[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


File: 1789965688930-2-0.png (38.88 KB, 600x700, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1789965688930-3-1.png (1.08 MB, 1042x1042, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1789965688930-4-2.png (922.36 KB, 1125x1557, ClipboardImage.png)

 

LET ME SEE YOUR WAR LIPS YOU BLOODY WANKERS!

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cmn0jke547r5o

<If the UK suddenly found itself at war, would you know what to do? Do you know what would be expected of you?


>The government wants us all to start preparing for severe disruption to our lives. It wants us to stockpile canned food and drinking water, strengthen our civic resilience, and plan for the possibility of war.


>Work has begun on the government's so-called "war book", which hasn't been updated in decades.


>The UK's most senior soldier has sounded the alarm. The Chief of the Defence Staff Sir Richard Knighton this week said the threat from Russia meant Britain was living through the "most dangerous" period of his 35-year career in the armed forces.


>But what is the threat? In 1940 the danger of a German invasion of the UK was very real. But the chances of Russian tanks rolling up Whitehall are surely negligible.


>"It's not the tanks you need to worry about," says historian Margaret MacMillan, author of War: How Conflict Shaped Us.


>"It's the cutting of cables on the ocean floor. It's the hacking into systems on which so many things depend. The possibility for asymmetric war, for cyber war, is growing by leaps and bounds."


>But are we ready? After 80 years without war on our own soil, are we, as a society, psychologically prepared for it? Are we ready to approve large increases in defence spending, and for the sacrifices that that might entail in other areas of our national life? Or does the threat seem too far-fetched to be real?
556 posts and 92 image replies omitted.

>>2932563
I'm sure it's not going to solely glaze JKR but probably will be like "well maybe she's bad but look at the random people making threats to her, she's basically an antihero"

>>2932560
The problem is that there's no organised anti woke left that isn't just insane social conservatives

Except maybe CPGB-PCC but they have like 20 members lol

>>2932578
Also they shoot themselves in the foot with inane shit like the recent "n word scandal" that was totally avoidable by them.

>>2932578
There is: Starmer Labour.

>>2932605
Still hoping for a glorious return from St Helena eh?

>>2932560
>>2932578
You cannot have a good anti-woke left for more than a very brief period. It's like asking for non-Scottish Irn Bru. It is inimical to the fundamental underlying appeal of the product. If, by some miracle, you do it briefly then it will inevitably collapse one way, the other, or both. (Think here even of /leftypol/ c.2016-17 and how it has ideologically changed since, in a way i'd glibly simplify down to 80% getting more woke and 20% getting completely brainwormed by rightoid slop.)

Instead of thinking of it in terms of ideological coherence think for a moment in terms of emotional or narrative appeal. If your whole thing is nostalgia for an imagined left that used to exist combined with loathing of the actually-existing left of today, you're already most of the way down a certain path. On the flip side, as I always hammer on about, plenty of people who didn't really care for the left in the past or who used to be much more radlib have trended left over time because the left caters to their emotional and narrative needs far more effectively. (e.g. scratch a self-described feminist under 40 and a pro-palestine activist with negative views on capitalism and positive views on socialism and maybe even communism will bleed.)

Or, if that doesn't land for you, you can get the right answer in this case with Schmitt: if the fundamental distinction is between friends and enemies, it doesn't take a genius to work out what happens when you put woke people on your enemies list…

>>2932563
>she's still the biggest UK artist of this century
and if that doesn't make you realise this nationbuilding project has failed and needs to go the way of Yugoslavia…

>>2932659
I'm just so fucking tired of being spoken down to by wannabe HR reps in left wing spaces.

>>2932686
The woke left have chosen their side.
They want to create right-wingers by making the left niche.

>>2932687
Well so what do we do then? It's either be miserable because of woke radlibs or be miserable because of social conservatives. Why can't people just be fucking normal?

