[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)
What is 6 - 4?

| Catalog | Home
|

File: 1741015516650.jpeg (68.98 KB, 772x980, F2dFY0HacAA6li0.jpeg)

 

Letter of the Warsaw Pact Countries to the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia
July 15, 1968
Dear Comrades!
Expressing the will of the Communist Parties and peoples of Bulgaria, Hungary, the German Democratic Republic, Poland and the Soviet Union, we address you with this letter prompted by feelings of sincere friendship and a sense of responsibility for the fate of socialism in our countries and the strengthening of the international positions of the socialist community.
We are addressing you at a crucial and dangerous moment for our Parties, for Czechoslovakia and for the entire socialist community. The development of events in your country is causing us deep anxiety. Our anxiety, and we must say this frankly, is shared by the working people of our countries, by all Communists, by all those who are faithful to socialism.
We cannot remain indifferent and shall never remain indifferent to the fate of socialism in Czechoslovakia. This is not only your affair. This is the common affair of all Communist and workers' parties, of the socialist states, of the international Communist movement.
The situation has become such that it is impossible to confine oneself to declarations of loyalty to Marxism-Leninism. It is necessary to move to active actions in defense of the common interests, the interests of socialism, the international interests of the entire Communist movement.
We believe that the offensive of reactionary forces against your Party and the socialist system in Czechoslovakia threatens to detach your country from the socialist community.
We see that in Czechoslovakia, with the connivance – we would like to stress, connivance – of your Party leadership, a campaign is being mounted against the Communist Party, against the socialist system, which is becoming more and more pronounced. The clubs and organizations that have recently emerged, and in which anti-socialist forces are rallying, are in fact becoming political platforms of the opposition. Right-wing forces are seizing the press, radio and television, turning them into a tribune for slander against the Communist Party and the socialist system and undermining the fraternal alliance with the Soviet Union and other socialist countries. The organs of state power and public organizations are subjected to increasing pressure from right-wing forces. There is a growth of antisocialist tendencies, and organizations are being established and reviPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

Statement of the Presidium of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia on the Letter of the Five Warsaw Pact Countries
July 17, 1968
The Presidium of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia has thoroughly and comprehensively discussed the letter from the Central Committees of the Communist and Workers’ Parties of the Soviet Union, Poland, the German Democratic Republic, Hungary and Bulgaria, which was handed over to us on July 16th, 1968.
We express our opinion on the content of this letter with a full sense of responsibility to our own working class and people, to the international communist and workers’ movement, and to the international socialist system.
We appreciate the concern expressed in the letter of the five fraternal parties about the development of the situation in Czechoslovakia. We are convinced that this concern stems from the shared responsibility for the fate of socialism and peace, and from the endeavor to strengthen international cooperation.
We believe that there are no objective reasons for anxieties that the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic is departing from the path of socialism, that it is in danger of severing itself from the community of socialist states. This anxiety is not confirmed by the facts.
Our post-January policy fully corresponds to the vital interests of our working class and all working people, is developing socialist society, and is strengthening the socialist system. This policy is not aimed against our international alliances, but on the contrary, it aims at consolidating them on the principle of equality and mutual respect, it strengthens the international position of socialism.
The Communist Party of Czechoslovakia is firmly in control of the development in our country, is actively pursuing its Marxist-Leninist policy, and is implementing the Action Program which was approved by the entire Party and society. This program expresses the will of the XIVth Congress of our Party.
Our Party and state are consistently pursuing a policy of all-round friendship and alliance with the Soviet Union and other fraternal countries, the foundations of which were laid down by Klement Gottwald. We are fulfilling and will consistently fulfill all commitments stemming from our membership in the Warsaw Pact and the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance. We stand firmly on the positions of Marxism-Leninism and proletarian internationalism.
Our press,Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

The Russians were right. Dubček was lying out of his ass. He was an early Gorbachev. If Russia continued the trend of intervening in liberalizing states like Hungary and Czechoslovakia the USSR would have been preserved. The Russians got weak and lost their will.



