[ overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / siberia / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime / music ] [ meta / roulette ] [ GET / ref / booru]

/anime/ - Anime

Graphical arts and related topics
Password (For file deletion.)

New Announcement: IRC<=>Matrix bridge #leftypol on Rizon
Please give feedback on proposals, new every Monday : /meta/

File: 1608528777155.gif (1.04 MB, 418x454, Tastetherainbow.gif)

 No.373[Last 50 Posts]

How would you go about fixing the Isekai (sub?)genre from its current state of mediocrity and stagnation?


Make the main character female.


just end the genre and go back to making more regular fantasy anime


To fix Isekai, you need a grand narrative. Why was we drawn to isekai? It's because that real world has become so bad we no longer hope for a good ending in a real world. A good isekai should be the one that not only provided escapism, but implicit show the solution to change the real world.
That's why I really those isekai that have MC quickly accept such things as slavery, because it teaches the readers to think that the only problem with this real world is that they're born unluckily into lower class, but not the system itself.


No OP bullshit powers
No (generic) harem
No webtoon art style
No braindead MC
That's all you need imo.


>ditch the generic copy-paste fantasy setting
>develop the mc
>don't spoonfeed the audience
>actually develop the setting
>real stakes
>actually make being in a new world a conflict


>No OP bullshit powers
This is really the entire problem with the genre now, for me.

As for the source of the problem? A bit of pasta from me on the subject:
>Any Isekai that don't make the fantasy natives look like backward morons?
&ltMost older series that are created before the recent isekai boom.
>Huh. So where did this new arrogance come from?
At first glance, I would've suggested the difference is vidya, since most of the newer and more cringey isekai are implicitly or explicitly running on JRPG/KMMORPG mechanics, whereas the older stories were just fantasy stories.

But on some consideration, I think the difference is sex (and to a lesser extent, age). Basically all of the modern isekai are shonen with a smattering of seinen, whereas all the best old isekai I can think of were josei (Twelve Kingdoms) or shojo (Escaflowne, Fushigi Yuugi). During this time shonen/seinen fantasy of course existed, but very rarely using the pretext of parallel worlds.


I don't know why nobody is talking about it,but the inherent problem of isekai,is that it's not a genre,it's just a pretext,a premise,there is like 4 actual isekai who actually use the whole "another world" trope as an actual scenario.
There is a dire need to be an actual link between the real world and the fictional,something that makes the whole idea of going between worlds a meaningful choice for the story to go through.
if there is not that,then it's just a generic fantasy story with no stakes.
all the things >>377 is complaining about is just bad powerfantasy writing,that has just been poured into it,because we're all craving dopamine in a shitty capitalist hellscape and it sells,so every editor and cynical artist tries to make a buck on it,and the fact that the current market for mangas is now just chasing around the ghosts of the past trying to remake the same thing over and over but having no idea or even envy to do it for most people,and even worse,going into a downward spiral were the demand is always created by the market,so everybody always wants the same thing in the end,if everything is shit,only shit is at the top.
This apply also to "old" isekai were the story of the fantasy world is interesting,but the pretext is still utterly asinine.


> current state of mediocrity and stagnation
1) Bring out another Season of Konosuba
2) Cancel grimdark edgelord shit like Re;Zero and Overlord as well as brainless shit like Log Horizon.
3) Take more obscure isekai LN series that have not been animated and make them.


Hamefura, honzuki.

Theres litterally two female protagonist isekai airing right now and theyre both great.


>How would you go about fixing the Isekai (sub?)genre from its current state of mediocrity and stagnation?
Less powerfantasy. 90% of isekai is basically just a "i went into some version of the past and i am now superhuman with my basic modern knowledge" or "i got litterally given godlike powers".
Shows like doctor stone are also just isekais.

Make the other world thing something actually meaningfull. At least half of isekais could work the exact same way with just a regular dude from the world they exist in right now. They just put in a dude or dudette from our own world in order to make it more relatable to the audience and because its an easy plot device.
Like hamefura is great, but so far you could have had the literal exact same show if instead of the MC "regaining her memories" she just had a vision of those things.
Though i guess that would rob us of the slight subversion (though it could have been a lot more on the nose for me tbh) of otome game tropes. Same for things like re zero. How would the show have been any different if the mc had been some random orphan that stumbled into the same place with the same curse? Him being from our own world literally does not play into the story at all.