>>2932605
They said 'left' anon, Starmer isnt a leftist


>>2932700
>Why can't people just be fucking normal?
They are, just not on radical politics forums.
Most people in the world don't even identify as "left" or "right", since these are fundamentally made-up terms that cause contradictions.

File: 1792082722122-5.jpg (169.72 KB, 1080x1032, utter woke nonsense.jpg)

>>2932686
I would agree but i feel like this died post Oct 7. Ironically 1.0 wokeness now only lives through the former anti-woke "populist" left who decided jewish feelings, "LGB" and "sex based rights" wathever that is are sacred ancestral law even though it only became a thing during Obama 2nd mandate.
Keir's Labour, Rowling and the few obsessed anti-trans anons we get in this thread represent this very well, they have one trillion sacred cows inherited from Obama-era liberalism and if you disagree with one of them or wants to push the enveloppe further to include more sacred cows you are some kind of naziradlibcommie warring against Western Civilization or English Culture, which encompass things that were considered disgusting, wrong or nonsensical by most of genpop and the elites before like 2012.

>>2932753
These people always seem like total losers irl as well having met a few. They just radiate redditor and tend to get socially ostracized pretty quickly for being total freakoids.

>>2932753
>"populist" left
As opposed to the sixth form left, I presume?
In any case, leftism is not really a socialist politics.
That's clear enough.
>>2932757
We're all freaks on this website.
Stop pretending like you are better than anyone else.

>log onto /leftybritpol/
>thread is just people arguing over 'woke', using the word without a hint of irony
>close /leftybritpol/

>>2931980
>>2931985
If you seriously think doctors should be paid less, you've lost your minds.
For the risk and stress involved, it's farcical doctors aren't paid more - as conditions in hospitals only worsen.
Nevermind that the inflated salaries in the private sector (whilst they went static in the public sector, particularly for doctors) put more educated/competent people off of studying medicine - or even leaving post-qualification.
Unless going the GP route, doctors in training will usually take 10+ years to even reach Consultant level

>>2932783
Why should I defend doctor salaries? Most of them do a shit job anyway and don't give a fuck

>>2932777
"woke" is an extremely efficient hueristic which allows people to know what you're talking about.

>>2932783
This is non-materialist rubbish.
You set wages competitively, against the private sector.
If wages were too low, doctors would flee the NHS, etc.
"Stress" and "risk" are fetishised economic categories; not real.
But in any case, how much is too much? There is always a limit.

>>2932753
>Keir's Labour, Rowling and the few obsessed anti-trans anons we get in this thread represent this very well, they have one trillion sacred cows inherited from Obama-era liberalism and if you disagree with one of them or wants to push the enveloppe further to include more sacred cows you are some kind of naziradlibcommie warring against Western Civilization or English Culture, which encompass things that were considered disgusting, wrong or nonsensical by most of genpop and the elites before like 2012.
Yeah this is a TRVKE. I think that glaring hypocrisy is really one of the biggest problems with this holier-than-though self-righteous shit no matter what brand or flavor it is. People want to get all indignant and offended, "how dare you!" and then they go and turn around and do the same kind of behavior, maybe with a slightly different target.

>>2932764
But I am better than everyone else

>>2932783
  1. I don't believe in doctor ownership. They should all be employees of the NHS. None of this partnerships and co-owner nonsense. Mid-ranked ER doctors earn pittance in comparison to these owners, contractors and middle-management freaks.
  2. The doctors only should get paid more or even as much as they do if it's relatively equal across ranks of doctors and it is to some degree, with whatever mechanism that can be developed, matched to nurses pay, who are drastically underpaid.

Gwan!
Fack you!

>>2932820
>Why you doing that?
>Is it for your GCSE?
>TWAT!
Waow, someone got above a C in English. I guess everyone really is a rapper now.

