it brings me no pleasure to announce this, but it's peak. the furry twink has done it again. total tumblr teen victory. i can't sleep at night and my life is irrevocably changed.
89 posts and 23 image replies omitted.>>45335well that or you would just chill in the winter town at the start or something,if it's THAT dangerous.
I feel like humans are more about avoiding danger altogether in the first priority
>>45491>would just chill in the winter town at the start or something,if it's THAT dangerous.anon, theres a kill all human policy. Plus flowey exists.
Peace was never a option
I do not care for December Holiday.
The game keeps bringing her up in a way that's meant to evoke sympathy from the player, but it's so inorganic and distracting from the plot. It feels like I'm being told to care about her rather than actually form my own opinion on her. And I can already see the "she wasn't a good person" reveal coming from a mile away, and I'm dreading it because it'll just take even more time away from the main plot than it already has.
The internet is fawning (lol) over her anyway, of course, because she's a blank slate furry tomboy they can project whatever they like onto her. And if you have fun doing that, that's fine, but if I hear one more person tell me that she's more important and interesting than Gaster - you know, an actual character that's been set up and building up for over a decade - I'm gonna lose my shit.
Oh, and don't even get me started on how she's poisoned the Knight discourse. I've always thought she was the least interesting Knight candidate, and it's only gotten worse in the latest chapters - but if you point that out, or call out the plot holes, or suggest a different candidate, or even just say that you personally find it boring and thematically irrelevant, you're called a contrarian and get the same Gooseworx copypasta over and over again. Nobody has learned a goddamn thing from the Kris Knight days, and it shows.
I'm just so tired of hearing about her, and I just know it'll only get ten times worse when Chapter 5 drops.
>>45507Yeah, don't you just hate it when people are affected by the death of a loved one, and don't just shut up and get over it?
>>45507i prefer rudy knight than dess knight
>>45508>plotline about accepting death #24531YAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWNNN
>>45510dont worry anon, deltarune is based on mother 3. This means that everything will be restored back to normal. Dess will come back, alive.
>>45508Why should I give a shit about a Mary Sue like Noelle interrupting the story to talk about her sister who either has no bearing on the plot or, if she does later, is being presented in an inorganic way to retroactively justify that writing decision?
This isn't the real world, anon, this is a bunch of fictional characters that Toby had full creative freedom over. He could have easily written them differently (or, considering that Dess didn't exist as a concept until late 2017 at the absolute earliest, didn't have to write at all, which just reinforces how unnatural her inclusion in the plot feels).
>>45509I personally don't think Rudy is the Knight due to a few logistical issues (how does he put on the helmet? How does he know about darkness, let alone freeing a Titan? etc), but I would gladly take him as the Knight over Dess in a heartbeat because at least he's got a motive that we can work with.
>>45527>noelle>mary sueyou sir are a uyghur
>>45528She's beloved by everyone, inexplicably talented, the center of shipping wars, has a tragic backstory that's undeveloped and only used to garner sympathy for her, and the plot bends over backwards to make her the center of attention. Her only flaw is that she's a doormat, which is not only done better by a different character (Ralsei) but any growth in that regard gets retconned by the end of Chapter 2.
The best scenes with her are between her and Kris, but they're either limited to a secret route or completely undermined as soon as her crush shows up (to the point where she becomes kind of an asshole to them, like not acknowledging them being strangled to death by Giga Queen). On that note, my god, SO much of her screentime is used for what Toby clearly wants to be the endgame ship despite them having very little chemistry together; combine that with the Weird Route being framed as forced shipping between Noelle and Kris, and it comes off as the author being actively hostile to those who don't agree with his OTP (which, for the record, I personally don't care either way so long as it's written well, I just don't think Suselle has much going for it and I can see why people might be upset about the Weird Route being framed the way it is).