I still like hamefura and re zero though.


>likes konosuba the most generic "comedy" isekai in existence
>dislikes re;zero that has one of the most unique storylines

what a fucking shit opinion


This. We got some gems like Konosuba, but it's time to do other stuff. Maybe 20 or so years from now we will have some fresh ideas for isekai.

Personally I would like to see some new attempts at stuff like Slayers and Record of the Lodoss War.


You never know. I guess it depends on how hard the animation industry gets hit by the new recession and how desperate Japan gets for material to adapt.


just have more interesting, well-developed settings than 'Dragon Quest without Toriyama' that's all you really need to do


Yeah, looking into it, the author launched a 3rd arc of mainline novels a couple years ago that's two volumes in by now. So there's a chance something interesting might happen with the franchise soon.


File: 1608528778016.jpg (7.78 KB, 256x197, index.jpg)

Yeah, I think we're really getting burned out. Too many anime have played around with reincarnation into worlds with video game settings. I don't even think the old hook of gender bendered reincarnation is novel anymore since everyone is so used to it and of trans people now.

Personally I'd like another Crest of the Stars, with the same deeply thought out setting (the author tried to create his own language just like Tolkein), with epicness and romance. This time I'd just want with less princesses and more communism, and it'd be nice if the main characters weren't essentially fighting withing a neoliberal empire.

I'm hoping the next generation of Japanese directors will be further left and so we'll see some pretty cool leftist fantasy soon instead of the usual nationalism + neoliberalism.


> the most generic "comedy" isekai in existence
It isn't though. Just because Cautious Hero and other Isekai copy its gimmick doesn't mean it's generic since its one of the first to come out. Its satirical and politically incorrect without having an actual ideology and is thus amusing for it
Time Loops have been an old hat since BEFORE Groundhog Day. Fuck there was a Naruto fanfiction published covering this EXACT concept before RE;Zero was even made. Re;Zero has an interesting CONCEPT, but executes it so horrendously that past the first 10 episodes, it becomes utter schlock. Like SAO it dangles interesting and good moments, only to then kick them to death, like that puppy in Elfen Lied.
Edgy grimdark shit and "muh 1 true waifu" is shit that plagues Isekai like SAO or Re;Zero. Either execute the idea fully or don't taint it.


>it'd be nice if the main characters weren't essentially fighting withing a neoliberal empire
LOL, that's a bit of a humblebrag, to say the least. Crest/Banner of the Stars isn't liberal, isn't even feudal, it's outright fascist revanchism. The Abh are basically Space Imperial Japan, playing up their "inscrutabru orientur curture" to justify their totalitarian society as an exotic quirk, and their "teehee we live in space and just politely annex planets under Not!Colonial governors"-schtick is basically Space Co-Prosperity Sphere.

But all of that is secondary to the central waifu plot.

If you want a politically conscious take on the same basic setting, play SC2.


I love Crest of the Stars. I have the old translated novels on my shelf. I hope they try adapting it again. A return to scifi anime would be fun. I'd like mecha to make a comeback too, but I'd be happy without it so long as we get more scifi.


Honestly I really didn't like Re;Zero either. It wasn't bad, but I didn't understand the hype. I guess it had some cool waifus, but I want a little more than that in my anime.


You totally correct, but I still loved the show and my fascist space elf waifu.


I stop making them at such as fast pace, and actually pay my animators a livable wage instead of pocket change per cel.


At least anime uses less 3rd-world sweatshop animation than "western" cartoons do


Animation coops might be a better alternative. I'm sure it would still have shitty pay, but at least the grunts at the studio could feed themselves.


File: 1608528778481.png (909.45 KB, 1200x880, anime incomes.png)

Anti-Seiyu Aktion


*I would
I'm not familiar with the extent of outsourcing in western tv animation.
Have you heard of the Animator Dormitory Project? It looks pretty interesting.


