[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


 

Previous Thread: >>2722737

Links:

Previous Thread Archives
Thread 1 https://archive.ph/ROnpO
Thread 2 https://archive.ph/f29Po
Thread 3 https://archive.ph/GZj20
Thread 4 https://archive.ph/ZHfse
Thread 5 https://archive.ph/PFHJH
Thread 6 https://archive.ph/Hnngv

Youtube Playlists
Anwar Shaikh - Historical Foundations of Political Economy
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTMFx0t8kDzc72vtNWeTP05x6WYiDgEx7
Anwar Shaikh - Capitalism: Competition, Conflict and Crises
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB1uqxcCESK6B1juh_wnKoxftZCcqA1go
Anwar Shaikh - Capitalism
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLz4k72ocf2TZMxrEVCgpp1b5K3hzFWuZh
Capital Volume 1 high quality audiobook from Andrew S. Rightenburg (Human-Read, not AI voice or TTS voice)
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUjbFtkcDBlSHVigHHx_wjaeWmDN2W-h8
Capital Volume 2 high quality audiobook from Andrew S. Rightenburg (Human-Read, not AI voice or TTS voice)
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUjbFtkcDBlSxnp8uR2kshvhG-5kzrjdQ
Capital Volume 3 high quality audiobook from Andrew S. Rightenburg (Human-Read, not AI voice or TTS voice)
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUjbFtkcDBlRoV5CVoc5yyYL4nMO9ZJzO
Theories of Surplus Value high quality audiobook from Andrew S. Rightenburg (Human-Read, not AI voice or TTS voice)
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUjbFtkcDBlQa-dFgNFtQvvMOgNtV7nXp
Paul Cockshott - Labor Theory of Value Playlist
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKVcO3co5aCBnDt7k5eU8msX4DhTNUila
Paul Cockshott - Economic Planning Playlist
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKVcO3co5aCDnkyY9YkQxpx6FxPJ23joH
Paul Cockshott - Materialism, Marxism, and Thermodynamics Playlist
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKVcO3co5aCBv0m0fAjoOy1U4mOs_Y8QM
Victor Magariño - Austrian Economics: A Critical Analysis
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpHi51IjLqerA1aKeGe3DcRc7zCCFkAoq
Victor Magariño - Rethinking Classical Economics
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpHi51IjLqepj9uE1hhCrA66tMvNlnItt
Victor Magariño - Mathematics for Classical Political Economy
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpHi51IjLqepWUHXIgVhC_Txk2WJgaSst
Geopolitical Economy Hour with Radhika Desai and Michael Hudson (someone says "he's CIA doing reheated Proudhonism" lol)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X7ejfZdPboo&list=PLDAi0NdlN8hMl9DkPLikDDGccibhYHnDP

Potential Sources of Information
Leftypol Wiki Political Economy Category (needs expanding)
https://leftypedia.miraheze.org/wiki/Category:Political_economy
Sci-Hub
https://sci-hub.se/about
Marxists Internet Archive
https://www.marxists.org/
Library Genesis
https://libgen.is/
University of the Left
http://ouleft.sp-mesolite.tilted.net/Online
bannedthought.net
https://bannedthought.net/
Books scanned by Ismail from eregime.org that were uploaded to archive.org
https://archive.org/details/@ismail_badiou
The Great Soviet Encyclopedia: Articles from the GSE tend to be towards the bottom.
https://encyclopedia2.thefreedictionary.com/
EcuRed: Cuba's online encyclopedia
https://www.ecured.cu/
Books on libcom.org
https://libcom.org/book
Dictionary of Revolutionary Marxism
https://massline.org/Dictionary/index.htm
/EDU/ ebook share thread
https://leftypol.org/edu/res/22659.html
Pre-Marxist Economics (Marx studied these thinkers before writing Capital and Theories of Surplus Value)
https://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/economics/index.htm
Principle writings of Karl Marx on political economy, 1844-1883
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/subject/economy/index.htm
Speeches and Articles of Marx and Engels on Free Trade and Protectionism, 1847-1888
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/subject/free-trade/index.htm
(The Critique Of) Political Economy After Marx's Death
https://www.marxists.org/subject/economy/postmarx.htm
324 posts and 99 image replies omitted.

>>2941517
>You have quite literally contended with me in the past
I have no idea who you are, sorry.
Please don't fall into a parasocial delusion on top of everything else.
Also, I thought you just said you would stop replying to me? Curious.
>a) Marx did not use dialectics and that b) a dialectical reading of capital is unjustified
Are you confusing me with Paul Cockshott? 😅
In any case, there is an archive of my posts saved in the OP.
My perspective is laid out here: >>2854956
I believe Marx's Capital is a fully dialectical logic parallel to Hegel.
Context for hesitation is given in my review of David Harvey: >>2854790
<It appears that Marx uses much of Hegel's logic in his analysis, but no one can be certain.
The point on certainty is repeated recently: >>2937816
<I personally believe that Marx intended his Critique to be structured according to Hegelian conception, but I cannot prove it directly
This is the enclosure of the discussion. You seem to be confused.
>you cannot actually define what value is
How do you mean? Exchange-value is the expression of a magnitude; namely, how much of [X] is traded for [Y]. If [X] = £2, it trades for 2 GBP. This is Marx's value form; an exchange-rate between goods.
>a priori
No, no. From my early posts, I have posited an a posteriori value.
Value is an effect, not a cause. Nothing has intrinsic value.
>This is the most you will get from me
Didn't you already say you would stop replying to me?
Somehow I doubt you will revert on your promises, again.
Anyway, as I say, I wish you well, my friend. May you find peace. 🙏

>>2941505
>I'm not continuing this conversation with a blithering idiot
>>2941517
>(continues anyway)

L M F A O (nta)

When all else fails, deny who you are and that you ever made those posts

>>2941525
>This is the enclosure of the discussion. You seem to be confused.
There is absolutely no confusion here, it is not Hegelian. You then outlined your own perverse systematisation of an idealist sketch of Capital's form. You routinely deny and then backtrack as that very argument began from the insistence of a denial, you are selectively paraphrasing your own posts in order to skirt the wider issue.

It is not cause and effect; you subvert an actual materialist understanding of value by posing it fundamentally as located in the act of exchange, hence you end up with the most baffling assertion that "nothing has value".

This is your most profoundly stupid assertion yet. The only defensible quote you may retreat to from here is your demented understanding of Fetishism (which you have butchered) in the misguided insistence value does not stalk around with a label saying what it is.

That you cannot actually 'locate' a correct understanding of value is debited to the fact that you fundamentally are incapable of reading Capital, and moreso abuse the idea of capitalist exchange as exchange de facto. Hence the repeated forrays into the appearance of the form of value in its historic guise (yet another lackluster misunderstanding!)

Again, read Robert's blogposts. Specifically on the US economy and AI development, and spare us from this inane obsession of refracting historical works through your own demented understanding of political economy.

I still fucking laugh at the fact that you called politics a fucking science. You have such a bourgeois understanding of the world because you have never actually read Marx. For anybody who does not wish to end up like this moron, read:

- First Premises of Materialist Method
- Theses On Feuerbach

The latter especially. When human thought is posed as sensuous activity and the idealist contemplation of the world subverted, the abstract universalisation of individual categories ends. Thus you end up out of the mire of shit this idiot has fallen into with their rubric of re-peddling long dead bourgeois economists.

>>2941548
>posing it fundamentally as located in the act of exchange
To any Marxist here this is such a baffling nonsensical assertion as to your contention that value then has no material existence

Again, you are arse backwards Smith-Anon. And this studied scholar has sunk 4 beers already. Alas, the night is young!

