[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)
What is 6 - 2?

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!

| Catalog | Home
|

File: 1776020498465.png (1.19 MB, 1515x1075, image.png)

 

If there exists class conflict between proletarians and bourgeoisie and historically proletarians have established their supremacy in certain countries and certain time periods like the dictatorship of the proletariat under Stalin in USSR for example was there ever a place where Lumpenproletariat has won the class struggle and established themselves as the ruling class?
Would it even be possible for Lumpenproletariat to seize the power and make their class interest the dominant one? How would such system look like and function?
Is there any political party at this moment advocating for the interest of lumpenproletariat?

Who even constitutes XXI century Lumpenproletariat?
8 posts omitted.

Lumpen cops

>Lumpenproletariat has won the class struggle and established themselves as the ruling class
"What a country!" - retarded illiterate pedo Jeffrey Epstein on class mobility
>>2780043
>Lumpen cops
"ICE is a counter-revolution of satanic guys who can't do productive labor against devout Catholics who actually produce real material value in their communities"

>>2780056
Nah, lumpens are lame. They're like failed actors who become conspiracy theorists. Proles are good.

File: 1776103085962.jpg (35.05 KB, 314x502, Michail-Bakunin-1872.jpg)

>>2779227
The great Lumpenproletariat are being organised in fascist anarchist squats in order to march against any worker's state available.

>>2779258
The lumpenproletariat is just a scapegoat for the labor aristocracy. Fucking Social Demokkkrats scapegoat queer people and the poor instead of their own labor aristocracy.



File: 1775869740608.png (133.02 KB, 1683x288, ClipboardImage.png)

 

Is the key flaw of Marxism that all of its predictions are bullshit? Why do communists feel like facts have to conform to their feelings when Marx never said that? Marx was never a moralfag and based his ideas in the fact he believed the collapse of Capitalism was inevitable. 200 years on, and it has not collapsed or led to any sort of successful socialist revolution.

You can identify the exact point at which Marxists start coping and treating their belief system as a religion. From the Preface of The Poverty of Philosophy on Marxists.org:

>The above application of the Ricardian theory that the entire social product belongs to the workers as their product, because they are the sole real producers, leads directly to communism. But, as Marx indeed indicates in the above-quoted passage, it is incorrect in formal economic terms, for it is simply an application of morality to economics. According to the laws of bourgeois economics, the greatest part of the product does not belong to the workers who have produced it. If we now say: that is unjust, that ought not to be so, then that has nothing immediately to do with economics. We are merely saying that this economic fact is in contradiction to our sense of morality. Marx, therefore, never based his communist demands upon this, but upon the inevitable collapse of the capitalist mode of production which is daily taking place before our eyes to an ever growing degree; he says only that surplus value consists of unpaid labour, which is a simple fact. But what in economic terms may be formally incorrect, may all the same be correct from the point of view of world history. If mass moral consciousness declares an economic fact to be unjust, as it did at one time in the case of slavery and statute labour, that is proof that the fact itself has outlived its day, that other economic facts have made their appearance due to which the former has become unbearable and untenable. Therefore, a very true economic content may be concealed behind the formal economic incorrectness. This is not the place to deal more closely with the significance and history of the theory of surplus value.


Marx never would have said this lol, this is plain magical thinking
45 posts and 8 image replies omitted.

>>2780259
>If the masses declare wage-labor to be done for
they will get beaten by their ruling class until they stop having wrong thoughts

>>2780153
The inexistance of a socialist world economy makes it impossible to do it in one country. How do you plan on keeping yourself afloat without a state capitalist economy? You must extract surplus value from your workers even if only from the purpose of international trade. To some degree all state controlled enterprises have a profit motive
>>2780224
Capitalism was always everything. Whatever mode of production you happen to be a participant of determines nearly everything about your life.