>>2932686
I won't pretend they're not tedious, but don't take it so seriously. It's just a status game.
Most "left wing spaces" in this country are a joke anyway. I will be very vulgar and speak honestly: what you want and need is not a political movement, but a hobby space with the kind of people who're cool enough to be left wing, but engaged enough with other stuff that it isn't the be-all and end-all for them. You achieve as much politically by discussing the shot composition of Mamoru Oshii's anime as you do joining any org in the UK at the moment, so you may as well watch weird cartoons about girls who don't talk and big robot movies that accidentally replaced all the robots with meditations on Japan's fake postwar peace… in peace.

>>2932687
Not quite. We live in an age of niches. The idea of the mainstream died on contact with the internet. The trick, then, is to have leftism fit into every niche. You do not generally find woke-anime types policing woke-furry places, or woke furries policing woke trainspotting groups, or so on.

Since I'm just firing out theories here, this all comes back to Girard: you don't feel resentment at King Charles because you and he are differentiated by birth. A fundamental conflict in modern politics is this: conservatives do not accept that we are moving from a system where you are differentiated against your will, to one where you are differentiated according to your choices. e.g. a man and a woman can side-step mimetic rivalry by going "well, they're an x…" but this option no longer holds in a world where a man can become a woman and vice-versa, hence why the concept drives them absolutely fucking bananas.

But the left does not actually want an undifferentiated world and cannot deliver on one. Nor does it seek, really, to create a hierarchy based on politics. Instead, it meshes well with the basic underlying dynamic that we find our points of difference elsewhere: e.g. a weeb and a furry can avoid feeling status rivalry because they occupy basically different circles, even if they're both woke.

The future is basically optimistic provided we can pass peacefully through the final dying efforts of the old world to suppress changes that are ultimately rooted in technologies we are not going to give up.

>>2932700
Don't be miserable, do what makes you happy. Don't take politics so seriously. You don't (and tragically, probably can't) become "apolitical" but you don't need to stress so much about things you've no agency over. You have supreme control over your own thoughts, so make sure they're serving you rather than vice-versa.
(Even if you think every single point I've made so far has been utter nonsense, that's the frame you should look at it from. I find them very helpful personally. e.g. I used to be very resentful of the nonsense people would spout as part of social status games, or wonder how people could come to irrational political beliefs.)

>>2932777
Eh, it can be a helpful shorthand/shibboleth. Even if saying "woke" is loser-coded unless you do it ironically, it's a brand like any other and you can learn a lot by how people feel about it.

>>2932820
what religion is he preaching
not going to watch 3 minutes of it, but I need that data to make a judgement

>>2932810
>If wages were too low, doctors would flee the NHS, etc.
That's not an option though, doctors have to do work within the NHS.
You do see an element of fleeing through increase in private work and leaving for medical work in other countries (e.g. Australia)
>"Stress" and "risk" are fetishised economic categories; not real.
What do you mean economic categories? I'm talking about the very real qualitative effect of stress over working in a time-pressured workplace where wrong actions can cause severe harm, which can be irreversible and/or deadly.
Sure the time-pressure can be somewhat alleviated through getting better staffing numbers or funding, but you retards are wanting to cut wages which would deter people from working as doctors.
>But in any case, how much is too much? There is always a limit.
Absolutely. But with how work conditions are in the UK, the public are lucky they get the care they receive, and the ingratitude seems not only unseemingly but misplaced.
Nevermind that ultimately, without good healthcare productivity will fall and the economy will crumble.

>>2932797
> Most of them do a shit job anyway and don't give a fuck
Instead of blaming doctors, why not consider the reasons why you would be unsatisfied with healthcare.
Could it not be that healthcare has become incredibly complex, with increasingly elderly population becoming increasingly co-morbid, with an increasing amount of medicines (with their own side effects and interactions), with an increased demand for services, and therefore less time to see patients?
Or perhaps there has been a push to offer longer-term cheaper care through employing less-qualified doctor replacements (e.g. advanced care practitioners; physician assistants)?
Or perhaps when the healthservice has a limited budget there is a tricky balance involved with how thoroughly certain presentations are investigated, and that there is neither the money nor physical resource to (e.g.) MRI scan everyone's whole body. Which of course therefore means there is greater risk people will slip through the net, conditions will be missed or found too late. A risk the public should be aware of but choose to ignore.
Whilst quality of doctors can certainly vary, it's not very "materialist" to chalk it up to most doctors doing a shit job.