>Politics is a science
I still can't stop laughing

Wait until the politicians find out mate

>>2941548
contemplation of the world inverted*

I'm done Smith anon, there are 2D images of scantily clad women that beckon

Good luck with Marx tho (or not, whatever) 👍👍👍

File: 1793348540274-3.jpg (90.58 KB, 512x506, Jesus.jpg)

>>2941539
>>2941553
Third times the charm.
Do you reckon he'll actually stay away this time? 🤞
>>2941545
There is literally an indestructible archive of all my previous posts in the OP. You are free to prove yourself right, but so far you have only proven yourself wrong, such as with this misattribution: >>2941474
Your first post is factually incorrect – nevertheless, you persist. You have only been incorrect. That is the legacy of your digital footprint.
>>2941548
>an idealist sketch of Capital's form
In Marx's writings, both "value" and "capital" are seen as conceptual.
That is the Hegelian intrigue:
<What was decisively important, however, was to discover the inner, necessary connection between value-form, value-substance, and value-amount; i.e., expressed conceptually, to prove that the value form arises out of the value-concept.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
<the general concept of capital – is that it is this unity of production and realization, not immediately but only as a process […] The contradiction between production and realization – of which capital, by its concept, is the unity […] capital already in its very concept divides into two capitals with an independent existence.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch08.htm
The Hegelian concept is a unity between the subjective and objective; to Marx, these are variable and constant capital unified as capital (k):
<the objective and subjective factors, as means of production and labour-power, present themselves, from the point of view of the process of creating surplus-value, as constant and variable capital.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch08.htm
The materialist aspect of Marx's dialectic I provide here: >>2855317
<Substance to Hegel is mind, which in Spirit, is made subject. To Marx on the contrary, the "substance of value" is labour. Here then, we have a materialist reversal, so as to put Hegel back onto his feet.
Quite cohesive, really.
>an actual materialist understanding of value
As a "materialist", does a thing called "value" exist in commodities?
<The value of commodities is the very opposite of the coarse materiality of their substance, not an atom of matter enters into its composition […] So far no chemist has ever discovered exchange value either in a pearl or a diamond. 
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Value is a superstition which you cleave to, apparently.
You literally embody the fetishism of commodities.
>nothing has value
Again, this is a misattribution. I said nothing has intrinsic value. I was expositing Marx's own perspective to simplify things for you:
<an intrinsic value […] seems a contradiction in terms […] Nothing can have an intrinsick value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
This is because value is inherently relative, as Marx footnotes. A thing is only worth as much as another thing; this is Marx's form of value.
>the appearance of the form of value
This is a tautology. The appearance of value is its form, to Marx.
Value does not exist outside of its appearance, consequently.
>the act of exchange
Value doesn't exist outside of exchange, to Marx. You already agreed:
<It is plain that commodities cannot go to market and make exchanges of their own account […] In order that these objects may enter into relation with each other as commodities, their guardians must place themselves in relation to one another […] this change of hands is what constitutes their exchange, and the latter puts them in relation with each other as values, and realises them as values
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch02.htm
You agree with me, and so get mad at yourself for agreeing with me.
Where you attempt to posture disagreement, you can only misquote what I have said, proving that taken by myself, you submit to me. As I say, this is what psychologists describe as "cognitive dissonance", typically associated with indoctrination, like religious propaganda. As a Marxist, you are evidently afflicted by a cultish loyalty to a master, in contradiction to reasonable scepticism, causing emotional problems. As I have said, I wish you peace, my friend. May you be cured. 🙏😁

>>2942170
>You are free to prove yourself right
<"Ah yes, I did in fact argue that there was no substantive basis for a dialectical reading of Capital"

>In Marx's writings, both "value" and "capital" are seen as conceptual.

This is laughable; you treat conceptual terminology as theoretical ideals divorced from their historically (contingent) realities. Thus Capital is a 'concept' (on par with 'value') and never proceeds from the scientific unfolding of human society; as such you need never depart from your scholarly activity of pulling quotations endlessly from myriad authors without ever actually engaging with what they have written.

Not only do you not understand Marx, but the same can be said for most of the authors you write about. And why? Because you are stuck in some fantastical professorial delusion in which your feet never touch the ground and you begin utilising long dead slave-holding society philosophers as on par with modern social theorists.

It is quite literally pointless in reminding you of this as you bend the truth where it suits you and resort to hitting over the head anyone who dares to contest the point with "BUT I HAVE WRITTEN ON THIS…" as you then quote absolute dogrel miscomprehensions of a slew of political thinkers.

Nobody here is going to engage with you, and if they do it is because they feel they must wage some sad defence in the name of truth which holds in common not some virtuosity of intellect but collective stupidity.

This thread has become some publishing corner for a dunce's poorly worded thoughts. You should be banned.

>>2942170
>Again, this is a misattribution
This is absolutely fucking comical as it is plain to see you have quite literally just stated it in the precious post

Why you are allowed to continue posting is a fucking mystery



File: 1793357871330-5.png (346.83 KB, 570x346, 7ktz1q.png)

>>2942191
>>2942192
Anon, is there a reason you keep saying that you'll stop replying to me, yet find it irresistable? You're totally addicted to me; I'm not sure why. I'm not interesting. In any case, repeated failures to keep promises displays a pathologically dishonest character in your person. It is only continuous of this facet of your being (e.g. feeling the need to lie, to yourself and others) which spurns on the repeated misattribution of what I wrote. You provide claims which are proven false (e.g. that I claimed Marx's work to be non-dialectical), or even conversely, you see that I interpret Marx dialectically, but in an idealist way. Both cannot be true at once, and further, I even present Marx's materialist reversal of Hegel. Every claim you make is either self-evidently false (e.g. contradictory), or proven to be false after the fact. Everything you say is wrong, and this begins in yourself. You are dysfunctional and I want you to get better, but this requires your effort, friend. Inshallah.
>you treat conceptual terminology as theoretical ideals divorced from their historically (contingent) realities
It's you who thinks "value" actually exists, remember.
>utilising long dead slave-holding society philosophers
You mean like Marx did? Wisdom is timeless.
Why do you think Marx calls Aristotle a 'brilliant genius'?
>Nobody here is going to engage with you
Anon… This is the fourth time you've written this.
Are you admitting to be part of a "collective stupidity?"
I never asked to live rent free in your head.
Please log off for your own mental health. God bless you. 🙏

>>2942195
Clara Ramas (San Miguel) as a student of Heinrich is evidently astute. For these reasons, she clearly sees that the fetishism of commodities is itself given in the form of value, where a commodity assumes the role of indirectly representing social production by spectral objectivity. Value is a superstition which is attributed to being inherent to products:
<The value of commodities is the very opposite of the coarse materiality of their substance, not an atom of matter enters into its composition […] The life-process of society, which is based on the process of material production, does not strip off its mystical veil until it is treated as production by freely associated men, and is consciously regulated by them in accordance with a settled plan […] The mode of production in which the product takes the form of a commodity […] makes its appearance at an early date in history […] its Fetish character is comparatively easy to be seen through. But when we come to more concrete forms, even this appearance of simplicity vanishes […] superstition […] no chemist has ever discovered exchange value either in a pearl or a diamond
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
For the same reason, a Communist society has no form of value:
<Within the co-operative society based on common ownership of the means of production, the producers do not exchange their products; just as little does the labor employed on the products appear here as the value of these products, as a material quality possessed by them, since now, in contrast to capitalist society, individual labor no longer exists in an indirect fashion but directly as a component part of total labor […] a given amount of labor in one form is exchanged for an equal amount of labor in another form.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1875/gotha/ch01.htm
So, commodities are themselves a fetish; alienated labour assuming a relationship between objects, rather than as between human beings.

>>2942219
>commodities are themselves a fetish
This is absolute fucking nonsense

Stop posting

File: 1793370002912-3.mp4 (829.97 KB, 640x360, Value.mp4)

>>2942243
Is this the fifth time you have returned to me? Please "touch grass".
Also, you don't seem to understand Marx; the commodity form is the manner by which alienated labour is expressed. It is the way in which social relations between persons appear as social relations between things. Thus, the value form is the fetish; an "inversion" of the world. You are the one who presumably posted the video, yet you appear to disagree with it – did you even watch it? Again, you just make your own problems. I hope you are able to be emotionally mature one day.