>>2779214
Most leftcom critiques aren't that great, but the better ones come from councilcoms who advance labor time calculation as the lower stage of socialism. The problem with the USSR is that workers had no right of disposal to their product, and were thus still alienated from their labor and society. Likewise the wage relation, commodity production, etc. still existed, even if their forms were distorted by the presence of central planning. You can't advance to communism from here, that's the central problem, you'd have to have a second economic revolution to truly abolish these forms and replace them with labor time calculation or something more advanced. The only thing a Soviet-style system can do is degenerate back into capitalism, which is exactly what happened, facilitated by the intense alienation of Soviet society and the general falsification of Marxism in the east.
>>2779610
Way to completely miss the point. Leninism is the economics of Social Democracy taken to the extreme: a paternalistic party-state which provides for the people, ensures fair distribution of wages and commodities while bullshitting enough theory to make people think it's "socialism".

>>2780149
>also how does one country develop socialism in one country alone?
By eliminating their bourgeoisie in the main and beginning the process of socialist construction through the rational planning of the economy

>>2780264
>And you can always jump to any other mode of production.
This is anti-thetical to Marxist historical materialism. Why would a prior MoP be reverted to unless a catastrophic loss in productive means occurs? Means of Production are, alongside the expropriation of surplus, the defining characteristic of Modes of Production. Yes it's true that once a more advanced MoP emerges other societies at a much lower level of development can skip the intermediary stages due to transfer of technology and state formation, but this chart acts as if for example the reversion from a Socialist Economy to a Capitalist economy was a reversion to a historical MoP which isn't true, the existence of a "Socialist Economy" itself indicates that the Capitalist MoP still has elements in society that never went away. This chart then replaces "Feudal MoP" is "peasant economy", I guess so it can sandwich together 11th century Europe and ancient Sumer together as having the same MoP? You know that MoPs are characterized in part by the Means of Production right?



File: 1776060925726.png (363.2 KB, 392x600, download.png)

 

>grows massive fanbase of QANON believing Evangelical Christians
>said fanbase sees Trump as the fighter against shadowy pedophiles
>Trump on the 2024 campaign trail said he would declassify the Epstein list
>once in office he calls the Epstein files a democrat hoax
>uploads ai image of himself bringing life back to someone that looks like Jeffrey Epstein while looking like Jesus Christ

File: 1776061427139-0.png (14.34 KB, 788x135, ClipboardImage.png)

File: 1776061427139-1.png (21.93 KB, 795x165, ClipboardImage.png)

>don't fight back against your masters you slaves… just sit tight and you'll get rewarded after you die

>and your masters? they're gonna burn in sulfur… trust me dude. so no need to fight back


greatest psy op of all time



File: 1775671342503.png (1.09 MB, 1280x1280, IMG_5341.png)

 

So according to Vivek Chibber what communists need to do is the following:

-Middle class intellectuals must create a party of dedicated cadres who will then approach the workers by committing class suicide.
-Some of these workers will be recruited as ideologically committed cadres who will then unionize their workplace, creating unions separated from the core organization
-There must be discipline and accountability
-Once there, we will somehow figure out how to solve the questions on how to organize workers in the face of globalization, capital flight, and so on
  • Must engage in social reforms to gain ground and then weaken the enemy using their own tools

This isn’t very different from what Felix says, the only difference being Felix wants to use violence instead of organizing workers.

There’s no excuse at this point. Chibber has offered a viable strategy, the only problem is finding cadres willing to commit class suicide
8 posts omitted.

>>2774547
Watch this video, especially towards the end he explains what he believe a communist party should do:

https://youtu.be/PvFmBW7PY7k?si=npzAvVCsPIXg7Ad-

I'd argue against trying to take your Tips for a Revolution from a Jacobin writer on principle, but that would be as unfair as it is valid.

I don't criticize intellectuals for doing what they do, because it is important. But the alarm bells always go off when the argument is "intellectuals should do this, but not me of course, because I'm the person writing about it, my job is to tell you how to do it."

I'm not saying he personally would have to do it to prove it's validity. I'm saying the reasons middle class intellectuals don't act on Chibber's strategy are generally the reasons he doesn't; "intellectuals" interested in The Revolution are smart enough to come up all of the ideologically valid reasons that they need to choose not to make their own lives worse in favor of that ideology. At least he's honest in his terminology. Very few people commit suicide, and it usually accomplishes nothing significant.

I met a Chibber fangirl at a local study group. She hates radlibs and is a qt. I need to figure out an excuse to see her again because she was only at the last meeting.

