>what would be the next step to break this cycle?the first step is to realize that a lot of these "brainworms" are ultimately just nothingburgers. why should i care if i am agp and doing it just for a "fetish"? you see many people use "agp" in pejorative fashion, but blanchard was never against agps transitioning. the way our community treats blanchard's typology is rather haphazard and unsystematic. for instance, this abstract "agp" is demonized, meanwhile it is often tacitly supposed that actually wanting srs makes you somehow valid, despite the fact that it is actually nonhomosexual transsexuals that would seem to be more likely to actually pursue srs from the perspective of intrinsic motivation. when you really dig down to it, the idea that "hsts" are the valid ones makes very little sense. they are just transitioning to sleep with men and this makes them more valid somehow?
really, there is something deeper which is at the root of such brainworms, along with other concerns such as "transmedicalism" and that is substance metaphysics. agp or not, having gender dysphoria are somehow "invalidating" and make you less of "true trans". but what the hell is true trans exactly? notice how everyone is talking about this as though there is some sort of trans substance floating about which enters into some people while does not enter others, which is somehow unable to pass into the "agps" but is perfectly able to pass into the straight transexuals? furthermore, why exactly should i care? let us say i am agp. ok, but does this detract from the real emotional and physical pain that i and other alleged agps feel about their bodies? even if the diagnosis is correct, all it does is outline the libidinal dynamics underlying the desire. it hardly gives a determinate direction with respect to where to go from there
of course, there are underlying political implications underlying why such issues have taken root. the first is the optics game. people latch unto blanchard's typology, despite blanchard's personal support for cross-typological transition, because "autogynephilia"
sounds bad. it coheres with all sorts of suspicions and paranoid cathexes which have constructed an archetype of modern transsexual that is somehow predatory or dangerous. besides this, there is the power-knowledge of the medical industries surrounding transitioning which have taken it upon themselves to define a particular subjectivity (the one with "gender dysphoria") who is legible for such and such medical procedures (hormonal and surgical transition), and this legibility also warrants insurance thanks to the biopolitical commitments of bourgeois institutions i.e. maintaining "well-being" or bare life. the medical subjectivity of the transsexual here is necessarily unstable due to its relation to the biopolitics of bare life. the medical procedures pertaining to transsexuality, especially those which involve surgical modification, could very well be classified as simply mutilation without medicalizing structures of justification. at which point, whether or not there should be eligibility of govt benefits and insurance, or even whether or not such procedures should be legal in the first place, come into question. the way this tension is resolved is by
the invention of a transsexual substance, ontological reifying the medical subjectivity of "transsexual" to confer it further legitimacy. your transition can no longer be predicated on a simple response to an all-haunting desire, it has to be made metaphysical. one has to belong to the category of "true trans", or must have "always been this way", etc. and then this transsexual substance must be defended from all of those who do not fit within this archetype until finally one's own eligibility to this ideal comes into question. all of a sudden, any libidinal tendency that would seem to infringe upon transsexual substance becomes devastating and capable of plunging one into an existential crisis
in short, ideas such as "agp" are so devastating to people because they put so much stake into some sort of substance metaphysics of transsexuality. this is a metaphysics that i reject and find largely incoherent. as such, the bite of the label simply holds little over me
after one moves beyond transsexual essentializations, there is now work to be done towards developing new transsexual subjectivities, and possibly developing a new ethics that no longer simply asserts well-being and no longer relies on substantial conceptualizations. i believe neo-confucianism is a positive step towards the latter and i have notes on this which may be compiled into a post in the future. with regards to the latter, there is the following blogpost again which not many people seem to have properly digested (inserting all sorts of assumptions with regards to what camp of transsexual politics i represent, not understanding that i reject all hitherto camps as false syntheses):
https://hidwehproject.nekoweb.org/pages/blog/posts/2025-11-04-On-The-Transgender-Question.html