Communist revolution isekai baybee. Something like gekokujo but with less child sweatshops and magic and more industrialization.


I think KyoAni.does the.majority.of.their animation in-house and pays their animators well.


I don't know how well the animators are paid, but they do get salaries which means the studio at bare minimum has to follow stricter labors laws. Given the quality of their animation and the fact they are one of the only studios that isn't paying per drawing I imagine a job there is super competitive.


File: 1608528778782.jpeg (322.53 KB, 1312x1242, Isekai protag harem.jpeg)

Stop having pic related be the focus of the story unironically… or at least have it actually be legitimate and not "oooh I'm horny, let me love this guy for NO real reason"


Kyo Anime did, but then their studio was burned down by a homicidal madman which killed half of the animators. They're no more.


>oooh I'm horny, let me love this guy for NO real reason
&ltdescribing 90% of battle-harem anime


They have multiple studios, and have recovered from the incident.


Recently finished watching Overly Cautious Hero (Shinchou Yuusha: Kono Yuusha ga Ore Tuee Kuse ni Shinchou Sugiru)
Honestly I have to say it was not what I expected. The first few episodes resemble Konosuba, but as it goes on it gets pretty dark and fucked up. It even has a few parts reminiscent of Berserk-tier shit which wasn't directly shown but the implications of which are still nauseating.
It still possesses humorous parts throughout though.

All in all a decent Isekai series that is relatively well made and possesses plenty of satirical and parodic moments. Definitely would watch again.


I enjoyed it too. I won't rewatch it, but I would pick up a second season if them make one.


Checked dubs.
I actually wouldn't mind them ending on 1 season simply due to the open-ended adventure potential it allows.


I don't know maybe there should be isekai about this


this being? was there an image to go with your post?


I enjoyed it more than I should have. When they showed how in the possible sequel they were going to liberate the world where Seiya previously failed I got hard. Really loved the darker parts of the show.


>That ending for Shin Highschool DxD Volume 4.
Fuck, Great Red better make a comeback


>I got hard
Excuse me!?

Based trips


This summarizes my opinion on the Overlord anime pretty well, though in less detail since I dropped it very early.


>ending for Shin Highschool DxD Volume 4
Hopefully his Power of Dreams will have something to do with it.


File: 1608528779446.jpg (19.24 KB, 500x367, 3ae.jpg)

>Excuse me!?


I actually remember liking the LNs a lot more than the anime. I enjoy the overpowered supervillain thing. It's just a nice change of pace from the usual shit, though I still think it is a weird wish fulfillment thing like most the isekai shit.


On the topic of DxD, we should spam ScrewAttack to do a Deathbattle with Issei Hyoudou vs another powerful protagonist of some kind.


File: 1608528836458.png (4.37 MB, 791x2699, Tsundere Storm Dragon.png)

On the note of DxD and Isekai I found the only fanfiction for Reborn as a Slime and DxD, which frankly is just begun but already a lot of fun.


Go back to super detailed settings and worldbuilding being expected, '90s-'00s isekai were great.


But world building is hard and otaku will eat up any generic half baked fantasy garbage if the waifus are decent.


What anime is picture from?


It's that slime isekai, won't be hard to find.


Its mentioned in my post y'know. Reborn as a Slime.


Holy shit I can't believe how much of this garbage there is.

Escaflowne was the best.


Have the MC miss his home-world and actively try to find a way back

Also, have him be a communist


>Have the mc be a communist


Am I the only one who wants to see the "And she don't stop coming" meme used with the Aqua rainbow vomit gif?


A similar fic, though more stereotypical isekai–shittish.


File: 1608528888302.jpg (2.43 MB, 1920x1359, ffvi party.jpg)

Escaflowne was Not!FFVI seriously it was good but I think there must've been some actual plagiarism going on


Some "leftist"weeb got really mad about how Overly Cautious Hero and Konosuba are totally chauvinistic and bad. It was pathetic


File: 1608528896487.png (2.85 MB, 1920x1691, 790893.png)

Anyone attacking Konosuba is my enemy.


Aqua is hot as fuck, I wish there were better doujins of her.


File: 1608528897058.jpg (450.76 KB, 2263x4096, 1594826344559.jpg)

Post more pictures of Aqua, please!


