[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / siberia / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta / roulette ] [ cytube / git ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru / zine ]

/meta/ - Ruthless criticism of all that exists (in leftypol.org)

Discussions, querries, feedback and complaints about the site and its administration.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

Join our Matrix Chat <=> IRC: #leftypol on Rizon

| Catalog | Home
|

File: 1628978254651.jpeg (155.21 KB, 1296x730, dredd01-h_2020.jpeg)

 No.10034[Reply]

The Just Republic: In defense of the modocracy

TLDR: Plato’s republic is the ideal form of governance for an imageboard

>“For surely, Thrasymachus, it's injustice that produces factions, hatreds, and quarrels among themselves, and justice that produces unanimity and friendship. Isn't it so?… if it's the work of injustice, wherever it is, to implant hatred, then, when injustice comes into being, both among free men and slaves, will it not also cause them to hate one another and to form factions, and to be be unable to accomplish anything in common with one another?… Then does it come to light as possessing a power such that, wherever it comes into being, be it in a city, a clan, an army, or whatever else, it first of all makes that thing unable to accomplish anything together with itself due to faction and difference, and then it a makes that thing an enemy both to itself and to everything opposite and to the just? Isn't it so?… And then when it is in one man, I suppose it will do the same thing which it naturally accomplishes. First it will make him unable to act, because he is at faction and is not of one mind with himself, and, second, an enemy both to himself and to just men” - Plato, The Republic


As said previously in my note on recent events, the frequency of splits, the schizo-paranoia, it’s clear that there is something incredibly broken about how leftypol recruits staff and moderators, and this has almost lead to the death of leftypol several times. Many people here, including certain former moderators, have expressed the desire to have more “user input”, for user congresses. This is all utterly misguided. It’s fine to have a channel for user feedback, and to take suggestions, but the idea of LARPing a direct democracy, without accountability, in an anonymous or pseudo-anonymous medium just can’t work. The capitalist structure of ownership, of private property with regards to web domains and servers, really prevents this from being anything more than a democracy in name only. As we have seen, the only people with real power are those that control these resources, and everything else is really just play-acting. At worst, it just introduces an ability for loud retards to override the silent majority or right wing crossposters to manufacture consensus.

Instead of LARPing as an Athenian direct democracy, the moderators should model their form of governPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
50 posts and 13 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10840

>>10721
There was far less stasi and volkspolezei in the DDR than intelligence agents and cops in west germany, which was essentially a police state. The Cold war Germany situation demanded heavy police presence and surveilance. The communist east got by on far less than the west.

 No.10854


 No.10897

>>10854
The intrusive questions on the paperwork of liberal states are not equivalent to engaging in psychological warfare on the civilian population

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zersetzung

 No.10898

File: 1630288675162.png (249.62 KB, 500x360, cc4.png)

I think we can safely say its over. .org won

victory!

 No.10986

>>10898
You're every bit as terrible as space_ if not worse. Enjoy your dying community and the pile of dirt you have inherited. You are all, literally, no better than Jacobin. No one won here accept your massively inflated egos.



File: 1630231782252.jpg (19.06 KB, 500x375, 1601806572395.jpg)

 No.10855[Reply]

Is it true that you are raiding 4chan and shilling proprietary garbage on /g/?
15 posts and 9 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10871

File: 1630233605266.png (548.95 KB, 614x412, 13ending_tyranny.png)

>>10869
You can check out >>>/tech/ maybe you like it.

 No.10872

File: 1630234041669.jpg (540.73 KB, 810x1200, 1618422181739.jpg)

>>10871
Could check it out

 No.10873

Did you fall for that really obvious /pol/ false flag listing all the boards and shit takes next to each? Protip: if you can't see replies, it's a /pol/troon screencapping themselves.
The simple fact that our board mascot is in SuperTuxKart and that our board software IS FOSS without any third party connections should tell you all you need to know. Just look at our /tech/ board.
Leftypol don't raid and we don't give a fuck about influencing 4chan. Not only is it a worthless endeavor, but we don't have the numbers. Internet drama beyond funny shitposts is fucking stupid.

 No.10878

No
Actually we're the ones that have been shilling gentoo for almost a decade on /g/

 No.10881

The only OS I shill is TempleOS



File: 1629675446791.jpg (23.93 KB, 400x290, i will protect it.jpg)

 No.10538[Reply]

Hello everyone. Welcome back to the second week of the proposal system. To see last week's successful proposals, please go to the voting topic for this week. We have these proposals which failed last week, that perhaps we should discuss again this week:

>>10296 Proposal: Create actual policies on subjectively moderated topics
>>10297 Proposal: Standardize ban lengths for various rule violations"

Once again, I must clarify that ONLY MODS CAN ACTUALLY VOTE ON PROPOSALS OR VOTES. Anons are free to have their say and offer suggestions and feedback to improve proposals/votes but these are only advisory and user votes are not counted for official decisionmaking. But who knows, a persuasive enough argument might sway the mod team to your cause?