Read this for clarity:
<In order, therefore, to find an analogy, we must have recourse to the mist-enveloped regions of the religious world. In that world the productions of the human brain appear as independent beings endowed with life, and entering into relation both with one another and the human race. So it is in the world of commodities with the products of men’s hands. This I call the Fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities, and which is therefore inseparable from the production of commodities.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
See then, this fetishism is inseparable from commodities. The "products of labour" are fetishised when they become commodities:
<the Fetishism inherent in commodities, or by the objective appearance of the social characteristics of labour
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Value – "objective appearance of the social characteristics of labour"
I hope this helps in your learning journey. We can teach each other. 👍

>>2942277
You've reversed the object subject relation because you still cannot comprehend materialism, hence the inane miserable misidentification of commodities be a fetish rather than the converse being the case.

The fact that you've done this whilst quoting a Marxist theorist is all the more ridiculous.

You still have not understood a word of Marx because you cannot even explain the critique within Theses on Feuerbach. Any attempt to do so by you will likely be riddled with your incessant need to vomit words onto a screen by struggling and failing to encounter the central underlying argument as you reduce it to yet another blog post of taxonomising authors and playing your version of Punch and Judy with them.

Do fuck off.

>>2942280
commodities as a fetish*

You quite literally do not understand any of the topics on which you write. Unironically, are you disabled?

It would be absolutely no surprise Smith Anon if you had Asperger's syndrome

>>2942280
>>2942282
>>2942283
This is the sixth time you have had a tantrum.
Four times you promised to never reply again. What happened?
>misidentification of commodities be a fetish
Marx literally writes it here:
<fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
We can go through this slowly (i):
<fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
So then, we understand that products of labour become fetishised (ii):
<so soon as they are produced as commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
And this occurs when they are produced as commodities.
So, to read Marx plainly, commodities are fetishised labour.
Clara Ramas agrees with me. She is a Marxist scholar. It is clear.
I sincerely hope you can get a grip on your mental health. Good luck. 👍

>>2942285
>Marx literally writes it here:
><fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities

And again you've misunderstood the quote because you've stripped it for an argument you do not understand. Material reality is produced by human intercourse, thus it is commodity fetishism and not fetishism-commodities as it would be by your logic.

But what is this Sperg-Anon, can we not unpick this stitch because you have no real capacity for engaging with half of what you write? And why? Because you bend the truth, retort in circular arguments, and then cover up your own miscomprehensions.

>>2942286
>>2942285
This argument is so inane because you attribute to commodities that very quality which Marx critiques

This is such an irony it cannot be overstated. You do not actually understand Marx. Reread him, please

>>2942286
>>2942287
>it is commodity fetishism and not fetishism-commodities
Anon, the title of the section is "the fetishism of commodities".
A fetishism "attaches itself to the products of labour", as Marx writes.
You are so deranged that you think Marx didn't understand himself.
Seven is a lucky number, so hopefully you can begin healing, now. 🙏

>>2942292
It isn't a simple rewording you fucking dunce, I'm aware of what the chapter title is. As expected you cannot actually engage with the point because it means accepting you've misunderstood the materialist premise itself.

Fetishism, which somehow exists in your deranged conception unlike value, is not a property of a commodity. It is the fetishism of commodities in their social relation as objects of exchange which constitutes what the speaker terms the inversion with their quote of volume 3 ("madame and monsieur", "ghostlike", etc) and hence the reality whereby commodities are not a "fetish" but a fetish is an existent state within capitalist society which describes how commodities themselves are inscribed.

But oh look, have you once again not only misunderstood Marx but completely subverted a materialist understanding through your own poorly informed version of idealistic Platonism.

Just stop posting. You don't understand Marx, you certainly have no actual grasp of Political Economy, and you have not understood a word of what has been discussed in the video. It is a poor joke that someone must respond to your inane horseshit repeatedly in order to get you to shut up.

>>2942354
The difficulty of relating the differential between your own distortion and what a social fetish actually is is compounded by the complication of its usage, whereby you have in the past a) labelled all things and everything under the sun a fetish and b) cannot understand that while 'nothing has value' is false will then walk around asserting commodities as possessing some magical intrinsic property which defers from their usages.

Capital is a social relation; it is a property of capitalist society whereby exchange itself is compounded into a fashion in which value has a material reality, and thus Capital exists fundamentally as a process of its dialectical unfolding.

I cannot relate this explanation to you in one hundred words let alone ten thousand because your own stupidity forbids the first step of actually engaging with materialism. When it is said "Capital is a social relation" the primary expectation of the reader is in having advanced beyond whatever pitiful and sorry understanding you have of Hegel to the critique that is implied in the Theses. You have decided yet again to break Marx down into a quote-mine to be stripped out whenever your ego demands you must vomit up some deluded and demented writing on the latest book you have read.

It should be made a precondition of at least asking questions in this general that you have this, said, capacity. Why you are allowed to shit up this general is beyond me.

>>2942364
I do not want to see your brain addled orange quote responses, I literally do not care to read them.

You cannot actually be spoken to about political economy because you fundamentally cannot engage with any materialist argument which is offered.

If you seriously want to spent the rest of your life shitting up this general posting nonsense diatribes on long dead scholars to be read by two or three people a week, go right ahead.

My advice is actually download a university syllabus and work through a reading list or better yet, go and do an actual fucking degree.

>>2942369
Ah but Smith-Anon, this is a tantrum.

You've won! The nonsense-horseshit-posting can continue apace!

It is so sad that you are incapable of actually understanding what fetishism is, as it is the chapter on which turns the axis of Marx's entire works, as it pulls together every argument made in the body of capital. Thus it is you believe Marx has walked away calling everything a 'fetish' without the slightest capacity to understand what has actually been accomplished.

You have been given a suggested reading list, it is in your precious archive. Go back and read First Premises Of Materialist Method, it is simple. Then Theses on Feuerbach. Then the Manifesto. Then On The Jewish Question. Then Critique of Hegelian State.

It is that simple.

File: 1793378014235-9-1.mp4 (829.97 KB, 640x360, Value.mp4)

>>2942374
>>2942369
>>2942354
>>2942364
This is the 8th time you have replied to me whilst you professed never to reply to me ever again – 4 times. Why are you obsessed with me?
>Fetishism […] is not a property of a commodity
To Marx, labour is fetishised when it becomes a commodity; a "value".
This is what both myself and Marxist scholars say. You disagree.
>you once again not only misunderstood Marx
Please interpret this passage for me:
<fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
>you have not understood a word of what has been discussed in the video
Please interpret both of these videos for me. What is she saying?
>value has a material reality
No it doesn't. We can read Marx again:
<The value of commodities is the very opposite of the coarse materiality of their substance, not an atom of matter enters into its composition […] no chemist has ever discovered exchange value either in a pearl or a diamond
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Value is an abstraction. Immaterial.
If you recall, only concrete labour is material (e.g. use-value).
>I literally do not care to read them.
Well, it's clear that you have learning disabilities linked to literacy. The first thing you posted towards me was a misattributed quotation. This is why I try to provide for your special needs by keeping things simple. I hope you are able to become mentally healthy and allow yourself to have a great life, instead of causing your own problems. Be healed. 🙏

File: 1793382660818-0.jpg (35.11 KB, 511x511, Peridot.jpg)

Also, to provide proof of your error.
You remark: >>2941517
<You have quite literally contended with me in the past that a) Marx did not use dialectics and that b) a dialectical reading of capital is unjustified
I wonder how far back you imagine things, because here is a post I made [17–04–25], which is identical to what I posted [30–06–26]:
<this makes a bit more sense in hegel's logic, where "being", is given its concept in the dialectic: [quality-quantity-measure]. in the commodity form, its two factors are united in measure. this is why commodities possess value. […] in the hegelian dialectic of "essence", or "nature" [essence-appearance-actuality], the value-form [exchange-value] gives expression to this, where magnitude [X] is given concrete appearance by [Y].
https://archive.ph/f29Po
I repeat this more cohesively later on: >>2854956
Here, I present a Hegelian logic of Marx, 18 months previously.
And even earlier we have this [16–12–24]:
<i do accept marx's dialectical meaning. he says early in chapter 1 of capital that the value form is the phenomenal form of an essential value.
https://archive.ph/ROnpO
This was written 22 months ago, or nearly two years ago.
I'm afraid to say that you have hallucinated my supposed statements.
As for an apparent charge of mis-using "fetishism" [20/8-04-26]:
<the fetishism of commodities; that where there is commodity exchange, the essence of man is alienated into this idol […] Are you implying that value exists outside of the commodity fetish? There is no "thing" [i.e. value], apart from the fetish.
https://archive.ph/Hnngv
This was written around 6 months ago, and is my first series of posts on the topic; there is no record of me using the term flippantly; so, I am proven on record to be entirely consistent in my worldview, since I obviously approached these topics with a competent understanding. There is no contradiction in my presentation, since I'm not a slave to the dialectic, I suppose. Comunists live in ease with logical errors, and project their failure of reasoning into matter; into reality itself. Clods.

