>>2298789What point exactly are you trying to make with this article? Is it that the material benefits of imperialism for white workers in the US magically don't exist because the US specifically doesn't have
as formalized a welfare state? Their disproportionately higher wages (disproportionate to the value created by their labor) and cheap commodities (enabled by the paying nothing to the people who actually created the value overseas) just don't exist? Even if such a thing were true (it isn't) what about the other settler-states which do have universal healthcare?
That these workers don't live in a utopia doesn't change their overall relationship to the rest of the world, in the same way that a celebrity or business owner "having it hard too" doesn't change their overall relationship to production.All of these states contain a strata of
temporarily embarrassed settlers who fall through the cracks, but even then their primary struggle is the possibility of having to work an inglorious industrial or service position (that still has disproportionately high wages) until they get back on their feet. This is simply not the same struggle as the vast majority of workers worldwide, who struggle for basic daily survival in sweatshops, mines, and forges they don't even know if they'll be allowed to leave when their shift is done. The workers of the world face death and dismemberment every day and fear that death will come for them, the settler-worker in the US faces rude boss taking
some of their benefits and fear becoming a worker like in the rest of the world. The settler is still a worker in the strictest sense, but their relationship to capital is warped by social relations and material conditions on the ground.
I also shouldn't have to point out the major issue in self-reporting "living paycheck to paycheck", namely that the bougiest motherfuckers you've ever met will look you in the eyes and claim that.
Fucking Mr. Beast claims he lives paycheck to paycheck! Surveys can provide very useful data but in cases like this they prove fuck all. In particular a self-reported survey doesn't allow you to flatten the class struggle in the US or anywhere into a little idealist storybook depiction of class where internal contradictions don't exist.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.