 

I know a lot of people think it's cool to hate the Pope, but let me rap at you for a second

turns chair around, puts Holy See baseball cap on backwards

This is the same cat who has:

-said he wants a church that is "poor and for the poor" and is "bruised, hurting and dirty because it has been out on the streets, rather than a Church which is unhealthy from being confined and from clinging to its own security… caught up in a web of obsessions and procedures"

-said he wants "a church based not on fancy vestments and infallible pronouncements, but on love of God and love of others"

-has tried to decentralize the Catholic Church, one of the most hierarchical institutions for millennia, as exemplified by the Synod on Synodality

-expressed acceptance of homosexuality, saying "If a person is gay and seeks God and has goodwill, who am I to judge?", supported civil unions and legal protections for same sex couples, and has called homosexuals "children of God"

-has laid the groundwork to allow women to enter the governing structures of the Church
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
14 posts and 2 image replies omitted.

It's spread to his kidneys.
He might not be long in this world.

>>2165823
That is, the punomia. He is experiencing kidney failure and is in critical condition.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/pope-francis-critical-condition-pneumonia-121721240.html?

>one of the pope's potential successors is an Italian dude named Pizzaball

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierbattista_Pizzaballa

>>2159417
>Pizzaballa
I thought you were trolling. Polentas don't mess around with their names

and he still hates seeing women terminate their pregnancies and being priests. wonderful



File: 1740950638203.jpg (666.65 KB, 3000x1968, 1740462296684288.jpg)

 

Hello, fellow humans, I'm creating this thread in the hopes of get recommendations of genuine radical books, not traditional book like Marx or Lenin, I mean non popular or non mainstream leftist books that are genuine radical in their ideas, like some obscure modern philosopher or something. I'm curious to get to read some non conventional ideas and concepts.

From the top of my head I think "Beyond Capital" by Mezaros or "Dialecticals of Capital" vol 1 and 2 by Sekine are non mainstream, specially Sekine with his whole idea of finding out the pure structure of capitalism.
12 posts and 2 image replies omitted.

>>2174237
Reddit knows him well, he's quite popular around the leftist subreddit

>>2174070
literally me and my gangstalker cell gaslighting co-workers into marxist class ideology


>>2174014
there's a few users who like to spam a massive list of books written a hundred years ago as ESSENTIAL READING. I actual think Das Capital is essential but these dudes can't help themselves by overwhelming people with irrelevant stuff .

Anyway, here's a list of books that I feel open up new ways of thinking about capital.

The State- Bob Jessop
Dialectic, the Pulse of Freedom- Roy Bhaskar
Devil and Commodity Fetishism- Michael Taussig
Spirits of Resistance- Aihwa Ong
Subaltern Studies- Various Authors
Along the Integral Margin- Stephen Campbell
Rethinking Capitalist Development- Kalyan Sanyal
Imperialism in the 21st Century- John Smith
Multitude- Hardt and Negri

>>2174470
Interesting reading recommendations

bump



 

I think fascism is more likely to emerge in countries with history of what would be called in modern day authoritarianism, which is most of them. If the past for example was based mostly on peace democracy and freedom, then it would work less, than if it had more exclusionary and discriminatory practices. Part of the reason Germany fell to fascism so fast was that there wasn't faith in democracy and many elites and probably former aristocrats conspired against it. That's what I got from a YouTube video at least. It would be harder to justify a national rebirth by the far right unless pulling from other cultures. I'm not talking about America though, it's about the Iroquois in particular. They weren't perfect but had much cleaner history than the USA.
8 posts and 3 image replies omitted.

>>2168628

The main voting block initially for the Nazis was disproportionately people who formerly voted for centrists and liberal leaning arties though.

>authoritarianism
Begging people to read On Authority before swinging around radlib jargon

>>2174739
>that would be called in modern day authoritarianism
That doesn't sound like an acceptance of the term, but an acknowledgement of it's use.

>>2174747
Acknowledging its use in an apologetic framing like OP without an expressed denouncement is as good as endorsing the viewpoint

>>2174749
I disagree that acknowledging the term and how it's used is an endorsement, but I concede that I don't know op's actual position. Still, we live in a liberal world and have to engage with their terminology and precepts regardless of how useful or accurate they are. You still have a pretty good idea of what a liberal means when they say authoritarian, even if they don't.