>>2773890
Yeah, they tried this in the 60s and 70s. It didn’t really work out but I guess they learned some things through empirical observation?

>>2778977
In that video I posted he recognizes that people from his class (middle class intellectuals) must be willing to compromise. I don't know if he plans on doing it himself though



File: 1771647553922.jpg (33.43 KB, 640x331, castro.jpg)

 

Cuba is currently facing one of its worst energy crisies in its history, entirely caused by the US goverment further tighting sanctions on Cuba, and with the recent overthow of the Venezuelan goverment now Cuba has lost its most valuable trade partner.
There is a deficit over 2,000 MW, so its supply isn't even coming close to its demand.

Local transportation, services, and obviously healthcare is being restricted. And considering Cuba does more for the global south in heathcare then literally any western country, it tells you how much this really effects the world, not just the nation itself. As of writting this thread Russia is sending a humanitarian ship to Cuba, do we think the US is gonna stop the ship?

So i must ask, what can we do indiviually to help Cuba?
63 posts and 37 image replies omitted.

>>2760915
>is what they are likely telling themselves
Yep. They never allow for the law of unintended consequences so they have to keep making rash judgements on the fly.

File: 1774908604692-0.jpeg (73.67 KB, 1080x718, HEfeev_WQAAogiV.jpeg)

File: 1774908604692-1.jpeg (89.64 KB, 1080x837, HEfeewdbgAAxvan.jpeg)

File: 1774908604692-2.jpeg (51.29 KB, 1080x718, HEfeev-XgAAax1y.jpeg)

more ejercito cubano

>>2760358
crazy how darth putler the right wing dick tator was the only one to step up on this meanwhile all the latam "leftist" goverments cucked out

Monke sent another tanker

>Lifeline lives

>>2777462
shut up man.

Trump says hes gonna invade cuba next after Iran, lets see if that happens.



File: 1775862128137.png (1.19 MB, 1109x1330, ClipboardImage.png)

 

>Previous Bake
>>2774149

<Report the false thread made by the jakspamming zionist…. edition


Latest News
>Hezbollah announces resuming of war
<Iran closed the straight of KHÄMAS again but nothing else so far
>Israel attacked Lebanon killing thousands
<World doesn't really care about vitcims of Pissrael and wants to help US when it can
>Oil prices are still high

Trump Timeline:
Mar 3: "We won the war."
Mar 7: "We defeated Iran."
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
606 posts and 179 image replies omitted.

>>2778517
>>2778508
"left" "com" cuck has been real quiet since these dropped

>>2779488
>Third World Mafia

>>2779515
Thanks for the bake, i was too slow.

>>2779473
This should also be pissing SA, Iraq, Kuweit, Qatar and UAE or can those ships pass?

>>2779502
Trump would have to nationalize the oil industry, put forth a export ban and do massive investments in renewables and refineries. To keep gas at $4, and he should have done that two years ago. This is like with the tariffs, he destroyed the chips act which was industrial policy to spur domestic chip .manufacturing and trump ripped that shit up and slap tariffs on everyone. All while the entire economy was shifting towards A.I bullshit and data centers.

>>2779534
Passing at all means they paid the toll, which means… oops.



File: 1775658713732.webp (550.43 KB, 3072x2305, russia-map-2022_4x3.webp)

 

>state withers away just like marx predicted
>get yeltsin and putin
MLs: WAIT NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO NOT LIKE THAT NOT LIKE THAT THAT DOESN'T COUNT
3 posts omitted.

>state is illegally dissolved by a revisionist coup that goes against all public sentiment
<withering away
pick 1 lol

>>2773590
The cia literally coupled it also the ussr didnt start collapsing until they brought perestroika(though it could go all the way back to the mistakes of Brezhnev and revisionism of Kruchev)

This is why Russia is Communist today btw. ZOV ZOV ZOV

>>2774180
No it isn’t it’s a liberal “democracy”

>>2773627
they organised the coup to wither away the state moron



File: 1775770536670.png (206.47 KB, 600x399, ClipboardImage.png)

 

