[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internet about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)
What is 6 - 2?

Not reporting is bourgeois

| Catalog | Home
|

File: 1754674556530-0.jpeg (151.74 KB, 1170x658, Gwp8rGdXgAAsxQB.jpeg)

File: 1754674556530-1.jpeg (99.44 KB, 1170x420, Gxysq_LXAAANqnQ.jpeg)

 

I get that "Socialism in One Country" was ultimately a disastrous policy that ended in complete failure and that the Stalinists revised a lot of Marx's and Lenin's theory to falsely claim that the USSR had already achieved Socialism and ended class struggle in the fucking 30s but realistically speaking, what other approach could they have taken after the failure of the German and Hungarian revolutions?
Like if you were Stalin in the 1930 what would you have done differently to ensure that the Soviet Union stayed in the path of socialism while also maintaining theoretical purity?
220 posts and 45 image replies omitted.

>>2445492
you'll never believe this, but it is

idk if its as much of a reddit/discord raid and two or three people who happen to be in a reddit discord that share links and shitpost together

does that really constitute a raid or expose how easy it is to flood a dead website

Raid. Le interimperialist conflict. Ussr was imperialist.

File: 1756553754584.jpg (4.3 KB, 128x96, 1750164920446.jpg)

It all went wrong in 1914

Leftcoms are the worst. They deny the importance of race and nation in building socialism, they dismiss foundational theorists of Marxism like Lenin, Stalin and Kim Il-Sung, and they have the audacity to suggest that class struggle is possible within the imperial core.
Just a completely unserious, garbage ideology.



File: 1756479970695.png (179.61 KB, 346x311, ClipboardImage.png)

 

[AI was used responsibly when writing this text (proofreading)]

The relative success of historical revolutionary movements, particularly the RSDLP in Tsarist Russia, emerged from conditions where the brutal exploitation by an autocratic state created clear, unambiguous class antagonisms. In stark contrast, the modern imperialist state has developed sophisticated mechanisms for pacifying its domestic population through the economic exploitation of the Global South and a comprehensive ideological apparatus that permeates media, education, and culture. This system actively manufactures consent and produces what has been termed "one-dimensional" thought, systematically stifling revolutionary imagination and limiting opposition to symbolic protests or fragmented riots that fail to challenge state power fundamentally.

This challenge is compounded by the prevalence of what the Ancient Greeks termed idiotes - private individuals indifferent to public life who prioritize personal existence centered on family, property, and stability. This separation of private and public life, coupled with a deep-seated aversion to examining one's own manufactured desires and historicity, creates fundamental obstacles to meaningful political action.

Within the left itself, this stagnation manifests through tendencies that reproduce different forms of one-dimensionality: left-communism through abstract reductionism and orthodox Marxism-Leninism through sometimes-uncritical defense of historical socialist projects that, despite their achievements, did not represent communism as the final resolution of history. The totality of Marxism—its rigid, all-encompassing system for examining the social world that rejects esotericism and religious thinking—provides the tools to understand these limitations, but also reveals why mere theoretical understanding is insufficient.

The writings of Marx, Engels, and Lenin provide a unified blueprint for addressing these challenges through patient construction of independent structures for communication and education. This methodical approach responds directly to the ideological hegemony of the bourgeois state and the political disengagement of the idiotes. The Marxist struggle thus operates on multiple fronts: against the sinking pull of bourgeois society, against its ideological current, and against the temptation to pursue premature political actions before establishing necessary organizational foPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
6 posts omitted.

>>2452348
okay. there's no mention of gramsci in the text, but still, the ruling ideas are the ideas of the ruling class.

>>2452354
The text does allude to it
Along with Marcuse' One Dimensional Man
https://www.marcuse.org/herbert/pubs/64onedim/odmcontents.html

That isn't a bad thing

>>2452320
Your theory is trash and your newspapers are trash. IDGAF what some retard college student wrote about <<issue of the day>>. Pseudo-Marxist newspapers never fail to disappoint me with their rncredibly poor quality of analysis. Marxism is the revolutionary science and Marxist newspapers are revolutionary toilet paper.

But seriously though quality over quantity. It's not about screeching loudly in red paint. It's about equipping the workers with the tools to understand and criticize the situation.