>>2942383
Two things

>To Marx, labour is fetishised when it becomes a commodity; a "value".

From the get to this is just plain nonsense, the sentence is indecipherable and just confirms your misunderstanding as to what a fetishism is. It is when social relations are reproduced in a historical system of production whereby they said relations present themselves within the objects of production, chiefly commodities. (Laughibly here you have completely misunderstood volume 1 as labour is the source of value). This does not make commodities somehow 'fetishised'; it is a structural relation which is inverted between the subject and the object in which the latter appears on behalf of the former. This diagnostic criteria could be used for your little magpie archive of treasurable posts as it is the central criticism upheld against you for your lack of understanding the materialist ontology. The rest of your post is just wild flailing around this issue. This also leads neatly onto the second point:

>value has a material reality

Yes it does you moron; you cannot uphold the idea of a conceptual understanding of fetishism and argue against this, it is ridiculous. This is typical of your dogshit understanding of commodity fetishism. Value is a material force which exists objectively as a result of the social relation of capital and ergo can be said to exist in a material sense. That you deny this on a Marxist image board is so ridiculous beggars belief. The rationale behind your counter quote is again a misquote to this fact, and on par with Senior's last hour in terms of reasoning.

>>2942444
The stupidity of your position is such that you are contending commodity fetishism exists by using the same inverted logic Marx critiques

You cannot be brought down from this because your position is once again unassailable as you quote mine capital for walls of text akin to hurdles.

>>2942422
My friend, I am not going into the archive for what is scored into my memory very keenly

Your insistent and partially cloaked denial (how far you think ahead!) of the structural composition of Capital Volume 1 and its dialectical relation.

I can remember the very fucking day I sat down to read that horseshit.

>>2942451
>posts hard evidence
<denies reality anyway
I hope you are at least aware that you are delusional.
>>2942444
>>2942446
>the sentence is indecipherable
We must proceed from the analogy provided. Marx:
<to find an analogy, we must have recourse to the mist-enveloped regions of the religious world. In that world the productions of the human brain appear as independent beings endowed with life, and entering into relation both with one another and the human race
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Here, "fetishism" is understood generally (e.g. fetishism in that time referred to superstitious worship; idolatry, etc.) Marx sees how the "productions of the human brain" gain independent and mystic forms:
<So it is in the world of commodities with the products of men’s hands. This I call the Fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities, and which is therefore inseparable from the production of commodities.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Thus, "the products of labour" attain the same mystifying relation, but what exactly is this obscurity? Marx says it begins in the commodity:
<The mystical character of commodities does not originate, therefore, in their use value […] Whence, then, arises the enigmatical character of the product of labour, so soon as it assumes the form of commodities? Clearly from this form itself.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
So then, the form of the commodity is itself the mystical character:
<A commodity is therefore a mysterious thing, simply because in it the social character of men’s labour appears to them as an objective character stamped upon the product of that labour; because the relation of the producers to the sum total of their own labour is presented to them as a social relation, existing not between themselves, but between the products of their labour […] the Fetishism inherent in commodities, or by the objective appearance of the social characteristics of labour
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
This "objective appearance of [social labour]" is the spectre of value.
Therefore, the fetish-object is the commodity itself (i.e. value).
>said relations present themselves within the objects of production
Question: does Communist production have fetishism?
Why does Marx say that Communism abolishes the value form?
>Value is a material force
No it isn't. Marx says that it is purely immaterial; a phantom.
You even agree that it is a social construct constituted in exchange:
<value is realised only by exchange
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
As I say, you agree with me, then get angry at yourself. Get help. 🙏

>>2942444
>>2942446
>>2942451
>>2942473
To simplify everything, please read this from Marx:
<Whence, then, arises the enigmatical character of the product of labour, so soon as it assumes the form of commodities? Clearly from this form itself. […] the Fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
The form of commodities itself is therefore the fetish.
There is nothing more to conclude. You can only deny reality.

>>2942476
The commodity form is not a fetish you dunce, you misapellate the term because you fundamentally do not understand it. There are objective social forces in this world you will never understand until you actually contend with materialism, mark my words.

As to the rest, consider it unread. It's a Friday, I'm drinking. Ta ta!

>>2942479
>There are objective social forces in this world
Precisely – and these are fetishised into the form of commodities.
The fetishism of labour into the form of value is its mystification.
Value is an inversion of human relations into object relations.
It is a misrecognition of social production; an indirect expression.
The theory of Communism therefore is to directly express labour.
The value form is abolished because the fetish-object is abolished, etc.
>It's a Friday, I'm drinking. Ta ta!
Should I consider this a fifth time you have claimed to stop replying?

>>2942483
i'm actually not sure you understand what "fetishism" means in this context

File: 1793391597669-9.jpg (129.6 KB, 442x434, golden calf.jpg)

>>2942484
What do you feel I misunderstand?
Fetishism in this context is commodification; the inversion of social relations between men into social relations between things, by the spectre of "value"; a phantom-like objectivity which stamps products with its mark; namely, social labour, indirectly received in its quantity. The fetishism (e.g. superstition) is thus an attribution of commodities possessing a thing called "value" as an intrinsic property. Value is an abstraction, which by internal dialectical development, conceives the capital relation, and so on, where mystification is most intense (e.g. in the "trinity formula" of the "prices of production"). Communism thus seeks to abolish fetishism by abolishing the form of value (e.g. the commodification of production, thereby directly representing labour):
<The life-process of society, which is based on the process of material production, does not strip off its mystical veil until it is treated as production by freely associated men, and is consciously regulated by them in accordance with a settled plan
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Thus, the "settled plan" (e.g. central plan) is the rational form in which social production proceeds, without internal contradictions of value (e.g. the precedence of exchange-value in capitalist production leads to general crises – which as we see today, even threaten civilisation). Fetishism is itself a primary irrationality on which all other irrationality proceeds. The moderns are more superstitious than the ancients, etc.
<The mode of production in which the product takes the form of a commodity […] makes its appearance at an early date in history […] its Fetish character is comparatively easy to be seen through. But when we come to more concrete forms, even this appearance of simplicity vanishes […] superstition
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
<nowhere with the Romans do we find that the right of private property was mystified as in the case of the Germans
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/ch05.htm
<Up till now it has been thought that the growth of the Christian myths during the Roman Empire was possible only because printing was not yet invented. Precisely the contrary. The daily press and the telegraph, which in a moment spreads inventions over the whole earth, fabricate more myths (and the bourgeois cattle believe and enlarge upon them) in one day than could have formerly been done in a century.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1871/letters/71_07_27.htm
This perhaps also clarifies why I find much affection for the ancients.

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2026/11/03/ezeb-n03.html

Capitalist Crisis, Imperialist War and the World Socialist Revolution

it's over…

>>2951387
Its excellent news that markets are correcting instead of crashing down like the dotcom bubble. Still my opinion is that this will just postpone the bubble popping while making the crash itself less extreme.

>>2951423
The core issue is going to be the super-inflated computer costs need to payout to something to balance out the debts accumulated, all of these AI companies bought out loads of land, computer parts, and whatnot and need to provide an ROI which simply isn't manifesting. It's not the kind of thing that can be quietly corrected on the supply-side.

>>2951387
>>2951423
The dotcom crash happened over a period of about 2 years or something.