File: 1608528897182.jpg (67.62 KB, 750x422, water.jpg)


File: 1608528904473-0.gif (878.48 KB, 498x298, ThotGoddess.gif)

File: 1608528904473-1.jpg (154.44 KB, 1500x1500, Eris.jpg)

Aqua has decent booty, but I personally prefer the only true goddess Eris.




File: 1608528904735.jpg (464.36 KB, 1748x2480, Best Goddess.jpg)

She has an overall better personality in comparison, which actually makes her tolerable unlike the drunk thot Aqua. So my question is:


File: 1608528904805.jpg (93.57 KB, 993x879, aqua is useful 1.jpg)

>Better Personality
Maybe, Aqua is good once she's disciplined. Besides, Eris is a bit of a brevno (log).
Oh and



Firstly, yes. Secondly, idc, I just want my trash waifu


I thought the appeal of Aqua was that she's a dumb bitch.


That's part of the appeal to me.


We're not being burned out, we're just lacking with any one anime/manga/LN that concretely and properly executes the ideas without hamstringing itself with plotholes, poor romantic lines and edginess.
SAO abridged actually does the concept of SAO much better than the original. And Konosuba and Cautious Hero demonstrate how one can play with the gamer Isekai genre humorously.
Reincarnated as a Slime, which uses gaming mechanics, also is good, because it embraces how OP the character is and manages a good story around it. If this kind of thing was applied to a real SAO-type gaming anime, we'd probably be satisfied.


>make the main character Yuri-bait


I won't allow you to call Maple and Sally yuribait even if they are


Watcha gonna do? Call the Yuri police?


Do something other than a fantasy setting goddamn
Also make the MC just some guy who doesn't have bullshit powers


They both use the same Koreans


Yes, but less of them. I sincerely doubt there's one single American left that draws tween frames professionally for broadcast or theatrical animation, and the number of such Americans drawing keyframes is probably in the triple digits.


It amazes me how much better SAO Abridged is than the actual anime. SAO Abridged and SAO Alternative Gun Gale Online are the only good things to come out of that franchise in my opinion.


Perestroika, obviously.


File: 1608528937265.png (261.47 KB, 469x414, 1599704799086.png)

The only solution is to pretty much just stop making them and return to tradition (fantasy anime). It seems to be slowly dying on its own, anyway.

Also fuck Konosuba, the anime was good (probably thanks to Deen's QUALITY) but the novels ended up turning into what it was parodying and had a shitty open ending, plus the author is a one-trick-pony hack who made at least two other works that are literally just Konosuba but with a few changes. Seriously, go look them up, the guy can't write anything else.


Cursed joke

>novels ended up turning into what it was parodying
Because there is only so much you can do before the product has been wrung dry, by which point it's just extended for the monies.
>two other works
Names please?


Eh, I don't mind them keeping the novels going. At this point I just enjoy the characters and want to continue reading about them doing shit.

I thought his wrestling series was fun, but I only watched the anime.


The same thing sort of happened to Highschool DxD and is exactly what derailed SAO from the beginning.


i don't remember SAO being a parody at all but just legitimately honestly genuinely isekaishit


The cheese pizza man can pass reforms.


The Wizard of Oz is a good isekai. Kindred is a good isekai.
Just don't make them fanservice for otaku always.


What I meant about SAO and DxD is how unique they were in their genre in terms of ideas.

DxD has held up for at least 12-16 volumes at least, and I still am interested in the rest of it, however the original 'magic' of DxD was how Issei, instead of being a wussy dude who has girls liking him for no reason and getting all ashamed of pervy things, is the opposite. He's an unabashed pervert who powers-up on the idea of groping and sucking tits. He peeps on girls unashamedly and his saving grace is his loyalty to friends and kindness. He's weak as fuck in the beginning, but through sacrifice and training gains power and the girls he was into start taking him seriously instead of a boytoy. Sure, it gets into a shonen power-wank later on, but that's part of the fun, since Issei is a reluctant fighter, who unlike most Shonen protags, doesn't like having strong rivals and a lust for fighting.