>>2452438
The newspaper is not important. It's the skeleton which forms around the 'newspaper'. The newspaper can be whatever.
>Crucially, the technical demands of producing and distributing such a paper—the collection of information, regular correspondence, and organized distribution networks—actively necessitate creating a framework of local agents. This logistical requirement itself becomes a revolutionary organizing tool, forming an organizational skeleton that develops the capacity to respond flexibly to diverse events

You can up the quality of responses by assigning the AI a role. E.g. "you're a scholar of marxism, with a particular focus on successful revolutionary movements. [the rest of what you want to ask]". This kind of thing can weed out the liberalism pretty well

To me this little essay is more or less concept salad. It's hard to follow and the conclusion is not very comprehensive, maybe other than that first communist intellectuals need to reach each other, then organize, and probably not the other way around



File: 1756418000741.png (1.63 MB, 1468x940, latest-1255607050.png)

 

After reading Marxist literature, studying the history of Marxist states, and interacting with self-proclaimed Marxists, I've come to the conclusion that "Marxist" as a term isn't particularly useful.

In common usage, it describes a number of largely distinct ideologies and forms of political and economic organization that are connected by genealogy and geopolitics. China under Mao was a very different beast than China under Xi, and yet they're both seen as Communist because the latter came from the former, and the former had its basis in the Soviet Union under Stalin had its basis in the Soviet Union under Lenin had its basis in the writings of Marx and Engels. And this is just one state (technically two, but you get the point); looking at the bigger picture, things are even more variable based on time and place.

This isn't to talk ill of China or the Soviet Union by the way, I admire both greatly. My issue is more that "I'm a Marxist" isn't a phrase that tells anyone much of anything unless it's heavily qualified.
24 posts and 8 image replies omitted.

>>2452761
Yeah that's the type of philosophical bullshit I mentioned. Of course communism is a state of affairs to be established, an ideal of which reality will have to adjust itself:

End commodity production (end bourgeois property, end wage labor, production for exchange, etc.)

End classes.

End the bourgeois family.

End the distinction between town and country.

End religion.

End the state and replace it with an "administration of things"

Lower stage socialism with labor vouchers used to take from the common stock the equivalent of what you put in.

Marx is a thinker like anything else, the human mind thinks in abstracts which is both a blessing and a curse regardless of how educated the person is.
Which is a problem.
There are no terms used to describe how devotional to Marx many "Marxists" are.
Fucking Hitler read Marx you know that right? Two distinct sources state he did, and obviously he did, it was the 1900s, if he wanted to get political he would have to do so eventually, and he almost always went into a autistic rage at "Bolshevism" more than he name dropped Marx, as well as appropriated his terminology but most people would never say he was a Marxist.
Marx himself was most critical of all other socialists. to the point where I don't think he would have ever stopped finding anything wrong with the current state of affairs.
In this however, almost 80% of what modern socialists espouse is actually something he'd call them fucking retards for. There was a book posted here, the title was so abstract I can't even recall it, but I read it, it had citations down to the letters he shared when I read it, and he shit talked every single concept trying to make socialism feasible in his time. You can argue he was trying to tweak it but chances are he was against a lot of those things and more in line with doing away with it for a more decentralized, cashless communism. It's a whole thing.
Third and in relation to the above, there is a giant trove of shit Engels and Marx both said that just would not fly today, it's either going to be seen as insane, reactionary even, or just outdated in relation to places that no longer exist, knowledge that was just wrong, and the more we figure out to be fact with new scientific measurements the more it all comes into question. How come even the most hardcore orthodox Marxists kneel and say "Yeah Marx was wrong and a fucking retard actually."
So what makes a Marxist?
The answer is nothing, we have a tendency to group people together, and before you know it people think they're part of the gang, and that all it takes is agreeing with dialectics or class struggle to be Marxian, or believe in a DOTP.
If Marx came back today he would shit himself and throw a tantrum going "No! I'm the only Marxist! You fucking uyghurs have besmirched my name! Me I am the only one! How dare you turn my works into this!"
He would then be lynched by a angry mob and decapitated in public, his head now used as a football by them would be smiling as deathPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

> "I'm a Marxist" isn't a phrase that tells anyone much of anything
<"The modern synthesis was the early 20th-century synthesis of Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and Gregor Mendel's ideas on heredity into a joint mathematical framework. Julian Huxley coined the term in his 1942 book, Evolution: The Modern Synthesis. The synthesis combined the ideas of natural selection, Mendelian genetics, and population genetics. It also related the broad-scale macroevolution seen by palaeontologists to the small-scale microevolution of local populations." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_synthesis_(20th_century)
Neo-Marxism would presumably also be a synthesis of some kind that collects a bunch of diverse fields into one…but the thing is, its all still Darwinian natural selection. Marxism is all still a historical materialist critique of liberal political economy that obscures class war as the root of historical development