File: 1740977908484.jpeg (1.07 MB, 828x1231, IMG_1692.jpeg)

 

Years ago, there was a time when the African union would directly involve itself in military affairs in the continent. Libya and Somalia are famous examples being you can still find footage of African union soldiers in service to this day.

These days, it seems to have taken a “backseat” approach to conflict where it favours peace talks and ceasefires. I’ll admit, I thought this was idiotic, but I can understand this change. However, many of the conflicts going on in Africa today are self defeating.

The Tigray war ended, the Sudan war saw the RSF rapidly decline spontaneously, and the m23 group has lost all its momentum and is growing closer towards being forced to meet the AU’s original demands. To me, it seems like the union’s leaders are dismissive of war in the continent today largely because they are aware that they really don’t have to involve themselves in these conflicts for the continent to see peace.

Obviously to the reader here, you’ll probably want to know what the Union is doing in place of getting involved these days. From what I’ve read, the union is taking a stronger stance on promoting education throughout the continent and women’s empowerment more.

>From what I’ve read, the union is taking a stronger stance on promoting education throughout the continent and women’s empowerment more.
That's good.
How effective are their initiatives on these fronts?

>>2174607
Very good given how fast the continent’s literacy has grown.

>>2174632
Good to hear the African Union still has weight.
I thought the murder of Ghaddafi by the USA had destroyed it



 

Who are your country's heroes? What are their professions? How have these changed over time?

I believe this is a useful insight into which people a country's culture values. Especially interesting examples might be how this has changed after a cultural revolution.

___

I suspect Australia will differ from most countries, because after the initial European invasion, WWII was the only truly defensive war we've fought. I wouldn't really say we have national war heroes, we just name roadside rest stops after VC medal winners and have a couple of remembrance days focused on WWI and WWII. Average Joe probably couldn't name a soldier that isn't a relative.
I wouldn't really say we call our European country founders heroes either. Sure, they have statues, but that's more just historical. And especially now, as the newer generations become more and more critical of colonialism. Nor would I really call iconic indigenous activists national heroes outside of their movements.
As far as folk heroes go, I'd say bushrangers are the big ones. Ned Kelly is the most famous of the lot. Bushrangers were outlaw criminals during the colonial era, usually convicts transported here from the UK who escaped into the bushland and robbed banks and trains and shot cops.
For modern heroes, probably sports stars, like Olympic medal winners and outstanding national professional sportsmen (think Don Bradman).

The big three would be sports stars, old ANZAC soldiers and old outlaw robbers.
In fact, I just looked up "Australian national heroes" and the first two results are Don Bradman and Ned Kelly, along with Phar Lap (a fucking race horse), Edward Dunlop (military surgeon POW), Harry Morant (soldier and poet executed by the British for serious war crimes in the Second Boer War), Dawn Fraser (Olympic swimmer), Kay Cottee (first woman to sail around the world non-stop solo), some entertainers like Barry Humphries, Saint Mary McKillop (helped improve education) and Charles Kingford-Smith (an aviation pioneer). But some of those are pushing it, they're all famous and notable but I wouldn't call them all national heroes.

>>2174588
Greek Diasparoid from Aus. Two national heros among Greeks would be two particulars- Theodoris Kolikitronis and Aris Velichoutis. Both were guerilla leaders fighting against an imperialist occupier, one being the Ottomans the other the Nazis.

Aris has my admiration in particular for being one of the last truly based members of the KKE before they went full fuckwit on him and kicked him out, leaving him for dead at the hands of reactionaries because he dared call out the so-called "truce" between the partisans and allies as a compromise and rightfully pointed out the imperialist nature of the Brits. He truly believed in a direct-democratic form of government, and had a hand in implementing it to. Arguably the Greek Communist Partisans were some of the most effective fighting forces in WWII.

Both Theodoris and Aris were known for their hot tempers, their grand gestures toward the revolution as well damn good fighters.

You can find statues dedicated to them throughout Greece.

Ngl though, for other Greeks who may be ITT- I too have some reservations about Kolikitronis.

