[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!


 

>NojRants
I have yet to hear a good takedown of this guy. He always cites sources, he always gives the Bolsheviks a fair shake in his analysis, and he seems sincerely more interested in studying and learning from the mistakes of the early USSR than many self described communists, who, if they bother read sources at all, only uncritically read primary sources form that era if they are written from the perspective of the central committee, rather than rank and file party members, or "losers" who were later purged. The few times have seen his videos posted here before I have seen very short bitter responses: "Anticommunist propaganda" But I was never able to get those anons to actually clarify what they meant by that, and it seemed to me that they didn't actually have any specific critiques, like "he is wrong about A, B, and C, because reasons X, Y, and Z." It seemed more like a prejudiced and kneejerk reaction, of "just don't watch this." basically treating it the same as if it was some fascist dreck. So what's the deal? Can anyone take a real shot at this guy? And I don't mean personal attacks or simply discouraging people from watching it all. Or surface-level reactions to titles and thumbnails. I mean why are his sources wrong, why is he wrong, why are his conclusions wrong. Inb4

>breadtube isg


nah this guy flies to russia, reads primary sources in the archives, translates them into english, cross references and interprets, this is actually some of the most scholarly and respectful work I've ever seen on the early USSR.
139 posts and 14 image replies omitted.

>>2952622
>The proletariat though it must be supreme in power cannot self regulate
If it couldn’t, we wouldn’t be advocating for supreme power for the proletariat. The most advanced are necessary for guidance and leadership, not governance.

>>2952639
>And Lenin even acknowledged that class struggle itself still exists under proletarian dictatorship
For the bourgeoisie
>Bourgeois revolutionaries

File: 1794410994709-9.jpg (239.84 KB, 1432x1783, waiterwaiter.jpg)


>>2951649
Ending large degrees of poverty and industrialization of backwaters are achievements that would impress a liberal

File: 1794411666819-2.png (5.43 MB, 2262x2673, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2952657
it's not impressive, just historically necessary

<"Socialism is inconceivable without large-scale capitalist engineering based on the latest discoveries of modern science. It is inconceivable without planned state organization, which keeps tens of millions of people to the strictest observance of a unified standard in production and distribution. We Marxists have always spoken of this, and it is not worth while wasting two seconds talking to people who do not understand even this."


- Lenin, “Left-Wing” Childishness, 1918
pic unrelated

>>2952658
>just historically necessary
Sure, but it is no communist achievement.

>>2952660
no, it's a prerequisite to that.

>>2952512
>he didn't deepthroat Bakunin so it's all made up

>>2952639
>Bourgeois revolutionaries give way bourgeois bureaucrats who moderate conflict within the bourgeoisie.
There are a lot of communists who refuse to recognize and apply basic principles of stagecraft that have been refined by bourgeois or even earlier forms of government. Class dictatorships must still manage to contradictions within a class, and there is no reason to expect anything else under socialism. The problems of governance remain the same in form if not in content, but for whatever reason many socialists (Leninists specifically) feel the need to assign to the vanguard party functions which bourgeois society has shown are actually more effective when split between various institutions. The basic principle of a tripartite government that separates legislative, executive, and judicial functions has shown to be the most effective form of class dictatorship thus far. I think that a strong socialist judiciary would be far better than a vanguard for preserving the character of a revolutionary government. Purges failed to stop Khruschev and Gorbachev, but an independent judiciary could have stopped glasnost and perestroika.

>>2953255
I agree. A government without specialized institutions is just putting all your eggs in one basket and forcing the central committee of a vanguard party to wear too many hats at once like a "Jack of all trades and master of nothing"