>>2932819
>I don't believe in doctor ownership. They should all be employees of the NHS.
Sure, but to be clear this is a GP phenomenon and not hospital doctor.
>matched to nurses pay, who are drastically underpaid
Nurses should absolutely be paid more
But, and I may be misunderstanding you, are you saying you think nurses should be paid the same as doctors? I would struggle to see that being widely accepted or practical, given if a nurse will need to escalate something they will typically turn to a doctor, with the expectation the doctor is responsible (and that a nurse will be severely reprimanded by their own regulatory body if they have not escalated and something goes wrong).
Though with the caveat that if you are a senior nurse, or in a managerial role, you are paid significantly more than middle-grade (i.e. specialist registrar) doctors already - and the work is not comparable.

>>2932845
I'm guessing Christianity. He says "spreading the word of the gospel."

>>2932820
Cool how they don't show any of what he was actually saying, the boomer is probably right they're preaching filth

>>2932850
I saw 3 doctors that didn't help with my condition until I was lucky enough to see an advanced practitioner who was a younger guy that actually helped me, since then I could give a fuck about doctors gatekeeping their industry

>>2932845
>what religion is he preaching
Bitchass. Boomer is correct whatever religion it was

>>2932853
Sorry you had that experience, must've been so frustrating to say the least.
If the public want to be seen primarily by professionals who have studied less, don't do post-qualification/specialist exams, and work increasingly ill-defined roles (and above expected responsibilities) then fair enough.
I'd just be wary of the consequences. It's certainly not what I want for myself.

>>2932859
It really depends on what you're seeking treatment for. e.g. basically everyone on an ADHD or transgender waiting list knows what they want and the NHS is just standing between them and it.

The problem is that the NHS as an institution is more interested in arse-covering and maintaining the illusion these things are big impartial judgements administering professional treatments and not a sort of ad-hoc "try this and see if it works for you" thing. Just giving people what they want undercuts that professional status.

File: 1792095482653-4-0.png (92.99 KB, 1181x659, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1792095482654-6-1.png (1.21 MB, 880x1210, ClipboardImage.png)

Timing on this seems interesting.

>>2932898
This shit just makes me scratch my head.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/eritrea-country-policy-and-information-notes/country-policy-and-information-note-national-service-and-illegal-exit-eritrea-december-2025-accessible

How do you give people asylum because they're escaping the Eritrean government, but also get mad at the Eritrean government for not taking back the people you don't want? It seems to me all the Eritrean government has to do is promise to persecute these people they want to send back, then that would make their asylum claim valid.

First claim in the Brand case from yesterday is that he raped a woman at Blair's Labour conference.

>>2932816
Sure – that's why you're a flagfag on a dying imageboard.
>>2932850
>the public are lucky they get the care they receive
They pay for it… Being a doctor is doing a job; not charity.
>>2932838
>undifferentiated
But this itself is entirely contradictory.
If there is no "difference" between men and women, why does identity matter more to the deviant than to the plebeian? Status is difference itself, as you already imply. My point is that status-seeking is retarded and vain. An actually-undiffentiated society is one with a common identity. Wokeness presupposes exceptionality, so can never be at peace with normalcy. It purposefully excludes the common – moreover, postured individuality is itself pastiche and boring. No one is more of a conformist than the pronoun performer (e.g. the current thing enjoyer). So, my advice is always be yourself, meaning to be boring and normal.

>>2932898
The Ethiopia lobby in action.