The relation between religious retards and their disillusionment with the world coming to bring their baggage while demanding change from the real movement that has already done its hundreds of years' worth of material analysis to explain the phenomena occurring by atheist anti-theist might, to come and label onself as "christian, muslim, jewish, pagan socialist-esque" or even worse an "anarchist" clinging to the niche of creative writings, seeking legitimacy and to be legitimized of ones' metaphysical supersititous retardation gives no room for development of the real movement, it stagnates it as a retrograde aesthetic tending towards reactionary stillness in life - a status quo of demanding to preserve feudal and pre-feudal mythos when the movement is trying to bring workers to view reality for what it really is, all conceptions of GOD, GODS, SPIRITS, DEITIES and such being man-made as words and remaining solely as conceptions with addendum of personal experiences always unexplained as "feelings" - trying to mitigate research and development by situations presented in such a way that they inherently deny rationale.

It is the status quo of the majority of the world population being turned retarded-submissive by abstract religiosity and contempt with its decay. To synthesize decay and growth or present decay as growth in an attempt to paint oneself a "socialist" or "progressive force" is to lie for closure.
As Il Duche himself wrote before opportunistically clinging to the catholic church in Italy for politician gains - God Does Not Exist, so we affirm his essay. Luddic left liberalism and leftism as the bourgeois liberalism it will always be - is always reactionary and the road of religiosity and negation. Reactionism will always be against the notion of revolutions, a reactionary revolution or a conservative revolution can be nothing less than Adolf Hitler's rise.
Call for the liquidation of religiosity and not its synthesis and integration within the movement against the present state of things, it is a part of the present state that has plagued civilization since all previous modes of production and continuing in liberal "secular" capitalism. Deny entryists. A "religious socialist" is either a confused socialist in need of psychiatric help or a religious reactionary posing as socialist.

A religious "socialist" is only a re-branding in name of the same feudal bullshit that has stagnated and appropriated human development foPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
57 posts and 11 image replies omitted.

File: 1775842755479.mp4 (9.48 MB, 540x540, AB.mp4)

>>2776411
Bordiga.party soon

>>2776464
0% Muslims
0% Christians
0% Religious Jews
0% Pagans
0% Religgers
100% The Invariant line of the real movement

>>2776468
The greatest invariant line is the one that divides Bordiga's ass into two

>>2776304
Communes are Hitlerite and the family must be abolished. Communes do not abolish the state but return to the state in its most primordial and despotic form. GTFO with your communal slave plantation.

>>2775548
Does it really matter? Ideology is a meme in the original sense of the word. it evolves, mutates and takes on different characteristics. So it is synthesis



File: 1775560443677.jpeg (87.64 KB, 600x399, IMG_0418.jpeg)

 

Why is it so hard for Marxist-Leninists to admit that the bureaucracy of their regimes end up constituting a class with their own interests different from ordinary workers?
93 posts and 9 image replies omitted.

"Democracy" as it actually exists IRL as well as what most people desire it to be, will be abolished after the communist revolution.

>>2775679
Which is precisely why MLs can't be trusted

This was more of a problem in the past but in terms of the actual planning of the economy we can simply use verifiable mathematical models and trustless data collection mechanisms. This is the natural evolution of the means of communication. Cybernetic communism solves a huge portion of the bureaucratic problems faced in past regimes.

>>2771833
I unironically want to be a line cook after the revolution
I want to serve people food

>>2770983
They did nothing wrong, it was idiots like Gierek who bankrupted countries that had 0 national debt prior to their loan maxxing that brought on the troublesome 80s



File: 1773522496647.jpg (322.54 KB, 1080x1143, 3322111111.jpg)

 

Communist Cuba is about to be overthrown.
59 posts and 2 image replies omitted.

>Morón
thats pretty much saying trump will be overthrown bucause the republican party office in Ogallala, Nebraska was attacked

>>2738393
Yeah? Its an interimperialist conflict anyway. Le workers have no country and shit. Total cuba death

Up

Why weren't they mopped up after the USSR fell?

2 more weeks



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]
[ 1 /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /17 /18 /19 /20 /21 /22 /23 /24 /25 /26 /27 /28 /29 /30 /31 /32 /33 /34 /35 /36 ]
| Catalog | Home