[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/lgbt/ - LGBT

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender +
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


File: 1769722817918-0.png (737.7 KB, 1148x840, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1769722817918-3.png (1.83 MB, 1123x1307, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1769722817918-4.png (983.38 KB, 1280x1280, ClipboardImage.png)

 

what's the synthesis of IBs and trans culture?

obviously pre-2016-fed/pol/ era, if you're a tran browsing IBs you're or should obviously be old enough to remember life before the rise of "beta" and "incel" culture in 4chan, where the absurd became nihilism and then it came the grooming;

it's not a conspiracy, the "glowie" meme became a thing thanks to the known fact of federal agents browsing these sites, but back on topic:

I don't usually do this but;
>TW:
<Brainworms
<Depression
<Slurs(?)

think Bailey Jay, tranchan and "trap aesthetics" guides, faproulette?

at least for me it was an important part of my self-discovery as a depressed teen isolated and with no education on what even trans people, spending time between IBs only interacting with terminally online incels at the peak of my delayed puberty

Giving up and taking my first steps in gender exploration i realized i had to make a choice between "malebrained" nihilist spaces and actually transitioning, fast forward to the present i'm here, brainworms and a shaky early transition due to contact with transmedicalists overlapping with Blanchardism makes me stick to /tttt/ culture

and here's where i make a pause to make a critique of "transmedicalism" not as a method but as a cope starved for validation
I once got kicked for "comparing it to nazism" while making the comparison to how quoting Evola doesn't make you a nazi/fascist, but puts you in a place where you're at least adjacent to nazi/fascist ideas.

now let's think the two sides of terminally online trans spaces: trans hugboxes and trans brainworm nests

they're different enough in "vibe" and yet they both represent a terminally online space where both positive and negative feedbacks of self-affirming dogmas and paranoias.

As a result of this i struggle constantly with the concept of Autogynephilia to a point where it affects my bf;
as an outsider he doesn't understand it, but he has an aversion to the concept and a desire to understand it as he wishes to understand me.

I've infected a cis person with brainworms.

I have to tell him it's not real but he says there seems to be a degree of credibility to it. it hurts me, and even without that second opinion the fact that Blanchardism has been co-opted by trans spaces, in fact the mere fact the AGP typology is still part of the DSM-V is hurtful even if i recognize psychology under capitalism seeks to colonize such conditions; in order to explain it to a group of scholars who clearly have no interest in the wellbeing of the people they pathologize.

How do we break this cycle?

we have the Thesis; a pathology that makes trans women in particular (for some reason) dwell in a cycle of self hate which innevitably overlaps with the same nihilistic worldview that degenerated IBs into what they are today

and on the other side the Anti-thesis; the hugbox where you won't hear any of this, their sisters are falling apart and their reaction is "fuck them, they're rude and their negativity makes me sad, best of luck but fuck you", liberalism in it's maximum expression, *every woman by herself.* if i pump the music higher i won't hear their screams.

what would be the next step to break this cycle? do we engage? do we appropriate? how would you organize this purposefully balkanized community?

>>6166
>Lots of buzzwords
>Lots of -isms being lumped in with trans welfare

Buddy I think your worldview of transgenderism is too much fueled by your imageboard culture.
Trans culture predates image boards.
If anything image boards are being overly wrongfully associated with trans and fascists and the like due to 4chan.

File: 1769728140386.png (18.99 KB, 353x452, ClipboardImage.png)

>>6429

that's why i specified "terminally online"

also what was the last time you spoke to an old trans lady?

>>6166
>AGP
i dont really care about it and think blanchardism is stupid. yeah so what im AGP, is that supposed to be bad? how is it any different than saying women dont enjoy sex or a sluts/mental if they do. its just boomer logic
>transmedicalism
im really annoyed by this one because theres like two or three types and philosophically obviously i think its wrong to say you cant be trans if you dont medically transition but also this detached philosophical notion plus arguing with transmeds made me rep longer. instead of arguing for a medical definition i think proponents should argue for the benefits of HRT and dispel myths
>dwell in a cycle of self hate which innevitably overlaps with the same nihilistic worldview that degenerated IBs into what they are today
i think its actually just IB and incel chud culture more generally. like half of the brain worms come from the concept of passing and half the posters on /tttt/ are not trans theyre fucking polyps pedophiles who think 19yo is too old because they hit the wall and divide women into maddona/whore and "would"/ogre boxes based on like a single slightly dark brown hair on their forearm. their standards are psychotic and based on chinese cartoons wholly separate from even the cosmetic advertising and hollywood industries. i think the answer is to develop a healthy relationship with what real people actually look like

>>6436

the problem of being "yeah i'm AGP" it's that people start asking "what is AGP"?

not engaging with it makes people think we're scared of it, engaging with it it's rarely productive.

specially on the circus that is the Internet.

there's just no space to discuss these topics in legimately good faith.

sending Blanchard into the exile just made him a martir he just goes around crying "i've been silenced"; imagine how much better everything would've been had he just been ignored for being a freudian retard.