File: 1794239465034-6.png (3.61 MB, 1973x1654, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2951475
> It's not the kind of thing that can be quietly corrected on the supply-side.
bailout time

File: 1794260470196-4.png (5.73 MB, 2262x2673, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2951596
>bailout time

To make things even clearer, let us first of all take the most concrete example of state capitalism. Everybody knows what this example is. It is Germany. Here we have “the last word” in modern large-scale capitalist engineering and planned organization, subordinated to Junker-bourgeois imperialism. Cross out the words in italics, and in place of the militarist, Junker, bourgeois, imperialist state put also a state, but of a different social type, of a different class content; a Soviet state, that is, a proletarian state, and you will have the sum total of the conditions necessary for socialism. Socialism is inconceivable without large-scale capitalist engineering based on the latest discoveries of modern science. It is inconceivable without planned state organization, which keeps tens of millions of people to the strictest observance of a unified standard in production and distribution. We Marxists have always spoken of this, and it is not worth while wasting two seconds talking to people who do not understand even this (anarchists and a good half of the Left Socialist-Revolutionaries). At the same time socialism is inconceivable unless the proletariat is the ruler of the state. This also is ABC. And history (which nobody, except Menshevik blockheads of the first order, ever expected to bring about “complete” socialism smoothly, gently, easily and simply) has taken such a peculiar course that it has given birth in 1918 to two unconnected halves of socialism existing side by side like two future chickens in the single shell of international imperialism.

  • Lenin, “Left-Wing” Childishness, 1918

File: 1794300734871-5.jpeg (27.98 KB, 588x339, images.jpeg)

There are many debates around Marx's theory of value, which have conflicting interpretations due to the internal conflict of the author himself. My comprehensive view presented here is that Marx has a consistent theory of value from 1844–65, of alienated labour, and post–1867 is a revised theory of value which reifies "value" as such, showing dishonour and degeneration in Marx's person.

The earliest writings Marx has on value are this (1844):
<The mediating process between men engaged in exchange is not a social or human process, not human relationship; it is the abstract relationship of private property to private property, and the expression of this abstract relationship is value, whose actual existence as value constitutes money […] as an equivalent is no longer its specific mode of existence. It has thus become a value, and immediately an exchange-value. 
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/james-mill/
Here, "value" is not something immediate to production, but is only something mediating exchange; value is the alienation of labour itself, in the form of self-relating private property (e.g. the fetishism of commodities). It is further, "immediately an exchange-value" whose "actual existence as value constitutes money". So, value is both (i) exchange-value and (ii) money. Value is thus money:
<the real value of things is their exchange-value and this in the last instance exists in money
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/james-mill/
Still, Marx reserves mystery:
<How this value is more precisely determined must be described elsewhere, as also how it becomes price.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/james-mill/
So Marx also sees a medium term between (exchange-) value, purely, and money (i.e. price). Here, the minimum case is that value only has existence as estrangement of labour, where anti-social production appears social. In describing non-alienated production and exchange, property does not bear the mark of possessing "value".

By 1847, Marx addresses Proudhon, by viewing conflict between the use-value and exchange-value as a conflict between producers and consumers – a dialectical unity:
<Demand is at the same time a supply, supply is at the same time a demand.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/poverty-philosophy/ch01.htm
Marx simply substitutes "exchange-value" and "value" in the meantime, as the SNLT for a commodity's creation, which as he adds, is only "ascertained by competition". Too, Marx describes value as a purely relative reality:
<[value] constituted, not by the time needed to produce it by itself, but in relation to the quota of each and every other product which can be created in the same time.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/james-mill/
So then, value is an inherently relative phenomenon:
<Money is not a thing, it is a social relation.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/poverty-philosophy/ch01c.htm
Finally, Marx states in this text that slaves make "value" for the American colonies, so the value of commodities is then presumed to occur from a relation of exchange (e.g. between the master-seller and the purchaser). In this case, the labour counts, even without being paid, so value does not begin in commoditised labour, but only in labour which becomes a commodity. Value in exchange. In the same year (1847), Marx also had a short series of speeches in which he determined "price" as "estimation" of the exchange-value of a commodity in money. This then resolves the earlier mystery in 1844, where a "price" is a monetised exchange-value (i.e. SNLT) of a product.

We now jump forward to 1857, in the Grundrisse, where Marx describes a "product" as being both "potential" and real, where only consumption constitutes its reality. So, for example, a house that is not lived in is not a "real" house according to Marx, etc. No invocation of "value" is given, but is relevant to later comments made in 1867:
<nothing can have value, without being an object of utility. If the thing is useless, so is the labour contained in it; the labour does not count as labour, and therefore creates no value.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
This will be returned to, later on. For the present, Marx sees that commodity exchange requires a money-form:
<does not the bourgeois system of exchange itself necessitate a specific instrument of exchange? Does it not necessarily create a specific equivalent for all values? […] The value relation between A and B is expressed by means of the proportion in which they are exchanged for a quantity of a third commodity, namely silver […] exchange value of a commodity, as a separate form of existence accompanying the commodity itself, is money […] impossible to abolish money itself as long as exchange value remains the social form of products.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch02.htm
So then, in exchange, there are 3 commodities; A and B, and C – money. The "exchange value" of commodities is thus money, which is the "social form of products". Too, Marx writes that commodities have an exchange-value:
<[money is] the embodiment of the exchange value of the other commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch02.htm
So then, we still presume exchange-value as referring to SNLT, with money only expressing its independent form:
<In exchange value, the social connection between persons is transformed into a social relation between things
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch03.htm
We again return to the 1844 comments. Money is the concrete form of estrangement, being exchange value:
<On the basis of exchange values, labour is posited as general only through exchange
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch03.htm
This follows from what was said before, that "mediation is required, a means to accomplish this abstraction", in the form of exchange value. Money is then the positing of labour "as general", capable "only through exchange". Without this medium, labour cannot attain abstraction:
<the exchange of commodities is evidently an act characterised by a total abstraction from use value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
So, only by exchange value is labour seen to be abstract:
<C–M: the exchange value of the commodity is expressed […] in the material of money
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch04.htm
Here, money is not simply exchange value, but is seen as expressing the exchange value of commodities, as already commented on. So, we return to comments in 1844, that value as a social relation is exchange-value and money. Exchange-value expressed in money is also price, so each are seemingly identical. Marx writes this:
<Is not value to be conceived as the unity of use value and exchange value? In and for itself, is value as such the general form, in opposition to use value and exchange value as particular forms of it?
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch05.htm
Unfortunately, this is not really developed, but it reveals his thought-process, which has some later continuity:
<Commodities as values […] the commodity is immediate unity of use-value and exchange-value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
So, "value" in and for itself, becomes the commodity.