With SAO it was a relatively under-rated idea that was wasted quickly. Compare SAO to Log Horizon…. there are no fucking stakes in Log Horizon because death is nonexistent there. in SAO, if you die in the game you die IRL. But SAO wasted this potential instantly, both in the anime and in the LNs. This is why I liked SAO Abridged more. Sachi's death has lasting impact throughout the first season instead of being a forgotten "tragedy". Kirito is not some good person who's also a gamer, he's a broken and slightly sociopathic trauma victim who loves movies and other escapism. Despite his anti-social behaviour, he still is good at heart even if he's cruel in how he goes about it. The S-Class Ragu Rabbit cooked by a maxed out Cooking Skill had a logical result of making any food, real or virtual taste like garbage. There's plenty more, but point is, this is all non-existent in the original. It's so bland that they had to make it up with heart-tugging shit like Mother's Rosario and the brutal-over-reality of Alicization's edgefest.

TL;DR They began to squander their potential as steam and inspiration began to be lost.


SAO Abridged Kirito is essentially just like Kazuma except with power.



For a moment I thought you were talking about Saint Seiya and I was hyped, then I realized this was referring to a different show… I am dissapoint.


Hail Eris?



>I was hyped, then I realized this was referring to a different show
I realize this sounds like Kayaba from SAO Abridged now.


File: 1608529089022.jpg (83.65 KB, 1280x720, Visa no.jpg)

>>795 Youjo Senki thread BTW


>make the setting something more interesting than just generic fantasy or video game world, something that would actually create interesting contrasts for the protagonist
>alternatively, or additionally, make the protagonist something other than ordinary nondescript Japanese guy, give him interesting traits
>no harem or powerfantasy bullshit
>it doesn't even have to be a fighting or adventure plot
Essentially fish-out-of-water stories are supposed to be interesting because of the contrasts between the MC and the world, most isekai is just blatantly "life sucks I wish I was an anime protagonist".
No meta shit either. I mean parodies and """deconstructions""" are alright but they're no solution and eventually become saturated themselves. You're just binding yourself to what's problematic about the genre.
Someone else mentioned Wizard of Oz. Literally one of the most famous stories in English literature is an isekai: Alice in Wonderland.
But truthfully it'd be best to let it die for a while. Sometimes something is so overdone and tired that even a good version can be hard to enjoy.


Pretty solid solutions


What anime needs is another GATE that isn't gross JSDF propaganda, maybe more in line with how StargateSG1 did it (which was in turn USAF propaganda but way better done).


>GATE that isn't gross JSDF propaganda
GATE without JSDF propaganda would just be another generic shitty isekai instead of a nationalist right-wing shitty isekai.


not at all, since it presupposes a civilizational level connection, not just the shitty MC that gets wooshed away. the terrain of colliding worlds on a grand scale is much more fertile ground than the tired fish out of water setting


Go watch Outbreak company.


The key with Stargate was in making Earth a low-tech backwater usually protected by little more than obscurity or treaty obligations between actual galactic superpowers, and Earth itself only eking out wins against them by exploiting preexisting tensions within/among its enemies and encouraging allies to play to strengths they didn't know they had through an "outside the box" perspective.

Ironically, in spite of USAF involvement (possibly even because of it, on a horseshoe basis of the conflict between 'merkin ideology, versus actual behavior deeply contradictory with those ideological ideals) I think Stargate's story ideologically feels less like imperialist propaganda, and more like anti-imperialism.

There's even an interesting contrast in how Earth handles these utterly superior enemies between SG-1 and Atlantis **. Where in SG-1 Earth wins through these machinations playing on the weaknesses of great powers, versus Atlantis, where Earth's presence in Atlantis just desperately makes even bigger messes and fucks up repeatedly because it's just Earth and totally marginal allies versus one pretty much unified enemy.


Make it so their isekai is just a state if psychosis that has real world impact.


File: 1608529108154.jpg (196.12 KB, 1200x881, reincarnated as a spider.jpg)

An interesting Isekai is Reborn as a Spider. I usually dislike CBR but this article is actually fairly good.