File: 1792142183421-0.jpeg (23.24 KB, 651x307, images.jpeg)

>>2932838
>>2933180
And just to be clear, wokeness is not equivalent to the concept of civil liberty – but is still coincidental of "civil rights", as per Hanania's analysis. The positive law of a forced assembly called "integration" displaces any racial freedom of association which thus politicises the civil, and so confuses the categories. We see during WW2 that the British were naturally receptive to Black soldiers from the US, whilst the positive law of segregation made barracks separate, and so on, within American corps. It was alien to Britain to have such impoliteness, and so was spontaneously resisted where it was encountered. Overcorrection in the US case, by replacing one force by another, was transposed to the UK, which made racial minorities adopted by the state – a mediator between different people made voluntary association difficult, since it was contrived (e.g. by the Race Relations Act – you see this today, where the "British" and "English" identity is separated, between the state and society as such). This was made even harder by Thatcher's Public Order Act, which criminalised "hate speech", once more policing civil society by mediation. Effectively, honesty was censored. At the same time, homosexuals were petitioning for rights, and so postured themselves as a racial category; being "born this way"; homosexuality was now considered entirely accidental as an attribute, but was also protected by the state from discrimination. Not merely decriminalisation, but legalisation. Gay men and women were now sponsored by the state, and so lost immediacy to civil society. The same thing for the transsexual population with the GRA2004, which gave a legal title for one's preferred identity (e.g. identity seen as a legal entity, not a social entity, as it was treated beforehand). This also mediated between cis and trans women by force of the state, so denied voluntary means of association (e.g. the state is always anti-social in its contrivance). With EA2010, 'protected characteristics' were posited in mutual contradiction (e.g. as with the supreme court ruling, which by statute, overturns GRA, yet still leaves legal identity in limbo. Religious freedom is also implicitly exclusive of homosexuals, so declining a gay wedding, for example, is reserved – we saw in the US the controversy regarding a clash between religious bakers and gay customers – this would be solved by the freedom of association by medium of property, rather than the state in a normal case, but this is abolished). Wokeness is really in this tract; of abolishing society for the medium of the state to manage different identities. I believe in human goodness; woke people cannot, since they perceive the state as a shield against the public. Both TRAs and Gender-Critical Feminists are woke, and so deserve each other in this climb for government gibs. There is no civil humanity between either of them.

>>2933202
How is having the right to gay marriage etc being "sponsored by the state"??

>>2933180
Status seeking is basic human behavior. By typing a post you're seeking (you)s and perhaps agreement on /leftypol/. It's best not to hold people in contempt for such things.

The only way to be normal and boring is to, in Internet terms, not exist. And even then that means being a freak in private most of the time. (Say what you will about the most tedious tumblrite, I'd be them in a heartbeat over being publicly associated with this place, let alone 4chan)

>>2933202
I prefer to think of wokeness as a civic religion and frankly one of the better ones that has existed. The emphasis on the state is overblown: in this very thread you've got people so negatively polarized by the state's anti-woke actions as to have become functional libertarians, to recognize that it's better to allow sinners than to have the state captured by the devil and mandate we sin..

(And as with status, you can't not have a (civic) religion in this context. The question is merely what that religion should be…)

>>2933180
>a flagfag on a dying imageboard

Exactly, I dont rot my brain on social media like most plebs.