>>2952501
>Can the proletariat have multiple political wills?
yes, we are not vulgar determinists, nor general will-tier idealists. the bourgeoisie has multiple political wills- think the industrial and financial capitalists of marx's brumaire. they came to their conclusions of the moderate republicans through different, if interconnected, misfortunes- this is to say nothing of intersectionality, e.g. women workers' unique struggles, lgbtq+ people, african-americans, tartars, uyghas, etc. there are multiple ways of representing these interests in institutions, e.g. a women's bureau, autonomous unions, multiparty soviets or their one-party equivalent in factions. you can see this in the trade union question where trotsky, lenin and the workers' opposition put forward separate platforms that appealed to different sections of the population. for example, the lattermosts' disproportionate popularity amongst metalworkers

these're all proven ways to ensure a workers' state remains just that rather than a
>heckin' advanced section
tripping over each other in less than three decades to be let back into porky's club. arguments otherwise like >>2952613 have to rely on the silly teleologies that characterise most philosophy, or the idealist monk-bureaucrat of >>2952639 who, clever little sorcerer's apprentice he is, has become completely immune to the temptation of the senses and has arrived at what's best for you; shut up and let me reintroduce the profit motive! for i alone can resist it's influence, just look at >>2952658 and marvel at how many commodities we can trade with israel!

>>2953255
>but an independent judiciary could have stopped glasnost and perestroika
fuck, mr. gorbachev, they've had us. we've been served a strongly worded letter with no direct consequences to our power… what will we do?

>>2953423
>stopped glasnost and perestroika
>fuck, mr. gorbachev, they've had us. we've been served a strongly worded letter with no direct consequences to our power…
A judicial decision isn't a strongly worded letter, its a declaration from the state's highest legal authority that the actions of a leader or government are illegal, and that the various organs of state power don't need to comply with it. This immediately puts anybody who refuses to do so on the right side of the law and immune from retribution. Sure they could theoretically just ignore it, but that would create a serious political and constitutional crisis, and would signal a far more severe breakdown of state power and social cohesion. Meanwhile under the Soviet vanguardist system, the minute a revisionist clique gets control of the CC they can basically do whatever they want with no official or legal opposition. If judicial intervention works to preserve the bourgeois character of bourgeois states (e.g. blocking Truman's attempts to nationalize the American steel industry) then there is no reason to think it won't work for a proletarian state. Besides, its not as if purges and the KGB stopped glasnost anyways, so clearly they don't work.

>>2953470
>Sure they could theoretically just ignore it, but that would create a serious political and constitutional crisis, and would signal a far more severe breakdown of state power and social cohesion.
because the ridiculously hierarchical and hilariously easy-to-corrupt armed forces have never sided with an overbearing executive at any point in history
>Meanwhile under the Soviet vanguardist system, the minute a revisionist clique gets control of the CC they can basically do whatever they want with no official or legal opposition.
also true, even if revisionism is a meme word
>(e.g. blocking Truman's attempts to nationalize the American steel industry)
truman did not fear judges knocking down his door and putting him on trial for violating the constitution, he feared the class that controlled the judiciary's ability to enforce their rules

i'm not even necessarily disagreeing with you here, institutional design and statecraft is an important and much-neglected topic amongst leftists because it's not a dopamine subject. it's a boring, law and history-heavy policy discussion, but i'd urge you to ask yourself if the separation of powers really befits a workers' state like it does a bourgeoise? an unaccountable judiciary tied directly to an executive, in which the only democratic input is in who selects the cabinet, when the legislature (if still a heavily distilled representation of democracy) already represents what he should supposedly? this works when you're only representing goldman-sachs stockbrokers, but the whole working class? even in terms of quantity, serious qualitative changes need to be demanded to make it applicable… but then, why stop there? why not shift the burden to direct consultation with politically active constituents, a… direct democracy, with always-recallable representatives as the need arises? base its power and protection in the hands of the class it represents- a working body, workers and soldiers, etc. etc.

… the judiciary is an annoying question where this isn't as easy an answer to come by, though. i'm going to read pashukanis soon to hopefully shed some light on the subject

>>2953504
>an unaccountable judiciary tied directly to an executive
Well first, I don't think it should he tied to an executive. Judges should be chosen by sortition imo. Second, the unaccountability is actually part of their value. It means they aren't beholden to short term political interests or actors. A judge who strikes down some piece of revisionist legislation as unconstitutional doesn't need to worry about it impacting their career. They can afford to act exclusively on principle without selfish considerations.
>this works when you're only representing goldman-sachs stockbrokers, but the whole working class?
Judges in bourgeois states don't represent a handful of stockbrokers, they represent the entire bourgeois class. Their entire function is to balance the divergent interests of this whole population into a coherent body of law that allows for the general interest of the bourgeoisie to prevail. I don't see how they are less well suited to a proletarian government than a bourgeois one. If you're a vanguardist then they are essentially just performing a function that the party would need to do anyway (ie defending the constitution and preserving the class character of the state), but has historically failed at.
>but then, why stop there? why not shift the burden to direct consultation with politically active constituents, a… direct democracy, with always-recallable representatives as the need arises?
I'm not opposed to this in principle, but the problem there is more with siege conditions that any revolutionary government is likely to be confronted with. This is going to make free debate and discussion difficult, which is why the USSR tended towards a kind of party autocracy to begin with. A strong and independent judiciary provides a way to maintain the integrity of the revolution even when its democratic institutions are forced to compromise in a crisis.