Returning to the present text:
<As a slave, the worker has exchange value, a value; as a free wage-worker he has no value; it is rather his power of disposing of his labour, effected by exchange with him, which has value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch05.htm
So then, only a commodity (i.e. a slave) has a value, to be equated with its exchange-value. Value is exclusive to the status of commodities, it seems; exchange-value:
<exchange between capital and labour […] This living labour, existing as an abstraction from these moments of its actual reality […] as the existing not-value, and hence purely objective use value, existing without mediation […] Labour not as an object, but as activity; not as itself value, but as the living source of value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch06.htm
So then, living labour only has abstraction from actual reality, given by the exchange relation. In its actuality, it is a not-value (i.e. use-value) because value is only a medium. As such, pure "use value" is valueless. As we read, value is a unity of value in use and exchange, and too, value is made equivalent to exchange-value. So, we see "value" as only existing in exchange. Surplus value:
<Capital as a form consists not of objects of labour and labour, but rather of values, and, still more precisely, of prices […] how it can create exchange values greater than those with which it began […] not the sum of values which enter into production […] he obtains objectified labour time, i.e. value, without exchange. Half the working day costs capital nothing; it thus obtains a value for which it has given no equivalent
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch06.htm
We see thus that because capital as a form doesn't deal in labour (i.e. use-value), but value (i.e. exchange-value), surplus value is not effected merely by a non-exchange:
<surplus value on capital’s side appears identically on the worker’s side as surplus labour
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch06.htm
To be consistent therefore, surplus labour in itself can't be surplus value, but only surplus labour in exchange:
<The increase of values is therefore the result of the self-realization of capital […] labour […] has become already a moment of capital.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch07.htm
Surplus labour becomes in itself a surplus value. Only with capital therefore are labour and value identical, since the use-value of labour is itself an exchange-value. This is contradicted by Marx, however, on devaluation:
<money becomes capital only through the realization process – appears at the same time as its devaluation process [Entwertungsprozess], its demonetization […] In the production process itself […] as a commodity, it appears dependent on circulation, which lies outside this process […] new value can be realized only through a sale […] consumption itself – the need for it.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch08.htm
So then, in production, there cannot be value in actuality, but like the product, only in potential. This defined by an absolute negativity; i.e. devaluation. So then, without the demand (i.e. need), there cannot be the value of goods. Value then is exclusively realised by exchange media. It is incorrect to then identify production with a real value. All value is necessarily given from an exchange-value:
<new value can be realized only through a sale
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch08.htm
Again:
<become devalued, i.e. made the transition from money to the form of a particular commodity
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch08.htm
So, this is reminiscent of comments in 1844:
<value, whose actual existence as value constitutes money
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/james-mill/
Money, as the independent exchange value of products, is the very form of value itself; of abstract human labour. If value is then exclusive to trade, whence cometh value?
<circulation does not itself produce a moment of value-determination, for that lies exclusively in labour
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch10.htm
So then, production; devaluation, is simultaneously the process of "value-determination", not value-realisation. A value is then given potency, but is only real in exchange.

Marx writes this on the "form of wealth as wealth":
<the development of the concept of capital, that it is value as such, money, which both preserves itself through circulation and also increases itself through exchange with living labour […] the aim of producing capital is never use value, but rather the general form of wealth as wealth
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch12.htm
Here, "value as such" is identical with money, which from capital, preserves and expands itself in circulation, not as use-value, but "wealth as wealth"; i.e. exchange-value:
<the values of products are measured not by the labour employed in them, but by the labour necessary for their production […] through exchange
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch12.htm
Again, exchange is the prerequisite for "value as such":
<As long as it remains in the production process it is not capable of circulating; and it is virtually devalued.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch12.htm
So again, production is a process of devaluation. Now:
<Value as such is always an effect, never a cause.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch13.htm
This seems to convey Marx's meaning. The production process creates use-values, but only where exchange is effected, do commodities become values – as we read, that the unity of use-value and exchange-value gives us this "result", which fundamentally occurs by exchange:
<The exchange of living labour for objectified labour – i.e. the positing of social labour in the form of the contradiction of capital and wage labour – is the ultimate development of the value-relation and of production resting on value.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch14.htm
So, all value is present by the "value-relation", supposing "production resting on value", which therefore supposes "value" to be entirely particular, not universal, of labour:
<capital […] relating to itself, through the mediation of […] profit
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch15.htm
So then, surplus value is expressed by this medium, in the same way that "value as such" becomes money. So, value is always apparent, exclusively as a medium term.

From 1844–58 therefore, we see a consistent view of value being the medium of exchange (i.e. money) from which the various exchange-values of commodities are expressed in an independent form. It is by this manner of representation that abstract labour can manifest. It is then the act of exchange that constitutes commodities as exchange-values; a purely relative phenomenon. In production, value has "determination", but is a potential, not a reality. Where a commodity is not purchased it has no value, therefore, and products in themselves are not valuable, either. Value is emerges from a "value-relation", nothing else. Value is a social category, nothing natural.

In 1859, Marx begins his description of commodities:
<Every commodity […] has a twofold aspect –use-value and exchange-value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
This seems canonical of what has been written thus far:
<Labour which creates exchange-value is thus abstract general labour […] an abstraction, but it is an abstraction which is made every day in the social process of production
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
As we have read, the abstraction is peculiar to the level of competition. We see here though, abstract labour as something particular to the form of commodities alone:
<labour of an individual can produce exchange-value only if it produces universal equivalents […] use-value of one commodity is brought into relation with the use-values of other commodities. The exchange-value of one commodity thus manifests itself in the use-values of other commodities […] the use-values of all other commodities form its equivalent
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
This is only possible due to a factor of use-values:
<as materialisation of universal social labour-time
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
This again, is made exclusive to commodities. Use-value as such is not regarded as a result of abstract labour:
<1 yard of linen = 1/2 lb. of tea […] = 2 lbs. of coffee […] = 8 lbs. of bread […] = 6 yards of calico […] This is in fact an infinite series […] The exchange-value of a commodity as the objective expression of universal social labour-time finds its appropriate expression of equivalence in the infinite variety of use-values […] The commodity, however, is the direct unity of use- value and exchange-value, and at the same time it is a commodity only in relation to other commodities. The exchange process of commodities is the real relation that exists between them […] The commodity is a use-value […] it is simultaneously not a use-value […] a non-use-value […] or simply a means of exchange […] The commodity is a use-value for its owner only so far as it is an exchange-value […] The commodity therefore has still to become a use-value, in the first place a use-value for others. Since it is not a use-value to its owner, it must be a use-value to owners of other commodities […] as a result of this universal alienation […] does the labour contained in them become useful labour […] they were non-use-values for their owner, and use-values for their non-owner […] Hence, only be being realized as exchange-values can they be realized as use-values.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
This is all crucial for our understanding. A commodity is a unity of use-value and exchange-value, and only from a "real exchange" is each of these affirmed, and so the commodity is also only itself by trade with a commodity. Only by exchange is "labour contained in them become useful labour" and thereby "can they be realized". Now:
<Universal labour-time thus appears as a specific thing, as a commodity in addition to and apart from all other commodities […] the reification of universal labour-time […] a universal medium of exchange […] a universal use-value […] constitutes money […] the exchange process becomes at the same time the process of formation of money
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
So then, money is the universal commodity; exchange-value of all other commodities, as we read beforehand:
<Price is the converted form in which the exchange-value of commodities appears within the circulation process […] Commodities as exchange-values must be antecedent to circulation in order to appear as prices in circulation.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch02_1.htm
Here is where ambiguity begins. As we have read, the value of commodities are only able to be realised by an act of real exchange, elsewise they are devalued. But, at the same time, a valueless product possesses a "value-determination" in potential. Where Marx assumes the antecedence of exchange-value, therefore, this cannot be an actual value, but only as a potential value, purely. So then, this is also continuous of what we read before; i.e. value is exchange-value, exclusive to commodities, which as "value" generally, is a unity of its particulars.

Next, we can jump to an 1864 work by Marx:
<when the man who was previously a slaveholder employs his former slaves as wage labourers, etc., production processes with a different social determination are thereby converted into the production process of capital […] The slave ceases to be an instrument of production belonging to the employer of that instrument […] they all confront each other as owners of commodities, having only a monetary relation in common […] slave receives the means of subsistence necessary for his maintenance in a natural form, which is as fixed in kind as in extent — in use values. The free worker receives them in the form of money, of exchange value, of the abstract social form of wealth.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1864/economic/ch02a.htm
Here, we see continuity between earlier comments on "value-relation" constituting value as an abstract reality. Where the same man is employed under different kinds of payment, the medium of exchange determines if his labour is returned as use-value or exchange-value. So, it is only by a value-relation that labour becomes a value.

Next is Value, Price and Profit (1865):
<What is the value of a commodity? How is it determined? […] social labour […] Like that of every other commodity, its value is determined by the quantity of labour necessary to produce it.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1865/value-price-profit/ch02.htm
Here, we have three things in concurrence: (i) value as a determination, (ii) value as social, abstract labour, and (iii) value as exclusive to the exchange of commodities.