>>2174588
I dunno, Churchill? I try not to engage in hero worship or watch the news so I genuinely don't know, I think that our heroes are Spiderman and Spongebob Squarepants like that Iranian guy said



File: 1740733219357.jpg (12.83 KB, 330x336, 1738872417387172.jpg)

 

hello sorry im writing this while its almost 4 am and im feeling sort of blackpilled

im a bit of an apocalyptist schizo and i can see that the way things are going the technocratic class is probably just going to end up automating everything while the working class is liquidated out of existence. a major problem with technology is that it has a tendency to intensify the stakes of contradictions since the concentration of ownership it affords means that workers inevitably have fewer and fewer bargaining chips

the only way this can be avoided imo is through a political movement that is distributed throughout. imo the problem with a more centralized approach to achieving communism is that it doesn't really preserve any bargaining chips. i especially dont like approaches that are class collaborationist in some way because that always opens you up to corruption as well. if you dont have any real basis materially for worker control, then you are just hoping whoever is in charge has the right ideology which imo seems really idealist to me sorry

on the point of parties i feel like they are of course important but such things need money and property to truly be effective. you can only strike for as long as you can actually pay rent and eat. hence the cost of sustaining yourself is a fundamental limit to your bargaining power. currently things are much worse seeing as how much agriculture is owned by large corporations. beyond this, money is useful for expanding social outreach and controlling narratives. you can also use it to exert soft power so more people hear about you. it definitely feels like current parties could do more and part of this is the need to secure power and not just raise consciousness

for these reasons i think there is merit to integrating the party structure with worker cooperatives and stuff like what the acp is doing. i dont even like haz but he seems to be trying out new ideas that are worth actually trying out. another nice thing about the workers coop thing is that you have a bit of propaganda of success thing going on. when people see how successful and efficient such an enterprise, there is much more rhetorical force behind socialist arguments

also i feel like now is actually the time to really get going with this stuff? the trump administration has gut the reach which the glowies had so there is now a bit more space to like actually do communist projects. patchwork doesn't need to be neo-reacPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
12 posts and 1 image reply omitted.

>>2170259
We take banana
And then uhhhh

Banana LOL

>>2170259
>automate everything
I don't know if you've identified this loose end in your model yet, but the question is: automate which production? (and in what time scale?)

The bourgeoisie is very small, they can only use a fraction of the total product of our society, which has developed with the market of 7 billion in mind. Some things, like food, will be able to be massively downsized. Some things, like technology, or really any commodity or service that has a lot of dead labor represented in it, will be increased (or mostly, the amount of labor concentrated in each thing will increase, while the amount only has to increase with relation to the bourgeois who purchase it). This process is a total restructuring of the means of production and society. And it is already underway, not because the proletariat is superfluous and the bourgeoisie are engaging in economic planned for aristocratic socialism, but because the share for the workers is decreasing, while the share for the owners increases. So this is the proper thing to doom about. Less and less will be produced for you, and more and more of society's total labor power will go towards more and more useless and lavish goods and services.

With that in mind, isn't it also the bourgeoisie's pastime to order people around, make people rub their feet, and suck their dicks? In a realistic blackpill end-stage-capitalism scenario, we won't be superfluous, we'll just all be oriented towards providing for the whims of those who have everything, while we get the bare minimum in slavelike conditions. There's no reason for them to automate everything anyways. Actually, if we don't deviate from the capitalist model, eventually it's too expensive. The surplus value they receive is not enough to both invest in new, higher-productivity or advanced fixed capital, and also maintain their level of revenues (without which, what is the point? they'll only do this if the alternative is to be out-competed). And if they are forced to take a cut in order to keep a share of the market and thus some revenues, next their surplus value is insufficient for investing and also maintaining their variable capital input. From here on out, their surplus value falls not only relatively, but absolutely. They have less left over from production if they invest than if they don't. So, they doPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

>>2170270
Hmmm you know I've never been a fan of the KKE but that is admirable. Why bother with the PSL or CPUSA method of micromanaging all of the party member's socials? It only makes sense since they have zero priorities outside of recruitment and "activism" like getting Amy Klobuchar to sing Which Side Are You On? at a DC protest. Just let the party media do the talking.