>>2953423
i'm baffled that i said basically the same thing as you using different words, but then you called me an idealist monk bureaucrat. I was reading your post with delight and agreement and was quite surprised when i got to that part lol

>>2953423
>who, clever little sorcerer's apprentice he is, has become completely immune to the temptation of the senses and has arrived at what's best for you; shut up and let me reintroduce the profit motive! for i alone can resist it's influence,
not sure how you got that out of my post
>marvel at how many commodities we can trade with israel!
why are Marxist Leninist regimes constantly reproached for who they trade with. I really don't understand this moralism. I constantly hear on here how awful it is that China trades with Israel, but nobody demands that China stop trading with Israel's sponsor, the United States, a nation that has also genocided and replaced indigenous inhabitants. The USSR also traded with the USA and Israel. You'd be hard pressed to find any pair of nations on earth that don't have some kind of bilateral relations, "AES" or otherwise, yet I am "idealist" and a "sorcerer's apprentice" for refusing to be shocked by this.

File: 1794547764689-4.webp (4.71 KB, 278x253, double uyghur.webp)

WHERE ARE THE SOVIETS, STALIN?
YOU SAID THERE WOULD BE SOVIETS.

File: 1794562064384-2.png (157.92 KB, 480x270, deng.png)

>>2951649
>muh liberalism
Opening the market is as a tool for economic growth as closing it, kek. There's no actual structured ideology behind liberalism, you guys are fetishizing a literal economic tool that you might turn on and off depending on what's happening. Also, either you do international or you do bowing down to the capital eventually.

>>2951651
>deng xiaoping
>the american agent who tried to invade Vietnam while the NVA was too busy bringing Pol Pot down and freeing the Cambodian people
>failed
Problem is, amost no one is able to open or re-open the market without that level of self humiliation and disrespect for the whole revolutionary legacy that put you there in the first place.

File: 1794592791345-0.png (574.89 KB, 559x448, ClipboardImage.png)

>>2953801
why did china not simply commit suicide by cop on the global stage for the sake of ideological purity

>>2954018
>suicide by cop
Like Vietnam did with both the US and China (and quite some more)? They seem more than fine to me today. There are no excuses for this. If it's okay to be a coward and shit on every principle that held your cause together, the struggle has lost meaning completely, just declare your own country as a capitalist puppet already. Get a grip son, if you're not willing to kill or die you can't call yourself a communist.

>>2954028
Vietnam was always an imperialist satellite, illegally occupying Kampuchean and Chinese land and committing genocide on the native inhabitants. It’s essentially to Southeast Asia what “Israel” is for Palestinians

>>2953534
>judges should be chosen by sortition imo
agreeable, as is
>the unaccountability is actually part of their value
… so long as you accept that
>act exclusively on principle without selfish considerations
is possible, which it isn't. all institutions need to be materially accountable to their constituents. but then, how to negotiate biases? that's the issue
>judges in bourgeois states don't represent a handful of stockbrokers, they represent the entire bourgeois class
correct, i should've been clearer considering the conversation that i'm being abstract w/my nouns
>but has historically failed at
… because it wasn't directly democratic, there rises our issue again! a working body negotiating the affairs of a class much larger than the bourgouise amongst itself, to me, is the solution, if one w/pitfalls that need to be addressed
>the problem there is more with siege conditions that any revolutionary government is likely to be confronted with. this is going to make free debate and discussion difficult, which is why the USSR tended towards a kind of party autocracy to begin with
>siege conditions
like many others, a real concern bloated with paranoia as to appropriate it to special interests, not once did collective leadership threaten the ussr. what destroyed the ussr was, in fact, the fact that nobody below could do anything to stop the newly endowed porkies' restoration of capitalism- but then, why would they? what did their geriatric party have to offer them anymore besides (tellingly) blaming it all on jews after the fact as they privatised what they supposedly steward for the workers

its always democracy that needs to be compromised in crisis, never the idea the leadership that produced it could've been wrong

