>“Every living body builds itself out of nonliving material, in other words, out of food, out of the environmental conditions.”
― Trofim Lysenko, Heredity and Its Variability
Thread about Lysenko and his views on biology and his application of dialectical materialism
> In our Leftypol anons are not born: organisms are born, but men anons are made—tankies,dengists ,posadists , armchairs ,egoists. I was not born a anon , I was made a anon
>a anon
ESL
Leftypol Lysenko threads are my favorite because I can't see who is trolling and who is serious.
Anyway, he was pretty much the soviet version of rfk jr today
Libs shit on Lysenko but given the Nazis embracing social Darwinism it's kind of understandable why the CPSU listened to him
The idea of there being "proletarian" and "bourgeois" hard sciences is stupid.
>>2959218>bourgeois xyzgenuinely what does this even denote? where do demonstrably "bourgeois" relations present themselves in academia?
>>2959222Plz 🙏 study the works of Comrade Stalin
Your answer is there
Protip **soft sciences hooomaaanities, wissenschaft/wissennatureschaft yes distinction exists, hard science natureschaft, lol 咳咳咳咳可可 不好一素 👌ok**
>>2959218Imagine thinking this when the most popular view on quantum mechanics is the Copenhagen interpretation, which is deeply subjectivist and therefore bourgeois
>>2959225Lmao, ok, tell me in your own words why it is demonstrably wrong.
>politicians talking about science
Lmao
>>2959237U deny immortal science of ML?
>>2959225I don't care if it's "subjective", "idealist" or "magic", if it permits workers to produce and consume cool treats like smartphones and computers and shit this is proletarian
>>2959253Y u no can into maths or science?
it's just basic marxism bros
these threads are dumb because neither side actually knows what the scientific contentent of the disagreement was about, both assume the sensationalized caricature of the actual positions then argue whether it was based or cringe
the actual scientific debate was actually quite narrow and even banal, having to do with whether there is evidence for extra chromosomal acquired heredity
geneticists were wrong because there is, lysenkoists were wrong because their model for how such inheritance works was incorrect
>>2959264As a side note on pseudo-science
Every civilisation except the west accurately recorded supernova events that were blatently visible to the naked eye
>>2959241MLs are wrong in politics, imagine how wrong they are on science
>>2959255Can you prove that LTV and TRPF are science and not religious zealotry?
>>2959309Right now give me a short (or long, whatever) definition of what is Marxism-Leninism.
Did the wheat turn into barley or not?
>>2959223vaguely gesturing at systemic knowledge, the natural sciences and what i assume is some chud-level disparagement of social science isn't an answer
>咳咳咳咳可可 不好一素are you having a fucking stroke?
>comrade stalinmarxism and problems of linguistics explicitely challenges assigning class characteristics to language
i know this kind of shit is typical of mls but if anyone honest could give me an answer i'd appreciate it
Yes the idea of genetic determinism sucks ass for socialism but we can rid ourselves of it by practicing actual science not this garbage
Polite sage
>>2959329so, it's just shit they don't like? i know mls do this w/categories like national, bureacratic and comprador but its always a little more complex than just "xyz is,,, le bad!"
>>2959330Who the fuck is out here promoting full genetic determinism? I thought the consensus was some outcomes are genetic, others are shaped by environment, this is called epigenetic. Sometimes recessive genes cause blue eyes, sometimes you get Huntington’s disease. Some are born with a tendency for alcoholism and actively avoid alcohol consumption because it ruined a family member.
>>2959335Leftist are more idealist when it comes biology. Truthnuke is that what people blame on environment is just epigenetics at play.
>>2959338The epigenetic and the environmental aren’t quite the same thing but do heavily overlap
>>2959335false actually. 100% of outcomes are environmental if you ,easure stuff anyone cares about
what % of gagarin's DNA contributed to him becoming a cosmonaut, vs the environment?
well, uh, he had to pass medical tests you say. this is the wrong way to pose the question.
if gagarin was born in the environment of the paleolithic, what chance did he have of ending up in space? 0%
therefore, environment (the soviet union) contributed 100%
>>2959353A yuri gagarin born in the paleolithic wouldn’t be yuri gagarin, he would be a guy named grug
>>2959335Lysenkoism seems like it was adopted as a cope to deal with the depressing realities of genetics and resultant genetic determinism. But we are much more advanced than the 1930s and we don't have to abide by it just because they didn't know any better. We may actually have a path to fix the natural inequalities of man via gene editing rather than pretending Michurinism works in the big 26
>>2959335yes, the largest meta-analysis to date concluded an average heritability of 49% across studied traits but this is wrong now and will be even more wrong next century, then maybe a little more right in five, then laughable in 15- why? because its an estimation based on one observation of an infantecimal amount of traits expressed under a variable AND tiny range of conditions. genetics are only expressed in their reaction to stimuli and do so in innumerable ways- think of them as a range of rather than fraction- they thus completely inseparable from nurture, something we can evaluate much more consistently considering how similar we all are
>99% genetically similarand we're 1% off chimps! we're talking so incredibly minute here its practically worthless. genetics are, statistically, borderline irrelevant, but very interesting
>>2959372Genetics are borderline irrelevant: therefore by intense focus and study, all humans are able to transform into bananas. This is the trvthnvke that capitalists are hiding from you.
>>2959375banana might be too ambitious given current technological development but I bet I can reliably turn you intto a vegetable with a solid blow to the head you reactionary mendeloid
>>2959375if that's what you got from my post you're already a fucking vegetable
>>2959382in the second panel it looks like he's going to miss