File: 1740813697875.jpg (114.6 KB, 727x1024, young Mao.jpg)

Start with killing all the landlords

>>2171976
>Actually, if we don't deviate from the capitalist model, eventually it's too expensive. The surplus value they receive is not enough to both invest in new, higher-productivity or advanced fixed capital, and also maintain their level of revenues
this is an interesting point but i think u miss the fact that much of capital is about power and not just profit. capitalists don't just chase after profit blindly all the time. see for instance netflix, that company used to bleed tons of money as it was strangling blockbuster to death so it could establish a streaming monopoly. see also twitter. why do people hold unto twitter even though it is not immediately profitable? because the "town square" is very alluring, and if they find just the right business model maybe it can be converted into gold. they are perfectly fine with bleeding a bunch of money if they can utterly outcompete everyone else in the future. and also as you said "Actually, if we don't deviate from the capitalist model". what is project stargate?
>Be blackpilled over our decreasing share of total social labor with me
im also blackpilled about this but ai motivates skepticism about other projects as well
>The kind of centralism that communists talk about is about the structure of decision making, and specifically adherence to decisions
yeah and how are you going to do that? if it is through centralized violence then i have a problem. if it comes simply from solidarity and everyone working together then sure that's cool



File: 1740884589127.jpg (225.08 KB, 1136x1600, terrorista_pppa.jpg)

 

Israel agrees on US plan for temporary ceasefire in Gaza, PM's office says
On Saturday, Hamas's armed wing posted a video showing Israeli hostages still in its custody in Gaza and stressed that the remaining hostages can only be freed through a swap deal as stated in the phased ceasefire agreement that began on January 19.
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israel-agrees-us-plan-temporary-ceasefire-gaza-pms-office-says-2025-03-01/

US approves $3 billion arms package to Israel
Under the largest part of the deal, Israel will acquire thousands of 2,000-pound bombs for $2.04 billion. More than 35,500 bomb bodies and 4,000 I-2000 penetrator warheads will be delivered starting in 2026.
https://www.newarab.com/news/us-approves-3-billion-arms-package-israel

PKK: We will comply with Leader Öcalan's call, we declare a ceasefire
On the other hand, we are ready to convene the party congress as Leader Apo wants. However, in order for this to happen, a suitable security environment must be created, and Leader Apo must personally direct and lead it to make it successful.
https://anfenglishmobile.com/features/pkk-we-will-comply-with-leader-Ocalan-s-call-we-declare-a-ceasefire-78180

Two years after Tempi train crash, workers shut down Greece in general strike
Unprecedented protests swept across Greece today, as approximately one million people took to the streets in hundreds of localities, demanding justice for the victims of the Tempi train crash. Trade unions, student associations, and political organizations led the mobilization, turning the day into a nationwide general strike that shut down public services, transport, and universities.
https://peoplesdispatch.org/2025/02/28/two-years-after-tempi-train-craPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
1 post and 1 image reply omitted.

‘Erased generations of talent’: US public land stewards decry firings and loss of knowledge
The firing spree has also taken an exacting toll on the workers themselves, many of whom have long borne the brunt of tight budgets and ever-expanding workloads. Some said they had just settled into housing after spending years living out of their cars to accommodate low pay and remote work. Others said they’d lose access to medical coverage, including one employee in the midst of a cancer diagnosis. Most have been grappling with an uncertain future, looking to the few private-sector options available for the specialized roles they once filled.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/01/public-land-stewards-loss-job

MAGA world erupts over Andrew Tate release, Epstein stunt
the Justice Department released 200 pages of documents mostly consisting of recycled Epstein flight logs and contact information that had long been in the public domain. The online reaction was furious: Prominent Trump supporters accused Bondi and the influencers of staging a PR stunt and failing to release any new information.
https://www.axios.com/2025/03/01/trump-maga-epstein-files-andrew-tate

$60 Billion in Waste and Fraud Easily Found Where Trump Refuses to Cut: The Pentagon
The Tesla CEO met with Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth earlier this month for preliminary talks about possible spending cuts; Hegseth suggested climate programs at the Pentagon could be on the chopping block, but did not mention any cuts to weapons systems—advocating instead to shift current spending to other DOD programs.
https://www.commondreams.org/news/pentagon-spending

California waits for Harris decision in governor’s race
A November poll from the Institute of Governmental Studies at the University of California, Berkeley, found the former vice president with a big polling lead. A February survey from Emerson College Polling/Inside California Politics/The Hill also found she “would start as the clear favorite”Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