>>2953566
>but then you called me an idealist monk bureaucrat
i never meant to insult you personally, sorry it came out that way- perhaps i've misread you?
>but nobody demands that china stop trading with israel's sponsor, the united states
glad to make your acquaintance

>>2954030
>kampuchean
you've revealed your hand too early

>>2954030
>Vietnam was always an imperialist satellite
>committing genocide on the native inhabitants
You lying stooge. Studying History out of your ass? Maybe next you're going to tell me Kissinger was an anti-imperialist justice warrior, huh? Fuck off. Every single figure involved in attacking the Vietnamese are capitalist thugs, you are no exception.

>>2954110
Cowardice and lies stems from this individual's words from the beginning to the end.

>>2954772
vietnam is itself capitalist and revisionist bourgeois state

>>2954822
If Vietnam is that sort of state, then no country could be called Socialist in current times. But I can tell you're either a cheap troll or a retard for defending that take, nothing good can come out of you at this point.

>>2953801
Why does Vietnam get to have a veto over a socialist regime in Cambodia? Especially when Cambodia itself has a history of their land being taken by the Vietnamese? You are an imperialist. This is the hilarious part about all the "anti-Dengists" they have no guiding principles just finding excuses to hate on China even when they're actually in the right. China was correct to intervene against Vietnam invading Cambodia. In fact most Asian countries in the region at the time saw Vietnam as unjustified in their attack on Cambodia and as needlessly aggressive. After attacking Cambodia Vietnam then proceeded to set up a puppet government to run Cambodia for the next decade. Both Romania and North Korea refused to recognize the Vietnamese puppet government. Now compare China's behavior in the Sino-Vietnamese war. They advanced 40km into the country, took multiple cities, then called it enough of a demonstration and pulled back. Their sole purpose was to try to divert Vietnamese military forces from Cambodia to give Cambodia breathing room, and they demonstrated no intent in usurping Vietnam and installing a Chinese puppet government in Vietnam. They had the opportunity to and refused. It's clear to any sane person looking at this conflict without bias that out of all sides it was Vietnam being imperialist.

>>2954833
Ok, I will publically start genociding your fellow citizen in my socialist country, and if you invade me you're the imperialist

>>2954851
and the Zigger reveals himself

>>2954851
Vietnam is the country illegally occupying Khmer land and went on a brutal ethnic cleansing campaign against them backed by the Zionist Entity. Democratic Kampuchea engaged in a basic level of self defense and the western leftists still hadn’t forgiven them for not laying down and dying

>>2954833
sorry, dengoid, the khmer rouge WILL stop killing children on cia orders
>Both Romania and North Korea refused to recognize the Vietnamese puppet government.
oh no, what will we do without the support of nicolaei ceausescu?
>They advanced 40km into the country, took multiple cities, then called it enough of a demonstration and pulled back.
… so they're either cowards who abandoned the cambodians to their fate, or you lie? how telling, >>2954772

>unironic khmer rouge deffenders
lmao

>>2954833
>Why does Vietnam get to have a veto over a socialist regime in Cambodia?
What socialist regime? Their socialist uprising was bombed by Nixon and your patron Kissinger, giving way to your beloved murderous ethno-cultist who usurped the Cambodian Communist party, by killing competition quite literally. Also,"get to have" what? China "gets to have" the right to flex over Vietnam's territory with zero reason to do so besides intimidating a small one growing too strong outside their influence. This is the golden example of an imperialist move and how imperialists operates. I'm not even going to talk much about the obvious will of the USA in financing the Khmer Rouge AGAINST the expansion of Socialism and to use their newly proxy (at that historical moment, which changed), China.

>Now compare China's behavior in the Sino-Vietnamese war. They advanced 40km into the country, took multiple cities, then called it enough of a demonstration and pulled back.