Keep in mind that while it's really good for quite a while (not as fast in the manga as in the novels, but still eventually) it does the typical isekei thing of going UTTERLY and COMPLETELY to shit once powerlevels get too high.


too bad Kon is already dead or he would have been the man for the job


File: 1608529108868.png (344.71 KB, 1014x1035, GutsCrying.png)

Man, his absence never stops hurting.

Though thinking of him, Paranoia Agent's message was about 70% of what the most vicious and laser-accurate takedown imaginable of isekai's worst failings would look like.


What's fucking interesting about this? That she starts as nothing and… quickly becomes OP? What a snore.


File: 1608529110094.jpg (425.64 KB, 2400x727, Dragon Lords porky.jpg)

Here's an isekai idea for y'all (it's ironic since I remember having a similar idea, but instead it was a socialist MC who convinces Dragons and Dwarves to work together).


double checked, nicu-desu

It's subverting tropes typical - i.e. le handsome bishounen getting to live the real life! - having it be a spider and let shenanigans ensue.
>muh power up
No shit, it's a silly escapist fantasy, not a serious work. Nobody claimed it was.

All good things come to an end usually


I haven't read them, but there's already isekai novels/anime/manga kind of like that (about using the MC's economics knowledge in a fantasy setting), such as Koushaku Reijou no Tashinami.


Anyone here watched/read Drifters? Literally the only good isekai I ever encountered. Its about bunch of historical figures being send to the generic fantasy world, with mission to either save it or destroy it. It utilizes the isekai premise really well, lot of focus is on showing how introducing these foreign elements into the fantasy world changes it. Like the fact that a guy knows how to produce gunpowder, or retro-engineering pieces of technology they brought with them are key plot points. Also the main villain is probably Jesus Christ.
It is illustrated by the same guy who did Hellsing.


I watched the first season it was great some stuff was a bit weird and I have no idea how they want to continue the story but overall pretty neat. Will there be a second season?


fash garbage LMMAO


Havent heart anything about second season, first one covered 40-50 chapters, and currently the manga is on 80, so there is not enough material to adapt yet.

I would not say it is fascist, thematically its kind of like edgier Lord of the Rings. Uniting people of all races to defeat great evil and all. But yes, it has that Japanese quality where you can tell author does not share our sensibilities concerning WW2.


currently rewatching and taking notes because I didn't understand it on a first viewing, I'll have to take your word for it lol
gave the first episode a go, it looks good. significantly more trashy than I would have liked, I guess you can't have it all tho


>currently rewatching and taking notes because I didn't understand it on a first viewing
If you watch while understanding the main message to be "self-deception is bad", the show obviously hammers nonstop on these points.

I think it couldn't get any blunter than in the final episodes when the older detective smashes apart a literal cardboard fantasy of his idealized memories after his frail wife singlehandedly fights off the gargantuan Shonen Bat with nothing more than a stern lecture on sincerely accepting her own failings and making do despite them.



gotta say, they almost lost me with the beach episode, but luckily best girl came through in the end


By not wasting their potential likeRe:Zero or any other mediocre work with a good premise does.


>wowsie im in an another world!!
This not a genre, this is a dump trope.


It's not a dumb trope lol,, it just gets poorly executed because it's an easy tool for lazy writers. It has become a genre at this point.


it's a pretty dumb and usually pathetic trope: hurr I wasted my life until I died but the universe loves me so much I get to start all over in a world where video games are real and I am the only Chad so all the Staceys naturally fall for only me

like there's wish fulfillment and then there's isekai


File: 1627319094344.jpg (2.46 MB, 1200x4616, Isekai film heroes.jpg)

>hurr I wasted my life until I died but the universe loves
That's not what Isekai is, that's a plot device method that poorly made Isekai take part in.
Pic related are all Isekai, and most are good movies and stories
>in a world where video games are real
You've described not even 1/3 of in-another-world fiction.
>I am the only Chad so all the Staceys naturally fall for only me
Again that's the most generic cashgrab garbage, not the majority of the genre
> there's wish fulfillment and then there's isekai
Yeah you need to expand to actually good Isekai instead of consuming shit and claiming all of the genre is shit. You sound like a person who sees Hunger Games and denounces all dystopian fiction as "muh chosen one" garbage.