Finally we come to Marx's Capital Vol. 1 (1867):
<The value-form, whose fully developed shape is the money-form, is very elementary and simple.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/p1.htm
Here we have new vocabulary, a "value-form". In the first chapter, the commodity is also not immediately seen as the unity of particular parts, but it also follows Zur Kritik:
<let us consider two commodities […] the same value exists in two different things […] Both are equal, therefore, to a third entity, which in and for itself is neither the one nor the other […] the exchange-values of commodities can be reduced to a common-entity, of which they represent a greater or lesser amount
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
Here we see repetition of a "common denominator", with exchange-value and value still seeming to be identical:
<the substance of the exchange-value is something utterly different from and independent of the physical-sensual existence of the commodity or its reality as a use-value […] by the abstraction from the use-value […] The common social substance which merely manifests itself differently in different use-values, is – labour […] commodities are first of all simply to be considered as values, independent of their exchange-relationship or from the form, in which they appear as exchange-values […] Their reality as values forms, on the other hand, their unity. This unity does not arise out of nature but out of society […] Commodities as values are nothing but crystallized labour.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
Here we begin to see revision of what came before. We have seen that exchange-value was the only way for abstract labour to manifest, but now "value" is to have a consideration apart from its "exchange-relationships" in the commodity. Commodities as values thus precede their forms as exchange-value. This has precedence in how price was formed before realisation, but only from its potential, or determination as a value. What Marx is saying presently, is that a value in-itself precedes the act of exchange, which can only be consistent in applying a potential to it. Marx now completely revises himself:
<A use-value or good only has a value because labour is objectified or materialized in it.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
Here, all products of labour (i.e. not just commodities) are attributed as possessing "value". Value becomes a natural category, rather than social reality. Moreover:
<A thing can be a use-value without being an exchange-value. This is the case wherever the human relevance of the thing is not mediated by labour […] A thing can be useful and be the product of human labour without being a commodity […] In order to produce a commodity, he must produce not merely use-value, but use-value for others – social use-value. Finally, no entity can be a value without being an object of use. If it is useless, then the labour contained in it is also useless, does not count as labour and, hence, does not form a value.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
Now, value belongs simply to a quality of being useful. Anything useful is also valuable, to Marx, at this point, granted it has been made by humans. Exchange-values and commodities are purely functions of mediation. An exchange-value and commodity seem to be identical; value is different, also belonging to non-commodities.

From 1844–1865, we have seen value be exclusive to commodities, exchange-value and mediation, but now it is inclusive of immediate use-values, making the critique of value as a social relation impossible, since if literally all human products are values, it is thus inescapable. It is only now that exchange-value is simply the form that value attains an appearance, but this does not destroy the essence. To Marx, from 1867 onwards, value is an essential reality of all human products, naturalising it:
<Being human labour counts as its essence (Wesen), being the labour of tailoring counts only as the form of appearance (Erscheinungsform) or definite form of realisation of this its essence […] the product of labour only goes to create value insofar as it is undifferentiated human labour, so that the labour objectified in the value of the product is in no way distinguished from the labour objectified in the value of a different product.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/appendix.htm
This is a simple dialectic, but even so, is essence to be realised? And how? We have read it. Only through use is a thing proven to be a value, so only by use – like Marx's earlier description of a product. In 1857 therefore, Marx separated "value" from products, but now he does not:
<utility is thus represented by the value in use of its product […] use value […] a use value, or useful article, therefore, has value only because human labour in the abstract has been embodied or materialised in it […] every product of labour is, in all states of society, a use value".
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Marx makes "value" a universal, natural, transhistorical product. Marx even appeals to some mystical reasoning:
<The price or money-form of commodities is, like their form of value generally, a form quite distinct from their palpable bodily form; it is, therefore, a purely ideal or mental form. Although invisible, the value of iron, linen and corn has actual existence in these very articles: it is ideally made perceptible by their equality with gold, a relation that, so to say, exists only in their own heads.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch03.htm
Here, an "actual", "invisible" reality is made perceptible by "purely ideal" means, just like all works of faith. It is seen that Marx nowhere invokes "potential", but only the opposite. He presumes a substantial "value" in goods. It is then in the post-1867 period that Marx degenerates his own theory of value into a reification of capitalism. This is seen in his writings on so-called skilled labour:
<In order to modify the human organism, so that it may acquire skill and handiness in a given branch of industry, and become labour-power of a special kind, a special education or training is requisite […] expenses of this education […] enter pro tanto into the total value spent in its production. The value of labour-power resolves itself into the value of a definite quantity of the means of subsistence. It therefore varies with the value of these means or with the quantity of labour requisite for their production.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch06.htm
Here, Marx is simply attempting to justify inequality of wages by contradictory appeals. To Marx, the greater skill, the more productive – but the less valuable must his labour be per product. Too, past labour cannot count for future labour. Education costs do not continue into a person. If I spend £100 on books, this doesn't re-appear in my wage. Finally, Marx in this chapter presumes that wages are paid out according to physical needs, and so he also presumes the hardest workers are paid most. It is plainly capitalist propaganda to claim this absurdity, since the hardest workers are paid the least. We can so compare Marx's earlier comments on wages (1865):
<the real rise of wages that took place in Great Britain from 1849 to 1859 […] initiated by, and based upon, a diminution of the quantity of labour employed
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1865/value-price-profit/ch01.htm
So, Marx refutes himself on this very basic point.

Finally is Marx's "Notes on Wagner" (1879):
<I do not proceed from “concepts,” hence neither from the “concept of value,” and am therefore in no way concerned to “divide” it […] I do not divide value into use-value and exchange-value as opposites into which the abstraction “value” splits up […] for me the “value” of a commodity is neither its use-value nor its exchange value […] arguing hither and thither about the concepts or words “use-value” and “value.” […] German stupidity.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1881/01/wagner.htm
This again presents Marx's hypocritical degeneration. We may read an excerpt which contradicts this (1857):
<Is not value to be conceived as the unity of use value and exchange value? In and for itself, is value as such the general form, in opposition to use value and exchange value as particular forms of it?
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch05.htm
Thence (1859/67):
<The commodity […] is the direct unity of use-value and exchange-value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/ch01.htm
<Commodities as values […] immediate unity of use-value and exchange-value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/commodity.htm
Even by early 1867 does Marx uphold this view, only to then abandon it in later revisions of his own theory. He does not develop for the better, but only for the worse.

So then, this proves that Marx had a consistent theory of value from 1844–1865, and post–1867, he revised himself, to only reify categories, like "value".