911 - Red Dawn feat. Radio War Nerd (2/24/25) Chapo Trap House
We’re joined by Mark Ames & John Dolan of Radio War Nerd to discuss what may be the wind-down of the war in Ukraine. We look at the political ramifications both domestically and internationally, how the west & Russia have fared militarily, and the lives of the Ukrainians affected by the conflict. Plus, would you believe fighter aircraft, MMA, and a drive-by slagging of union general loser George McClellan all get mentions in this?
https://soundcloud.com/chapo-trap-house/911-red-dawn-feat-radio-war-nerd-22425

Rizospastis: The bargaining for Ukraine's mineral wealth exposes the imperialist pretexts
The article goes on to say that “The US-NATO-EU propaganda in defence of ‘democracy’ and ‘Western values’ is collapsing like a house of cards. The role of the ND government is exposed, as well as that of the social-democratic parties (PASOK, SYRIZA) and others who support the country’s involvement in the war. The positions of the KKE are confirmed”. “The sharing of the spoils between the Euro-Atlantic ‘allies’ and Russia is at the heart of the negotiations for the ‘day after’ in Ukraine. Amid the destruction of the war, the US and the EU are vying to get their hands on the precious metals, while Russia is also negotiating to sell rare earths to the US. This is why wars are fought! Imperialist 'agreements' and 'ceasefires' not only fail to defuse the rivalries, but also trigger new, harsher ones. (…) The imperialist peace that is being prepared in Ukraine has the same objectives as the imperialist war, including the division of mineral wealth. That is why imperialist agreements will not defuse or reverse the course of escalating competition and conflicts; on the contrary, they will accelerate it,” the article concludes.
https://www.idcommunism.com/2025/02/rizospastis-bargaining-for-ukraines-mineral-wealth-exposes-imperialist-pretexts.html

The US Economy Runs on Billionaire Pocket Change
While millions of Americans are struggling with a growing consumer debt crisis and surviving pPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

TYBNA!

TYBNA!

File: 1740964411793.jpg (73.57 KB, 750x881, 1j0vcio.jpg)




File: 1740954862966.png (10.07 KB, 345x285, Impishy.PNG)

 

how do 40 year old MAGA normies still use /pol/. It’s not even fun anymore to bait them. Like one time I saw a post saying Europeans should fight for ZOG in ww3 because he’s a elite trying to save the white race. And they actually supported the bait in the replies geg. I pray for 4chan being shut down man same with twitter and reddit
5 posts omitted.

>>2174100
Leftypol is now filled with election tourists as well, except it's pro-Kamala ones

>>2174145
Not even remotely true lmao

>>2174296
No, really, point me to one singular pro-Kamala post literally anywhere on the goddamn site. I genuinely can't think of a single instance of someone here praising that ghoul in the entire time I've used leftypol.

>>2174143
It's narcissism of small differences

>>2174145
I doubt that but the rest of the internet has gotten even more far right since musk(antichrist) bought twitter and trump won making the hogs go wilder than usual, so there's not a lot of choices if you're not right wing



File: 1740840651290.jpg (370.95 KB, 800x955, SAAM-1929.6.154_1.jpg)

 

Is "ancient and medieval Christianity gave more rights to [Christian] women and children than any other religion/ideology from that time" a dogwhistle?

This anon saw that position being propagated by:

-Catholic fascists
-"Western civilisation" - worshipping liberal racists
-Unironic /poltards
-Christian socialists
-At least one (1) anarchist

From that list alone it seems it should be a reactionary myth and therefore, fake, yet the arguments presented in its support somewhat make sense:

-Non-Christian societies are normally neutral to polygyny, which encourages rich men treating their multiple wives/concubines/whatever as property and their very numerous children as disposable livestock, then popularise their standards of treating women&children among poorer men. Also, rich men collecting all of nice women in their harems breeds pre-modern "incels" a lot. In contrast, Christianity from its very first days promoted strict monogamous marriage, encouraging men to see their wife as a person (inferior and submissive sort of person, perhaps, but still a person and not property), and severely limiting amount of [legitimate] children they can have, prompting them to value their kids more as well.

