So say a Marxist-Leninist economy has all of the stuff important to the state nationalized and operating under scientific planning, it tries to give the basic needs of life like employment and housing to everyone as possible, but there's additionally a private sector for commodity circulation because trying to micromanage every small business to the smallest detail is silly in general. The private sector is heavily regulated to prevent them from subverting the rest of society, and also taxed to help pay for the rest of society.
So what exactly is bad about this generally speaking? Especially on a neoliberal Earth where the international elite, outside of china, can flee and go anywhere and has no accountability? The strategy of dengist economics has produced the same results that people like Mao and Stalin wanted out of their countries like mass industrialization, electrification, and prosperity but at the same time holding their own societal elites accountable.
83 posts and 13 image replies omitted.>>2865198<So what exactly is bad about this generally speaking? Especially on a neoliberal Earth where the international elite, outside of china, can flee and go anywhere and has no accountability? The strategy of dengist economics has produced the same results that people like Mao and Stalin wanted out of their countries like mass industrialization, electrification, and prosperity but at the same time holding their own societal elites accountable.I guess in the long run its not sustainable because its a partial market economy and suffers the same flaws as capitalism. But it may be worth it in the short to medium run to have industrial capitalism on the most favorable circumstances to China rather than no limits colonial exploitation version
>>2865198The main thing is that it's a poor fit for a very large country such as China which ends up with large internal town-country contradictions.
>>2911457Confederation of armed worker councils lead by the party
>>2865436being a developmentalist with 0 standards makes it easier to soy face at 2,000,000 babies getting degrees from porky's university of commodity production than it'd be for a communist
>>2939344>Confederation of armed worker councilsBased
>lead by the party<not plagued by bureaucracy and governorsNGMI leftychud
>>2939425>uncritical support for the liberals that sold out the USSRWhy are nu-MLs such cucks? Even normie libs have less of a slave psychology than these freaks
>>2940900>slave psychologylog off
>>2910119>Naturally, whenever anything is successful, MLs claim that is what they believed in all along.you're starting to get it. that's what's meant by the innovative role of the party. many experiments were written off in the soviet union starting with lenin's times because that's just the material conditions for you. that's called dialectical materialism buddy. the correct line is what works best in the specific conditions the party finds itself in, by definition. the bolsheviks didn't come into power with knowledge of all their future policies, they were discovered through practice.
liberals will be mad because policy comes down from the platonic realm of the forms to them, all the good things just happen to be innate human rights given by god- i mean just be the consensus among good progressive folks, history doesn't exist chud, just be a Good Person (tm) okay????
>>2910119>When Dengism started to pay off. yes>>2910119
>In the 80s and 90s Dengism looked like a betrayal of Communism, because China was weaker than America. Now China is stronger than America and America is dying, so Dengism looks like a long term successful 4D chess move to steal manufacturing from the US empire. Naturally, whenever anything is successful, MLs claim that is what they believed in all along.yes. and currently, only the most state directed economies, whether you regard them as socialist or not, are capable of the long term planning and investment in unprofitable but strategically important endeavors necessary to expand the forces of production despite the falling rate of profit. america can't do it.
>It doesn't matter if a cat is black or white, if it catches mice it's a good cat.
Its retarded
>>2865198there was this one german guy who dedicated his life to developing the most accurate description of dengism. in fact he developed a whole framework for historical and social analysis which can grossly be summarized as revolving around who owns the deng in a society. the book is just called deng. i recommend you read it.
>>2867053Yes, Marx celebrated the American revolution as progressive. We should celebrate China as progressive and then call for overturning it as soon as it is not.
>>2941222>We should celebrate China as progressive and then call for overturning it as soon as it is not.So since the 1970s
>>2941258Since the 70s. Their attempts to horde industrial progress is concerning and should be countered as soon as possible, especially in such near apocalyptic times where international industrial capacity will be life or death more so than any other previous point in time.
>what are the flaws of capitalism
>>2939589It was more giga to just pick the ones I liked personally :)
Honestly, I think Deng saved China from the insanity of Maoism, I don't believe a fully socialist country can survive alone in capitalistic world, I think Deng was smart and played the long game, as whether the current China leadership actually follow the idea of playing the long game is a open question to me.
>>2941427I think your low trust in socialism says it all
>>2941435Be objective, dude, a lonely socialist country is cooked in a world fully of capitalistic countries, I think was playing the long game when he changed the economy of China, that not to say that everything is perfect in China and "trust the plan" will always pan out right, things change over long time as so the need to adapt to those changes, the more important question to me is: Do the actual CCP leadership actually care for the long term goal of a fully socialist society or just playing along and getting rich?
