>>2959921I agree with most of your post but want to push back on this:
>All the parts of the job that was somewhat of an art-form, like crafting elegant code, are now gone.Employers were never hiring software engineers to write elegant code. They were hiring them to produce a working product. Imo, elegant code is simple, readable, and maintainable code. Clever one liners and abstractions nobody else can follow were always a problem. Good code is code the next person can pick up six months later without having to reverse engineer what you were thinking.
If you let an AI agent go wild on a complex feature without any constraints, rules, or guidelines, you sometimes get the exact opposite: duplicated logic, weird abstractions, five different patterns for the same thing. It does work, though. Imo that's more the fault of the dev who gave it the task that way. Give an inexperienced junior dev the same task with no design doc, no conventions, and no code review, you'd get pretty much the same result, because they don't have the experience yet to know what could trip em up.
The agent mostly mirrors what you give it. If the codebase is consistent, the rules files are clear, and the feature is broken into well-defined pieces with defined interfaces, the output tends to follow those patterns. If the codebase is a spaghetti and the prompt is "build X, Y, Z" it'll pile more shit onto the mess and produce more spaghetti.
I don't think the craft is gone but moved. The skill now is in deciding how a feature should be structured before any code is written, defining guardrails, knowing what not to build, and reviewing diffs to catch when something works, but might be a maintenance problem later. Imo typing code was never the difficult part, it was maintaining and avoiding tech debt, fixing old shit, etc.
I'm a dev that wears a lot of hats and it's been invaluable for me. Reviewing old codebases, finding security issues, debugging, writing one off scripts for maintenance, improving sql queries, etc. In my off time it's allowed me to move a lot faster in personal projects. I'm pretty much in agreement with how Linus views AI and LLMs