[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]

/edu/ - Education

'The weapon of criticism cannot, of course, replace criticism of the weapon, material force must be overthrown by material force; but theory also becomes a material force as soon as it has gripped the masses.' - Karl Marx
Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)
What is 6 - 2?

Check out our new store at shop.leftypol.org!

| Catalog | Home
|

File: 1742971009232.jpg (333.52 KB, 1600x2416, 1742861308014492.jpg)

 

The way that we would do it is choose a date every week and then get into a voice chat together and have one member read through a portion of PoS followed by something like Kalkavage's Logic of Desire (or Hegel's ladder) and then talk about it together. We'd have a reading session every week until we finish the book. Everything would be contained within the session.
2 posts omitted.

>>24044
threads are slow here yeah, also there's a matrix chat. Users here don't like using discord for infosec reasons.

>>24046
I get that, I've tried matrix but it seemed dead to me (or maybe no one wanted to respond to me lol). I have no attachment to discord, if there are people who want matrix (or other apps) I'm fine with that, I chose discord because it's normie friendly.


>>24047
You could also think about bridging the matrix and discord. Seems quite simple if you have anywhere to run the bot https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-discord#end-user-documentation

>>24049
Good idea, I'll look into it if there is a significant amount of members on matrix.



 

Title. Have been reading into Soviet history for a while now and have recently came across his works. Halfway through both his overaching Soviet works and have thought them brilliant thus far in their fairness toward all parties involved in the experiment.

Can anyone offer any further laudations and/or criticisms? It's far too monumental of a task to verify it all alone, though from what I've seen it's mostly accurate.



File: 1742669404491.png (489.6 KB, 840x472, vote.png)

 

im searching for a good book about the weimar republic, specifically the nazi's rise. a million books have been written on the topic but i dont want to accidentally read the liberals' opinion

I started reading "wages of destruction".



File: 1742551211869.png (1021.33 KB, 740x743, image-45.png)

 

Still somewhat new to this but… How does labor value exploitation works with the service industry ?

I would say obviously someone like and hairdresser or a bank employee is exploited even tho none of them are litteraly tied to a mean of production, but what about say…. a lawyer ? Or a social worker ?

Social workers works for the state so i suppose it can still counts as exploitation, but what about lawyers or any other job in which you dont so much have a boss, i know theres some more services that work with people only having "collaborators" with whom they would technically work on an equal standing with.

I recon they're part of the logistics part of production. Like they enable the ones that are directly producing commodities to do so in some form or another.



File: 1742394918714.jpeg (90.01 KB, 500x350, IMG_7630.jpeg)

 

This thread is about sharing and recommending literature pertaining to the Soviet Union.

This could be about political economy, architecture, art, women‘s issues, the revolution, personalities, et cetera.

Fuck Stalin




File: 1721679923367-0.jpg (Spoiler Image,42.25 KB, 831x513, 2.jpg)

File: 1721679923367-1.jpg (Spoiler Image,22.48 KB, 928x429, 1.jpg)

 

I remember when I first came here, many people questioned my identity, thinking that I was not a real Chinese. At first, I was a bit annoyed, but later I felt that being cautious is normal. In today's chaotic and disordered internet, there are many people who disguise their identities.

>Posing as a 49-year-old teacher and “Z poet” named Gennady Rakitin and using an AI-generated profile picture, a group of activists began posting Russian translations of poems by Nazi writers on the VK social network as an experiment in summer 2023, Zakharov said.


>Replacing the original poems’ references to Germany and Nazi soldiers with mention of Russia and Wagner Group fighters, those behind the Rakitin character aimed to highlight the absurdity of Russian government notions of patriotism in what Zakharov called a “work of conceptual anti-war art”.


>By the time of Zakharov’s post revealing the true nature of the poems, over 2,200 people had become “friends” with Rakitin on VK, including former Roscosmos space agency head Dmitry Rogozin, senator Andrey Klishas and presidential culture advisor Yelena Yampolskaya.


https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2024/06/29/over-100-russian-officials-fall-for-nazi-poetry-prank-pulled-by-anti-war-activists-en-news

I have used VK, and through my account left on VK, I quickly found his account:
https://vk.com/rakitin75

Actually, on VK, as long as you're willing to send friend requests, getting thousands of friends isn't hard. I think they must have specifically sent friend requests to Russian officials.

Post too long. Click here to view the full text.

我也来自中国。这个网站让我体会到了一些更本土化的东西,不是被什么逆天营销号或者反动自媒体转述的东西,算是拓宽了视野吧。这个地方对中国人来说真像一个荒地,你可能遇见别的中国人,但是你们只能说再见



File: 1741626015870.png (714.95 KB, 959x1297, Gramsci.png)

 

What should i read before tackling Gramsci? Gramsci seems to me a monumental figure whom i must read if I were to understand the world a little better. For these reasons I don't want to rush it. What are the works I need to read before him, and what book of his should i start with?