>>6442

i had no Internet during the time period i would stare down buildings and think of jumping for the chance to be reincarnated as a woman.

>>6441
>the problem of being "yeah i'm AGP" it's that people start asking "what is AGP"?
if you are saying in response to an accusation then they arent going to be asking what it is they are the one who brought it up. i dont mean introducing yourself that way lmao
but i mean i would say that in an internet argument fully aware that its a circus to debrainworm others
its a version of "making them explain the joke"
and im not talking to chuds about agp irl im asking why the are obsessed with transhumanists for knowing what that is

and secondly i believe it, why exactly is it supposed to be a bad thing? its supposed to be a binary classification of trans women right? so either its really broad and it applies to roughly half of trans women and also to many cis women, or its really hyper specific and applies to like 1% of 1% of 1% of people and is basically meaningless.

wait wat do u even think it is

also who cares if its in the dsm. psychiatrists are fucking frauds and psychology isn't a real discipline and thats true entirely outside of trans stuff lmao. their job is to passify workers who are rightly and rationally emotionally damaged by shit conditions and redirect it to overcoming individual failing. its only useful as a institution in so far as you can manipulate it to get what you want and should be dismantled and replaced with something proletarian

What the fuck are you talking about, Donnie???

>>6436
trans people simply have less inherent value than cis women, they cant give birth
therefore they're not fit for starting a family, and if they want someone to settle for them they have to be pretty much perfect or nobody is ever going to want to date them unless you wanna fuck a bottom chaser in the ass

>>6444
Are you autistic or just an incel lol

>>6442
Fake news. I wanted to be a woman back in elementary school, when I didn't have the internet or even a computer, and I hadn't experienced any traumatic events.

File: 1769802521573.jpg (50.03 KB, 681x675, chudcat.jpg)

>>6448

what did i even do? :(

>>6436
>i think its actually just IB and incel chud culture more generally. like half of the brain worms come from the concept of passing and half the posters on /tttt/ are not trans theyre fucking polyps pedophiles who think 19yo is too old because they hit the wall and divide women into maddona/whore and "would"/ogre boxes based on like a single slightly dark brown hair on their forearm. their standards are psychotic and based on chinese cartoons wholly separate from even the cosmetic advertising and hollywood industries. i think the answer is to develop a healthy relationship with what real people actually look like

From what I see, there's more people saying 30 is hitting the wall and 18-22 dating anyone outside of their age number is pedophilia and blaming anime for their own self-image problems.

>>6166
>synthesis
Respegt dhe fuggin wymyn :DD

IMO the problems with both ultimately stem from having internalized misogyny, with 4transhumanistoids literally inventing their own version of unrealistic expectations towards women. Being trans is like being a guest to everyone of your chosen gender and sneeds should act like it, even to the Dworkinites. Not to say transhumanists should feel any special obligation to cismoids though, they're the most socially ignorant and pandered to demographic after all.

>>6445
>either its really broad and it applies to roughly half of trans women and also to many cis women, or its really hyper specific and applies to like 1% of 1% of 1% of people and is basically meaningless.
The former i would plainly call "autophilia" and the latter matches what i've seen refered to as "auto-gyno-andro-morpho-philia" and i honestly get this distinction intuitively. Before i considered myself as mtf i sometimes used to play these rpgmaker slowburn feminization games. Aside from the fact i rarely have the desire to play erogames anymore, nowadays i tend to only play rpgmaker porn about cis women or DoL with the "crossdresser" background occasionally. I've never particularly cared for the "cishet guy gets feminized" trope, but now it literally does nothing for me.

File: 1792476651876-0.gif (306.65 KB, 500x234, puke.gif)


>>6447
>trans people simply have less inherent value than cis women, they cant give birth
how terrible, I can't produce a gross crotch goblin that will cause me to age by a decade and gain a ton of weight!!

My Thai passoid ex had never even heard of 4chan, /lgbt/ and all that shit, lul.

>>6447
trans people are inherently more valuable than breeders it takes more refinement and expertise to reach such a heightened state of being, and because breeders are an inferior clay thats only purpose is to produce more of itself.

>>11212
it takes more refinement and expertise to reach such a heightened state of being
Haha no, you're not special just because you have gender dysphoria.