An index of Marx's contradictory comments are needed, where it concerns the painful transition from his earlier view to his later view. As we have seen, value was once equivalent to exchange-value, until it became equivalent to use-value. But even this is not consistently upheld. It is necessary to examine both claims. First in use-value:
<Use values become a reality only by use or consumption: they also constitute the substance of all wealth, whatever may be the social form of that wealth. In the form of society we are about to consider, they are, in addition, the material depositories of exchange value […] exchange value, generally, is only the mode of expression, the phenomenal form, of something contained in it, yet distinguishable from it […] each of these products […] human labour power has been expended in their production […] they are – Values […] substance that manifests itself in the exchange value of commodities, whenever they are exchanged, is their value […] A use value, or useful article, therefore, has value only because human labour in the abstract has been embodied or materialised in it […] A thing can be a use value, without having value. This is the case whenever its utility to man is not due to labour […] A thing can be useful, and the product of human labour, without being a commodity. Whoever directly satisfies his wants with the produce of his own labour, creates, indeed, use values, but not commodities. In order to produce the latter, he must not only produce use values, but use values for others, social use values […] Lastly nothing can have value, without being an object of utility. If the thing is useless, so is the labour contained in it; the labour does not count as labour, and therefore creates no value […] the labour, whose utility is thus represented by the value in use of its product, or which manifests itself by making its product a use value, we call useful labour […] all labour is […] an expenditure of […] abstract human labour, it creates and forms […] concrete useful labour, it produces use values […] every product of labour is, in all states of society, a use value […] the magnitude of the coat’s value is determined, independently of its value form, by the labour time necessary for its production […] properties of a thing are not the result of its relations to other things, but only manifest themselves in such relations […] expression of the value of a commodity originates in the nature of value, and not that value and its magnitude originate in the mode of their expression as exchange value
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Here, use-value is a "value in use". Concrete labour is an expenditure of abstract labour, and "use value, or useful article, therefore, has value". So, to Marx, all values are use-values. All human products are therefore values, yet only in commodities may these 'values' actually 'appear'. So, we can now turn attention to exchange-value itself:
<the exchange of commodities is evidently an act characterised by a total abstraction from use value […] as use values, commodities are, above all, of different qualities, but as exchange values they are merely different quantities, and consequently do not contain an atom of use value […] If we make abstraction from its use value […] all are reduced to one and the same sort of labour, human labour in the abstract […] if we abstract from their use value, there remains their Value as defined above. Therefore, the common substance that manifests itself in the exchange value of commodities, whenever they are exchanged, is their value […] the value of a commodity represents human labour in the abstract […] in so far as abstraction is made from their special qualities, only in so far as both possess the same quality of being human labour, do tailoring and weaving form the substance of the values of the same articles […] the value of commodities is the very opposite of the coarse materiality of their substance, not an atom of matter enters into its composition […] the value of commodities has a purely social reality, and that they acquire this reality only in so far as they are expressions or embodiments of one identical social substance, viz., human labour, it follows as a matter of course, that value can only manifest itself in the social relation of commodity to commodity […] commodity is a use value or object of utility, and a value. It manifests itself as this two-fold thing, that it is, as soon as its value assumes an independent form – viz., the form of exchange value. It never assumes this form when isolated, but only when placed in a value or exchange relation with another commodity of a different kind […] every product of labour is, in all states of society, a use value; but it is only at a definite historical epoch in a society’s development that such a product becomes a commodit […] Whence, then, arises the enigmatical character of the product of labour, so soon as it assumes the form of commodities? Clearly from this form itself […] Fetishism which attaches itself to the products of labour, so soon as they are produced as commodities, and which is therefore inseparable from the production of commodities […] So far no chemist has ever discovered exchange value either in a pearl or a diamond […] the use value of objects is realised without exchange, by means of a direct relation between the objects and man, while, on the other hand, their value is realised only by exchange, that is, by means of a social process.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Here then, we have two totally contradictory views. It cannot both be true that (i) all concrete labour is a type of abstract labour, therefore all values are use-values, so the magnitude of value precedes the form of value, and also that (ii) abstract labour emerges in exchange, and thus proceeds concrete labour, making magnitude of value proceed the form of value – yet, Marx provides this "double result". It is both seen to be true that "properties of a thing are not the result of its relations to other things", yet "value can only manifest itself in the social relation of commodity to commodity […] value is realised only by exchange". Marx never explains this. If value precedes exchange, how is it only realised in it?

We return to Marx's absurdity:
<The price or money-form of commodities is, like their form of value generally, a form quite distinct from their palpable bodily form; it is, therefore, a purely ideal or mental form. Although invisible, the value of iron, linen and corn has actual existence in these very articles: it is ideally made perceptible by their equality with gold, a relation that, so to say, exists only in their own heads.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch03.htm
Value is real, yet "exists only in their own heads"? It is both "actual" and "invisible" yet requires "purely ideal" or "mental" forms to perceive it? This is not just dialectics; this is not just jargon. It is a shameless contradiction:
<The value of a commodity is expressed in its price before it goes into circulation, and is therefore a precedent condition of circulation, not its result.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch05.htm
So again, value precedes circulation; it exists purely as a use-value, yet it is also necessarily an exchange-value?
<The general value form [e.g. money] is the reduction of all kinds of actual labour to their common character of being human labour generally, of being the expenditure of human labour power
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Here, we see money facilitate the abstraction of labour once more, but at the same time, it is a passivity to the activity of relative value, not equivalence. Marx wants it both ways, but cannot have it both ways. Contradiction.

Further, since we are discussing magnitude of value, Marx sees it preceding exchange, as he is in the habit of repeating. We may see his mockery of others, here:
<The mercantilists lay special stress on the qualitative aspect of the expression of value, and consequently on the equivalent form of commodities, which attains its full perfection in money. The modern hawkers of Free-trade, who must get rid of their article at any price, on the other hand, lay most stress on the quantitative aspect of the relative form of value. For them there consequently exists neither value, nor magnitude of value, anywhere except in its expression by means of the exchange relation of commodities, that is, in the daily list of prices current […] superstitious mercantilists
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
Let us be aware of this, then. Marx thinks that imagining exchange affecting the value of commodities is a vain "superstition", since value precedes exchange. Marx:
<Let us now accompany the owner of some commodity — say, our old friend the weaver of linen — to the scene of action, the market […] In order to entice the money out of that pocket, our friend’s commodity must, above all things, be a use-value to the owner of the money. For this, it is necessary that the labour expended upon it, be of a kind that is socially useful […] But suppose his product turn out a real use-value, and thereby attracts money? The question arises, how much will it attract? No doubt the answer is already anticipated in the price of the article, in the exponent of the magnitude of its value […] If the market cannot stomach the whole quantity at the normal price of 2 shillings a yard, this proves that too great a portion of the total labour of the community has been expended in the form of weaving. The effect is the same as if each individual weaver had expended more labour-time upon his particular product than is socially necessary. Here we may say, with the German proverb: caught together, hung together. All the linen in the market counts but as one article of commerce, of which each piece is only an aliquot part.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch03.htm
So then, Marx sees that exchange thereby determines the value of commodities. If it is not purchased, its value is altered. This is pure hypocrisy. Infernal corruption.

Too, we know that the magnitude of value determines the exchange-value of commodities. Cause and effect:
<in the midst of all the accidental and ever fluctuating exchange relations between the products, the labour time socially necessary for their production forcibly asserts itself like an over-riding law of Nature […] determination of the magnitude of value by labour time is therefore a secret, hidden under the apparent fluctuations in the relative values of commodities
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch01.htm
We should first ask whether or not these magnitudes are determined before or after they are set in the market:
<The possibility, therefore, of quantitative incongruity between price and magnitude of value, or the deviation of the former from the latter, is inherent in the price-form itself. This is no defect, but, on the contrary, admirably adapts the price-form to a mode of production whose inherent laws impose themselves only as the mean of apparently lawless irregularities that compensate one another.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch03.htm
Supply/demand fluctuate, but value always equates;
<commodities may be sold at prices deviating from their values, but these deviations are to be considered as infractions of the laws of the exchange of commodities, which in its normal state is an exchange of equivalents
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch05.htm
For this very reason we may inquire into this comment:
<average prices do not directly coincide with the values of commodities, as Adam Smith, Ricardo, and others believe.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch05.htm
Curious. So after describing a "law of nature", this law is apparently not in effect, after all. Is Marx just a liar, then?
<Ricardo (following Smith) lumps value and production costs together […] values and production prices […] do not coincide. Why not? That I have not told Mr. Wagner […] I proceed from the assumption that [a commodity] is really paid at its full value, which is in fact not the case
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1881/01/wagner.htm
Marx simply refuses to tell us why he said something which "in fact" wasn't true. That is a lie. Marx is a liar. So then, Marx first writes that magnitude determines price, to which he denies this and instead says the price (i.e. the market) determines magnitude, and now we read Marx claiming that in fact, magnitude doesn't determine average prices at all. He criticises others for believing this, in fact, but doesn't explain why to his loyal readers. Incoherence born from deception. Finally, he writes this:
<Objects that in themselves are no commodities, such as conscience, honour, &c., are capable of being offered for sale by their holders, and of thus acquiring, through their price, the form of commodities. Hence an object may have a price without having value.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch03.htm
So then, twice is Marx self-refuting: (i) value both does and does not precede exchange-value, (ii) magnitude of value both does and does not determine average price. Marx then has a faulty metaphysics (as the positivists accuse him of), between a priori and a posteriori value.

Examined truthfully thus, we see a non-contradictory theory of value from 1844–65, where both value and its form of appearance have identity in the commodity, as exchange-value, exclusively. From 1867 onwards, value is conflated with (human) use-value, causing immediate logical contradictions, as well as intentional deception.

>>2951949
> dishonour and degeneration in Marx's person.
based?!


Unique IPs: 21

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]