You prefer to make ode to that laughable imperialist demonstration of power rather than to accept that you are condemning actual liberators and defending a facinorous regime that systematically murdered peasants based on ethnicity (and their own sometimes, for fun). The interference of Vietnam in Cambodia was a notable outlier comparing to basically every interventionist operation of the 20th century, if my memory doesn't fail me, there was no other comparable example. I'm not in favor of interventionism for the sake of a supposed morality, because that is usually what countries like the US does. But the objective result and objective historical facts have shown that Vietnam was absolutely in the right. If they were replicating Soviet interests in that, the Soviet interests were in the right as well. It really doesn't matter who invaded Cambodia. This is one of the few cases in history where intervention was necessary and admirable in every single aspect. They did what the World didn't have the balls to do back then, and what the World doesn't have the balls to do right now in occupied Palestine. And you dare to compare "Israel" to Vietnam. Despicable. You'd probably condemn any country who had the courage of declaring war on "Israel", because "interventionism bad", right?

>"anti-Dengists"

I wouldn't go that far. I'm "anti-Pol Pot", AKA, a minimally conscious human being. Deng knew how to push the buttons and he had his moments of brilliance in the geopolitical stage, I wouldn't deny that for the sake of defending Vietnam's position in this. The thing is, YOU are defending the fucking Khmer Rouge and I don't know what can motivate a person to love Deng so much to the point of not admitting that China's (and the whole world's position except for Vietnam and the USSR) position in that context was absolutely abnormal and reprehensible, not only in choosing to become an obstacle to the elimination of the Khmer Rouge and Pol Pot, but also to NOT collaborate in the obliteration of Pol Pot's regime ASAP. The Khmer Rouge was an abyssal abominance, and that is the objective truth. If they were batshit primitivists but didn't brutalize their own people for the sake of fucking nothing, one could even argue a bit. That's obviously not the case.

>Their sole purpose was to try to divert Vietnamese military forces from Cambodia to give Cambodia breathing room

That is exactly the problem. It is cool to intervene in a country doing the rightful and virtuous Leninist deed of stopping one of the worst brutalizers of the proletariat that history have ever witnessed, in the name of what? A shared red flag, a political coalition? The "sovereignty" of a country taken by a sadistic cult disguised as a Communist Party? Pressure from the US? Reprimand from the UN? Oh, poor China, they didn't have a choice. Fucking wrong.
Pol Pot's regime was not only not socialist or communist but an absolute offense to anyone and any country who have ever had contact with Marxist-Leninist revolution and theory, not only that, but it was objectively THE WORST and most bizarre example of what the corruption and usurpation of the Socialist ideals by literal sociopathic racist demented retards can cause to their own people. You have to be blind to not see that.
The Vietnamese position of defending the Cambodian people and the ethnical minorities in Cambodia against that disgrace was the only acceptable position from every possible angle one could look. It could be any country for that matter, and of course it wouldn't be the US. It could be China, though, if they weren't so busy throwing a tantrum at the Soviets. Mind that you are propagandizing against an actual Socialist country that defeated imperialism many times (in a row) and defended their people with utmost virtue and ferocity, and after whopping Amerikkka's fat, oily ass, they rushed to defend their own people and the people of Cambodia from literal genocide. For the sake of what? Deng's reputation or the preservation of China's historical image? Utterly pathetic. You should be ashamed of yourself.

>>2954853
>Vietnam is the country illegally occupying Khmer land
Illegal my ass. You defend legalism even if the alternative is the genocide of a whole ethnical group and the corruption of international Socialism. You are a piece of shit.

>>2954884
Yeah, unbeliavable.

>>2954028
> Get a grip son, if you're not willing to kill or die you can't call yourself a communist.
i'm sure you're knee deep in porky corpses by now
>Like Vietnam did with both the US and China (and quite some more)?
America invaded Vietnam without provocation. It was not "suicide by cop".
>There are no excuses for this. If it's okay to be a coward and shit on every principle that held your cause together, the struggle has lost meaning completely, just declare your own country as a capitalist puppet already.
Yap yap yap yap yap: get in the trench and put on the budenovka or shut up. you will go to work tomorrow, and so will the chinese. you will not die for communism and neither will the chinese proles. nobody wants to get in the trench and get shot at anymore. most people realize that's it's better to win slow. everyone has nukes and it's not 1917 anymore. you can no longer overthrow the biggest country on earth with a handful of peasants with horses and mosin nagants.