>>2452754
>actually a useful older word that means system of belief
<Red Scare podcast neoliberals: "I'm not like those other girls, I'm non-ideological"
the liberal idealist conception of "Ideology" (VS the Marxian Althussy view of the 'ideological state apparatus' as you mentioned) is only a useful word for shit eating radlibs to pretend like they are just rational and objective scientists who magically know the truth

>>2452058
That just means you dont understand Marx's reasoning and way of conceiving of things

>>2451433
>In common usage, it describes a number of largely distinct ideologies and forms of political and economic organization that are connected by genealogy and geopolitics.
sorta yeah sorta not really. ML is just marxism applied to soviet conditions. MZT is applied to chinese conditions. HCMT to vietnam, juche to korean, foco to cuba. that last one even makes an example of itself by not working applied to different conditions. thats why marx oriented ancoms and demsuccs still get critical support when they arent atagonizing communists. its possible they know their conditions and they might apply. the proof is in practice not in theory, and thats marxism.



File: 1754310240527-0.png (886.41 KB, 993x1211, IMG_8224.PNG)

File: 1754310240527-1.png (926.51 KB, 1240x1628, IMG_8222.PNG)

 

Its fucking over WW3 is about to start.



nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty nuclear beta radiation was too short or empty
13 posts and 6 image replies omitted.

>>2452043
Probably should be putting that shit into american water supplies at this point

File: 1756458938347-0.jpg (410.26 KB, 1200x1200, 12052-5-1099027296.jpg)

File: 1756458938347-1.png (178.59 KB, 300x329, 1681107940386.png)

File: 1756458938347-2.jpg (113.68 KB, 831x468, donnie.jpg)

Wrong
You think nukes will stop us/them?
We will simply get back up and do it again.
The American Spirit is unbreakable. It may be under another name, a different continent altogether but the great Burger in the Sky will appear again.

at this point nuclear war would be better than slow climate collapse

Putin should gib Salla 2 Suomi

>>2452904
Salsa status, mayo monkey?



File: 1756391070081.jpeg (328.16 KB, 828x718, IMG_0168.jpeg)

 

So every socialist or communist group I join in America is the same. I have a meet and greet for example the FRSO and they tell me straight to my face they do not see the working class seizing the memes as revolutionary but the petit boo shop keeper as the real revolutionary and give me the example of the Kuomintang as “yes they killed communists but they United the small businesses and were communists” and every socialist party I join I look into they are a NGO tax free donation machine making millions and paying out the top executives huge Salaries and doing nothing while we work for free . If I dig deeper into members politics it’s just neoliberalism . It’s fucking liberalism everywhere anyone else experience this !
6 posts and 1 image reply omitted.

>>2450525
>No, making the 9999th trot split of the month won't help.
"Trotsky split from worthless failed programs" not the argument you think it is!

>>2450490
>neoliberalism
what other economic structures can we use besides "entrepreneurial brand building for individuals competing in the market"?

>>2450543
> Amerikkkan trade union labor aristokkkrats are the real revolutionaries
A McDonald's worker is more revolutionary than AFL-CIA shit.

>>2451401
>shit nobody said
can you talk like a normal person or is 4chan memes the only way you mush-for-brains can manage

>>2450490
ACP is the same



 

Do communists and libertarians agree on foreign policy? I mean… do they? On the one hand, libertarians hate intervention, war, and sending money overseas. Communists… well, they usually want to meddle everywhere, right? But then again, some leftist types claim to oppose imperialism too. So, do they line up sometimes, or is that just random? I honestly don’t know.
4 posts omitted.

>>2452938
>Communists… well, they usually want to meddle everywhere, right?
Not as much as you think actually. One of the problematic things about communism in the 20th century is that you had a lot of communist parties basically follow the USSR, but the Soviet government more and more subordinated communist ideology to the interests of Soviet realpolitik over time (this gets controversial though and there are all kinds of debates about this), which more or less precluded revolution in Western capitalist countries because that would mean World War III. I mean a communist revolution in France for example. Now that's a different matter in Angola.

This could also be disastrous at times like the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, which whatever you say about it as a pragmatic maneuver for the Soviet Union, did put Soviet-aligned communists in an awkward position because they were now under pressure to adopt a non-interventionist line for two years until Germany invaded the Soviet Union. Then communists were full win-the-war types. Also the most impactful communist victory after that was in China where the communist party there broke with Soviet direction in the 1930s. Also this might surprise you, but Soviet aid to the Chinese communists was much less than you might think. The U.S. provided a lot more aid to Chiang Kai Shek's forces than Stalin did for the communists.