Please reply to this post to post proposals for consideration next week. If a user proposal seems like a good idea, we may adopt it and make it official. Thanks everyone. Feel free to post your opinions but try not to spam or needlessly bicker back and forth in order to keep the thread clear and legible. Any off-topic posts may be removed without warning.
25 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10788

>>10732
Approve.

 No.10790

>>10787 (me)
maybe not the Image hover on catalog

 No.10799

>>10732
Agreed except for image hover on catalog also, that seems a little much..

 No.10823

I can't log in rn so I will confirm in the staff room that this post is me
>>10732
Agree with enabling the 2 except for the catalog hover
>>10692
Vote yes with negotiation on definitions as others have mentioned
>>10560
Abstain but I think this could be worth considering again in the future with specific circumstances
>>10663
Vote against. I think a public list would negate the utility against for instance "guests" spamming the filtered words and ruin the fun a bit
>>10551
Vote yes
>>10553
Vote yes however I'm not sure what exactly kind of thread you are describing

I can't see the soyjak spam rule here but please give me a vote no against it

 No.10852

>>10538
Proposals for next week:

Proposal: Filter National socialist to Not socialist

PASSED (4 votes)



Proposal: Create an OC thread analog for /b/ where not strictly leftist shitposts and images can be kept

PASSED (3 votes)



Post too long. Click here to view the full text.



 No.10532[Reply]

These are the votes for this week. Please vote on the posts below, not this OP itself. Once again, please not that anons cannot actually vote, and their opinions are simply advisory. Thank you to all users and mods for their participation.

In addition, please keep this topic on-topic. All extraneous posts may be removed without warning. With that, here are this week's votes;

>>10088 Proposal: On the creation of /roulette/ - /lounge/.
>>10089 Proposal: Remove certain types of soyspam.
>>10094 Proposal: Rename /b/ to /siberia/ to remove the 'expectations' that it needs to be exactly like 4chan /b/ and to fit more consistently with the rest of the board names.
>>10104 Proposal: Bring back vaush -> agent kochinski wordfilter
26 posts and 8 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10726

pls ban loli and /zoo/ porn

 No.10727


 No.10845

>>10533
vote yes
>>10534
vote against
>>10535
vote for
>>10536
vote for

 No.10846

>>10845
messed up mod tag

 No.10851

>>10532
Vote: On the creation of /lounge/. This board is intended as a comfy off-topic space which is more moderated than /b/ (or /siberia/) to create a social atmosphere. Porn will also be disallowed on this board in order to create a more 'social' atmosphere. This board should also be a focal point for community events and so on.

The board will be run through the /roulette/ system to test its viability, with the performance judged by mods after one month.

For: Caballo, Wvobbly, Redlidmilk, M00dy, Barbara_Pit
Against: Krates, Pask

PASSED AND WILL BE IMPLEMENTED ON 1ST SEPTEMBER



Vote: Ban 'soyspam'. (ie. soyjak posts that do nothing but post a derivative soyjak and include no original text). This is not intended to remove posts which rephrase another post in a derisive or mocking manner (with a soyjak or not) as these are a time honoured form of criticism. Exceptions may be made at moderator's discretion for 'unique' or custom-made soyjaks.

This rule will also target soy OPs which have little or no 'useful' material, even on /b/.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.



File: 1629957823915.jpg (15.33 KB, 400x400, question-mark.jpg)

 No.10735[Reply]

Why is this site suddenly insanely glitchy and broken since the split?

 No.10736

We can't help you if you give no examples. Works for me™.

 No.10827

ok watermelon

 No.10830

File: 1630102412970-0.png (7.69 KB, 303x120, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1630102412970-1.png (9.71 KB, 420x168, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1630102412970-2.png (86.47 KB, 707x407, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1630102412970-3.png (7.72 KB, 299x120, ClipboardImage.png)

>>10736
>>10736

yesterday the header theme didn't match the page but the text did so the page was white text black background while the header was white text white background two days ago I was getting a capcha error when I tried to post on any board

 No.10832

>>10827
pls dont shitpost on /meta/

>>10830
The captcha was turned on for a few hours that day due to automated bot flooding from a /pol/tard, and it was a slow glitchy start as it needed to change some minor back-end details to setup on this site. There was one person claiming it didn't work on their mobile either so that's something we might need to look into.
The "socialismSocialism" was a problem with importing flags on pre-split posts due to a rushed crawler script, so it doesn't apply to new posts. Probably won't be fixed due to priorities.
I don't know what's up with the white background and can't think of any change then that could have caused it. Did you have a reading mode on or something? That's the closest thing I can think of.