>NojRants
more like soirants lmao gottem

>>2954851
>Cambodia was committing genocide
>>2954877
>Khmer Rouge was killing da kids and backed by CIA
>>2955093
>Khmer Rouge were ethnonationalist "cultists"

All the typical retarded Westoid talking points. No investigation, no right to speak. Not even Chomsky thought the Cambodians were doing mass killings. You are no different from the conservatives claiming Stalin was killing everyone for fun during collectivization.

>>2955093
>Their socialist uprising was bombed by Nixon and your patron Kissinger
<KHMER ROUGE WERE CIA SPIES
>Why did Kissenger and Nixon bomb the living crap out of them then?
<UHHHHHH

Your narrative is so retarded it even contradicts itself. Pol Pot and his allies were the people being bombed by Nixon and Kissenger, who you desperately want to portray as the "real puppetmasters" or backers of the Khmer Rouge. This is insane. It would be like calling the Cuban government and officials puppets of Marco Rubio as he is strangling them to death.

>>2954028
> Get a grip son, if you're not willing to kill or die you can't call yourself a communist.
Real.
>>2955143
>i'm sure you're knee deep in porky corpses by now
He said willing.

Cowards don't belong anywhere. May the enemy have all the cowards in the world.

My family died in some random ditch somewhere for this shit and I am ready to go to when the time comes. Don't want to say too much info but my relative who shares the same name as me his other family member was getting cold feet and saying "well who is going to look after our family" but he said "but what about all the children out there who don't have family like us to look out for them?"

To due fighting for what is right is a hood death and way better than dying from old age.

File: 1794729010193-0.jpg (36.88 KB, 388x515, images(220).jpg)

>>2955314
>Don't want to say too much info but my relative who shares the same name as me his other family member
His *this maybe I came back.

>>2955093
>Pol Pot's regime was not only not socialist or communist but an absolute offense to anyone and any country who have ever had contact with Marxist-Leninist revolution and theory, not only that, but it was objectively THE WORST and most bizarre example of what the corruption and usurpation of the Socialist ideals by literal sociopathic racist demented retards can cause to their own people.
Quick question, since you are a complete retard who is just repeating all the pro-Western and pro-Viet talking points without even trying to pretend to be objective: did Vietnam's puppet government in Cambodia maintain socialism or did it liberalize? If your argument is that the Vietnamese could have been trusted with the future of an entire foreign country and people, then logically Cambodia today should still be socialist, no? After all, the Vietnamese were successful in overthrowing the Khmer Rouge. So is Cambodia today socialist or capitalist? And if you admit the truth - that they are now capitalists who liberalized - what does that imply about your assertions of Vietnam being the safe-guarders and true devotees of socialism in Cambodia?

>>2955317
Cambodia isn't a Vietnamese puppet
every socialist country has liberalized,every single one of them

>>2955320
Even DPRK?

>>2955309
>>2955310
>you retarded westoid!
Not an argument.
The bombings set path for the Khmer Rouge. The CIA and the US administration facilitated the survival and resurgence of the Khmer Rouge primarily to counter Vietnamese and Soviet influence in Cambodia, by literally giving them money during the Vietnamese-Cambodian war. That's a common and respectable position to have towards this historical context since it has a shitload of evidence around it, such as the few ones I'm bringing here.

>>2955143
>more conformity and anti-revolutionary cynicism
Does not surprise me.