>>11212
>trans people are inherently more valuable than breeders it takes more refinement and expertise to reach such a heightened state of being
trvke

the ubiquity and anonymity of the internet has drastically increased the turbulence of the noosphere. if you visualize the collective cognition and communication of all human beings on the planet as something like the atmosphere, i.e. this big chaotic living system with climate and weather patterns, you can imagine what a tremendous disruption the recent development and global adoption of the internet must have been, this technology that suddenly opened the floodgates for random long-distance and disinhibited human communication all over the world.

all these seemingly novel and alien ideas about gender and sexuality and whatnot have always been in our brains from the very beginning, but to talk about something or even think about something at the conscious level, we have to make up words for it. and to merge it into the noosphere we have to speak the words to other people who can grasp their meaning, i.e. likeminded people who are thinking the same thing we are thinking but don't have the words for it. until the internet was a thing, this was far more difficult for people who had unconventional ideas about sex or gender, the church and the empire and the loyal conventional square masses dictated thought and language and most people who were queer could not become consciously aware of it and the very few queers who did manage to become aware of it were spread out and isolated from each other like small local weather events, a group of friends here or there, maybe a small community in some major urban cultural center or big prestigious institution where wealth and status and population density protected them from persecution.

the internet has completely overhauled human communication and turned the noosphere into a chaotic worldwide firestorm that nobody can really control, though they certainly have been trying, and it's having all kinds of good and bad consequences and we have no idea where it might lead and that scares the living shit out of the square world, they feel like the world has gone mad and they can't understand what is happening and they are coming up with all kinds of absurd harebrained conspiratorial explanations, because they have monistic authoritarian thinking and therefore they don't understand pluralism or chaos theory; they don't have the words.

File: 1793126518086-8.png (1.3 MB, 1200x1200, ClipboardImage.png)

This comic was pretty on point with it ig.
really liked it

File: 1793170339110-7.png (72.23 KB, 578x586, meedhsken-tea copy.png)

>what would be the next step to break this cycle?
the first step is to realize that a lot of these "brainworms" are ultimately just nothingburgers. why should i care if i am agp and doing it just for a "fetish"? you see many people use "agp" in pejorative fashion, but blanchard was never against agps transitioning. the way our community treats blanchard's typology is rather haphazard and unsystematic. for instance, this abstract "agp" is demonized, meanwhile it is often tacitly supposed that actually wanting srs makes you somehow valid, despite the fact that it is actually nonhomosexual transsexuals that would seem to be more likely to actually pursue srs from the perspective of intrinsic motivation. when you really dig down to it, the idea that "hsts" are the valid ones makes very little sense. they are just transitioning to sleep with men and this makes them more valid somehow?

really, there is something deeper which is at the root of such brainworms, along with other concerns such as "transmedicalism" and that is substance metaphysics. agp or not, having gender dysphoria are somehow "invalidating" and make you less of "true trans". but what the hell is true trans exactly? notice how everyone is talking about this as though there is some sort of trans substance floating about which enters into some people while does not enter others, which is somehow unable to pass into the "agps" but is perfectly able to pass into the straight transexuals? furthermore, why exactly should i care? let us say i am agp. ok, but does this detract from the real emotional and physical pain that i and other alleged agps feel about their bodies? even if the diagnosis is correct, all it does is outline the libidinal dynamics underlying the desire. it hardly gives a determinate direction with respect to where to go from there

of course, there are underlying political implications underlying why such issues have taken root. the first is the optics game. people latch unto blanchard's typology, despite blanchard's personal support for cross-typological transition, because "autogynephilia" sounds bad. it coheres with all sorts of suspicions and paranoid cathexes which have constructed an archetype of modern transsexual that is somehow predatory or dangerous. besides this, there is the power-knowledge of the medical industries surrounding transitioning which have taken it upon themselves to define a particular subjectivity (the one with "gender dysphoria") who is legible for such and such medical procedures (hormonal and surgical transition), and this legibility also warrants insurance thanks to the biopolitical commitments of bourgeois institutions i.e. maintaining "well-being" or bare life. the medical subjectivity of the transsexual here is necessarily unstable due to its relation to the biopolitics of bare life. the medical procedures pertaining to transsexuality, especially those which involve surgical modification, could very well be classified as simply mutilation without medicalizing structures of justification. at which point, whether or not there should be eligibility of govt benefits and insurance, or even whether or not such procedures should be legal in the first place, come into question. the way this tension is resolved is by the invention of a transsexual substance, ontological reifying the medical subjectivity of "transsexual" to confer it further legitimacy. your transition can no longer be predicated on a simple response to an all-haunting desire, it has to be made metaphysical. one has to belong to the category of "true trans", or must have "always been this way", etc. and then this transsexual substance must be defended from all of those who do not fit within this archetype until finally one's own eligibility to this ideal comes into question. all of a sudden, any libidinal tendency that would seem to infringe upon transsexual substance becomes devastating and capable of plunging one into an existential crisis

