So, been reading this for a while now, and gotta say this book really puts things into perspective. All those Bukharins, Kamenevs, Zinovievs, Trotskys, all of them started their treacherous ways as far back as 1917, or even earlier. In retrospect, those people are obvious. They were bosses who were outraged that workers and peasants ditched them for Lenin and Stalin
Like, there's a comparison in the book between two insurrections, one in Petrograd and one in Moscow. In Petrograd, Lenin and Party's center, including Stalin, got their way, and made a bloodless insurrection that saw all bridges taken, all government buildings seized, counter-revolutionaries (social-revolutionaries and mensheviks as well as cadets they were covering for) isolated, no armistices, no negotiations, no nothing, just pure overthrow of power and seizure of it in favor of Soviets. Whenever any trade union or organization objected, Bolsheviks sent delegates to their rank and file, and their bosses screeched in outrage that Bolshevik were so easily stealing their voters and supporters away
In Moscow, since Bolshevik organization there was infested with "future traitors", insurrection came to bloody street fights all over Moscow, with cadets managing to lie their way into seizing Kremlin with arms inside and disarming soldiers there - only for cadets and officers to shoot disarmed soldiers against the wall, without any fucking mercy, while socdems (SRs and mensheviks) were preaching for armistice, reconciliation and shit like that to Bolsheviks. Bolsheviks in Moscow themselves were buying into ALL AND EVERY negotiations bait; from the get go they organized a joint revolutionary military committee with Mensheviks, and even Bolshevik delegates were constantly trying to cheat rank and file of Bolshevik party and negotiate some nonsense. As a result, streets of Moscow ran red, and if Revolution wasn't successful elsewhere, Petrograd and all around, Moscow would have been lost to counter-revolutionaries
And it was fucking telling that "future traitors" were bundled in Moscow like this. Lenin called it vaccilations in the party, those people were described as defeatists, compromisers, cowards, whatever else, because they sabotaged under any possible pretext the victory of the Revolution.
Kamenev and Zinoviev, for example, under the pretext of "government is too strong, workers will all die if we do insurrection right now, we must instead wait and wait and
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.