>isekai is good
>posts images of shit that are not isekai
rip van winkle is isekai lmao star wars is isekai lol isekai is good because everything is isekai and everything includes good things so isekai is good laffo


>shit that are not isekai
<Isekai is literally 'in another world'/fish out of water stories
Are you ok?
>schizo strawman about other fiction
Concession accepted.


Calm down


What is the last one? I don't recognize it. Is it good?


you are retarded and don't know what isekai is

you should kill yourself


Stay mad, no argument brainlet

It's called Lastman https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6296094/


>you are retarded and don't know what isekai is
What is it according to you?
How are the movies in the pic not isekai?


>It's called Lastman https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6296094/
I have watched it and it's not an isekai. Maybe if there will be a second season where the action would take place in the Valley of Kings, but as it is, it's no more isekai than War of the Worlds.


File: 1627972541308.png (263.08 KB, 500x671, ClipboardImage.png)

Anyone watch Redo of Healer? I've only seen the summary and clips but frankly while it's an interesting concept, it feels really friggin' edgy, especially with it being a 'harem' show that gets down to it. Aa comment I read summarizes my impression of the show from what I've gleaned of it, "Redo of healer really puts you on your toes one of the animes where yes you completely understand why he does what he does but at the same time you are thinking jeez dude chill"

So, is it worth watching this or is just an edgy grim-dark 'fantasy' like every other DnD edgefest to ever grimdark?
Because this is giving me Shinimaou no Basara vibes and I loathe that discount-DxD hentai.

Also is it just me or is there a trend of Isekai/fantasy anime having an edgy MC getting (petty) revenge and power, we got Shield Hero, Isekai Shihai No Skill Taker, Arifureta, Nidome no Yuusha, and Moonlit Fantasy, heck Moonlit Fantasy is one of several anime where an isekai character is banished, wanders the world penniless and bitter and meets magic creatures and becomes super OP and shit. It's so repetitive yet eaten up. Not that Isekai should be the happy-go-lucky shit like Isekai Cheat Magician or Isekai Smartphone but frankly it feels nauseating. Overly Cautious Hero, Re;Zero* or Goblin Slayer balanced levity and grimness which is why I can enjoy it, but other stuff makes me feel dirtied. Dungeon Seeker managed to not feel contrived either. I think I might be a bit annoyed also by the artstyle itself - it's generic moeshit with 0 sakuga and the colorful, flat color pallet makes it clash horribly with the ideas. Like Berserk had good animation that fit its dark fantasy setting, and had detail and complex shading.

*I'm not saying RE:Zero is good, it's not, but it has some good moments that I appreciated and it knew not to overdo the "It's time to suffer and die Subaru-kun!" concept to the point of insensitivity.


File: 1628138985671.png (1.82 MB, 1280x720, ClipboardImage.png)

So the idea of Overly Cautious hero is that there are pantheons of gods and stuff that support selected Isekai heroes to free worlds ranked D, C, B, A, S , SS and SSS.

This gave me an idea for a sort of reverse Isekai where Earth is a SSS-class world because there is no one Devil King and his armies to take down and instead the various magic heroes end up killed because they can't solve societies problems (so figures like Jesus Christ or Che Guevara or Hercules are examples of such failed Isekai heroes, who nonetheless had impacts on the world.


I think this "overly edgy isekai" thing is just a fad that won't last long.


File: 1628149204590.png (339.73 KB, 500x532, ClipboardImage.png)

It's been going on since at least 2015 (that's omitting earlier edgy works). I mean I recently watched Arifureta and it wasn't outright awful (though it derailed quite a bit) but regardless, overall this 'fad' is getting annoying because they don't go for a dark storyline but an edgy one, otherwise you can't fit in the Moeshit, and generic harem gags and other shit aspects into it. At least Shield Hero tried to be somewhat consistent in its story telling.

BTW another shitty manga that is outright porky-shit is Meikyuu Black Company, a play on the Japanese term;


File: 1630126055791.jpg (154.87 KB, 1170x1179, edgy dick meaasure.jpg)

Ex-Arm: A "3D anime" that hired animators that have never worked on a anime project before, with the director having only experience with live-action and chosen a studio that only did work for Sekiro.