>>2955317
>And if you admit the truth - that they are now capitalists who liberalized - what does that imply about your assertions of Vietnam being the safe-guarders and true devotees of socialism in Cambodia?
It's not my desire to picture Vietnam as "the safe-guarders and true devotees of socialism in Cambodia". They simply did the right thing by any rational diplomatic and geopolitical stance and I cannot understand how isn't that objective enough for you. You must think I'm devoted to defend the Vietnamese in all points and to exalt them, no, I'm not bound to this stance like you're blindly bound to defend China. The only thing I defend is Marxism-Leninism even so, critically, not dogmatically.
Vietnamese troops occupied the country until September 1989, restoring basic services and the Cambodian people's rights. Free elections took place in 1993 (enforced by the UN through the UNTAC after the Vietnamese did all the heavy lifting despite UN disapproval) and they implemented constitucional monarchy. Which is better than ethno-nationalist pseudo-socialist genocidal regime. Or is it not? That only shows that Vietnam did not took control of the Cambodian state. Also, after decades of attrition with China, one of the Khmer Rouge patrons, and as one of the decisive factors for this, Vietnam's diplomatic position in the world has been gravely affected. They didn't have any political strength at that point (in the 90s) to enforce a political puppet in Cambodia, even if they wanted to.
As long as the Khmer Rouge gets completely dethroned (which should have happened in the war, WITH the help of China, not in 1999), I really wouldn't care much since one have to make a real fucking effort to implement something worse than that. Being quite honest. I mean, if minimizing the damage of Deng's politics on this is more desirable in your opinion than to question any allegiance with the Khmer Rouge, that's completely your choice.

>>2955309
>was killing da kids
concern for the slaughter of children being so prepostorous as to be a joke to you is revealing, no wonder you are a running dog for the cia and zionist entity. dengoids need to be institutionalized
>retarded westoid talking points
well for a start most western marxists, at least, wouldn't feel the need to be ableist to convey their philobabble to me
>chomsky
did not have perfect information and presented a healthy suspicion of the western narrative that was understandable at the time, but why would i expect nuance from an unironic pol pot defender?
>no different from the conservatives claiming stalin was killing everyone for fun during collectivization
conflating nuance with the extreme, another typical ml dishonesty

sigh, another win for westoids!

In my ideal communist society, people who defend Pol Pot are summarily executed. Trust with that kind of person is literally impossible.

File: 1794756989222-2.webp (17.02 KB, 623x713, disgusted shaggy.webp)

>>2955317
>img

What in the fizzity yuck is this? Is this supposed to actually be some kind of refutation to the idea that "Year Zero" was a travesty? Hmm yes, on the one hand we have the documented fact that the Khmer Rouge went on a campaign of ruralmaxxing, hunting down intellectuals or anybody perceived as such, an ethnic cleansing campaign against Vietnamese, and just in general butchering their population. But on the other hand, you've got a Khmer Rouge spokesperson who assures us that Year Zero "zeroes everything bad, and doesn't zero anything good". Very persuasive!

>>2955143
>>2955314
>To due fighting for what is right is a hood death and way better than dying from old age.
people say this like they're winning something for the proletariat and not just ending up compost in porky's garden

>>2955443
i've come to accept that many people on here view the historical method and not having a one sided analysis as "bourgeois science" and uncritically believing everything /ourguy/ says with no investigation as "proletarian science"

I will hug IRL M-Ls and demand the execution of $$$Online-Left$$$ "M-L"s.

Nationalist scum who cannot critique their idols need to be kept online, away from any real local movement.

>>2955320
They were when the Vietnamese were occupying them. Quick question: did the Vietnamese ever allow Cambodians themselves to choose their officials during their occupation of the country? The answer is no. The imperialism is obvious.

>>2955362
Holy fuck am I talking to bots? You literally handed me a pdf proving the CIA was not helping the Khmer Rouge. Kill yourself moron. If you read the pdf you blindly threw at me you would realize it states the CIA did not help the KR.

You don't even read the crap you're posting as "evidence". Even the article by Jack points out that all the US did was fund relief organizations operating in fucking THAILAND and not even Cambodia. Sorry but is your argument that the US should have not tossed whatever meager funds they did to Thailand (which was clearly just a bribe to try to get on good terms with Thailand's government dealing with an incoming refugee crisis) after Vietnam's invasion, to ensure Thailand wouldn't be able to cope with the refugee flow so that all the Cambodian refugees could starve and die instead? If they chose to go back to Cambodia afterwards to fight an occupation of their country, that was their choice. The US never paid or ordered them to do so. What an absolute joke. Your position has collapsed from "Kissinger and Nixon were puppetmasters ordering the KR around" to "Thailand's Government was hosting refugee camps to feed displaced people fleeing a war and this is bad because some of them, not even all but just some, went back afterwards to fight a foreign occupier".