>Do communists and libertarians agree on foreign policy? […] But then again, some leftist types claim to oppose imperialism too. So, do they line up sometimes, or is that just random? I honestly don’t know.

The word "policy" is too narrow here because it implies something the U.S. government (say) should adopt within the framework of the existing system. On the left, that's more of a social-democratic approach like Bernie Sanders or AOC. Like "we should reduce foreign interventions" because "that's harmful." And the solution is to change the policies. There are also libertarians who say things like that. Communists want to change things in a more fundamental and systemic way. The fact that U.S. engages in military adventures around the world is not an accident or a mistaken policy but something embedded in how the whole capitalist economic-technological system and its reinforcing social structure operates. It's mPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

This is a more communist way of thinking about war:
https://songmeanings.com/songs/view/3530822107858868480/

>>2452938
>do communists and libertarian agree on foreign policy.
This argument falls apart when you realise Libertarians collectively have a hard on for pinochet- the far right wing anti-communist dictator who was installed into power by the Chicago Boys/ CIA.

>>2453183
*Fascist

>>2452938
>communist bourgeois policy
see how stupid you sound?



File: 1756502208932.jpg (102.64 KB, 883x1178, @nonenullnan_pppa.jpg)

 

Panama signs agreement with banana giant Chiquita Brands to resume operations after strike
In May, Chiquita fired thousands of workers, saying the strike had cost it at least $75 million. Under the agreement signed Friday in Brazil, the company agreed to hire back 3,000 workers in an initial stage, followed by another 2,000. The government aims for the company to be fully operational in Panama again by February 2026, it said in a statement.
https://apnews.com/article/panama-chiquita-banana-mulino-strike-c5b29559b45f26cc7de0bcf4a5481434

Mexico to suspend package shipments to US as tariff exemption set to expire
Mexico says it will suspend package shipments to the United States before the end of a tariff exemption for small-value packages. The announcement on Wednesday follows similar moves by postal services from several European countries, including Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Italy, and the United Kingdom, as they await further details from the US government.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/8/28/mexico-to-suspend-package-shipments-to-us-as-tariff-exemption-set-to-expire
https://archive.ph/ow8oP

Human rights lawyers call for Netanyahu's arrest on Argentine soil
Human rights lawyers said on Friday they have filed a criminal complaint in Argentina's federal courts seeking the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he sets foot in the country, amid reports of a possible visit in September that remains unconfirmed. .. … …; .. . . . . … … .. .
https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/human-rights-lawyers-call-netanyahus-arrest-argentine-soil-2025-08-29/

Limited funds won’t deter campaigns for 2026 LGE: Mapaila
The South African Communist Party (SACP) says limited funds will not deter it from contesting the 2026 local govePost too long. Click here to view the full text.

Nearly 1,000 'Workers Over Billionaires' Protests Planned Across US for Labor Day
Unions and progressive organizations are planning nearly 1,000 "Workers Over Billionaires" demonstrations across the United States this Labor Day to protest President Donald Trump's assault on workers' rights. The day of national action has been organized by the May Day Strong coalition, which includes labor organizations like the AFL-CIO, American Federation of Teachers, and National Union of Healthcare Workers, as well as advocacy groups like Americans for Tax Fairness, Indivisible, Our Revolution, and Public Citizen.
https://www.commondreams.org/news/workers-over-billionaires-protests

Detainees report alleged uprising at ‘Alligator Alcatraz’: ‘A lot of people have bled’
The allegations, made by at least three detainees in phone calls to Miami’s Spanish language news channel Noticias 23, come as authorities race to empty the camp in compliance with a judge’s order to close the remote tented camp in the Everglades wetlands. The incident took place after several migrants held there began shouting for “freedom” after one received news a relative had died, according to the outlet. A team of guards then rushed in and began beating individuals indiscriminately with batons, and fired teargas at them, the detainees said.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/aug/29/alligator-alcatraz-uprising-florida-immigration

'AI Death Panels': Trump Pilot Program Seeks to Bring 'Very Worst' For-Profit Insurance Practices to Medicare
As reported by The New York Times on Thursday, the pilot program will hire private firms to deploy AI to make what are known as "prior authorization" decisions regarding whether Medicare should pay for certain procedures, including spinal surgeries and steroid injections. The program is set to run first in Arizona, New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, and Washington.
https://www.commondreams.org/news/trump-ai-medicare-program