 No.10815[Reply]

Thanks mods for saving the board again
2 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10818

feels like home

 No.10819

Put me in the screencap

 No.10820

File: 1630035951577.png (286.01 KB, 3400x2300, sigma reddit.png)

I am humbled. Thank you for reporting and helping keep reddit clean

 No.10821

File: 1630036083622.gif (199.98 KB, 403x649, 1628413418746.gif)

>>10820
Seethe 4faggot, your precious free speech is what's allowing spammers and newfags to nuke your boards which is why all of your communities are dying

 No.10822

File: 1630036444957.jpg (5.61 KB, 301x167, doge.jpg)

>>10821
I was just being cheeky sorry haha. Thank you actually for reporting, it helps.



File: 1629964886634.jpg (25.69 KB, 600x582, 1625288111028.jpg)

 No.10737[Reply]

What's up with all the DDoS fuckery going on? A lot of people can't access the site, why is this?

 No.10786

>>10737
We were being raided by pol. I was going to turn it off but I got busy. Give me a min.

 No.10797

>>10786
Ah I see

 No.10804

>>10786
Was /pol/ raiding and also trying DDoS the site? Because there were two things happening at once.



File: 1629985621626.png (154.46 KB, 730x402, ClipboardImage.png)

 No.10791[Reply]

layout on posts with media is frequently fucked up. embeds are worse.

 No.10802

>>10791
I literally cannot reproduce this issue so I can't fix it unless you help.
Which device (mobile or desktop, is it wide or narrow)?
Link to a post that does this.



File: 1628892937783.png (615.16 KB, 736x527, ClipboardImage.png)

 No.9886[Reply]

This coup was supposed to have improved the state of affairs, but it might just have accelerated the decline of the website. The jannies on all sides seem to be quite disconnected from the masses which have composed the life essence of these boards. It is long past time, therefore, that a tribunal representing the popular thrust be established to directly parley with the cliques of moderators, because there are many problems which urgently require resolving and the petty factionalist struggles of the administration have caused those issues to be forgotten. And what better individual to be the Tribune of the Posters than Shay, who not only has been a fixture around here through the multiple tribulations of migration, retreat, and reconstruction of this place but also represents decently the unity of the ideals which /leftypol/ is supposed to uphold. Steeped in the culture of both effortposts and shitposts, she is rooted in the material reality of the average posters. Shay is proletarian in class background, someone opposed to imperialism and Angloid Boxism, and also one who is not so spooked about the usual progressive canards. The current crop of moderation, be they the junta, the soyjak avatarfag narcissist axis, or the furries, can argue in /meta/ to the end of time, but most of the resident anons dedicated to the improvement of /leftypol/ know a true government of action is of utmost importance at this moment of upheaval.

Make SHAY TAN the SUPREME LEADER of /leftypol/.

Overthrow moderators' bourgeois vestiges.
4 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.9996

>>9890
Flog yourself

 No.10204

oppose, I find Shay to be too unstable for this, no offense

 No.10206

So you want to install a degenerate debauchee transhumanist that posted nudes here before?

 No.10208

>>9910
Only some of them. After a certain period. They can be brought back, but IMO it's not worth the effort.

 No.10734

>>10204
>>10206
If anything my biggest problem is a lack of technical experience in moderation, but as for nudes if anybody posted them saying "transhumanist board owner" it would only make people horny rather than make them feel disgusted



File: 1629829888209.png (1.75 MB, 1000x618, 1609464403227-2.png)

 No.10675[Reply]

I missed out on the newest split. Can someone TL;DR me on what happened
2 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

 No.10681

>>10675
I think there is a thread on /meta/ about this but the gist of it is that some mods tried to coup the admins, they succeeded for a couple of days but then the old admins yanked control back and the site split between two domains.

 No.10682

>>>/leftypol/29 has at least 5 TL;DR summaries.

>>10679
Both claim to be the real one.
There was a proposal by a mod for us to change default theme (DemainDark or LainchanJP) but it barely went anywhere.

 No.10684

>>10682
god that is so dramatic of leftists, in the usa there were two separate parties called FRSO for years and years because they both refused to rebrand after their split. so annoying

 No.10713

[extreme shilling]

 No.10730

>>10675
theres already a thread about this in >>7



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / siberia / hobby / tech / edu / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta / roulette ] [ cytube / git ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru / zine ]
[ 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 7 / 8 / 9 / 10 / 11 / 12 / 13 / 14 / 15 / 16 / 17 / 18 / 19 / 20 / 21 / 22 / 23 / 24 / 25 / 26 / 27 / 28 / 29 / 30 / 31 / 32 / 33 / 34 / 35 / 36 ]
| Catalog | Home