Before you call me a pseud for not knowing this, I'm a marxist primarily because I saw communism as the extension of Rousseau's social-contract and more broadly as an extension of republicanism unto the economic sphere when I started getting interested in political philosophy. I decided to read the Capital and agreed with Marx on his critique.
That said, I don't really see how Marx is a philosopher in any meaningful way. I've read some marxist "philosophers" and Hegel and I don't understand shit. Hence, my questions are essentially :
>wtf does Marx mean by "dialectic" and how is it a method you can analyze things by ?
I've read an intro to Hegel book and it presented the dialectic as Humanity's self-consciousness (Spirit) development towards its collective self-recognition in a rational order, not something you could abstract and apply to any object (unlike the syllogism for instance).
>as an extension of the prior question, what is dialectical materialism ?
>how does Marx's concept of alienation makes sense with the Capital economic analysis
>How is the frankfurt school marxist ?
5 posts and 1 image reply omitted.I'm not some super duper Hegelian, I've just read some Lecture on history of philosophy by Hegel.
Things: you, apple, etc - called finite. It is that they have a bound. If you say "I", there need be something not you. Contrary to infinite things, unbounded.
You can use old Skeptics to show that any finite thing is contradictionary, there is a number of methods they developed. You can show red is not red, etc. Idk, may be they will ask you: ok, we change light frequency slightly, is it still red?
Then you can stop thinking.. conclude, nothing is true. But you can also make Skeptics a step in your logic. If red = !red => do_something..
An infinite thing, called "shitty" infinity can be also false. 1, 2 ,3 … inf, going from A to B, from B to A, etc forever. When you say: I will call this red today, the next time I call it differently.. that is "shitty" inf. You just do this infinite loop, that is it.
But an infinity such that something returns back with new knowledge, is not just going back to the same place. You can't contradict this by using Skeptics, it is true infinite. It will be movement of idea of color, etc. do_something, I do not recall, but it is called speculative step? You get something positive with it, new content.
Something like this.
>>2952833Am I the only one who didn't understand anything from this wall of text and sees it as simply pseudo-intellectual?
>>2952885outside of the weird frankfurt school point it's correct but explained in possibly the worst way i've ever read
>>2952850I do not know if I need to say this, but that is what I think is dialectics. 1. skepticism 2. speculative thought, positive. In science, not always, but first you get data to contradict the model. Then you speculate new model. But here to "think it dialectically", you need to assume, before you get new data, that the model is contradictionary?! I Hope I'm not making it more confusing..