Massive CDC walkout eruptPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

Daughter of the Revolution
While the famous and infamous inevitably attract admiration and attention in abundance, a very particular strain of curiosity is reserved also for their offspring. Children of the Revolution is a well-received 2011 documentary by Shane O’Sullivan about two women whose mothers were leading figures in radical leftist politics in, respectively, West Germany and Japan: Bettina Röhl, daughter of the Rote Armee Fraktion’s Ulrike Meinhof, and Shigenobu May, daughter of the Japanese Red Army’s Shigenobu Fusako. O’Sullivan’s film struggles under the sheer weight of the historical legacy and complexities of the movements in West Germany and Japan, but makes the savvy decision to focus on the personal reflections of the two women, whose lives were indelibly shaped by the ideologies and underground activities of their mothers. Though I’m His Daughter is a recently released documentary by Nagatsuka Yō about one of the daughters of Asahara Shōkō, the infamous leader of the Aum Shinrikyō doomsday cult who was executed in 2018 for orchestrating fatal sarin gas attacks in Tokyo and Matsumoto in the mid-1990s. The daughter, Matsumoto Rika, has faced discrimination and stigma due to her father and her putative status as heir to Aum’s successor group, which is closely monitored by police (officers raided the home of Asahara’s widow and son earlier this year, finding huge sums of cash allegedly donated to them by the group). Matsumoto was denied admission to a university due to her family background and had to fight a legal battle to win the right to attend.
https://throwoutyourbooks.wordpress.com/2025/07/23/daughter-of-the-revolution/

Elections in Bolivia: tectonic shifts in the political landscape
For the first time in 20 years, Bolivia’s Movement for Socialism (MAS) has lost the presidential election – and it was not just any defeat. Having won almost 55 percent of the votes in 2020, MAS now barely reached 3 percent. In second place, with 26.7 percent of the valid votes, is Tuto Quiroga, a right-wing establishment candidate with ties to former dictator Hugo Banzer. Victory – with more than 30 percent of the vote – went to Christian Democratic candidate Rodrigo Paz and his vice president, former police officer Edman Lara, who has gained prominencePost too long. Click here to view the full text.

File: 1756519173590.png (459.55 KB, 800x600, 1610145438429.png)

Thanks News Anon

Thanks bna ilu <3



File: 1756466393907.jpeg (29.05 KB, 395x498, 99xariiwcmjf1.jpeg)

 

>Accelerationists when people start supporting the exact previous status quo that existed before the violent chaos instead of creating a new socialist world through revolution.

She is me on every level except physical
But I have no expectation of westerners whatsoever
Everything is going swimmingly actually.

If socialism will happen when things go to hell then how come every hellhole doesn't burst into socialism? Instead people suffer and keep their heads down. I suppose there's that one theory about how it's actually frustrated expectations of a rising society that causes revolution, but I dunno man.

>>2452499
Revolutions happen when the old cannot rule in the old way, and the new is not ripe enough to rule in a new way. The time of le monsters

>>2452499
exactly. normies are so demobilized at this point that porky could write off every one of their rights and they would sit and do nothing about it. actual cuck behaviour.
techbros actually killed humanity



 

When you're high you can literally touch the dialectic. I want to know how much influence altered states have had on philosophy and Marxism in general. A lot of Marxist philosophical concepts make more sense under the influence.
15 posts and 2 image replies omitted.

>>2447046
>3:55
>he saw two familiar symbols, a hammer and a sickle
that wasn't the symbol for communism until around the october revolution

File: 1756271020239.png (1.25 MB, 1208x1444, ClipboardImage.png)


>>2448350
thank you for clarifying that the story about time travelling marx isnt accurate

>>2448350
The red flag was definitely a symbol though. Maybe he found familiarity in the simplicity of the symbols paired with the red banners.

>>2448350
>two familiar symbols
Familiar, not certain. \_(ツ)_/



File: 1756494770681.png (71.79 KB, 234x215, ClipboardImage.png)

 

Present is X, X is None∴
It ∴ until None, (X) is None and ∴
∴ into None, None is Not X.
None it is ∴ .
Waiting for None to disappear, if None disappears then ∴.
None is ∴ . None is X ∴.

>>2452620
X is None ∴ because if it weren't None ∴ it would cease to be X, this is the basis for this thought experiment.

∀ ∈ X, X = ∅ ∴ X

>>2452628
I call this the NEH formula. Or the "Nothing Ever Happens" formula.



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]
[ 1 /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /17 /18 /19 /20 /21 /22 /23 /24 /25 /26 /27 /28 /29 /30 /31 /32 /33 /34 /35 /36 ]
| Catalog | Home