>>2933180
>Being a doctor is doing a job; not charity.
Exactly my point

>>2933203
Notice the framing.
It's not about rights to gay marriage, it's about rights from being barred from gay marriage – and this also misses the greater point, that marriage itself includes arbitrary legal protections to exclude homosexuals – the raison d'etre of so-called "gay marriage" was to remove obstacles, not to posit one's membership in a ceremony (e.g. the legal status of marriage allowed hospital visits, etc. But in essence, and de jure, all marriages since the 19th century have been treated as civil partnerships. With the right to divorce, marriage as an institution was effectively abolished – Marx by 1848 already discusses the abolition of the family, proceeding from Carlyle). The heteronormative illusion of moder. "marriage" is a bourgeois vanity.
>>2933208
>you're seeking (you)s
Notice how cynical you are.
I'm trying to have a discussion, and you're tallying points.
>wokeness as a civic religion
Rousseau was already false in treating state religion as civil religion
Wokeness is not an "ideology", it is a tendency of legal statute.
>state's anti-woke actions
Such as? All factions are woke, that's the point.
>you need a civil religion
No you don't. Religion is a parasite on culture. Culture is organic.

>>2933229
I am not tallying points, I am having a discussion. The moment friendship occurs is when two people notice they can freely swap places in the status game, e.g. they recognise it as a game and play it. I am simply trying to convey that there is no pure world free of status games amongst humans.

You draw hanania too far. You can explain elements of institutionalised HR wokeness by reference to legal and state structures, but this does not explain the part once termed "SJWism", whereas a dispositional theory - for example - is much more powerful.

There is either no such thing as organic culture (it is all man made) or religion (considered broadly) is an organic phenomenon. I share contempt for that which is generally recognized as religious faith but I do not believe the underlying impulses towards it have been removed from man. Politics, media, fandom, Internet communities, all are ersatz religions in one way or another. (And that's basically a good thing)

>>2933245
>status games
No. Friendship occurs by a dissolution of competing status.
A friend doesn't care what you are signalling to others.
>SJW
Material analysis.
What are the concrete demands of SJWs?
Political, economic and social power, relative to what they consider the hegemony of "straight (cis) white men". It is vulgar class war.
>man-made means inorganic
What? We are humans, so everything we do is "man-made".
>worshipping your own alienation (objectification) is good
You mentioned girard. What does he say about scapegoating, again?
Religion presupposes tribute to an alienated subject through which we become objectified. Capital is idolatry which demands sacrifice, etc.

>>2932820
Not watching all of that though I really don't have that much sympathy for some of these street preachers

>>2933279
By what means is the competition dissolved? By recognising it as a game where one can harmlessly play high or low depending on what is more fun at the time. It never actually disappears: many of the behaviours we engage in with friends only make sense in the context of there still being a generalised status game going on. Plus, of course, we still compete with friends (even if playfully) in various contexts. (Most obviously in actual games, where the general pattern is to try to win, but then switch to letting the friend win if you're winning too much. What most people really want is to be just slightly above their peers, not enough to upset egalitarianism, but not slightly below either…)
Moreover a friend absolutely cares what you signal: try never signalling interest in what they have to say and see how long they remain a friend!

I agree that SJWism is vulgar class war (broadly or functionally, most then-SJWs are now self-proclaimed socialists and communists) but this, if anything, reinforces my point that "wokeness" as a floating signifier includes these people despite the fact their existence is rooted not in a certain legal framework, but in other underlying material conditions. (the ones that have lead basically every first world country to electorally polarise politically by age, education, and to a lesser extent sex) thus, you draw Hanania too far.
>What? We are humans, so everything we do is "man-made".
Yes. All culture is an artificial creation unless you want to go down the rabbit hole of whether some animals have culture. This is precisely my point.

If you look at all the contemporary ersatz-religions save perhaps the global Trump cult, they are less cruel than what has come before. To objectify oneself to Marxism Leninism or the TADC fandom or some other inane cause is a cultural leap ahead of doing so in the name of the supernatural. (Not to be confused with the TV Series Supernatural, you can objectify yourself as a fan of that all you like.)

p.s. stop doing this quote line-by-line thing. You claim not to be here for point-scoring but the only reason to write in such a way is to score points instead of engaging with a post holistically.

>>2928345
Guy who hates the spontaneity of the working class but will do nothing to organise them. There can be no 1917 without 1905.


Unique IPs: 30

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]