By your retarded logic, American-funded NGOs and UN and aid workers operating in Palestine and Gaza to alleviate starvation or to provide medical support, are strengthening Hamas and controlling the Palestinian resistance movement.

>I'm not bound to this stance like you're blindly bound to defend China.

I'm not defending China you retard the only purpose China had in this conversation was to illustrate the DIFFERENCE between what they did in Vietnam vs what the Vietnamese did in Cambodia. Vietnam forcefully took over Cambodia and set up a puppet government that lasted for a decade, depriving Cambodians of their own right to choose their own government. China took over parts of Vietnam and COULD HAVE done the same and set up their own puppet government as retaliation, but instead they just pulled back and left. Over the course of these years I've come to realize that everyone in the West is fucking wrong about Cambodia and the Cambodian communists were unjustly smeared, but because Vietnam+America+Europe+the modern liberal Cambodian government all agree on the narrative of "Cambodian communists = crazy lunatics", and because China's is totally unwilling to fight back against the constant smears or to explain to people, the truth got buried.

For example, I haven't even brought up yet that after the Vietnamese finally retreated and the new Cambodian government took power, the Khmer Rouge CONTINUED TO FIGHT AGAINST THE NEW LIBERAL GOVERNMENT. This is proof they were not "ethnonationalist cultists" but genuine revolutionaries committed to socialism as they continued to fight after the Vietnamese had left, against the new Cambodian liberal government, and the CIA and Americans explicitly demanded after Vietnam left that the next Cambodian government was forbidden from having the Khmer Rouge take part of any government coalition. Does any Western source or Wikipedia even mention this? NO, because it destroys the narrative that "Khmer Rouge are CIA puppets".

>The only thing I defend is Marxism-Leninism even so, critically, not dogmatically.

YOU ARE the dogmatic. You came into this thread accusing Cambodian revolutionaries of the most ludicrous nonsense imaginable despite never having studied this matter. Chomsky rightfully pointed out that the mass death toll was from the US bombing campaign against Cambodia and its aftereffects and the Cambodians could not be blamed for the majority of deaths, and decades later the Americans have successfully convinced everyone that the death toll was instead Pol Pot and the KR's fault. If you were half as "critical" as you profess to be, you would recognize the tragedy of how all this black propaganda so successfully smeared a genuine revolutionary communist movement, but in your arrogance and desire to hate on China by using this conflict as a proxy to attack them, you sacrifice all principled inquiry.

>>2955409
Again, absolutely ZERO proof of atrocities just you constantly demand people accept smears and lies as truth. You have never even BEEN to Cambodia and you insist you know better. Kill yourself moron. Oh look I can accuse you of killing children too and since you think all it takes is being a Westerner to be trusted, and since I am a Westerner, you are now guilty of killing children simply because I accused you of it. What an amazingly stupid view.

>>2955443
>documented fact
"Documented" by who? Let's think: A Vietnamese military occupational government that had every incentive to paint the KR as monsters to justify their takeover. American historians, media, and academicians who are resolutely anti-Communists happy to ascribe all sorts of nonsense to Communist leaders and movements, and, in the modern day, a liberalized Cambodian government that also hates the KR and attacks them as lunatics and pushes an education curriculum criticizing and attacking the Khmer Rouge. Oh did I forget to mention that? Yes that's right the modern day Cambodian government relentlessly attacks the Khmer Rouge in their national education curriculum. Funny how your perspective lines up perfectly with the modern capitalist regime of Cambodia.

Wow it's amazing how everyone agrees on the same convenient self-interested narrative while the ACTUAL revolutionaries are never given a chance to defend themselves. And you think yourself smart for believing in this nonsense?

You are the exact type of gullible fool that would have believed there were WMDs in Iraq, or that Assad gassed Syrians and tortured millions of them in prisons, or that Gaddafi mass raped Libyan women. What an absolute joke this board is where I am literally the only person with a functioning brain.

>>2955601
Funny how I'm literally the only one who brought actual testimonial from a KR member into this thread, proving I have researched into this more than anyone else in this thread, and you all pretend like believing in lies is more intellectually sound.


Unique IPs: 29

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo / 420 ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]