The few unique and interesting character traits she has (like an implied tendency for violence, or being a glitch hunter) are either limited to out-of-game content or are criminally underutilized (really, Toby? You didn't think to make her interest in glitch hunting prominent in the route based on doing exactly that?). Without those traits, she hardly stands out from the rest of the cast, which is a shame in a series like UT/DR with so many big and dynamic characters like Susie, Papyrus, Asgore, Alphys, Spamton, etc.
To her credit, she works VERY well in the Weird Route, and if she becomes a meta commentary on Mary Sues or "the girl" tropes in fantasy stories I'll take back what I've said. But Toby seems to be playing her straight so far, unfortunately.
She's just not a very well-written character IMHO and I can already see her taking up more screentime in Chapter 5 to keep making the same disaster lesbian joke over and over. Or worse, Rudy gets killed off purely so she can have some kind of development…
>>45536at first glance this seems suprisingly fair. However, I still want to smash your head in with a block for disrespecting my noelle
>>45527youd have to be such a fandom-brained retard to think the knight is anyone but dess lol
>>45484toby fox took the few good aspects of homosuck and the lips man and discarded all the garbage, especially the tvtropes addict nonsense
>>45536You don't understand what makes good writing, fundamentally.
>b-but I wrote an essay! that makes me right! >>45536>>45542yup this is exactly what i mean by tvtropes addict nonsense, your post is like a text version of ur average youtube video analysis
reminds me of people complaining about the possibility of dess being a plot device. well, whats wrong with that, narratively? morons who only
read consume fanfiction slop want everything to be le epic subversion these days
plus writing isnt all there is to a fucking video game so not only do you not understand writing you dont understand games either
>decided to post that summary in the 4chan doe general
<no one seems to disagree with it so far and some even support it
<meanwhile some anons here are hostile against it
nta but hmmmm
>>45544>why do people with an actual brain disagree with me, the midwits from not just 4chan, but some shitty general from the furry porn board agree with me!!!!fandom-brained retard status: confirmed, lmfao
>>45545>he assumes im that anon>he ignores that i posted this in the noelle general where people are obssesed with her. And thus would even irrationally defend herhmm hmmm hmmmm
>>45541You're literally proving my point
Dess Knight has a dozen different plot holes and contradictions (i.e. no means or motive, how the hell would a teenager know how to free a Titan, the Organikks straight up calling the Knight a man, the lyrics of Big Shot and Raise Up Your Bat putting Dess and the Knight at odds, no one seeing Dess leave the Library during Chapter 2, how Dess and the Knight are in two places at once multiple times, why the Knight would endanger Noelle, etc.), but instead of actually addressing these issues you just shit on everyone who calls this out or doesn't like the story it would tell. You're going to learn the same lesson about hubris that the Kris Knighters had to, I guarantee it.
>>45542Couldn't come up with a response? Sad!
>>45540Fair enough. You're welcome to enjoy the character, I personally just don't like her very much outside the Weird Route.
>>45550you know, the fact that the noelle fags on doe seem to agree with you is, quite interesting
>>45550Post chains like this remind me why I only rarely visit /leftypol/ nowadays.
Do you base your world view on the latest news post you saw too? Also, by the logic in the cap Susie is an equal candidate (she was just pretending in the church bro).
You're also so close to a realization with how Noelle is treated by the narrative. Dig a little deeper.
>>45563welcome to fandoms everyone is an illiterate perpetual 12 year old
>>42902It's a good thing Toby Fox is good at making catchy music because he sure is a bad writer. His ability to achieve maximum density of charming nonsense is undeniable, but basically everything beyond that is either banal, confused, or self-defeating. Especially apparent with the critique of "perverse sentimentality" (with completionism and repetition as symptoms) that it conflates with the incoherent "the characters will be upset" angle, that Undertale tries to develop and so shoots itself in the foot.
Not that I'm looking for something crazy deep from that game or Deltarune obviously but I just don't think he understands the motivation structure behind player action and emotional investment in fiction. Which is a problem because that's basically what it's all about.
