oversight for public agencies


  1. Mutual aid the basis of public policy

  • make all essentials free
  • end the commodity relation when it comes to food, housing, healthcare, etc.


  1. Debt abolition and transforming economic morality

  • mutual banks (Proudhon)
  • cancel all student loan debt
  • cancel all debts held by the elderly and disabled
  • challenge the privatization of essential services through debt-financed business models


  1. Deal with bureaucracy, administrative power, and ensure the politics of freedom

  • simplify access to public benefits and eliminate unnecessary eligibility procedures
  • give public-sector workers more control over institutional decisions
  • establish democratic oversight for public utilities
  • expand community participation in the design of public services


  1. Shorter working hours and freedom from unnecessary labour

  • maximum 32-hour work week
  • high minimum wage
  • expand vacations
  • strengthen public investment in healthcare, education, and ecological restoration
  • get rid of unnecessary administrative and managerial positions in workplaces
  • create policies that allow productivity to translate into recreation instead of profits


  1. Direct action and creation of alternative economic institutions

  • tenant unions
  • community-controlled housing
  • community-controlled renewable energy projects
  • establish neighbourhood assemblies
  • establish community-owned media
  • expand strike funds and solidarity networks


  1. Rethink foreign policy through anthropology

  • support international labour organizations
  • oppose policies that force poorer countries to submit to imperialist countries’ control
  • support debt relief for countries facing unsustainable obligations
  • promote international cooperation for the climate
  • support indigenous sovereignty, indigenous control of natural resources, and land back
  • expand international cooperation through non-military public investment and localized knowledge-sharing


The point is to emphasize the cooperative relations that already exist in our world instead of relying entirely on state planning and control, and also to apply democracy in every aspect of everyday life so that we can be freed from the domination of overlords. The main economic objective needs to be FREEDOM, not control.

File: 1794903630827-7.jpg (98.82 KB, 640x454, al7cah.jpg)

>>2956506
>The main economic objective needs to be FREEDOM, not control.
<Freedom does not exist in a vacuum or atomized political field; it exists embedded in shared social reality, simply giving workers more rights without engaging with the history of the current situation, and its emancipatory potential within its contradictions won't solve the underlying problems of the capitalist society.
In other words, the solution must be totalitarian because liberalism is itself a totalitarian ideology, just that it masks itself as not being so by appealing to human nature that only begins to exist in the late 1700s.

There can be no reform within the system and only a critical dissection of its rational foundation

>>2956512
> because a is b, we must do b again to fix a

I suspect a lot of it has to do with the fact that even a lot of leftist intellectuals in the US are basically isolated from any real movements or organizing and are instead relegated to the cloisters of the ivory tower, and the same goes the other way: the supposed indoctrination of students into communist ideology that conservatives used to screech about is all usually shallow, diluted, all the traces of radical thought strategically removed from texts except if a leftist thinker is an established part of a canon and therefore is more like an exhibit in the museum of (largely western) ideas. It's not just that the left has no political power in the US but also that there is no coherent next generation of leftist intellectuals and students who would form a vanguard, while the few living intellectuals we have are aging academics who are comfortably getting their bag in tenured professor (or emeritus) jobs. The left in the US is so nonexistent, and what little passes for the left today so milquetoast or infantile, that the best we can really expect right now is to build things up from square one.

>>2956515
which is to say: read theory, faggots

>>2956515
Things might not look much different because of constraints placed on Mamdani by the bond markets and the fact that he has to work with the state government of New York to get money for his projects.

BTW I listened to Rubio's whole speech at the Federalist Society (which is a group of conservative lawyers, law students, judges, future judges, etc.). That's where he said the spirit of Marx is haunting the world, which the left had lot of fun with. But one of the more substantial parts of the speech was him making this right-wing Gramscian argument about a whole-of-society approach to building power, that holding office is not, like, *the* ultimate goal as some think. It's a temporary thing where different parties come in and out and are renting it for a period. That was kind of copium right after the midterms, but the logic is sound. Anyways he was really telling the Federalist Society that they're a kind of vanguard of conservatism that's going to keep doing their thing.

>>2956514
no you lumpen,A is generated by B, and B is reproduced through −B, we must transform −B to overcome A.
Read about dialectics smh

>>2956490
Lenin specifically told us not to do entryism.

>>2956506
ChatGPT clearly wrote this.

>>2956525
>Lenin specifically told us not to do entryism.
I am pretty sure social-democracy proved why this is bullshit but you'll be suprised how many romanticists are around

>>2956506
>liberalism

>>2956490
>Why aren't DSA people openly consulting David Harvey or Richard Wolff to help them with their economic policies?
They probably are, they just aren't big enough to implement those policies yet.

>>2956528
garbage opinion of totalitarianism fetishist

>>2956490
>Judith Butler's former students are all running soup kitchens and needle exchange programs in Oakland.

Okay but we actually need soup kitchens and needled exchange programs.

>>2956541
>acting like all borgeoise ideologies aren't totalitarian
Nice opinons lib

>>2956546
Dumb larper. Your position is akin to "killing is so cool we need more war", because war was a necessity at some time.

>>2956545
Wouldn't you rather have leftitss get elected into political office where they could implement policies that make food free for everyone?

File: 1794908771598-2.jpg (158.41 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault(1).jpg)

>For instance, why aren't DSA people using David Graeber's works on anthropology, bullshit jobs, etc. as inspiration for establishing localized economies and dealing with the overall soulless job culture? Why aren't DSA people openly consulting David Harvey or Richard Wolff to help them with their economic policies? Why isn't Judith Butler being invited to DSA meetings where she can advise people on gender issues and shit like abolishing the family? Or Mariame Kaba helping the DSA with prison abolition? Or any leftist intellectual who wrote largely about American imperialism helping the DSA become more anti-imperialist in their foreign policy plans?

Holy fucking cringe petit-booge pseudo-intellectualism. 'Job culture' really? There are plenty of intellectuals that part of the post-Bernie left. It's just that the core message of it is based on economic populism that's why they are inviting economists rather than whatever intersectional author you are currently reading in your reading group and people that can't pay their rant wouldn't give a shit about.

>>2956549
alright let's leave the capitalist organisation of familiar life intact while we give le rise to worker's and give them workplace democracy that will totally work guy's

>>2956554
Isn't this lady a keynesian

>>2956506
>encourage worker self-ownership and self-management
>support democratic control over things like hiring, scheduling, working conditions, etc.
>creation of neighbourhood councils
>make all essentials free
>end the commodity relation when it comes to food, housing, healthcare, etc.
>give public-sector workers more control over institutional decisions
>maximum 32-hour work week
>strengthen public investment in healthcare, education, and ecological restoration
>tenant unions
>community-controlled housing
>establish neighbourhood assemblies
>expand strike funds and solidarity networks
>oppose policies that force poorer countries to submit to imperialist countries’ control
All of this is just basic bitch socialism.


Unique IPs: 10

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]