Just jump in. The prison notebooks is just his random thoughts, it's not like really dense complex arguments for the most part. The hardest part is sorting through the weird terminology he uses to evade the prison censor. The edition I have has a lot of explanatory footnotes.




File: 1741007652572.jpeg (25.79 KB, 797x618, bmpo9ki9kt3d1.jpeg)

 

Im at crossroads between joining - or applying for- a catholic seminary, OR, becoming a (non-militant, but firmly (non?) believing Atheist) . It may sound extreme or stupid but consider this: IF God exists, he exists absolutely and all his attributes are true (remember im working within a catholic framework), this means hell is absolutely true, as is heaven; as I genuinely dislike sex, I won't get married ever–why not go full the mile and be a priest? or at least Brother, Canon,etc? seems rational.
OTOH if Atheism is true ,and I eventually find out in the future, I would-have wasted decades of my life, so better to take on the strongest atheist arguments now, see if I can tank them -or not- and go from there.
tl;dr: Give the best books about Atheism, from scientific POV such as Darwinism, Cosmology, geological time; or philosophy and social sciences (history of Ideas, archeology, sociology and studies on mental health, or, even brain scan\ neurology\ biological clinical science about belief)
1 post omitted.

There are a lot of contradictions in christian doctrine (think cosmology and the existence of evil), that when properly addressed reduce it towards a semantic non-sequitur, i.e. saying material reality "is god" is meaningless. As i understand it though, catholicism and orthodoxy derive their legitimacy from their legacy as religious communities. Here i say their growing irrelevance and age-old use as a tool to justify the status quo undermines this legitimacy, the proof is in the pudding so to speak.

Also read >>23788 Feuerbach and Marx to get the best of philosophical atheism. tl;dr Religion reflects society and ubiquitous criticism of it back as a sedating spirituality https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1886/ludwig-feuerbach/index.htm

>>23793
>this is why every atheist is also a moralist
Good and evil are christian as well as specifically catholic categories, therefore the problem of evil is an internal logical contradiction endemic to their doctrine. Look at https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05649a.htm for a taste of the mental gymnastics involved.

>>23795
You're being obtuse here. Obviously in some form the categories of good and evil existed long before christianity, most notably in zartoshti and manicha.
>being present in christian doctrine means it can't be in anything else
<what no set theory does to a mf
Flood detected; Post discarded.Flood detected; Post discarded.Flood detected; Post discarded.Flood detected; Post discarded.

>>23797
>>23796
Christianity has become so genericised that criticising it means you criticise the fiber of moral conscience.
And yet, Christians complain about being hated by the world?

>(someone like adam green is guilty of this, while richard spencer seems to be becoming more nuanced)

Adam Green?
Know More News?



 

My analysis of the imperial core.

- Capitalist
- Comprador (tokens, social justice inactivists, plastic shamans, …)
- Labor Aristocracy (WASPs)
- Declassed (survivors of cultural genocide and white women, incarcerated, disabled, queer, certain immigrants, etc…)
- Working Class (the inherited working class, Indigenous, Black, etc…)

In my opinion, much of Communism consists of the labor aristocracy arguing with the declassed and comprador classes.

Is there any theory which discusses the declassed groups in more detail?

In my opinion, the declassed are an extremely confusing mix of reactionary and revolutionary sentiment. They are born into indoctrination with capitalist sentiment but do not benefit from this. Essentially, they are just really confused. It's not about oppression Olympics, just whether you were likely to hear that the Black Panthers were based growing up.

The Black Panthers discussed the white declassed a little but failed to go into detail. What is important is that the leading fringe of the white declassed will always be the disabled, transsexuals, queers, women and so on.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.



File: 1739797568462.png (Spoiler Image,262.23 KB, 330x461, guidance.png)

 

Title. Answers to this question are also cool- have read Fanon in preparation for multiple essays on the topic and want to back it up with historical context. Obviously preferably dialectically materialist histories recently published. Africa preferred.

Bump with hypothesis: the violence of decolonization movements is directly proportional to the violence of the colonization they oppose.

Botswana would be interesting as a case study of a territory that peacefully transitioned from a British colony to a bourgeois liberal democracy with almost no political violence.



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / rules / faq / search ] [ overboard / sfw / alt ] [ leftypol / edu / labor / siberia / lgbt / latam / hobby / tech / games / anime / music / draw / AKM / ufo ] [ meta ] [ wiki / shop / tv / tiktok / twitter / patreon ] [ GET / ref / marx / booru ]
[ 1 /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /17 /18 /19 /20 /21 /22 /23 /24 /25 /26 /27 /28 /29 /30 /31 /32 /33 /34 /35 /36 ]
| Catalog | Home