>>45739Could you please elaborate,there's just too much >implying being done for me to get it
>>45739I don't think there's confusion. It's a fixation on the technicalities that was adopted from Homestuck/Hussie. It is shallow though, but hey, in the land of the blind the man with one eye is king.
I disagree with your reading of the story as a critique of sentimentality (any). You're overestimating the depth of the motivations behind the narration. It's way more shallow: the sentimentality is sincere and the ultimate goal is Christian moralism.
>>45570Anyone should get the opportunity to speak their truth. Unfortunately on imageboards that roads tends to lead towards puerility.
>>45388this was the most progressive thing you could say on the internet in 2009
>>45388idek how people find it confusing for toby fox to still be friends with hussie and omocat, hes clearly just like them lol
>>45858My favourite is when people try to shoehorn Toby into the nihilist category.
Maybe burgerpeople have been broken by the constant barrage of evangelism and fundamentalism. Any Christian who appears as anything but a monster is assumed to be something else.
On topic: we'll see where the story and its meanings go. The presence of light of life and flood arc motifs was disappointing, but maybe he'll do something interesting with these Biblical quotes in the coming chapters.
deltarune is a subversion of christianity
>>45868>playing themes straight is subversion, actuallydo not learn analysis from tvtropes
>>45563>Do you base your world view on the latest news post you saw too?what in the ad hominem
>Also, by the logic in the cap Susie is an equal candidateDo…do you think I'm arguing for Kris Knight? After I explicitly used it as an example of a debunked theory that people were overconfident in? Or do you think the tweet is post-3&4 (it's not, though the author of the tweet is in fact still a Kris Knighter)?
>You're also so close to a realization with how Noelle is treated by the narrative. Dig a little deeper.If you think there's some merit in how Noelle is written, just say it instead of implying it's obvious. This is the exact kind of smug attitude that's making the fandom insufferable right now and it needed to die yesterday.
>>45986Condescending tone is not an ad hominem (neither are insults for that matter). That claim coming from you is rich, considering you fully engaged in "ad hominem" by your own standard.
Furthermore, alleging smugness rings hollow as you turn your nose up at divergent interpretation and then tarry with a broad brush. Practice skepticism of the useful kind, as was my point before.
I said YOU were close (special), not that it was obvious (general).
>just say itWhy? What's stopping you from digging into the text?
>>46011 (nta)
ad hominem post
>>46011 (not him btw)
ironically,this is an ad hominem
inb4 what part :
"alleging smugness rings hollow as you turn your nose up at divergent interpretation and then tarry with a broad brush" is just an attack on his character and motivation,instead of at least thinking he's saying it in good faith
>What's stopping you from digging into the text?5/10 ragebait
lol ofc the deltarune thread would be illiterate morons who dont know what fallacies even consist of
< Ad hominem refers to a type of argument that attacks a person's character or attributes instead of addressing the argument itself, while an insult is simply a derogatory remark about someone.
>>46020if you try to bolster an argument with an insult,it becomes an ad hominem,if you disagree,tell me exactly what differentiate insults and attack of character according to you
also saying "that claim coming from you is rich,considering you do the same" is a typical tu quoque fallacy,but I ignore that one since it's just shitflinging about who is more deserving of contempt.
its gonna be a fucking omori twist isnt it. kris caused dess to dissapear by accident
>>46088not the first time toby fox played a part in some mainstream slop, he voiced an extra in that baby bears cartoon
>>46088WOODY THEORY IS ALIVE
>>46020Reading comprehension so low they skip over "instead"…
yup convinced glown is a rage baiter
>>46110havent bothered reading the actual deltarune discussion itt but outside of that you people are actually retarded and illiterate so (what else can you expect from gamers really). you dont even know what a fallacy is and then misread a simple definition of it too like cmon LOL
yup hes a ragebaiter
>>45818>the ultimate goal is Christian moralism.Are Susie and Noelle gonna see the light and repenet from their sinful lesbian urges? Also where do people go for insane Deltarune discourse? Twitter? Bluesky? I feel like a boomer we used to do this on game forums.
Unique IPs: 24