in short, ideas such as "agp" are so devastating to people because they put so much stake into some sort of substance metaphysics of transsexuality. this is a metaphysics that i reject and find largely incoherent. as such, the bite of the label simply holds little over me

after one moves beyond transsexual essentializations, there is now work to be done towards developing new transsexual subjectivities, and possibly developing a new ethics that no longer simply asserts well-being and no longer relies on substantial conceptualizations. i believe neo-confucianism is a positive step towards the latter and i have notes on this which may be compiled into a post in the future. with regards to the latter, there is the following blogpost again which not many people seem to have properly digested (inserting all sorts of assumptions with regards to what camp of transsexual politics i represent, not understanding that i reject all hitherto camps as false syntheses):
https://hidwehproject.nekoweb.org/pages/blog/posts/2025-11-04-On-The-Transgender-Question.html

>>11283
>wordswordswordswords 4t schizo essay, also pick up this SNCA religion from 20000 years ago or you're not TRUE trans

>>11313
>>wordswordswordswords
you have to go back

>>11317
>wordswordswords

File: 1793557858532-5.png (296.83 KB, 538x435, Capture.PNG)

>>6429
<buddy, your view of transgenderism is fueled by imageboard culture.

this is a stupid fucking way of thinking about it. this is tyler the creator cyberbullying tweet level stupid. We live in the internet age and being a luddite doesn't actually allow you to escape the effects of that.

you still see the thesis and antithesis outlined in the post in real life offline communities - you have liberal hugboxxers who shut down any discussion of transphobia or transfeminism, and you have depressed beautiful lady😍🥰s on the verge of suicide and pay the slightest attention.

<lots of buzzwords

I'm sorry your to stupid to google basic terminology. do you need your mommy to do it for you?

>>6448
>transhumanist experiencing basic dysphoria
"uh uhm! i bet your a retard! or maybe a incel!"
go back to 4chan

>>11313
>>11318

do you need chatgpt to summerize it for you?

>>11331
>Read my beautiful lady😍🥰igger babble

File: 1793674229991-9.jpg (340.76 KB, 1451x1470, 4tran.jpg)

Reminder that pre-tourist 4chan loved transhumanists. Now they delude themselves into believing the most marginalized and bipartisanly hated minority in the western world are somehow normalfags.

>>6442
If you're browsing so much trans internet that it makes you trans, is it really the internet's fault?

>>11356
>closeted trans, gooners, 30 yo virgins, bi

>>11362
so, every anon ever?

back in the day when 4chan morons were all marching in lockstep about how much they hated transgender people i knew that a sizeable percentage of them were closeted trans and i wondered when and how it would finally come out. i was still pretty naive about it however, i assumed that if and when they did come out their personal revelation would extend to their entire being, what i didn't consider is the possibility that they would come out as trans yet somehow remain fascists and would then become fascist 4transhumanisters going around the internet telling other trans ppl what is the correct way to be trans and which gender identities are valid and which are not and who is victimized and who is not. reality is stranger than fiction, i suppose.

File: 1794002349217-6.png (1.88 MB, 2730x1536, IMG_3672.png)

>>11397
>become fascist 4transhumanisters going around the internet telling other trans ppl what is the correct way to be trans and which gender identities are valid and which are not and who is victimized and who is not.

>>11397
i mean there is biological evidence of transsexualism and even nonbinary identities to some extent. these are real biological and inherent minority identities, that one is mostly just born into. there is no material evidence of xie/xer or other liberal made up ones. two spirit and other tribal understandings of intersex people were mostly that, understandings of intesexuality, and today they are just nonbinary, or more specifically intersex.
its more fascistic by way of degrading these real minorities to allow these people to coopt this real minority identity, ascribe made up traits and behaviors to them, all while acting like a stereotype because 99% of these fake people are white liberals, and thus chronically empty. people accept that wiggers are not black, but then permit this nonsense for trans people because they themselves are liberals and transphobic.

>>11399
>two spirit and other tribal understandings of intersex people were mostly that, understandings of intesexuality
Are you by any chance confusing intersexuality with transsexuality?

I was on 4chan from 2006-2009 until hoping ship to 420chan and royally making an ass of myself there for ten years while on drugs.

4chan was always about being an incel, we just didn't have a word for it. Mspain, friendzone complaints, nice guy posts, etc. it was always about trolling and started off as ironic racism then led to actual racism. 4chan was funny and we made Jew and jolly African-American jokes actively, spammed holocaust shit, etc. Even my Jewish friends partook.

It was always a bunch of chronic masturbators who couldn't get laid. Although my coked up years I'm glad I got off the site, I am not glad I shit up 420chan so bad.

People who enjoy 4chan deserve to not breed.


Unique IPs: 28

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]