Promised Neverland season 2: The second season of a beloved anime that completely destroyed eveything the previous season made, skipping a ton of arcs and cut characters that are important to the plot for no goddamn reason and replaced with a slideshow in the final episode.

ReHealer: An anime that has no reason to exist. Is just a poorly written edgy hentai fanfic that got alot of attention from twitter due to its controversial amount of rape because the main protagonist is a cuckoo maniac that enjoys the suffering of his victims. A poorly written edgy pornographic fanfic that some 14 year old that just stumbled upon dark tagged hentai and awoken their twisted fetishes decided to write a doujin themselves. Seriously, did anyone actually like this shit unironically? I feel like the score for this would have been way lower if stupid twitter people didn't complain about it for all the wrong reasons, because I feel people are talking positively of it just to spite these people.


It’s Chinese animation, but Link Click is interesting. Time traveling agency where they can access the memories of a person in the past and control their bodies. They must follow a rigid schedule according to their timeline’s memories, but also make sure to fulfill their client’s requests. This leaves the character controlling the body and the one witnessing memories subject to sexual assault and other harsh decisions in order for the sake of the timeline, but also past memories, such as of childhood and parent relationships. Haven’t finished it yet, but it’s an interesting concept


This is a pretty good idea.


File: 1630389231050.png (937.48 KB, 800x448, ClipboardImage.png)

Top ten Western non-anime Isekai movies https://archive.ph/mSpcx


>How would you go about fixing the Isekai genre
Make it more like an Abridged series (see SAO Abridged or Akame ga Kill Abridged as examples) and just let the anime go full throttle. They insert humor and remove excess bullshit that wastes time with prolonged scenes that have nothing of worth happening.


File: 1630598373763-0.jpg (225.39 KB, 1921x1078, ErZwQG_UYAA86Cc.jpg)

File: 1630598373763-1.png (1.21 MB, 1200x675, ClipboardImage.png)

Recently I watched Mushoku Tensei i.e. Jobless Reincarnation.
The writing is decent, the animation is pretty damn good for small isekai show. It doesn't get very far in the LN story, but it's been getting there. That said, I actually feel rather uncomfortable and even disgusted by some of the show's edgy or perverse content. Even more importantly, the character's behavior while quite realistic for a 30+ Otaku, can drag the show down. In terms of perverted characters, Rudy behaves like BNHA's Mineta as opposed to someone like Jiraiya or Issei Hyoudou, whose perversions are offset by their other character traits. Rudy does grow and change as a character but it takes a while to get there, and this can be depicted without being as vulgar as the show sometimes gets, I can understand by Bilibili stopped releasing it in China. The Father impregnating the maid and having that drama was a pretty daring move though, and honestly, excluding some of the sleaziness, this was an interesting story over-all. If you're able to bear a little fucked up shit, this is worth a watch.

The teleportation accident requiring escorting Eris home also reminds me a bit of Fairy Tail's Universe One spell.


Adapting an anime of the Rance Series might be a good idea, it's like Konosuba but less comedic, but lacking the edgelord attitude of something like Redo of Healer.


File: 1631809530502.jpg (63.4 KB, 540x861, Positive endings.jpg)

Make an Isekai story that's actually just a big game of pretend a la pic related. Just a big adventure in a story, playing on children's creativity and self-insertion.

For example Warhammer 40k is what happened when a bunch of kids got some green army soldiers, painted them and added stickers, and came up with their own backstories for each of their armies as they fought. Kids being kids this became a game of imagination one-upmanship, each saying their side has ever escalating weapons or powers, each making theirs out to be the meanest, bloodiest, most terrible side and before you know it these pre-teens have invented most of the nonsense lore and grimdarkness. Seriously this is literally the original Warhammer boardgame.

Someone has a Star Wars a parody like this: https://darthsanddroids.net/

original link for image: https://mckitterick.tumblr.com/post/176230226160

Unique IPs: 5

[Return][Go to top] [Catalog] | [Home][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / siberia / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime / music ] [ meta / roulette ] [ GET / ref / booru]