Cockshott isn't worth taking seriously on this. He joined the Alba party instead of any socialist org.
That may seem benign if you're unfamiliar with Scottish politics but it's a damning indictment of his judgement. Alba is basically the Scottish national party (e.g. socdems) with only three policy differences
- Soft climate change denial
- Anti-transgenderism and a general social conservative vibe
- Trying to rehabilitate the reputation of the disgraced Alex Salmond and undermine the SNP for prosecuting him for allegations of sex offences
Because nobody actually wanted that platform, Alba has never had a single elected representative (they all defected from other parties) and is currently deeply in debt, having spent as much money as the Scottish Greens at the last Scottish election (£200,000ish) where the Greens got 7 seats and they got none, while all their MPs/MSPs have either lost their seats or quit the party.
This is to point to the conclusion that he's starting with bigotry and then justifying it ex-post facto, which is the only model that can explain him joining Alba. No sensible analysis-lead approach would support doing that, even as a TERFy socdem Scottish nationalist.