-Unlike the situation with Roman slavery (where the decline of slavery corellating with the spread of Christianity is just yet another corellation that does not mean casuation) Christians appear to be the ones to abolish the Roman practice of infanticide by abandonment of unwanted (usually female) babies which was relatively normal in pagan Rome, even if their reason was pretty terrible ("Unbaptised babies go to Hell after dying!")
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
7 posts omitted.

>>2173315
i'm talking about real women

>>2173195
>Christianity itself was invented by Caesar to pacify Jews to stop them from revolutionary action against the Roman state.
/x/ is over there

File: 1740929604264.jpg (102 KB, 640x719, 1jmqpu3qkbc61.jpg)

>>2172235
Women already had those rights in the Roman Empire though you could say Christianity made women more influential since the Byzzies ended up having female rulers later down the line

>>2172459
Women were considered objectively inferior by Buddha

>>2172235
>-Non-Christian societies are normally neutral to polygyny, which encourages rich men treating their multiple wives/concubines/whatever as property and their very numerous children as disposable livestock, then popularise their standards of treating women&children among poorer men. Also, rich men collecting all of nice women in their harems breeds pre-modern "incels" a lot. In contrast, Christianity from its very first days promoted strict monogamous marriage, encouraging men to see their wife as a person (inferior and submissive sort of person, perhaps, but still a person and not property), and severely limiting amount of [legitimate] children they can have, prompting them to value their kids more as well.
Greeks, Romans and Germanics were all monogamous in the eyes of the law. Some of ruling class men still had concubines, but their children were not acknowledged as heirs unless the legal wife consented to it. Christianity continued monogamy and spread it over a larger area, but it only continued the prevalent practice of the Roman Empire. It's also important to note that Mormons had polygyny until the American government forced them to obey the law.

>-Female monasteries existed (and exist) exclusively in Christianity, allowing young women a way to avoid marriage without becaming a social outcast or possibly, like, being murdered by your father for refusing to marry. (Although being a medieval nun probably may have been a shittier fate than even the wife of some asshole knight… probably)

The monastery means that you become a social outcast, or at least it's perceived as such in popular culture. Being sent to the monastery is a punishment. Plus, the father still decided if a woman could go to the monastery or not.

The more you look at Christianity, the more you understand how connected it is to all other culture and how connected all other culture is to it. It's almost like there is no Christianity at all. There is a set of themes that are core to what Christianity was historically, but most of them aren't shared by the Protestants at all, for instance. Rejection of wealth and power as a moral signifier is a big one and it's turned on its head. The way they kiss the ground Jews walk on is also insane considering the way Christians actually interacted with Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

There's some truth to it, but it depends on what you're comparing it too. It was probably an improvement over Roman paganism since under earlier Roman law a man's wife and children were considered his property and he could legally murder them, sell them into slavery, or do any other terrible thing to them if he wanted. Infanticide was also relatively common as you say. However this wasn't the case for all non-Christian peoples. Norse pagans for example grave comparatively more rights and freedom to women and practiced a division of labour that actually empowered them like putting them in charge of the household finances. Even if its true that Christianity offered some humanitarian improvements over previous society, this doesn't support the reactionary argument that medieval Christianity represented the apex of human moral development. It was an improvement which can yet still be improved upon.
>Female monasteries existed (and exist) exclusively in Christianity, allowing young women a way to avoid marriage without becaming a social outcast
True but nunneries were extremely strict and harsh places. I visited a 16th century convent when I went to Bolivia that's now a museum, and the description of the lives these poor women had to lead were nothing short of prison-like. They were basically dumped there by their families as teenagers (usually to secure political/social standing by sucking up to the Church), allowed no outside contact whatsoever (there weren't even any windows on the outer walls, only windows facing inward to a courtyard), had to keep a strict schedule of prayer and work, allowed basically no recreation, were kept deliberately uncomfortable (sparse and plain food, minimal padding on beds, etc), practiced self flagellation, etc. The place was insanely interesting actually. Now obviously not every nunnery was like this and some were less strict, allowed their members to go out into the world, etc., but it wasn't exactly an easy life even then.



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]
[ 1 /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /17 /18 /19 /20 /21 /22 /23 /24 /25 /26 /27 /28 /29 /30 /31 /32 /33 /34 /35 /36 ]
| Catalog | Home