>>2941435Nothing more destructive than blind faith.
>>2941435>personal attack>reducing things to a matter of faith>X … says it ALL!!!! (doesn't elaborate on what X says, just winks at the intended audience and lets them make up shit in their own head)>zero acknowledgement of any particular arguments made, or direct replies to themyep, it's a giga
Lack of central planning
>>2941815Central planning used by PRC before Deng didn't work, bro.
>>2941437>Be objective, dude, a lonely socialist country is cooked in a world fully of capitalistic countriesYou have the international proletariat. Use it.
>>2941730So said the man who is ill read. If you need blind faith, then you are clearly not among the most advanced.
>>2941795>reducing things to a matter of faithI said trust, not faith
>X … says it ALL!!!! (doesn't elaborate on what X says, just winks at the intended audience and lets them make up shit in their own head)If you require elaboration, you need to hit the books
>zero acknowledgement of any particular arguments made, or direct replies to themThe arguments have been acknowledged. The response is: Read more
>>2941827when its done by an idealist then no and Mao was one and it also requires discipline
>>2941871The international proletariat doesn’t exist, there’s not a single case you can find of a trade union or a political party having an international chain of command. You’ll never have American workers going on strike to increase the wages of Filipino or Vietnamese workers. Proles are national, capital is international.
>>2941890>The international proletariat doesn’t existAnd Feudalism is still an existent mode of production. And unicorns exist too.
>there’s not a single case you can find of a trade union or a political party having an international chain of command- Why would a trade union have an international chain of command for communist revolution?
- We’re not talking about chains of command
>You’ll never have American workers going on strike to increase the wages of Filipino or Vietnamese workersThis does not disprove the existence of the international proletariat
>Proles are national, capital is internationalProles are restrained by nationality. International capital restrains the proletariat with nationality.
>>2941895So how do you unrestrain proles from nationality, and don’t just leave it at “revolution”
>>2941913I am leaving it at revolution, because as Marx said, it depends on the country.
>>2941927You need to be thrown into a corn thresher
>>2941932Whatever you say farm boy
>>2941890>trade union Laborers' International Union of North America, about 500k members
>political partySinn Fein
>>2865198The book
From commune to capitalism by Zhun Xu basically disproves the lies that decollectivization of agriculture was "spontaneous", and "voluntary". As well as showing the transformation did not in fact make things more "efficient."
You might be asking, why would China allow a more inefficient system to take place over the the communes? One of the main thesis of this book is that the real reason for privatisation of agriculture, was to disempower the peasents, and break up the worker peasent alliance to reduce resistance to capitalist reforms.
>>2942284Does the books say anything about the efficiency of the communes against the reform?
>>2942411Yes I am curious as to the efficiency claims for or against. I was always under the impression that collectives produced mainly for themselves as they were self-sufficient and did not care about commodity exchange. But then after privatization, they had no choice but to engage in the market so it led to the rat race. Some peasants became millionaires, the rest ended up being wage slaves for the millionaires. It's almost like efficiency can only come at the expense of free human time. But the contradiction is this rat race allows for more humans to exist and industrialization to occur. I am conflicted about this and have to prevent myself from taking the an-prim pill from time to time.
>>2942415Agriculture shouldn't just be for subsistence; it should also be for producing for others. In that sense, the market is more practical and easier. Although, of course, you can practice council communism and that people decide collectively what to produce, but doing that is much more complicated than saying "produce more and sell it"
>>2865198It invites the reconstitution of the capital class to make number go up. Because the party is the one directing these capitalists at first, there will inevitably grow a tight bond between the party and capital as capitalists promise favours to meet political objectives in exchange for concessions to themselves and their own wealth accumulation. It will not happen overnight, but Dengism ultimately will lead to the same place as social democracy due to the delusion that you can keep capitalists around and control them - the inherent wealth accumulation that capitalism affords the bourgeoisie means they can inevitably financially incentivise the political class to work for them rather than the other way around, or even to integrate into the political class themselves (already happens in China).
>>2942485right now the DPRK is allied to the PRC… are they slavish too?
>>2942485>They're le berniebros!!!Not everyone is american yanqui swine
>China was starving DPRK!!Literally the DPRK doesn't give a single fuck, so why should I?
Unique IPs: 34